Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Is outstanding always outstanding?

63 replies

Ann51abc · 21/02/2022 21:16

My child’s primary is classed as outstanding. This is in London, quite a affluent area just for context. I do not feel, after sending my child for 4 years it is very outstanding. I kept this to myself as I didn’t want to be too negative and picky but recently found out lots of parents feel the same!

So my question is if your school is outstanding what actually makes it outstanding? I suppose recent headings would count as I know a few in the area who last had an inspection 10+ years ago.

The issues I feel in my child’s school are: no communication at all, this year been told she was assessed wrong last year (by a teacher) so she’s actually very weak in a few areas, nothing has been done to catch her up even when I’ve requested - I’ve been told the school don’t have the capacity to do this. Other parents have hired tutors so I suppose this is the only help my child will get so I also need to do. Not important factor I suppose but the receptionist that works there is so rude! Trying to get any information from her regarding anything is always met with huffing and puffing

OP posts:
Sockpile · 21/02/2022 21:43

My DDs school is rated outstanding and DSs previous school was rated requires improvement not long after.

The behaviour at DDs school is much better, the staff turn over is lower. Progress was checked frequently so the teachers had plenty of data to show progress.

DS left at the end of year 8 but we received his year 9 timetable, he had multiple teachers for many subjects including 4 for English and 3 for Maths. DSs books were rarely checked and his teachers were not properly aware of the difficulties he was facing with getting his thoughts on paper. There appeared to be a significant number of children with mental health difficulties, more so than in DDs school. The communication appears good on the surface- a weekly newsletter, regular Facebook/Twitter/Instagram updates. Whereas DDs school just communicate what is necessary, the general atmosphere of the school, reputation and results speak for themselves they don’t need to push themselves on social media.

The primary school they went to was rated outstanding but hasn’t been inspected for over 10 years and towards the end of my children time there it didn’t feel like it deserved to be rated outstanding anymore.

Katya213 · 21/02/2022 21:41

My child’s school was rated that it needs improvement. I’m really happy with her there and she loves going in and loves her teachers. I sent her there as it’s literally on our door step, she can read, write and do her maths at the level shes expected, so I’m chuffed.

WlNDMlLL · 21/02/2022 21:40

The Ofsted rating is mostly a measure of the socio-economic background of the students I also agree with this, and additionally it can be how you cook the books. Infant schools are something like 7 times more likely to be graded outstanding than junior schools. That shows there is something very wrong with the system.

Mischance · 21/02/2022 21:37

@WlNDMlLL

As a teacher, I'd probably rather send my child to a good school than am outstanding one. What Ofsted look for and what parents look for are not necessarily the same. Many of the old Ofsted ratings were based largely on data so if KS2 results were good (at whatever cost) then the school could achieve an Outstanding rating. When was it last inspected out of interest? Many outstanding schools are long overdue inspections.
Definitely this.

I am a school governor - as long as you have a head who can tick all the boxes then you will get outstanding. The boxes that need ticking have nothing to do with your child's well-being - they are just statistics that the government can use to say that they are doing something about education.

Our school is Good - this is because we insist that we only do the minimum of box ticking and that the staff spend as much time as possible enriching the children's lives.

But still the poor Head is sending me emails at 2 in the morning - he should be asleep not messing with figures.

DolphinFC · 21/02/2022 21:36

I teach in an outstanding school.

It really was pretty good 9 years ago when it was last Ofsteded. Today it would fail.

jgw1 · 21/02/2022 21:33

@Ann51abc

My child’s primary is classed as outstanding. This is in London, quite a affluent area just for context. I do not feel, after sending my child for 4 years it is very outstanding. I kept this to myself as I didn’t want to be too negative and picky but recently found out lots of parents feel the same!

So my question is if your school is outstanding what actually makes it outstanding? I suppose recent headings would count as I know a few in the area who last had an inspection 10+ years ago.

The issues I feel in my child’s school are: no communication at all, this year been told she was assessed wrong last year (by a teacher) so she’s actually very weak in a few areas, nothing has been done to catch her up even when I’ve requested - I’ve been told the school don’t have the capacity to do this. Other parents have hired tutors so I suppose this is the only help my child will get so I also need to do. Not important factor I suppose but the receptionist that works there is so rude! Trying to get any information from her regarding anything is always met with huffing and puffing

The Ofsted rating is mostly a measure of the socio-economic background of the students.
Pinkflipflop85 · 21/02/2022 21:30

I worked in an 'Outstanding' school.

You couldn't have paid me to send my child there.

soapboxqueen · 21/02/2022 21:29

My dd's school is ranked outstanding but hasn't been inspected in about 15 years. The goal posts have changed many times since then.

In general, ofsted is of no use to you if you want to know anything about the operating of a school (outside of the address, pupil numbers etc). It won't tell you how well your child will do there, what they'll do if your child has issues there or how they will interact with you.

Ofsted reports have only a tenuous grasp on day to day reality.

I'm generally as suspicious of outstanding schools as I am of requires improvement since I've seen too many heads that chase 'outstanding' with very poor attitudes towards staff, parents and pupils.

In short, visiting a school and asking other parents of their experiences is vastly superior to an ofsted rating.

looloo247 · 21/02/2022 21:25

*recently graded good

looloo247 · 21/02/2022 21:25

Another teacher here, I'd choose a rectory graded good school over outstanding too as they're often striving to achieve outstanding. Outstanding schools could have been inspected many years ago under previous framework. They can keep their outstanding status even with a change in head/lots of staff/curriculum design etc.

x2boys · 21/02/2022 21:22

There is a school near me that is outstanding,but last had Ofsted in 2012 so who knows
The high school my nephew's went to and incidentally my old high school was rated outstanding in 2011,it had an Ofsted inspection a couple of years ago and was put into special measures ,and had apparently been in decline for a number of years but on paper it was outstanding .

WlNDMlLL · 21/02/2022 21:21

As a teacher, I'd probably rather send my child to a good school than am outstanding one. What Ofsted look for and what parents look for are not necessarily the same. Many of the old Ofsted ratings were based largely on data so if KS2 results were good (at whatever cost) then the school could achieve an Outstanding rating. When was it last inspected out of interest? Many outstanding schools are long overdue inspections.

Ann51abc · 21/02/2022 21:17

I know I’ve made typos such as a affluent instead of an affluent! Please ignore the numerous errors as typing on my phone

OP posts: