Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To admit I have no idea wtf is going on with Russia and the

538 replies

Dustlandcinderella · 21/02/2022 22:54

I follow the news and can see that There is a lot about Russia and the Ukraine. But I can’t quite figure out what is happening , what the background is, and what the truth is (bearing in mind in any war there is propaganda on each side).

Am I the only person who doesn’t actually understand what’s going on

OP posts:
socksnjumpers · 27/02/2022 11:46

@Keepyourheadscrewedon thanks for that but you are massively simplifying things. Just to be clear, I do not support conflict or resolution by military means by either side - you do as long as the West wins - and therefore yes we do differ as I do not support military conflict from either side.

In relation to Ukraine's independence they are not independent militarily obviously. In the last 10 years they have been supported from various quarters. In relation to deciding on what happens, the Minsk agreement would not have been put in place simply because of Russia wanting it and we have the unstable situation with Crimea which would need to be resolved neither of those things could just be left to Ukraine. Could they?

Or do you mean that Zelensky should be able to decide what should happen and everyone else put that in place for him?! Because I'd say that is unrealistic. There are a lot of issues and it is important that they are all covered off so that this won't all kick off again in a few years' time.

Anyway, moving on, Russia has asked for ceasefire discussions with Zelensky for today and last I heard Zelensky has agreed provided that they agree on venue and so fingers crossed there, I would like to see the fighting stopped asap.

Keepyourheadscrewedon · 27/02/2022 05:10

Germany have agreed to swift removal for 'some' banks.

We differ socks the outcome as you put it, needs to be decided by Ukraine, the people of Ukraine not outside forces or Russia. It is an independent country it can reorganise itself to represent everyone in the country once this is over. No more appeasement to Russia. That has been the policy for the last few years, and look where we are now. Russia doesn't care about the pensioners in the east of Ukraine or their rights, they just want to crush Ukraine's prosperity and independence and put them firmly back under Kremlin control.

It is game over for Russia now in terms of its world standing, creditability, respectability and quite frankly no one will trust a word they say after this. As they were actually invading Putin was telling us he had no intention of doing so. Liars, gangsters and murderers, all of them will need to be replaced by Russia

socksnjumpers · 26/02/2022 21:46

Sorry, I meant instability would continue not stability

socksnjumpers · 26/02/2022 19:02

@Keepyourheadscrewedon i just saw your response upthread. I didn't say that China defended Russia in my last post, if you read my post again I was quite exact with my words and every single thing I have said, if you google, it it will take you to a mainstream source. You post a lot on these threads, but you aren't really reading what people say to you properly.

There are things I disagree with and agree with in relation to most world leaders. I think you are wrong about anyone secretly wanting world domination (and I hope so too) it is more likely that if UN doesn't step in and Ukraine is taken, Ukraine will become another Chechnya. And stability would continue. And this would not be a good outcome.

I think that NATO members should have been in discussions with Putin well before last April when Putin started to build up a presence and most certainly since then far more than they have. But we are where we are and I think that world leaders now need to work out what the best outcome could be to satisfy both Ukraine and Russia interests - Putin has been interviewed many times about this over the last few years and his views have been consistent. And then work out how to achieve it with the help of the UN and as approved by R and U.

I think that this is achievable. But it needs some skilled negotiators.

I cannot understand how you cannot see that outcome is the most important thing here, for everyone including Ukrainians and Russians.

At some point I guess Nato WILL be tested, so lessons need to be learnt quickly it won't, too many (sensible) people are calling for negotiation. Nobody who understands the consequences of military action wants NATO to be tested

I always feel Germany for whatever reason finds itself on the wrong side of history, and this is the case again I think that you are completely wrong here. Also if you look at the sanctions imposed by US and UK both are without teeth. Sanctions were imposed after Crimea yet had no effect. Sanctions also affect the countries which impose them. I think that other ways of dealing with this peacefully and effectively exist.

ParsleySageRosemary · 26/02/2022 18:59

Latest on the Beeb is that Hungary is in full agreement with EU sanctions, and Germany is sending real arms, breaking a longstanding policy in doing so.

