Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To admit I have no idea wtf is going on with Russia and the

538 replies

Dustlandcinderella · 21/02/2022 22:54

I follow the news and can see that There is a lot about Russia and the Ukraine. But I can’t quite figure out what is happening , what the background is, and what the truth is (bearing in mind in any war there is propaganda on each side).

Am I the only person who doesn’t actually understand what’s going on

OP posts:
Bellalastrasse · 22/02/2022 16:19

So I’ve just read a Reuters article about Ukraine and the far right and a group called C14 who have been given the ok to patrol an area. That can’t be right? www.reuters.com/article/us-cohen-ukraine-commentary-idUSKBN1GV2TY

BerylStrip · 22/02/2022 16:19

I agree with @Keepyourheadscrewedon

Unless Putin backtracks, in a big way - and this seems unlikely - the SS Negotiation and Diplomacy has sailed.

Putin has no further need for negotiation - he has what he wants and sees no need for it. And, being blunt, given the West's reaction to his annexation of Crimea I find it hard to argue why he should behave any differently.

We have already seen with Putin what conciliatory responses get you. More aggression further down the line which is where we are now.

Keepyourheadscrewedon · 22/02/2022 16:16

Negotiation and diplomacy all the while Putin RIGHT NOW is passing legislation to use weapons and invade the rest of Ukraine.

The reality vs Socks' claims are unreal.

You can see how an entire nation have been brain washed into a zombie like response when you can't even acknowledge what he is actually doing, opposed to what you THINK he should/is doing.

He is moving tanks over as you speak Socks.

socksnjumpers · 22/02/2022 16:12

I agree with you, but I'm not suggesting we remove Putin. That's up to the Russians to do. I am simply saying we should extend to the Ukrainians the same courtesy and privilege we already have: self-determination. I fear the message that is being sent to the rest of the world is that democracy is weak and ineffectual and, so, not something to aspire to

This crisis is not about democracy, it is about a peace agreement and NATO's presence - and in relation to NATO when Russia put arms in Cuba during the cold war what did US say? You Are Too Close Take Them Away. Isn't that the same thing as what is happening now except Russia is saying it? Everyone was afraid it would end in war. It didn't because Russia removed the missiles.

You say you don't want to remove Putin, so what this really comes down to is the best way to ensure peace? I would say negotiation and diplomacy at this stage.

BerylStrip · 22/02/2022 15:55

[quote Alexandra2001]@BerylStrip In an ideal world yes but we don't live in one, did removing Saddam benefit the Iraqis or the west, like wise libya? all done in the name of democracy.

Russia is a paranoid country and yes, whilst the ukrainians might well wish to join Nato, that wish shouldn't come at the expense of war, which will devastate them and end up with them under the Russians & no longer independent.

What i find very sad is Boris's toothless sanctions against Russia but it goes far deeper than Russia and Putin, London has been at the centre of money laundering for years, especially in property.

Untangling all of this should have been years ago, Russia hasn't just popped up on our radar.[/quote]
Absolutely - I couldn't agree more re: the toothless sanctions and I absolutely agree that London is a good place to launder money. I'm sure one of the primary drivers behind Brexit was the desire to remove London from any EU oversight - or worse, enforcement action.

This nettle should have been grasped years ago, but the Tories are in the back pockets of the Russians and I'm quite sure the Russians know it.

Going back to your first point - I agree with you, but I'm not suggesting we remove Putin. That's up to the Russians to do. I am simply saying we should extend to the Ukrainians the same courtesy and privilege we already have: self-determination. I fear the message that is being sent to the rest of the world is that democracy is weak and ineffectual and, so, not something to aspire to.

veevee04 · 22/02/2022 15:49

[quote BerylStrip]@veevee04

The Japanese constituion essentially (I'm paraphrasing) forbids them from having a military or from engaging in war. The quid pro quo is that the US is entirely responsible for their defence.[/quote]
Not quite true anymore looks like they are steadily preparing themselves.

www.reuters.com/world/asia-pacific/with-an-eye-china-japans-ruling-party-makes-unprecedented-defence-spending-2021-10-13/

Alexandra2001 · 22/02/2022 15:48

@BerylStrip In an ideal world yes but we don't live in one, did removing Saddam benefit the Iraqis or the west, like wise libya? all done in the name of democracy.

Russia is a paranoid country and yes, whilst the ukrainians might well wish to join Nato, that wish shouldn't come at the expense of war, which will devastate them and end up with them under the Russians & no longer independent.

What i find very sad is Boris's toothless sanctions against Russia but it goes far deeper than Russia and Putin, London has been at the centre of money laundering for years, especially in property.

Untangling all of this should have been years ago, Russia hasn't just popped up on our radar.

