Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To admit I have no idea wtf is going on with Russia and the

538 replies

Dustlandcinderella · 21/02/2022 22:54

I follow the news and can see that There is a lot about Russia and the Ukraine. But I can’t quite figure out what is happening , what the background is, and what the truth is (bearing in mind in any war there is propaganda on each side).

Am I the only person who doesn’t actually understand what’s going on

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
DameHelena · 28/02/2022 09:19

@Whammyyammy

I don't believe Putin is serious about peace talks, but he's losing face in front of the whole world with this invasion as the Ukrainians have proved a worthy opponents, and making Russia look weak. This morning Russia has woke up to a broken economy, 20% interest rates, panic at the atms, rouble value slashed against the usd, banned from travelling to most countries, banned from most sporting events... loathed by most of the world.

The people of Russia will now suffer because of their leader.
I hope this cones to an abrupt end and the people of Ukraine can rebuild their lives.

This is what I can't see: how does Putin save face? It is not going as he planned; the West is uniting rather than dividing. He can shell Ukrainian cities but without ground troops with adequate training/prep/food, water and fuel, he can't hold them. I'm frightened that he may conclude that he has nothing to lose, in which case ANYTHING up to and including nuclear deployment is on the table. Lukashenko in Belarus is shit-stirring for all he's worth, too, for his own reasons.
Keepyourheadscrewedon · 28/02/2022 09:16

Whammy I agree - the 'talks' could well be a decoy, we have seen this many times before. Saying one thing and doing another.
If they were serious about 'peace talks' one might ask why they are still bombing the shit out of Ukraine even as we type, and why not stop and pause and allow the talks to conclude?

If Russian intentions are genuine then we should see an immediate ceasefire immediately, without that it is all meaningless.

Russia need to stall, they are losing badly in most areas and need to regroup. The plan was for a lightening erasure of Ukraine, and that ship has sailed and now they look bogged down in a never ending war - so they should take their chance now to leave Ukraine with dignity.

CasperGutman · 28/02/2022 09:15

[quote socksnjumpers]**@CasperGutman* I am slightly losing the will to live with this, because if you say anything at all which disagrees with @Keepyourheadscrewedon*'s idea of world order you get called a Putin apologist, but if you want to know what the Russian people really think, France 24 (English speaking) have made a few reports which are on youtube in the last couple of weeks, which interview Russians on the streets to get their opinions. In summary, one was filmed before Russia went in, and the majority of Russia thought that Ukraine and the West were to blame. One of the reports was shot after Russia had gone in and more people were critical of the war.[/quote]
A good point, and there are certainly those in Russia who are supportive of the current regime. However, there's a big difference between an informed opinion expressed in a secret ballot which people have confidence in, and what a self-selecting group are willing to say publicly on camera while they're living in a repressive regime.

Similarly, the fact that thousands of Russians have been willing to protest on the streets against the war in Ukraine is, to me, much more impressive than the time a million or more Brits marched against the war in Iraq!

Whammyyammy · 28/02/2022 09:11

I don't believe Putin is serious about peace talks, but he's losing face in front of the whole world with this invasion as the Ukrainians have proved a worthy opponents, and making Russia look weak.
This morning Russia has woke up to a broken economy, 20% interest rates, panic at the atms, rouble value slashed against the usd, banned from travelling to most countries, banned from most sporting events... loathed by most of the world.

The people of Russia will now suffer because of their leader.
I hope this cones to an abrupt end and the people of Ukraine can rebuild their lives.

socksnjumpers · 28/02/2022 08:41

Russia and Ukraine are due to talk.

I am really hoping that they agree to UN peacekeeping corps to go in and to maintain peace until the political issues have been resolved.

And that all the political issues are on the table to be resolved including the wider issues around Crimea, NATO and sanctions and agreements around NATO put in writing this time.

Keepyourheadscrewedon · 28/02/2022 08:17

You are extremely welcome socks

socksnjumpers · 28/02/2022 08:01

Thanks!

Keepyourheadscrewedon · 28/02/2022 06:27

socks I am afraid I am not so easily impressed, you have been largely supportive of Russia all the way through the thread (and others) and your obsession with trying to force feed to us what Russians think is remarkable. What do you think the rest of the world thinks having a despot threatening the world with nuclear strikes?

Your idea of diplomacy is laughable. 'Talk/agree or I will nuke you' will only take a country so far I feel. Nonetheless, Russia appear to be ready to talk, I personally don't believe it, and see it as a stalling tactic, another way to serve their own purposes of appearing 'reasonable' all the while bombing the shit out of Ukraine.

