Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To admit I have no idea wtf is going on with Russia and the

538 replies

Dustlandcinderella · 21/02/2022 22:54

I follow the news and can see that There is a lot about Russia and the Ukraine. But I can’t quite figure out what is happening , what the background is, and what the truth is (bearing in mind in any war there is propaganda on each side).

Am I the only person who doesn’t actually understand what’s going on

OP posts:
BusyEvenForBee · 22/02/2022 17:42

@jeannie46

Spot on!

BusyEvenForBee · 22/02/2022 17:41

BerylStrip

Keep your cool and do not get personal. I am not your love.

BusyEvenForBee · 22/02/2022 17:40

BerylStrip
Again, I did answer your question, but will elaborate.

This is the quote of what Putin said (apologies for using the quote in the original language):
“Минские договоренности были убиты еще задолго до вчерашнего признания республик Донбасса. И не нами, не представителями этих республик, а действующими киевскими властями. И признание этих республик продиктовано тем, что публично руководство Украины начало заявлять, что не собирается выполнять эти соглашения. В этом смысле да, конечно, минские соглашения – их не существует. Чего ж их выполнять, если мы признали независимость этих образований”, - сказал Путин

This is Google Translator:
Minsk agreements were killed long before yesterday's recognition of the republics of Donbass. And not by us, not by representatives of these republics, but by the current Kiev authorities. And the recognition of these republics is dictated by the fact that the leadership of Ukraine began to publicly declare that it was not going to fulfill these agreements. In this sense, yes, of course, the Minsk agreements - they do not exist. Why fulfill them if we recognized the independence of these entities,” Putin said.
What part is not clear to you?
Minsk agreements were killed long time ago by Ukraine itself not honouring it!

Alexandra2001 · 22/02/2022 17:40

@jeannie46 Very good post.

Our negotiating stance was "go away or else" and look at what has happened?

I'm not entirely convinced that arming the Ukrainian resistance will end well for us, the Russians or the Ukrainians, just as didn't in Afghanistan.

BerylStrip · 22/02/2022 17:39

@jeannie46

This has been a total failure of diplomacy. Neither the UK ( with the ignorant Truss) nor the US ( who know little about Europe and care less) have been able to negotiate meaningfully with Russia. You don't have to like Putin to appreciate his concern about having NATO forces in Ukraine particularly when they are supported by Fascist Groups.

Nor have the UK and the US examined the component parts of the Ukrainian Government or if they have they don't care.

It is disgraceful that fascist elements ( eg the Azov Battalions etc.) have been taken into the Ukrainian Army (to bolster its borders with the Separatist Donbass) and indeed become ministers and allowed to organise . These fascist, white supremacist organisations have organised pogroms/ street attacks against Roma people and attacked LGBT, International Women's Day meetings etc.

The Ukrainian Government has welcomed these elements because its own army was so weak. Out of desperation maybe, but Fascists are not democrats and the risks are that they will take over Ukraine. Remember they called Russians, Jews, Roma, LGBT etc 'untermenschen' who were only fit for slavery or extermination.

Surely no one wants a rerun of what happened in WW2 with mass murders of the Ukrainians by Ukrainian fascist groups.

All this may seem remote to us in the UK or US but very real threats by the Russians who lost 26 million in WW2 fighting Nazis. Remember neither the UK nor the US were occupied by Nazi armies in WW2 but Ukraine and Russia were.

Really ? Are we talking about the same Putin ?

because I promise you, his treatment of, say LGBT groups is much the same as the fascist groups you are claiming he's so frightened of.

BerylStrip · 22/02/2022 17:38

@BusyEvenForBee

BerylStrip

You are right. Broken record...

Pot, kettle and black love. Pot, kettle and black.
Gilly12345 · 22/02/2022 17:37

Russia is invading Ukraine because Russia (Putin) does not want Ukraine to join NATO.

BusyEvenForBee · 22/02/2022 17:32

BerylStrip

You are right. Broken record...

jeannie46 · 22/02/2022 17:32

This has been a total failure of diplomacy. Neither the UK ( with the ignorant Truss) nor the US ( who know little about Europe and care less) have been able to negotiate meaningfully with Russia. You don't have to like Putin to appreciate his concern about having NATO forces in Ukraine particularly when they are supported by Fascist Groups.

