Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To admit I have no idea wtf is going on with Russia and the

538 replies

Dustlandcinderella · 21/02/2022 22:54

I follow the news and can see that There is a lot about Russia and the Ukraine. But I can’t quite figure out what is happening , what the background is, and what the truth is (bearing in mind in any war there is propaganda on each side).

Am I the only person who doesn’t actually understand what’s going on

OP posts:
Keepyourheadscrewedon · 22/02/2022 13:23

There is literally nothing the Russian people can do, they can not protest or demonstrate their concerns. Russia is an autocracy. Putin does not answer to anyone.

I am listening to the sanctions discussion wondering how much of this is going to make any difference whatsoever, one can only feel that a few sanctions is rather like like running out into the firing line with a hairbrush. Surely a far more robust response is required, but how do we do that without triggering WW3.

This problem has been in the pipeline for years, if it had been addressed at the point of Crimea we may not be where we are today.

notimagain · 22/02/2022 13:22

if he is not part of NATO he doesn't want their warheads Ukraine!

Which NATO warheads/weapons system are people referring to with statements such as this?

ChardonnaysPetDragon · 22/02/2022 13:22

Are elections fair and democratic?

Ha! Look up Alexey Navalny.

Knittingchamp · 22/02/2022 13:19

[quote socksnjumpers]@Tigersonvaseline what horrors do you mean?

I just looked at Statista (statistics organisation founded in Germany) and on Putin they write:

"Vladimir Putin's approval rating in Russia monthly 1999-2022
Published by Statista Research Department, Feb 4, 2022
In January 2022, about 70 percent of Russians approved of activities of the Russian president Vladimir Putin. The popularity level saw an increase from the previous month. During the COVID-19 lockdown in the spring of 2020, the rating declined, before increasing again in the late summer of that year.
What shifted Putin’s approval rating?
Since his first presidential term started in 2000, Vladimir Putin's highest approval rating was measured at 88 percent, when he was the country's prime minister. In 2008, as a result of the war with Georgia, Russia recognized the independence of South Ossetia and Abkhazia. In 2014, Russia annexed the Republic of Crimea and the city of Sevastopol, viewing it as a historic reunification. Despite Western sanctions that were imposed on the country in response the violation of territorial integrity of Ukraine, the approval rating remained high over the following years. In February and March 2019, among the reasons behind the decline in approval were a pension reform and a retirement age hike.
What awaits Russia after 2024?
During his state of-the-nation speech in January 2020, Vladimir Putin suggested amendments to the Russian Constitution, some of which are aimed at restructuring the executive power within the country’s administration. Regarding the amendments, 47 percent of Russians believed that they were designed to prepare the political system for the period after 2024, allowing Putin to stay in power in a role different from a president. In March 2020, an amendment was proposed to the Constitution to reset the previous presidential terms of Putin, allowing him to stay as a president until 2036. The amendments were approved in an all-Russian voting with nearly 78 percent of Russians supporting them"[/quote]
Well if that isn't the most obvious start of an end-of-democracy dictatorship I don't know what is!

socksnjumpers · 22/02/2022 13:18

@Tigersonvaseline

Hmm

I don't know how to respond sock and I don't want to spam the thread with endless links.

Are the Russian people allowed to speak out with criticism against the regime? Or is it a political crime?
Are elections fair and democratic?

Statista is international but founded in Germany - why would they be presenting that information as fact? If you don't want to post links, what are your sources?

I am not suggesting that there is nothing wrong with how Putin operates, but there are two clear items on the table around this crisis - if people make this about us going into a righteous war to topple a despotic leader, they are asking for war which is exactly what we don't want.

We have not yet had ww3 because of diplomacy, diplomacy is what is needed, not to make this about personalities.

starfro · 22/02/2022 13:11

@Tigersonvaseline

Hmm

I don't know how to respond sock and I don't want to spam the thread with endless links.

Are the Russian people allowed to speak out with criticism against the regime? Or is it a political crime?
Are elections fair and democratic?

No, elections are not free and fair.

Speaking out is unwise. Media is state controlled.

starfro · 22/02/2022 13:09

Key events (hugely simplified):

1933 Adolf Hitler takes power in Germany, with a policy of gaining "lebensraum" (living space for Germans).

1937-1938 Hitler declares that various states are full of oppressed Germans, and takes them over with little recourse from Western powers. (note the similarity to Putin)

1939 Germany invades Poland and WW2 begins. Both Russia and Germany take over Eastern Europe.

1941 After having agreed with Stalin to share the spoils in Eastern Europe, Hitler turns on Russia and nearly defeats them, getting to within miles of Moscow.

1944-1945 Fortunes have now turned and Russia slowly makes its way through Eastern Europe, taking over in these countries. The Allies agree to split both Berlin and Germany. Allied areas are free to embrace democracy, whilst Russian areas were run by Communists in deference to Moscow.

1949 NATO is formed to protect Western European Countries against further Soviet aggression. It is an agreement that if any country is attacked, all members must defend that nation. This is part of the cold war.

1988-1991 The USSR collapses, and all the countries occupied by the USSR in 1945 gain independence. Ukraine also gains independence, and agrees to give up Nuclear weapons if Russia promises to respect its sovereignty.

1991 onward: Former Soviet countries look increasingly to the West, joining both NATO and/or the EU and embracing democracy. Russia becomes an oligarchy, eventually to be led by Putin. Putin slowly takes on the role of dictator, destroying democracy. Putin want to regain some of the "glory" of the USSR, looking to retake places like Georgia and Ukraine.

2014 Russia invades Crimea, part of Ukraine and takes it over.

In Ukraine there are still some areas that are somewhat Russian speaking, and have independence movements, backed by Russian money. Putin last night declared these regions as independent, and has moved in troops to guarantee their independence, in effect annexing them.

Tigersonvaseline · 22/02/2022 13:09
Hmm

I don't know how to respond sock and I don't want to spam the thread with endless links.

Are the Russian people allowed to speak out with criticism against the regime? Or is it a political crime?
Are elections fair and democratic?

socksnjumpers · 22/02/2022 13:08

PS other commentary on the approval rating is that Putin's popularity has been in connection with improved living standards in Russia

socksnjumpers · 22/02/2022 13:05

Also tiger if you watch the Putin interviews from the last few years, with various international leaders and journos, on youtube, he does in fact consistently talk about peace and negotiation. And wanting to be partners with US. It is not surprising at all that he wanted to be part of NATO and if that is correct it is not surprising at all that if he is not part of NATO he doesn't want their warheads Ukraine! This whole thing stinks of incompetence.

Either incompetence or gas.

socksnjumpers · 22/02/2022 13:01

@Tigersonvaseline what horrors do you mean?

I just looked at Statista (statistics organisation founded in Germany) and on Putin they write:

"Vladimir Putin's approval rating in Russia monthly 1999-2022
Published by Statista Research Department, Feb 4, 2022
In January 2022, about 70 percent of Russians approved of activities of the Russian president Vladimir Putin. The popularity level saw an increase from the previous month. During the COVID-19 lockdown in the spring of 2020, the rating declined, before increasing again in the late summer of that year.
What shifted Putin’s approval rating?
Since his first presidential term started in 2000, Vladimir Putin's highest approval rating was measured at 88 percent, when he was the country's prime minister. In 2008, as a result of the war with Georgia, Russia recognized the independence of South Ossetia and Abkhazia. In 2014, Russia annexed the Republic of Crimea and the city of Sevastopol, viewing it as a historic reunification. Despite Western sanctions that were imposed on the country in response the violation of territorial integrity of Ukraine, the approval rating remained high over the following years. In February and March 2019, among the reasons behind the decline in approval were a pension reform and a retirement age hike.
What awaits Russia after 2024?
During his state of-the-nation speech in January 2020, Vladimir Putin suggested amendments to the Russian Constitution, some of which are aimed at restructuring the executive power within the country’s administration. Regarding the amendments, 47 percent of Russians believed that they were designed to prepare the political system for the period after 2024, allowing Putin to stay in power in a role different from a president. In March 2020, an amendment was proposed to the Constitution to reset the previous presidential terms of Putin, allowing him to stay as a president until 2036. The amendments were approved in an all-Russian voting with nearly 78 percent of Russians supporting them"

Tigersonvaseline · 22/02/2022 12:56

Socks , at one point When it looked like Russia might have a chance at democracy pre Putin they actually asked to be a part of NATO!
So what does it matter how close NATO gets except to an autocrat dictator

socksnjumpers · 22/02/2022 12:52

I think that the west being absolute idiots over this crisis to be honest.

