Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To admit I have no idea wtf is going on with Russia and the

538 replies

Dustlandcinderella · 21/02/2022 22:54

I follow the news and can see that There is a lot about Russia and the Ukraine. But I can’t quite figure out what is happening , what the background is, and what the truth is (bearing in mind in any war there is propaganda on each side).

Am I the only person who doesn’t actually understand what’s going on

OP posts:
OneTiredMam · 22/02/2022 07:42

Basically better enjoy our gas heating while we have it, as soon we won't have that luxury. 🤷🏻‍♀️

The west didn't need to get involved, Ukraine even said that. Sleepy Joe, Boris and Europe have sadly brought this on themselves. We're fucked.

Monty27 · 22/02/2022 07:41

[quote FurryAntiWaxer]@Monty27

Who are all the superpowers being held to ransom. US and Russia have an interest in the outcome. US is technically stronger, but Russia still has the power to hit them where it hurts.
China doesn't care about Ukraine, but no doubt enjoys seeing the US and NATO squirm and will take advantage where they can.
So we find ourselves in a stand off.[/quote]
I'm just asking questions I don't know the answers to.

FurryAntiWaxer · 22/02/2022 07:39

@Monty27

Who are all the superpowers being held to ransom. US and Russia have an interest in the outcome. US is technically stronger, but Russia still has the power to hit them where it hurts.
China doesn't care about Ukraine, but no doubt enjoys seeing the US and NATO squirm and will take advantage where they can.
So we find ourselves in a stand off.

TheReluctantPhoenix · 22/02/2022 07:35

@DazzlePaintedBattlePants,

And the Versailles Treaty was a total irrelevance to WW2.

Where Putin has come from matters. Putin is a bully, but it is far from ‘pure and simple’.

Your ideas stem from the simple unipolar world that existed 30 years ago. China ‘owns’ the US, look at its treasury holdings. And Russia, due to its size and nukes, cannot easily be ‘stood up to’, especially by a weak EU who cannot even be bothered to arm themselves.

And, given the way Europe have condescended to the U.S, going crying to ‘mummy’ may be a bit harder.

MrsNoelFielding · 22/02/2022 07:34

Putin needs to go.

Do you think we have spy’s over there? I feel daft asking this question but surely we must have intelligence on the ‘inside’?

FurryAntiWaxer · 22/02/2022 07:33

@DazzlePaintedBattlePants

Who will be this person to tell China and Russia what they can't do, and what will be their authority?
Unfortunately, when humanity casts off its mantle of civilization we quickly learn that that the strong will do as they please and the weak will suffer as they must (as Thucydides kinda said).
We would all like to be the strong ones in a position to assert our will, but this is far from guaranteed.

Monty27 · 22/02/2022 07:33

Thanks. Is he really going to fall out with all these "allies" of his because of Ukraine though? I don't get it.
We know what we've been told by the meeja about the energy crisis but there must be a lot more to it.
It's genuine naievety here.
@TheReluctantPhoenix
I'd really like to be able to understand how someone could hold so many, even super powers whatever or whoever they are, at ransom, because they want Ukraine back.
And we'll find out who the king actually is? Excercet missiles?

DazzlePaintedBattlePants · 22/02/2022 07:22

Europe has shown no inclination to stand up to Putin. Germany needs to grow a pair, frankly, and do something about Nordstream.

ReluctantPhoenix I can’t think of a worse strategy, to be honest. Someone needs to tell Russia (and China, too) that they can’t behave like that. As people have failed to give a shit about Hong Kong’s treatment, chickens will start coming home to roost.

Putin is a bully, pure and simple.

FurryAntiWaxer · 22/02/2022 07:13

@Monty27

Apart from gas ...that mere trifle.

Without Russia's fossil fuels inflation will cripple our economies. Admittedly it will cripple Russia too.
And no amount of solar panels and wind farms can provide the cheap reliable energy that power our industry and gets European cities through winter.
If war in Ukraine had an easy predictable outcome, we'd not be in this position.

TheReluctantPhoenix · 22/02/2022 07:09

@Monty27,

Loads of commodities and a well educated population! Look at the number of top mathematicians and scientists from Russia.

And, as for the chess analogy, maybe. But, if you are wrong, what does knocking over our king look like?!

Monty27 · 22/02/2022 07:04

@TheReluctantPhoenix I cannot see your theory tbf. His bark is worse than his bite.
I seriously have no education other than chess in terms of manoeuvres.
Does he seriously think he's going to jeopardize world trade for parts of Ukraine just because it was once Russian and he wants it back.
Apart from gas what else does Russia actually have to offer?
Serious question.

ItsAlwaysThere · 22/02/2022 06:58

@DickeryDock

If I ever need to know what is going on and have missed the build up to something. I check out Newsround as they write a simple explanation 🤣
Just what I suggested!
ItsAlwaysThere · 22/02/2022 06:58

Sometimes, when I'm a bit lost on a big news topic I look at newsround. I know it's designed for children but they go back to basics and don't assume you already know the background.