Nor have the UK and the US examined the component parts of the Ukrainian Government or if they have they don't care.

It is disgraceful that fascist elements ( eg the Azov Battalions etc.) have been taken into the Ukrainian Army (to bolster its borders with the Separatist Donbass) and indeed become ministers and allowed to organise . These fascist, white supremacist organisations have organised pogroms/ street attacks against Roma people and attacked LGBT, International Women's Day meetings etc.

The Ukrainian Government has welcomed these elements because its own army was so weak. Out of desperation maybe, but Fascists are not democrats and the risks are that they will take over Ukraine. Remember they called Russians, Jews, Roma, LGBT etc 'untermenschen' who were only fit for slavery or extermination.

Surely no one wants a rerun of what happened in WW2 with mass murders of the Ukrainians by Ukrainian fascist groups.

All this may seem remote to us in the UK or US but very real threats by the Russians who lost 26 million in WW2 fighting Nazis. Remember neither the UK nor the US were occupied by Nazi armies in WW2 but Ukraine and Russia were.

BerylStrip · 22/02/2022 17:31

@BusyEvenForBee

BerylStrip

The agreement was torn up by the West as it was not honoured for a very long time. The only country which is between NATO and Russia is Belarus. USA has influence over the situation and they do want NATO missiles at all the countries of Russian boarders hence the Ukraine conflict.

Why are you so hell-bent on painting Russia as some poor little innocent in all of this ?

The West did not tear up Minsk or Minsk 2. It was generally agreed to have been superceded some time ago by pretty much everyone concerned.

It is of note - but you clearly won't have it - that the Russians have been destabilising Ukraine for years which puts the lie to them wanting Minsk and Minsk 2 to be made to work.

I repeat my question which you will not answer.

You have stated you want Minsk (and I will assume you mean Minsk2) to be enforced. Putin has said himself that it has been torn up.

How do you propose this is done ? Or do you concede it's a pipe-dream and we need to accept the realities of the current situation - namely that Russia has invaded part of Ukraine on a pretext and is likely to annexe the rest in the coming days and weeks ?

BusyEvenForBee · 22/02/2022 17:30

Keepyourheadscrewedon

Exactly for safety, as civil was did not stop.
By the way did you take many refugees from Iraq and Syria for that matter? When UK sent troops there.
Am afraid I consider your opinion is bs due to the lack of knowledge and information.

Sasketchewoo · 22/02/2022 17:29

If you're on TikTok look up Xenasolo - she lives in Ukraine and is posting most days about what's going on. I've learnt a lot from her, she's fab.

BusyEvenForBee · 22/02/2022 17:27

BerylStrip

The agreement was torn up by the West as it was not honoured for a very long time. The only country which is between NATO and Russia is Belarus. USA has influence over the situation and they do want NATO missiles at all the countries of Russian boarders hence the Ukraine conflict.

Alexandra2001 · 22/02/2022 17:23

@Keepyourheadscrewedon

alexandra and you can keep saying WW3 and that is certainly something Russia should be very afraid of. You can only push the west so far.
The west will not go to war with Russia over the Ukraine, Russia is a huge exporters of commodities, wheat, metals, oil and gas... things we all need coming out of CV.

We had the (slim) chance of keeping Ukraine independent but blew it on ideology.

Keepyourheadscrewedon · 22/02/2022 17:23

The elderly and kids are being moved out by the Russians as they prepare to invade Ukraine, they are not moving with their own free will but being sent to sports halls and thousands of miles away in Russia for safety as a significant invasion is just about to take place! How you spin such BS.

The Russians have now signed to move into Ukraine territory - across the whole of the flank, which is NOT old news as it was breaking news five minutes ago.

Putin is the new Hitler and he will end up being responsible for millions more deaths of both Russians and those in Ukraine, directly through military action and indirectly with the poverty and desolation that will follow.

BerylStrip · 22/02/2022 17:22

@notimagain @Alexandra2001

I accept what you say about Japan - but it is quite off-topic :)

notimagain · 22/02/2022 17:21

[quote BerylStrip]@notimagain

A self-defence force is permitted under their constitution.