Keepyourheadscrewedon · 26/02/2022 16:56

Yes one would hope we will see much more coordination now the shock is wearing off, some clear thinking is needed. Much needed.

We can't go in and create WW3 (as much as I was desperate to protect Ukraine when this first happened, I can see I was just outraged and wanted so much to help) At some point I guess Nato WILL be tested, so lessons need to be learnt quickly.

In terms of Europe rushing to help, I think they will in terms of support and refuge for Ukrainians, many will increase arms to Ukraine and support sanctions. Lots of countries are closing their air space, kicking out the cronies living in palatial mansions in their capitals and I would imagine if Germany is the only thing standing between all the allies with swift, surely they can not hold this line for much longer?

I always feel Germany for whatever reason finds itself on the wrong side of history, and this is the case again. I knew German people feel we do, but they do have an awful lot of Russian sympathisers in the government and that really needs addressing. How much longer would they be considered an 'ally' if they don't?

Alexandra2001 · 26/02/2022 13:39

The EU nations are a diplomatic waste of time - they can do money but they can't handle this. I dare say that Russia will have transferred most of its transactions to the Chinese clips systems by the time the EU agrees this mess

27 individual nations would never in a million years agree on anything at all.

Its all very well for the UK to call for a Russian Swift ban and stop using Russian Gas... whilst we wont suffer but then refuse to do SFA about the Putin supporters in London and their wealth incase it damages the London property market.

The EU had the laws already in place to instigate sanctions, the UK has not, we are talking about things we will do, or even more ridiculous Boris saying oligarchs had been hit when they hadn't.

France has seized a a ship in the channel taking cars to St Petersburg...

i'm not sure what you expect after a few days of the invasion? Few including the UK and USA really thought Putin would do this.

ParsleySageRosemary · 26/02/2022 13:36

Countries within it, that have been allied in the past, already are directly taking in refugees. The EU has agreed sanctions already with more on the way. They don’t have an army, partly thanks to their own pacifism, partly thanks to the US and U.K. working against it and partly down to too much idealistic trust in the power of hippy peace and love, but the one they are joined with is acting. Military supplies have been sent. What else are you proposing, I’m sure Macron would be delighted to hear practical suggestions of good will.

LexMitior · 26/02/2022 13:12

Economic giant, political pygmy - still true of the EU.

I look forward to the articles that say "Europe should step up". It won't.

ParsleySageRosemary · 26/02/2022 12:50

I thought the usual criticism and excuse for Brits leaving the EU was that they wanted to create closer ties and start having a unified vision and direction. I thought Britain wanted to remain in a trading system that was purely about the money. Not to mention the horrified talk of a dreaded EU army. Now they get criticised for the opposite, by members of the nation (presumably) that was pulling them that way until very recently??

LexMitior · 26/02/2022 12:09

The EU nations are a diplomatic waste of time - they can do money but they can't handle this. I dare say that Russia will have transferred most of its transactions to the Chinese clips systems by the time the EU agrees this mess.

howdoesthisworktoday · 26/02/2022 12:04

@Keepyourheadscrewedon

tiger I believe that Germany and Italy in particular are the problem, and this for Germany has been a public relations nightmare. They were slow to impose any sanctions, Nord stream 2, they have not supplied or helped Ukraine at all, save a few helmets! They have deliberately blocked further harsher actions by the allies and turned up to a meeting with Putin (Macron as well) playing them both for fools as they tried to arrange a 'meeting' with Biden, Putin was giving the green light to invade. They have seemed grotesquely ill informed, ill prepared and slow to manage any response of note. And I am sure we will hear that it is hard to get 27 nations to agree, but isn't that the point? At moments of crisis we don't have months to broker back room deals, we have to respond swiftly and robustly.

And even today Germany (and Italy) are blocking the removal of Russia from Swift. Self interest seems to be first and foremost even as their neighbours are being blown up and murdered as they stall and dither.