TheReluctantPhoenix · 22/02/2022 06:57

@PicsInRed,

Conscripts are irrelevant in modern war. It won’t happen.

TheReluctantPhoenix · 22/02/2022 06:56

@FurryAntiWaxer,

The Chinese are indeed very important here. If we won’t buy Russia’s energy, they need to sell it to China. So what they say and do really matters.

We live in a very unstable multi polar world right now.

Personally, I think being hard will get us nowhere. We need to listen to Putin and try and get Russia on our side by treating them as an equal partner in all our futures. He is one man and, as despicable as he is, he will go at some point.

So let him have his ‘victory’ and let us have his gas. I don’t think that he does want to take all of Europe. He didn’t really have an ideology. He just wants lifetime rule and respect (and plenty of dosh!)

Monty27 · 22/02/2022 06:56

@LibrariesGiveUsPower

Putin wants Ukraine. It’s an ex soviet nation so he thinks it should be part of Russia. So he’s starting war but obviously it’s someone else’s fault.
@BigMamaFratelli if Mumsnet had a like button I'd have jumped on this ^^ Spot on @LibrariesGiveUsPower. Jeez I can vaguely remember this stuff from history GCSE Talk about scraping the barrell Putin! What's his first name again? Rara? It's weirdo megalomaniacs playing with people's lives as they have no clue about humanity. Imvho
PicsInRed · 22/02/2022 06:52

Having seen that rambling, it's impossible not to see the similarities to 1938 and the annexation of the Sudentenland to "save" their own people inside.

The talk of "USSR" is particularly concerning given so many ex USSR countries are NATO and potentially we could find ourselves back in a "dominoes" situation where we are drawn into war by alliances.

Sweden and Finland are also concerning situations as they are not members (though NATO have an agreement with Sweden that we can choose to respond to their aid) so there lies the question: if one or both were annexed, what would we do, nothing, or something?

Increasingly we may also face the question: in the event a European war turned wider than professional forces could respond to alone, on what basis are we willing to send our own kids to war? It's a conversation we should have and decide upon before politicians have that conversation for us.

FurryAntiWaxer · 22/02/2022 06:47

@TheReluctantPhoenix if Putin just grabs those separatist regions he will see it as another victory, and it will be hard for the west to stop him. A ground war in a populated region where the locals want you to lose is a crapshoot. If the west hasn't learnt that, there really is no hope.
Meantime, western allies cannot simultaneously take on Russia and China on multiple fronts. I can see Putin biding his time till the west can't ignore China/Taiwan and striking out further then.
Meanwhile, it's just a game to wear us down as we deal with pressing internal issues like inflation, made worse by skyrocketing energy prices caused in part by the conflict.
I actually think we're a bit snookered over the next decade, but it probably won't be obvious how bad for a few years.

Gasp0deTheW0nderD0g · 22/02/2022 06:44

The other countries which used to be in the Soviet Union are Estonia, Latvia, Lithuania, Belarus, Moldova, Georgia, Armenia, Azerbaijan, Kazakhstan, Kyrgyzstan, Uzbekistan, Tajikistan and Turkmenistan. The USSR was enormous. Putin was a KGB officer back then. Clearly hankers for the old days.

BigMamaFratelli · 22/02/2022 06:41

@DickeryDock

If I ever need to know what is going on and have missed the build up to something. I check out Newsround as they write a simple explanation 🤣
Genius! I'll be doing that in future.

See, this is why mumsnet needs a 'like' button.

PicsInRed · 22/02/2022 06:37

@Viviennemary

I realisd its a lot more complicated. But the bard bones is thst Putin wznts thd old Soviet Union bzck.m
He did think himself rather a bard as he soliloqued his way back though "history" last night.
TheReluctantPhoenix · 22/02/2022 06:36

If he is rational, it is a tricky one to understand what he wants.

He can take Ukraine easily, but as we discovered with Iraq, holding it is a different game. On top of that, sanctions will hurt him and confine him and his cronies to Russia, and they really love Londongrad.

He might just take the two regions and then negotiate a good deal, and we will be so grateful he did not take the rest of it, we will give him one.

On the other hand, there are scary parallels between the end of the cold war and the end of the First World War and the Versailles treaty.

Russia, under Gorbachev, wanted peace and for Russia to be embraced as an equal country with the rest of Europe. They even asked to join NATO and we’re told to ‘get in line’.

Western investment bankers, never shy to feast off a corpse, got in there with very lucrative privatisations, stripping Russia of its wealth. We simply treated Russia, a proud nation with thousands of years of culture and history, as a medium sized emerging economy.

It is, thus, no surprise that the Russians embraced a strong leader like Putin.

But, where we go from here is (scarily) anyone’s guess. The least bad outcome is another cold war, the worst outcome is that he truly is mad and we actually go to war, one that mankind will lose.

SookieHouseboat · 22/02/2022 06:34

Is that you, Liz?