Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To admit I have no idea wtf is going on with Russia and the

538 replies

Dustlandcinderella · 21/02/2022 22:54

I follow the news and can see that There is a lot about Russia and the Ukraine. But I can’t quite figure out what is happening , what the background is, and what the truth is (bearing in mind in any war there is propaganda on each side).

Am I the only person who doesn’t actually understand what’s going on

OP posts:
Keepyourheadscrewedon · 22/02/2022 17:09

Just put on ANY news channel if you are allowed to have a break and check it out?

Putin has now decided to invade the whole of the Eastern flank, it is breaking news and everywhere.

I can help:

news.sky.com/watch-live

BusyEvenForBee · 22/02/2022 17:07

BerylStrip

You need to read about history in more depth then. What do you know about the Republic of Abkhazia and the Republic of South Ossetia. The key word is Republic.
But I believe we are discussing Ukraine here.
I suggest that Russian intelligence looked pretty deeply at any impact sanctions would cause and still made the decision. Sanctions will not work.
I agree with Sock, West should look into honouring Minsk agreements and keep Ukraine out of Nato.

Marchingredsoldiers · 22/02/2022 17:05

If I ever need to know what is going on and have missed the build up to something. I check out Newsround as they write a simple explanation

Good top tip! The newspaper and even bbc articles are often written with an assumption of some knowledge. Sometimes an "explain it to me like i'm a 5 year old" is needed.

TokyoSushi · 22/02/2022 17:04

Just checking in, I'm away on a ski holiday but trying yo keep track of what's going on.

BerylStrip · 22/02/2022 17:01

@BusyEvenForBee

StarbucksSmarterSister

No part of Georgia is occupied by Russian troops.

You are wrong.

en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Occupied_territories_of_Georgia

BusyEvenForBee · 22/02/2022 17:00

StarbucksSmarterSister

No part of Georgia is occupied by Russian troops.

Soffit · 22/02/2022 16:58

The culture and politics of that region is a lot more complicated than the average Brit would be able to assess. The Russians are generally a paranoid nation. I have worked out there (thankfully minimally). The first time I went they were bizarrely convinced that I could be a spy from the UK and their questioning reduced me to tears. I met a high society government employee and relayed my horror to her and she must have pulled a few strings. When I returned to the airport a few days later, the original psycho had turned into my new best friend 'Hi Do you remember me? I'm the person you met on Monday etc. You must come back. You are welcome back anytime" Confused

However, even then, I doubt they trusted me as my email account was hacked pretty much immediately after in a major way. I was receiving emails in Cyrillic referring to private conversations I had with my then best friend as though they were from said friend and being quite insulting so somebody had obviously snooped on all our conversations Blush

BerylStrip · 22/02/2022 16:57

[quote Bellalastrasse]@BerylStrip

Thanks, Beryl. The question I have then is why didn’t democratic countries align against Russia back on 2014? I remember a period online (on here ?) when there was talk of what was happening there - why didn’t we react more determinedly then?[/quote]
The West has lost any appetite for military intervention. It was simply easier to not grasp the nettle. It was easier to kick the can down the road.

In terms of the rest. Well, the Tories are in the back pocket of the Russians and would never do anything much that might jeopardise that funding. The Germans have a reliance on Russian gas. That's 2 big hitters in the EU effectively neutered.

The US probably didn't see Crimea as something worth getting involved in, especially given the lack of European appetite for the same.

I accept hindsight is a wonderful thing in all of this, but given the situation that is playing out now is not, really, so different to Crimea it's to be hoped the West will realise the mistakes made in 2014 and play a different game. I fear, though, it won't happen and worse problems will be stored up for the future.

There are no good, or obvious, solutions to any of this now.

StarbucksSmarterSister · 22/02/2022 16:55

I haven't read the whole thread so someone may have already mentioned this but let's not forget Russia also invaded Georgia in 2008. Part of its territory is, I think, still occupied by Russian troops and Georgia cannot now join NATO.

Georgia is 1/4 the size of Ukraine.

BusyEvenForBee · 22/02/2022 16:54

Keepyourheadscrewedon

Where did you get the information about invading other parts of Ukraine? At the moment troops are only in Eastern part. Send the link please

BerylStrip · 22/02/2022 16:53

@Keepyourheadscrewedon

Breaking news

Russia now announced they will invading other parts of Ukraine. As we knew he would authorise. We should expect a protracted and bloody war that will never end, because Russia have miscalculated what lies ahead.

Well that would put the kibosh on any diplomatic solution.

As I said all along, Putin was going to invade Ukraine come hell or high water. The only question now is how the West will respond. I'd suggest a massive raft of severe sanctions in the next 24 hours as the opening salvo is the only way to go.

Militarily I am not in a position to know, or suggest, what might happen. I fear the Ukrainians will be abandoned and that this will lead to worse problems around the world further down the line.