It is disgusting.

Italy at least is no longer blocking the removal of Russia from swift, as of today.
Prescottdanni123 · 26/02/2022 11:57

Putin has lost his mind. Some people disagree with this because there is a belief that you can't go off the rails and still lead a country/organise a war. But Hitler went as loopy as you possibly can go and he still managed to lead - he did a spectacular job of inspiring people to support him and brainwashing/terrorising those that didn't - and he started a war. Not saying that this is going to lead to ww3, just pointing out that you can go off your rocker and still be a world leader.

LexMitior · 26/02/2022 11:57

There's a long list of Western politicians in Europe who have supported Putin and given him and his associates a feather bed. Kleptocracy in the UK and the EU. That's on us to fix.

Russia isn't even a functioning democracy - given that, what difference does it make it that ordinary Russians may not agree? They have never had a say in their country.

velvet24 · 26/02/2022 11:53

Really? Get them out now !

LexMitior · 26/02/2022 11:52

@Keepyourheadscrewedon

Yes many millions of Russians are against this war, you can not ignore them and Putin does not speak for them.
I see a lot of Russians enjoying our freedoms here in London but they support Putin. They should be made to leave. They are corrupting us and our country.
Keepyourheadscrewedon · 26/02/2022 11:50

The Russian people need to find the strength to get rid of Putin. That is a matter for them. The sanctions were a choice, Putin said he did not care, so I will take him at his word.

Keepyourheadscrewedon · 26/02/2022 11:49

This war only has one person that is responsible for it: Putin.

It starts and ends with him.

The world stands by Ukraine.

velvet24 · 26/02/2022 11:49

Ok but they are being punished anyway with the sanctions and everything else. Putin is mad

Keepyourheadscrewedon · 26/02/2022 11:48

Yes many millions of Russians are against this war, you can not ignore them and Putin does not speak for them.

velvet24 · 26/02/2022 11:39

@Keepyourheadscrewedon

The whole world (including Russians) stand united with Ukraine.

The whole world wants Ukraine to prevail, and to return to their peaceful prosperity stronger than before.

Russians stand with Ukraine? Im now more confused
Keepyourheadscrewedon · 26/02/2022 11:38

The whole world (including Russians) stand united with Ukraine.

The whole world wants Ukraine to prevail, and to return to their peaceful prosperity stronger than before.

Keepyourheadscrewedon · 26/02/2022 11:35

socks

You need to post a link to confirm China defending Russia, because I have seen zero evidence of that. China voted to 'abstain' just yesterday at the security council, citing they DO NOT agree with the war. They could have vetoed and supported Russia, but they choose not to.
China is neutral, it does not agree with this action at all, they have been extremely clear about that, and it is good move. This is a total disaster and not one they wish to be associated with.

What is important here is the outcome, not the fact that Putin's attack is not diplomacy

No, what is really important here is NOT the outcome, but the thousands of lives being lost for no good reason. There is no good outcome for Russia. Best case scenario and they take over Ukraine - it will never be accepted or recognised by the rest of the world, and the west will continue to arm the Ukrainian forces until Ukraine is reinstated. A war that could go on and on and on. Ukraine are never giving up their independence again and with 44 million (armed) people, I don't fancy Russia's chances even in the medium term. This will break Russia if they follow this route and that is the best case, the worst case is that Russia actually lose this war.

You know socks there is a madman running Russia now, you should be more afraid of this then you appear to be, because if he makes a move out of desperation and does something truly despicable because he can't afford to lose then there will be no coming back from that. You have a little Hitler on your hands, if you can get him to talk and compromise, go for it - we are all ears.

socksnjumpers · 26/02/2022 11:33

Also, @Keepyourheadscrewedon the BBC editor who investigates misinformation has said that a lot of the reports coming out of Ukraine have been misinformation, which is not at all helpful either. This isn't to say the reports of dead and wounded and whether or not children are incorrect but the reports do all say that they have not yet been verified.

velvet24 · 26/02/2022 11:31

I dont understand it either