However, Russia are losing the war at the moment, with many many more losses than they were expecting so who knows? We can only hope for a compromise, and an uneasy solution. I personally pray this happens, and Ukraine is saved. You can not decide to erase an entire nation, which is the Russian aim, and take it over and expect to get away with it. I am hopeful but not optimistic a compromise may be reached but who knows?

Quite where that leaves the rest of the world, with a deranged man running a country that is just about to completely unravel who seems quite content to threaten nuclear every time he is challenged will be a bigger issue.

Putin will wake up to the huge run on banks today, panic is likely to follow, the Russian banking system could collapse, a currency that halved over night and his own population must be terrified now as well about the possibility of nuclear war. This is not going well for him needless to say.

I have always watched Russian channels to get their perspective, I have many Russian friends that are very informative. Many of whom are now in a very difficult situation, but my sympathy lies entirely with the Ukrainian people, and the babies and children that are now lying terrified in bunkers whilst their country and their fathers are being killed and blown up.

One man has caused of this utter destruction, distress and chaos and I have never heard you acknowledge that, and I am most definitely calling you out on it.

Susu49 · 27/02/2022 21:51

@socksnjumpers kudos for keeping your cool on this thread, I'm impressed your patience has lasted this long

socksnjumpers · 27/02/2022 21:10

@CasperGutman I am slightly losing the will to live with this, because if you say anything at all which disagrees with @Keepyourheadscrewedon's idea of world order you get called a Putin apologist, but if you want to know what the Russian people really think, France 24 (English speaking) have made a few reports which are on youtube in the last couple of weeks, which interview Russians on the streets to get their opinions. In summary, one was filmed before Russia went in, and the majority of Russia thought that Ukraine and the West were to blame. One of the reports was shot after Russia had gone in and more people were critical of the war.

socksnjumpers · 27/02/2022 21:04

@Keepyourheadscrewedon

Above post for socks otherwise known as a Putler apologist.
This is not true and a disgusting comment.

I have said clearly that I do not agree with any military action.

CasperGutman · 27/02/2022 20:47

An "autocrat" is a ruler with absolute power. If they can be removed by the people, they don't have absolute power. If they can't, then even if they were originally elected how can we know whether the country chooses them now?

CasperGutman · 27/02/2022 20:45

@Keepyourheadscrewedon wrote:
"I couldn't care less as long as a country can choose for itself if they wish to be autocratic fine, if they wish to be democratic that is also fine - but the wish of the people to have peaceful lives is paramount."

I don't understand this, I'm afraid. What does it mean for a country to "choose" to be autocratic?

How would you know what "the country" chose without the people expressing their views in some kind of election or referendum? Isn't that democracy?

If a country voted to maintain a system of government with a strong president and elected a particular person into that role, that would be one thing.

But can the people of Russia be said to have freely chosen to have Vladimir Putin leading them for all this time? If not, in what sense has "the country" chosen this?

MMBaranova · 27/02/2022 20:22

If no one wants mutual assured destruction, why can't we all get rid of nuclear weapons?

In the Cold War, MAD supposedly stopped nuclear war from happening. This was the time of just two massively armed superpowers, a British 'deterrent' increasingly tied in with the USA one and the French with their Force de Frappe/Dissuasion. Now we have more nuclear powers and the example of Ukraine's disarmament as an example to not give them up under guarantee.

MMBaranova · 27/02/2022 20:16

Every time I think life can't get any worse, something unexpectedly awful like this happens.

Agreed. What a run of awful things in recent years (I won't list MINE as some will disagree with one and take exception and that is not what this thread is about).

Earlier today I had a chat with a friend where we agreed that a Russian nuclear strike wouldn't be too bad in the light of the poor performance of the Russian army. Some would have nobody in attendance to fire them, many fail to launch, others head off lost in the wrong place in the sticks and only a few kill millions of innocents. Yes, this is the place we were in half jokingly. A week is all it takes to shift the ground beneath our feet.

I'd like last Sunday back again. However, I don't see that and whatever happens we are set on a different trajectory (together with all the other unmentionables).

ParsleySageRosemary · 27/02/2022 19:30

I agree about nuclear weapons. Proof positive that technology is advancing way ahead of any improvements in social or ethical capabilities. They are terrifying.

There was the nuclear disarmament treaty, but it requires trust so that - all parties it is now, rather than both, which complicates things even more - so that all parties disarm slowly and keep arsenals matching for their own protection. It’s dead in the water now anyway. The UKs nuclear deterrent is mobile, on submarines that are difficult to track

TYbakedpotato · 27/02/2022 19:23

Thank you for the explanation about NATO. I assume individual countries aren't allowed to take action 'independently' if they're members of NATO?