Bellalastrasse · 22/02/2022 16:52

@BerylStrip

Thanks, Beryl. The question I have then is why didn’t democratic countries align against Russia back on 2014? I remember a period online (on here ?) when there was talk of what was happening there - why didn’t we react more determinedly then?

Keepyourheadscrewedon · 22/02/2022 16:48

Breaking news

Russia now announced they will invading other parts of Ukraine. As we knew he would authorise. We should expect a protracted and bloody war that will never end, because Russia have miscalculated what lies ahead.

Keepyourheadscrewedon · 22/02/2022 16:46

alexandra and you can keep saying WW3 and that is certainly something Russia should be very afraid of. You can only push the west so far.

Oblomov22 · 22/02/2022 16:45

It is a reasonable question. Even if you know all there is to know about USSR's history, trying to work out Putin's reasoning for many things is tricky!

Keepyourheadscrewedon · 22/02/2022 16:44

alexandra this was never about NATO membership! It was just a ruse.
Diplomacy has not failed, because Putin never entertained any real desire to compromise. Germany and France agreed to convince Ukraine to stay out of Nato and respect the Minsk agreement they have barely touched down to even meet the president of Ukraine before Russia announced that parts of Ukraine were 'independent'!! And tore up the agreement altogether.....Putin gave the EU leaders no chance at all to bridge the compromise, he had no intention or need for one.

This is certainly a failure of the west for not doing something far far bigger when Crimea was invaded, they are guilty of taking far too long to recognise the modern day Hitler that Putin is, but they are certainly can not be charged with not trying to fix things. It takes two sides, and one was already checked out and ordering the tanks to cross the border.

BerylStrip · 22/02/2022 16:42

*stability into a region. Wretched autocorrect.

BerylStrip · 22/02/2022 16:41

[quote Bellalastrasse]@BerylStrip. Yes, true but my point was how come Ukraine is allowing this. Putin’s point is that the far right are too powerful there (isn’t that the argument he uses?) so why aren’t Ukraine doing something?

But yes this is some unintentional derailing from the much more informed argument here so sorry to derail - I am just trying to understand it all.[/quote]
Well it suits Putin's purposes. The argument he is using is a smokescreen to justify what he's going to do anyway. Really, for Putin to complain about extremism in another country given how brutal his regime is at home is a bit much to stomach...

Ukraine is not - yet - a proper democracy. It is generally classed as a 'transiting' or 'hybrid' regime. Various international agencies have been working to try to strengthen things like LGBT rights, free expression, civic oversight of security services and so on. Basically, the things we think of as desirable and an indication of democracy.

I sort of sound like a stuck record for which I apologise, but Ukraine is a candidate member of the EU and of NATO. For the former they have some way to go but my understanding is that progress has been made and the EU is happy to continue to help as are other international agencies. My personal view is that this is desirable for many reasons. It's good for the people of Ukraine, it's good for western democracies because it shows we are willing to 'walk the walk' and help people who aspire to our standards and way of life. It introduces stability into a reason that, frankly, is in sore need of it. There are probably many other good reasons as well.

Putin is now riding roughshod over all of this careful diplomatic work because it doesn't suit what he wants. He doesn't give tuppence for the Ukrainians, he just wants to annex the country and that's what he's going to do unless he's given a good reason not to. Saying they won't be allowed to join NATO is not a reason that is going to stop him - he will just invent another.

Alexandra2001 · 22/02/2022 16:36

@Tigersonvaseline

Yes because we don't let dictators demand which democratic independent nation's can join a club.ukraine has moved on it's non of Putin business
Defiantly worth having WW3 over.
Bellalastrasse · 22/02/2022 16:34

@BerylStrip. Yes, true but my point was how come Ukraine is allowing this. Putin’s point is that the far right are too powerful there (isn’t that the argument he uses?) so why aren’t Ukraine doing something?

But yes this is some unintentional derailing from the much more informed argument here so sorry to derail - I am just trying to understand it all.

Ncwinc · 22/02/2022 16:31

Corbyn is a joke.

Tigersonvaseline · 22/02/2022 16:30

Yes because we don't let dictators demand which democratic independent nation's can join a club.ukraine has moved on it's non of Putin business

Tigersonvaseline · 22/02/2022 16:28

Well Corbyn has blamed us And Said we are being provocative by putting tanks into area near Ukraine!

BerylStrip · 22/02/2022 16:25

@Bellalastrasse That article is 4 years old...

Alexandra2001 · 22/02/2022 16:23

@Keepyourheadscrewedon

Negotiation and diplomacy all the while Putin RIGHT NOW is passing legislation to use weapons and invade the rest of Ukraine.

The reality vs Socks' claims are unreal.

You can see how an entire nation have been brain washed into a zombie like response when you can't even acknowledge what he is actually doing, opposed to what you THINK he should/is doing.

He is moving tanks over as you speak Socks.

Well, if thats the case, then the West/your position on Putin has utterly failed. We haven't negotiated, we have stuck to our hard line on NATO membership and Putin is about to walk into the Ukraine.

We may as well re draw the map of europe right now.