BerylStrip · 22/02/2022 15:48

@veevee04

The Japanese constituion essentially (I'm paraphrasing) forbids them from having a military or from engaging in war. The quid pro quo is that the US is entirely responsible for their defence.

SmellyOldOwls · 22/02/2022 15:47

@Dustlandcinderella

I follow the news and can see that There is a lot about Russia and the Ukraine. But I can’t quite figure out what is happening , what the background is, and what the truth is (bearing in mind in any war there is propaganda on each side).

Am I the only person who doesn’t actually understand what’s going on

Remember learning about Hitler invading Poland? And then planning to invade other countries too, and then it all escalated there was a world war? It's like that but instead of Hitler it's Putin and instead of Poland it's the Ukraine.
veevee04 · 22/02/2022 15:40

@renovating

If China takes Taiwan the effect on the technology we all depend on for everything will be huge. And not in a good way.
Correct, Taiwan strategically is very important but after COVID and rapid inflation there's no appetite for war in the west I'm not sure the USA would let China take it without a fight. There's also talks of China and Japan arguing over disputed islands but Japan are very technologically advanced but right now don't have a military because of WW2. There are articles about them rearming because of the threat from China and they will be an ally to the west.
BerylStrip · 22/02/2022 15:36

@Alexandra2001

Well, yes re: Johnson and his Russian money. I believe I said as much.

Ukraine being made neutral - well, has anyone asked what the Ukrainians want ?

Your comment about the Russians destabilisting Ukraine is too late. They've been doing it for years. It's something they're really very good at...

Putin did not have to use his troops. That was entirely his choice. Ukraine has not become a member of NATO (or, indeed, the EU) although is a candidate nation.

Why is it everyone in a democracy is so keen on people being able to choose what they want, until suddenly it doesn't suit us any more because it's all a bit too difficult suddenly ? Surely we should be encouraging nations along the path of democracy and international co-operation ? Joining a democratic community like the EU or a co-operative defence pact like NATO should surely be encouraged ? No ?

renovating · 22/02/2022 15:34

If China takes Taiwan the effect on the technology we all depend on for everything will be huge. And not in a good way.

BerylStrip · 22/02/2022 15:31

This article in The Guardian (so not a rabid, right wing horror like The Daily Mail) today is very salient. It's written by a former British diplomat so one presumes he understands a lot more about it than any of us can hope to:

www.theguardian.com/commentisfree/2022/feb/22/west-appeasement-putin-russia-ukraine

Alexandra2001 · 22/02/2022 15:30

@BerylStrip

Putin’s “concerns” are sophistry

Clever arguments to justify something he was going to do anyway

The west needs to respond seriously to this or he will sweep over Ukraine and that will be that

The UK could start by deporting all the Russian oligarchs, freezing their assets and confiscating things like Chelsea football club from them. The Tories need to stop accepting Russian donations and don’t forget Johnson elevated one of them to the House of Lords.

Cut off their access to the financial markets as much as possible. Stop Aeroflot flying to Western nations. Basically cut them off as a start point.

...and how do you imagine Putin would react to all that? nothing left to lose, invade ALL of Ukraine....

The tories gave citizenship to all of Putins friends, as its illegal to take foreign donations, Boris even played Tenis with one of them for money ffs!
We should also be untangling Russian money in the UK and removing citizenship where appropriate.

I'd much rather Ukraine was declared a neutral country, Russia withdraws troops, with the threat that should Russia try to destabilise Ukraine or put back troops, they will be given automatic NATO membership and article 5 applies.

But we've stuck to a fixed position of Ukraine can join NATO in the future and that gives Putin no way out, so he has to use his troops.

Stupid as war in europe will devastate our lives, which will make covid lockdowns seem like paradise.

BerylStrip · 22/02/2022 15:27

@veevee04

This is bigger than Ukraine and Russia. China will be watching the west's response to this if it is weak this will be the green light to invade Taiwan. If I was Japan I would start rearming again, the Japanese are a formidable force at full strength
Exactly. Everyone is watching this.

The Chinese and the Russians see the West as decadent (in the true sense of this word - meaning decaying). They think we're fading into oblivion and they can basically rule the roost.

Many people do not realise how serious a Chinese invasion of Taiwan would be. Taiwan is a major produced of cutting edge semi-conductor chips. They produce the best in the world and the Chinese have nothing like it. Additionally, US trade embargoes have cut Chinese companies off from a lot of western technology so they're even more desperate. Their own processors are terrible compared with anything produced by western tech. Same with the Russians.

The point of looking at a bigger picture is to be able to see that 'doing nothing' might actually be our worst option in the longer term. I do not think the current situation is the same as that in mid 1930's Europe, but I do think there are some useful parallels to be drawn. Appeasement seldom works with people like Putin. At best it delays the inevitable.

Again, and again I see people saying "we want a diplomatic solution". Well, yes, of course. Everyone does. The difficulty is that it's looking increasingly unlikely there is an acceptable diplomatic solution to be had.

Let's say, for a moment, we agree that Ukraine is not a candidate member of NATO and, so, not going to have NATO weapons put there. Do you think, for one moment, that is going to get the deal done ? Because the answer is 'no'. What it's going to do is embolden Putin - he's going to look, almost certainly, at the Baltic states and then the situation is much worse. They are all members of NATO and we are treaty bound to defend them. Should we ignore our treaty obligations because we want a so-called 'diplomatic solution' ? Where, exactly, are we going to draw this line ?

Should we let China take Taiwan ? Does it matter ? It's a long way away after all.

I simply do not think the West can respond without being strong any longer. I think this is a pivotal point (I suspect most people agree with this statement, even if no others I've made) and our reactions to this crisis are going to have repercussions for decades to come.

Susu49 · 22/02/2022 15:24

@BerylStrip lay off the personal attacks on socks. You don't have to agree with them but you're taking it too far.

veevee04 · 22/02/2022 15:18

This is bigger than Ukraine and Russia. China will be watching the west's response to this if it is weak this will be the green light to invade Taiwan. If I was Japan I would start rearming again, the Japanese are a formidable force at full strength

TheHateIsNotGood · 22/02/2022 15:15

I found these series of Maps quite informative and interesting:

eurasiangeopolitics.com/ukraine-maps/

prh47bridge · 22/02/2022 15:11

@Aishah231 - You might want to check your facts. There was no military coup in Ukraine. Parliament and protestors ousted the then president after he and his government tried to use the police to put down protests using live ammo. The Ukrainian government is democratically elected. Both parliament and president were elected in 2019.

Would we be happy about a pro-Russian government in Ireland or Scotland? No. Would we invade or threaten to invade those countries if they elected a pro-Russian government? No. Spot the difference from Putin's approach.

BerylStrip · 22/02/2022 15:08

@socksnjumpers

Moscow tore up the Minsk agreement though.

If the Russians continue like this I think it's easy to see they'll look at the Baltic states next - they used to be part of the USSR, they're part of NATO now.

Perhaps a better question to ask is why do these countries not want to rush back to Mother Russia if it's all so fine and dandy there.

People in Western Democracies do not realise how lucky they are. Most countries in the world are not democracies. We are the lucky few and if you want to maintain this privilege then sometimes you have to fight for it.

For far too long the can has been kicked down the road and now (to mix my metaphors) this nettle needs to be grasped.

You say sanctions won't work. I am unsure - if the sanctions are fast enough and hard enough it sends a very clear message to Putin. Make no mistake, the rest of the world is watching and the West cannot be seen to be weak any longer.

Bullies in any context need to be stood up to or they just carry on bullying. We've all seen it, and I'm sure some have experienced it as well.

Putin is a bully. I'm not in a position to comment on his sanity although I know others do. Diplomacy will not work. It simply will not. He doesn't understand it and he doesn't care. He wants what he wants and, right now, he wants Ukraine. If he gets it he'll be eyeing up other choice territories further down the line.

Briony123 · 22/02/2022 15:05

@Scout98765

Don’t call it ‘the’ Ukraine. That’s from when it was a region of the Russian Empire/USSR.
It's about to be a region of Russia again so, if the cap fits..?
socksnjumpers · 22/02/2022 15:04

@TheHateIsNotGood

Well said socks
Thanks
socksnjumpers · 22/02/2022 15:02

[quote BerylStrip]@socksnjumpers

Negotiation is a two way street. There’s nothing from the Russian side except a salvo of bullets and a row of tanks.

Annexation is a game Putin is all too familiar with. If he’s serious about negotiation he’ll stand down. He’s clearly not. No amount of your propaganda is going to change this simple fact.[/quote]
See my diplomatic solutions in my first post above.

Nato agrees not to put weapons in Ukraine unless Russia attacks

International peacekeeping bodies read Minsk agreement and agree to enforce provisions

This is what Russia has been asking for
Why do you think the West isn't doing this? It would not weaken the West. Enforcing the Minsk agreement would strenghten the West

TheHateIsNotGood · 22/02/2022 15:01

Well said socks

Aishah231 · 22/02/2022 14:59

I don't think there is a good and bad right and wrong in this situation. The US is being provocative as it backed a military coup in the Ukraine and is pumping weapons into the area. The Ukrainian government is not democratically elected. The idea that Russia would accept the Ukraine joining NATO is also ridiculous. Yes they are a sovereign country so is Ireland do you think the UK would support a pro Russian government in Ireland or Scotland if they go independent. Putin is trying to rebuild the old soviet empire piece by piece so he is also to blame. The UK should stay out if it and the media should be ashamed of themselves again for the irresponsible jingoistic bollocks they are spouting.