Putin has been saying for months and months and months that he doesn't want NATO warheads in Ukraine - it is like the Cuban Missile Crisis in reverse, US kicked up a stonk about Russian missiles on Cuba because it was so close, Russian is kicking up a stonk about missiles in Ukraine because it is so close - nothing has been done about it, no solutions offered.

The diplomatic solution surely is to agree that NATO and all member states will not be in Ukraine unless Russia invades Ukraine

And secondly the Minsk peace agreement - if you watch the interviews and discussions with Putin, Ukrainian journos, UK journos, Macron, Japan, yadayada over the last few years it appears that the Russia has been the one calling upon the international community to ensure compliance with the agreement, and most ministers from NATO member states (including Truss...) don't even know what it says. The breakaway states Putin has gone into - Putin has been warning for a long time that Ukraine has been breaching the MA and using brute force there and no one has been paying much attention.

Diplomatic solution: member states of NATO read MA and go into negotiations a bit more informed than they were before and go into discussions with Putin and Ukraine about the same.

Putin has said that NATO said in 1990s that it wouldn't expand into the East but since then has expanded 4 times each time futher towards Russia

Tigersonvaseline · 22/02/2022 12:50

I'm trawling back looking for the offensive jokes?
Joy what were they? Surely not the Mel brooks pic??

It's a perfectly natural response to laugh at times of crisis.
It's very natural to laugh and poke fun at people like Putin also.
That doesn't detract in any way from the horror that could unfold here.

Horror I might add that has already been unfolding in Russia since he tightened his grip.

renovating · 22/02/2022 12:50

"Covid tests are made in China - how ironic."

Quite. And the Chinese vaccine has been supplied throughout SE Asia. Win/win really.

Mischance · 22/02/2022 12:43

@renovating

The UK has been laundering Russian dirty money for decades and selling most of our business assets and property to the Chinese. We have no room to talk tbh. It is practically impossible to buy anything not made in China because we want cheap goods.
Covid tests are made in China - how ironic.
Mischance · 22/02/2022 12:42

Ukraine has lots of mineral reserves - Putin wants to get his hands on them. That is the bottom line, never mind the history.

Tigersonvaseline · 22/02/2022 12:40

Germany is the EU. it's the only member with any real power so I don't blame them if they are reticent shout the gas line.
Without Germany there is no EU.
I'e push back against Putin.

Knittingchamp · 22/02/2022 12:39

@Joystir59

I'm a lesbian, perhaps my lame jokes are a way of warding off my deep primal terror of ever being at the mercy of the Putins of the world.
I thought it was great satirical comment as Mel Brooks produced The Producers. '...springtime for Hitler in Germany' being the most famous song line. Quite prescient of you, if you ask me, given that the man is literally a dictator who is invading another country as we speak!!
renovating · 22/02/2022 12:32

The UK has been laundering Russian dirty money for decades and selling most of our business assets and property to the Chinese. We have no room to talk tbh. It is practically impossible to buy anything not made in China because we want cheap goods.

Keepyourheadscrewedon · 22/02/2022 12:27

I am glad Germany have finally stepped up and done the right thing, rather belatedly but better late than never.

To have trusted Putin and Russia at all was a big mistake, and to rely on anything they supply especially essential infrastructure was a terrible mistake and Europe was warned over and over again, and took no notice, money talks.

heldinadream · 22/02/2022 12:19

Does anyone remember the part ordinary women played in kicking off the Northern Ireland peace process?
Am I mad to think some kind of similar initiative could be pulled together? Like a women's strike involving the women of Ukraine and Russia too? Stop it men, you'll get no dinner if you don't stop being damn stupid! I'm not being flippant I'm feeling helpless despair and trying to find a response that is something more. Another Arab Spring type swell from the grassroots?

Sideorderofchips · 22/02/2022 12:19

It's a very unpredictable situation

For now I think we all jsut need to be prepared for a rise in fuel prices ont he forecourt as the price of oil has gone up again in light of this

heldinadream · 22/02/2022 12:13

Germany has just announced it will halt the approval process on Nord Stream 2.

renovating · 22/02/2022 12:10

It is the nuclear capability that is so terrifying. That and the fact that there is nobody capable or sensible in charge anywhere. Putin is a psychopathic dictator, just like all the other psychopathic dictators now and throughout history. Johnson, Biden, Macron way out of their depth. Germany dependent on Russia for their power supplies, It is like a flock of sheep without a sheep dog.

Swipe left for the next trending thread