Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To admit I have no idea wtf is going on with Russia and the

538 replies

Dustlandcinderella · 21/02/2022 22:54

I follow the news and can see that There is a lot about Russia and the Ukraine. But I can’t quite figure out what is happening , what the background is, and what the truth is (bearing in mind in any war there is propaganda on each side).

Am I the only person who doesn’t actually understand what’s going on

OP posts:
Keepyourheadscrewedon · 23/02/2022 12:52

The US ruled out negotiation this morning claiming it was pointless. Indeed it does seem to be now, Russia troops continue to March across Ukraine.
Putin is just buying time until the military operations are in place.

Ukraine has just announced a state of emergency and you are seriously suggesting talks are still an option? Ridiculous.
Seriously ridiculous. You don’t hold a gun at the head of someone and tell them to keep talking. That’s called blackmail.
If you don’t agree to our demands we will blow your head off. Back in the real world no one outside of Russia would call that ‘diplomacy’

www.independent.co.uk/news/world/europe/russia-ukraine-news-war-putin-invasion-b2021232.html?amp

socksnjumpers · 23/02/2022 12:41

@Keepyourheadscrewedon also, the fact is the West has historically been pretty bad at predicting what Putin will do. We don't know for sure what is going to happen - you don't, I don't. What I do know is that sanctions, sending in foreign secretaries for discussions without the foreign secretary having a proper grasp of the facts, etc etc has not helped.

notimagain · 23/02/2022 12:38

@Keepyourheadscrewedon

“ Macron and France are both naive and irrelevant and Macron has embarrassed himself on the would stage by playing the hero”

Wrong,..

socksnjumpers · 23/02/2022 12:37

@Keepyourheadscrewedon

I think your messaging on here is disturbing socks. Every country is calling for negotiation, everyone wants a peaceful solution - except for Russia that is.
Disturbing, really? Firstly, you are incorrect, Russia has asked for negotiation and Biden has refused. Secondly, your view is that Russia is bullshitting and we need to stop him, so you are most definitely not calling for negotiation.
Alexandra2001 · 23/02/2022 12:36

@Wanderingowl I'm afraid we are wasting our time, some people have never heard of Austro-Hungarian Empire, Serbia and the various alliances formed in the early years of the 20thC.

Yesterday a poster was calling for Trump to be in the Whitehouse, now Trump is found to be a Putin supporter, calling him a genius make your mind up!!!

As for calling other posters German, i was called a Russian troll, like Putin, some people do like opposition and seek to remove it.

On France, they are sending troops to Romania to re enforce NATO's eastern borders and with one of NATOs biggest military forces.

socksnjumpers · 23/02/2022 12:33

Why does it even matter to putin if nato expands? They are a defensive alliance - not likely to ever use their military power beyond protecting countries from being invaded the same reason why US didn't want Russian weapons in Cuba. You have 2 neighbours - if one expands the other may feel threatened.
It is not up to putin to decide what security alliances independent countries choose to join but if nato has expanded and got close, against agreements, it creates a very difficult situation - which is explained in the link I put upthread.

If I lived next to an aggressive autocracy with nuclear weapons I would be looking to buy some security! Who wouldn’t faced with hostile war mongering neighbours and this is broadly what putin is saying about the US and NATO..... and there we have it, a difficult complex situation

Keepyourheadscrewedon · 23/02/2022 12:30

I think your messaging on here is disturbing socks. Every country is calling for negotiation, everyone wants a peaceful solution - except for Russia that is.

socksnjumpers · 23/02/2022 12:28

Putin sees the EU as weak and divided and Germany in particular is vulnerable now to the fall out. He despises NATO. Macron and France are both naive and irrelevant and Macron has embarrassed himself on the would stage by playing the hero Macron has tried to negotiate. India is calling for calm and negotiation. China is calling for negotiation. Your views are very, very simplistic and subjective and also dangerous - it is this sort of one sided rhetoric which causes wars. You are angry about Putin propaganda, yet what you say could be seen as propaganda too.

Why are you asking if a poster is German? It is really offensive you know, just like it is offensive saying to me that I am a puppet and cannot think for myself. Everyone who agrees with you is right, anyone who doesn't is a puppet - is that what you think? Do you think that is healthy?

Keepyourheadscrewedon · 23/02/2022 12:28

I did see the trump statement this morning, and quite frankly I am horrified. He is celebrating Putins ‘genius’ Confused

DetMcNulty · 23/02/2022 12:25

@Keepyourheadscrewedon

Are you German by any chance wandering because you seem to determined to ignore the facts and pretend that ferment did not cause both. WWs!
I agree with most of what you've said re the situation in Russia, and I'm Scottish, not German, but you're fundamentally wrong about Germany starting WW1. It's incredibly complex, and involves treaties / arms races on both sides.

You're also wrong about Trump, if you've seen his statements, you'll see he's pretty much behind Putin all the way.

Keepyourheadscrewedon · 23/02/2022 12:25

Why does it even matter to putin if nato expands? They are a defensive alliance - not likely to ever use their military power beyond protecting countries from being invaded.
It is not up to putin to decide what security alliances independent countries choose to join.
He is throwing his weight around - but NATO was never the issue. Expansion is clearly the aim, not agreements new or old.
If I lived next to an aggressive autocracy with nuclear weapons I would be looking to buy some security! Who wouldn’t faced with hostile war mongering neighbours.

socksnjumpers · 23/02/2022 12:19

@Keepyourheadscrewedon Putin planned this invasion long ago, he has amassed the troops since May of last year this is true, but does not undermine the fact that negotiation is going to work better than better than force, history has borne that out, that was one of the lessons learned from WW1 and 2. To negotiate you need a better understanding of Putin's motivations than you have.