I get your points about nuclear weapons being devastating, but but surely he's always going to be able to win any argument by threatening nuclear weapons then? If we don't stand up against action like this... haven't we just effectively elected him president of the world?

Why on earth do we even have nuclear weapons anyway? If anyone is crazy enough to want mutually assured destruction, they shouldn't be in charge of any country. If no one wants mutual assured destruction, why can't we all get rid of nuclear weapons?

I just feel really despondent. How have we ended up in a situation like this in 2022? Every time I think life can't get any worse, something unexpectedly awful like this happens.

ParsleySageRosemary · 27/02/2022 19:11

Also the UN cannot get any resolution through against Russia - which might give some international legal wriggle room for peacekeepers - because Russia has veto powers at the UN. China abstained in that vote. Does all that help at all?

Has anyone seen any Indian or Chinese reactions to Putin’s nuclear threats?

ParsleySageRosemary · 27/02/2022 18:50

We are in NATO and in the unlikely event that someone invaded our territory we could call on NATO help. NATO is a mutual defence organisation. US invoked it after 9/11.

Russia claims it is running scared of NATO. NATO did expand after the USSR collapse to take in a lot of the ex-Soviet states, that had once been free independent states before USSR came along.

Therefore he is invading the only free country left in that situation which is not in NATO. It’s not really supposed to make sense tbh, it’s a pretext. Anyway if NATO gets involved without the legal justification of defending its member, not only will that justify Putin’s paranoia in his mind, but China may get involved on Russia’s side. As could India. That’s a lot of nuclear powers with other territorial disputes getting involved.

Keepyourheadscrewedon · 27/02/2022 17:36

TYbakedpotato We are all just watching because Putin is threatening over again to nuke anyone that gets involved, so we can't allow this to become a nuclear war - yes of course it is the worst kind of blackmail of the very worst kind, but we are dealing with gangsters and murderers not a normal, sane, reasonable and rational government.

notimagain · 27/02/2022 15:36

@TYbakedpotato

Surely you can enter a conflict to stop a conflict rather than to aggressively attack one side. Why isn't this happening? Why are we all just watching?

Ukraine is not in NATO, so their forces directly entering the conflict would escalate matters way beyond where we are now (if that’s possible…)

TYbakedpotato · 27/02/2022 15:31

I don't understand what's going on either.

I've tried to do some reading, and whilst I can understand why Putin wants to invade Ukraine, what I don't understand is the rest of the world's reaction to this?

If you haven't attacked another country, and suddenly they're sending soldiers over to yours, surely there's a moral responsibility for the world watching to leap to your defence rather than just talk about how awful it is? Does that mean if some country randomly started attacking us in the UK, no one would help us either?

Surely you can enter a conflict to stop a conflict rather than to aggressively attack one side. Why isn't this happening? Why are we all just watching?

Susu49 · 27/02/2022 14:53

@Keepyourheadscrewedon

Above post for socks otherwise known as a Putler apologist.
I thought with stopped with the poster bashing? Give it a rest, please.
Keepyourheadscrewedon · 27/02/2022 13:15

Above post for socks otherwise known as a Putler apologist.

Keepyourheadscrewedon · 27/02/2022 13:14

I believe that Ukraine should have the right to exist, to be free and to be independent and if that means defending their children and their land then of course one has to support it! It is not about a 'win' for the west, do you honestly think normal people think like that? I couldn't care less as long as a country can choose for itself if they wish to be autocratic fine, if they wish to be democratic that is also fine - but the wish of the people to have peaceful lives is paramount. The ONLY aggressor here is Russia don't forget!!!! Ukraine did not invade Russia or do anything to harm them, they are simply defending themselves.
The violence is solely on one person: Putin.

It is up to Ukraine how they see their future and how each area of their country is run, NOT Russia.

Russia has asked for ceasefire discussions with Zelensky for today and last I heard Zelensky has agreed provided that they agree on venue and so fingers crossed there

Well, I wouldn't hold your breath the last time I checked Belarus was joining the war (and Chechnya I understand) so clearly Russia must be failing - why else would they need so much back up?! And so talks in a country that are sending soldiers to kill is hardly going to happen, and even if Russia move the talks they have insisted that Ukraine step down and stop defending themselves, a term that they know Ukraine will never agree to. Even if that condition was dropped, who in their right mind would ever trust anything Russia has got to say after the reassurances just days ago from Putin that he would not invade??? We will never trust Russia again - never. Only a fool would believe they were there for genuine intentions.

Ukraine will have to defeat Russia, whether it is now or in 20 years time and this war will go on and on, because it should never have happened in the first place.