What I said is correct. They are not allowed a military and they are not allowed to engage in war.[/quote]
Regardless of semantics I think most people would for example look at an Air Self Defence Force equipped with over 700 aircraft, including 100 F-15s and with 123 F-35s on order as being pretty well placed from a military POV.

Their Navy and Army are in pretty good shape as well.

BerylStrip · 22/02/2022 17:21

@BusyEvenForBee

BerylStrip

Russian was asking for 8 years to honour Minsk agreements. How much longer do you expect him to wait in order to get a response? There is civil war in Ukraine for 8 years. Children in Eastern Ukraine are used to shots being fired, to schools being destroyed, for members of their families being killed. There are thousands of refugees being taken by Russia at the moment: women, elderly and kids.

They may have been asking, but they were - at the same time - destabilising Ukraine. Doesn't say much for their honouring of the agreement, does it ?

In any event, you said you want us to honour Minsk. I repeat my question - given that Putin has stated it's effectively torn up, how would you like us to do this ?

Alexandra2001 · 22/02/2022 17:18

[quote BerylStrip]@notimagain

A self-defence force is permitted under their constitution.

What I said is correct. They are not allowed a military and they are not allowed to engage in war.[/quote]
Japan has many more frigates and destroyers than the UK & France combined... a unrelated thread fact.

Alexandra2001 · 22/02/2022 17:16

this was never about NATO membership! It was just a ruse
Germany and France agreed to convince Ukraine to stay out of Nato and respect the Minsk agreement

We could have called his bluff on the NATO membership?

We don't know what drives Putin but to compare him to a latter day Hitler is quite frankly incredibly insulting to the 24m Russians who died at Putins hands as well as completely wrong.

The Minsk agreements were never implemented or honoured (the fighting continued & had nothing to do with nato membership)

Ukraine couldn't met NATO criteria due to the disputed areas in Ukraine and the on going fighting since 2014, it had nothing to do with France etc asking Ukraine to drop their desire for NATO membership, which Ukraine wont do.

But what will encourage Putin is the UK's list of incredibly weak sanctions against Russia, what a joke - maybe the old meme joke that Boris is in fact a deep cover Russian agent is correct.

BusyEvenForBee · 22/02/2022 17:16

BerylStrip

Russian was asking for 8 years to honour Minsk agreements. How much longer do you expect him to wait in order to get a response? There is civil war in Ukraine for 8 years. Children in Eastern Ukraine are used to shots being fired, to schools being destroyed, for members of their families being killed. There are thousands of refugees being taken by Russia at the moment: women, elderly and kids.

BusyEvenForBee · 22/02/2022 17:12

Keepyourheadscrewedon

Eastern flank is old news. Putin recognised their independence and their leaders asked for help, agreement was signed. We know these news since this morning. You mentioned Other parts of the Ukraine.

BerylStrip · 22/02/2022 17:12

@notimagain

A self-defence force is permitted under their constitution.

What I said is correct. They are not allowed a military and they are not allowed to engage in war.

notimagain · 22/02/2022 17:10

[quote BerylStrip]@veevee04

The Japanese constituion essentially (I'm paraphrasing) forbids them from having a military or from engaging in war. The quid pro quo is that the US is entirely responsible for their defence.[/quote]
As has been mentioned that is not correct.

There are treaty restrictions but the Japanese have a very well equipped “self defence” force.

en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Japan_Self-Defense_Forces

BerylStrip · 22/02/2022 17:09

@BusyEvenForBee

BerylStrip

You need to read about history in more depth then. What do you know about the Republic of Abkhazia and the Republic of South Ossetia. The key word is Republic.
But I believe we are discussing Ukraine here.
I suggest that Russian intelligence looked pretty deeply at any impact sanctions would cause and still made the decision. Sanctions will not work.
I agree with Sock, West should look into honouring Minsk agreements and keep Ukraine out of Nato.

I merely rebuffed your assertion which is not correct; parts of Georgia are occupied by Russia no matter what you might like to think. We are, indeed, discussing Ukraine as you say, though.

Russia has torn up the Minsk agreement. Putin has said as much.

How do you propose we honour it under those circumstances ?