Do you think force by sanctions will work?
Do you think military force is a good idea?

You see Putin's actions as only aggressive and evil and you want to stop him. Even if you were 100 percent correct, unless you think we can effectively take over annex Russia (and China for that matter) your way will not work. You keep referring to WW1 and 2 but your proposals are that we do what we learned not to do as a result of WW1 and 2.

The 'diplomacy' about NATO and the minsk agreement was just abit of light entertainment along the way for Putin the way Putin sees this is fundamentally different from how the West leaders see it. There has been very little effort to resolve this by negotiation so far. Just as one example, you have said that if Putin goes into Ukraine he will be surrounded on all sides by NATO - using this as evidence that he is not serious about the Minsk agreement - but one of his stated grievances is this very fact, that NATO said they would not expand in the 1990s and they have done so several times, this is one of his current grievances.

Keepyourheadscrewedon · 23/02/2022 12:15

-* Germany

Keepyourheadscrewedon · 23/02/2022 12:15

Are you German by any chance wandering because you seem to determined to ignore the facts and pretend that ferment did not cause both. WWs!

Keepyourheadscrewedon · 23/02/2022 12:12

Unsuccessfully I might add

Keepyourheadscrewedon · 23/02/2022 12:12

Putin sees the EU as weak and divided and Germany in particular is vulnerable now to the fall out. He despises NATO.
Macron and France are both naive and irrelevant and Macron has embarrassed himself on the would stage by playing the hero.

Wanderingowl · 23/02/2022 12:07

@Keepyourheadscrewedon

I entirely disagree with your post wandering of course I am not going to post every detail about both world wars!! We know that Germany invaded France - France was allied to Russia during the First World War. Germany were looking to expand/secure their eastern flank. Yes the assassination appeared to be the catalyst but the rumblings were there years before. The Second World War Germany invaded Poland under hitlers direction - and the purification of race as we all know. On both counts Germany started the world wars - you can call it propaganda but the rest of us know the truth.
You don't get to disagree on facts that you are ignorant on. Actual things happened in history. While there is obviously room for different interpretations of the backgrounds and motivations there is still a very real, completely objective sequence of events that started the war. The Austro-Hungarian empire's invasion of Serbia was the invasion that started the war. You clearly haven't got the first clue about what you are talking about. You are genuinely completely and utterly ignorant on any of this history. Admit it. You didn't actually know about the July 28th invasion of Serbia did you???? So how can you suddenly learn you don't have a clue and still bed down in your ignorance? It's honestly this kind of wilful obstinance by people that allows these constant fucking wars to continue.
ChardonnaysPetDragon · 23/02/2022 12:05

[quote socksnjumpers]@ChardonnaysPetDragon I was talking about the various translations of the speeches on youtube, not the google translation[/quote]
Oh ok. Haven't seen those, but again the Google Translate version of the paragraph above is quite good.

socksnjumpers · 23/02/2022 11:54

@ChardonnaysPetDragon I was talking about the various translations of the speeches on youtube, not the google translation

Isitsixoclockalready · 23/02/2022 11:42

@Keepyourheadscrewedon

I entirely disagree with your post wandering of course I am not going to post every detail about both world wars!! We know that Germany invaded France - France was allied to Russia during the First World War. Germany were looking to expand/secure their eastern flank. Yes the assassination appeared to be the catalyst but the rumblings were there years before. The Second World War Germany invaded Poland under hitlers direction - and the purification of race as we all know. On both counts Germany started the world wars - you can call it propaganda but the rest of us know the truth.
Whilst being well aware of Germany's guilt during WW2 - I'm not sure why they'd be keen on a conflict with Russia now, especially given the suspension of the extremely lucrative Nord Stream pipeline.
socksnjumpers · 23/02/2022 11:41

I am looking at the French position on Russia at the moment and I think that this is actually a pretty helpful assessment of what is happening in Ukraine (going back to the point of the thread):

www.diplomatie.gouv.fr/en/country-files/ukraine/situation-in-ukraine-what-is/

There are also links to interviews with diplomats in the same website

@Keepyourheadscrewedon this is NOT propaganda!!

socksnjumpers · 23/02/2022 11:35

@Keepyourheadscrewedon

I entirely disagree with your post wandering of course I am not going to post every detail about both world wars!! We know that Germany invaded France - France was allied to Russia during the First World War. Germany were looking to expand/secure their eastern flank. Yes the assassination appeared to be the catalyst but the rumblings were there years before. The Second World War Germany invaded Poland under hitlers direction - and the purification of race as we all know. On both counts Germany started the world wars - you can call it propaganda but the rest of us know the truth.
I really think you need to take a step back here, keepyourheadscrewedon people are trying to help you understand the issues better, not brainwash you.
socksnjumpers · 23/02/2022 11:33

@Keepyourheadscrewedon

I don’t believe any of the propaganda that you post socks, and I won’t be watching it
It is a news report by France 24 ie a MAINSTREAM news agency IN FRANCE.

It is NOT propaganda.

As I explained in my last post France is not pro Russian.

Keepyourheadscrewedon · 23/02/2022 11:33

I entirely disagree with your post wandering of course I am not going to post every detail about both world wars!! We know that Germany invaded France - France was allied to Russia during the First World War. Germany were looking to expand/secure their eastern flank. Yes the assassination appeared to be the catalyst but the rumblings were there years before.
The Second World War Germany invaded Poland under hitlers direction - and the purification of race as we all know.
On both counts Germany started the world wars - you can call it propaganda but the rest of us know the truth.