Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Is outstanding always outstanding?

63 replies

Ann51abc · 21/02/2022 21:16

My child’s primary is classed as outstanding. This is in London, quite a affluent area just for context. I do not feel, after sending my child for 4 years it is very outstanding. I kept this to myself as I didn’t want to be too negative and picky but recently found out lots of parents feel the same!

So my question is if your school is outstanding what actually makes it outstanding? I suppose recent headings would count as I know a few in the area who last had an inspection 10+ years ago.

The issues I feel in my child’s school are: no communication at all, this year been told she was assessed wrong last year (by a teacher) so she’s actually very weak in a few areas, nothing has been done to catch her up even when I’ve requested - I’ve been told the school don’t have the capacity to do this. Other parents have hired tutors so I suppose this is the only help my child will get so I also need to do. Not important factor I suppose but the receptionist that works there is so rude! Trying to get any information from her regarding anything is always met with huffing and puffing

OP posts:
ExhaustedMumma · 23/02/2022 07:35

We had the choice between a good and an outstanding school and we’ve chosen the good one. This was based on feedback from parent friends and just the feel of the school when visiting and their attitude towards the parents and children. The local outstanding school hasn’t been inspected for many years and has doubled in size in that time so it is very different to what it was. The good one is becoming very popular and I’m a bit worried we won’t get DD in!

FatCatThinCat · 23/02/2022 07:32

My DD went to an outstanding primary school. I ended up taking her out and putting her in a good school. The headteacher of the outstanding one was only concerned about appearances and grades. The new school head wasn't really interested in those and was totally focused on the happiness and inclusion of all the children. You could feel the difference in atmosphere when you were there.

MargaretThursday · 23/02/2022 07:26

When was it last inspected?
I've seen a number of local headlines about schools being inspected recently and going from outsianding to l to inadequate.
They've normally been inspected about 15 years ago.
It also was easier to get outstanding back then

balalake · 23/02/2022 07:10

The words used for inspections are an example of inflated language, which is not only found in the ratings of schools.

FatOaf · 23/02/2022 06:42

You seem to be making the mistake of assuming that words in Ofsted reports (or any other government/quango reports) mean the same as they do in English.

Ofsted will have a list of tick-boxes that have to be ticked to qualify for each grade. A school rated as "outstanding" has ticked the required boxes for that rating. In the 21st century, a head teacher's job is to get those boxes ticked. A rating of "outstanding" doesn't necessarily mean the school is any good. Similarly, a "requires improvement" rating doesn't necessarily mean the school is bad.

I've seen all this in the absurd Teaching Excellence Framework for universities, which has nothing to do with teaching or excellence (and isn't a framework).

Phineyj · 23/02/2022 06:11

Sorry, wrong thread!

FlamingoQueen · 21/02/2022 22:33

Ofsted are a waste of space! They come with an agenda and aren’t happy until they’ve trashed a good school!
Ask to speak to a member of the Senior Management team if you have issues.

Foldinthecheese · 21/02/2022 22:25

I can’t stress enough how much data is relied upon to form these judgements. I worked at a secondary that got a requires improvement judgment, and the decision had really been made even before they walked through the doors. We moved to good within a year, again based largely on a new, much improved set of results, although there were also some changes in leadership and some effective new initiatives.

My children also used to attend a nursery that, at the time, was graded outstanding. The wait list was a mile long. It has now been graded inadequate due to safeguarding issues involving choking hazards and children being able to access hot drinks. An Ofsted visit only captures a moment in time, so you need think much more about how well the school fits your child, rather than the label it boasts about.

EnidSpyton · 21/02/2022 22:22

Ofsted reports aren't worth the paper they're written on.

I've been a teacher for a decade.

I've worked in three 'outstanding' schools.

Every single one had psychotic headteachers, terrible staff morale and huge turnover, and students being worked into the ground to crank out the required exam results, with no thought for their wellbeing.

All of these schools were excellent at social media self promotion, paying lip service to the latest educational trends, and data gathering.

Ofsted don't care about the experience the students are getting, or what the working environment is like for teachers. They spend very little time in classrooms. They interview teachers and students, but most are too terrified of the consequences if they tell the truth, so the whole teacher and pupil voice thing is mere window dressing. It's impossible for them to meaningfully experience what a school is like to learn or teach in during their visits - they spend most of their time locked in meetings with SLT anyway - and this is why Ofsted judgements are based almost solely on paperwork. If you tick the boxes, you get your outstanding, even if teachers are leaving in droves and half the students are on the waiting list for CAMHS.

Unfortunately the psychotic heads are the ones who are very good at charming Ofsted inspectors. They also frequently tend to be Ofsted inspectors themselves.

Honestly, pay Ofsted inspections no mind. Go and visit the school and find out for yourself what it's really like. Personally for my kids I'd never want them setting foot in an Outstanding school, because I know it'll have overpromoted, underqualified and egotistical SLT who parrot the latest edutwitter bollocks, forcing the teachers to jump through pointless hoops to fit in with whatever is trendy in pedagogy today, alongside putting kids through endless assessments to 'close the gap' - these schools all have three year KS4 too, because obviously spending two years on rote learning to pass your GCSEs isn't enough to secure that top of the league table position - and there will be no room for creativity, joy or fun.

My teacher friends with more experience than me always say a satisfactory school (funny that they changed satisfactory to requires improvement a few years ago - because satisfactory isn't good enough! It's all very Orwellian!) is a happy school and I'd be inclined to agree.

Lndnmummy · 21/02/2022 22:20

I recently moved my son from an outstanding (my arse) school in Y5. The ofsted is older than my child and not worth the paper its written on. His new "good" school ia in my opinion outstanding in comparison.

MarineBlue33 · 21/02/2022 22:19

If your child is behind, the school should be addressing it. Every school should have a Covid 19 policy up on their website which will outline how those effected more than averagely by lockdowns, will have their needs met. This means that they should have had more sessions e g with tutors (in school) to get them up to speed. It is like a catch up grant. Did your school do that?
Arrange to meet with the Head/ senco too to get these academic issues your dc has addressed.
Sooner rather than later.
Lots of outstanding schools are not so great as PPs have said .
Otherwise get a tutor- assuming you can afford one.

jimpamdwight · 21/02/2022 22:15

My 2 dc's are at a (inspected in the last couple years) outstanding primary school, it's the one in our catchment and has one of the best reputations in the area. (A large city, not London).

Things I can note:
•excellent communication from the school
•teachers have all in themselves been wonderful and any problems have been quickly dealt with
•school atmosphere is lovely
•covid home schooling was good with everyday zoom lessons (even for 4 year old at the time)

But we're in a city, space is limited, pe is often forgotten about, I recently spent some time in the class room and was surprised, in a negative way. We are now looking at local private schools to move our children to.

KimDeals · 21/02/2022 22:11

My DCs school is rated Good and I am amazed and constantly surprised at how great they are - the individual care, the knowledge they have of each of my children, the detail and awareness of their individual needs, the heartwarming care I see from them. I’m amazed they are not ranked Outatanding and I’m very relieved I didn’t get too hung up on it becisee I did have the option to send DC to a different catchment primary. I visited both at the time, and this school just left me feeling more settled after the visit so I went with them. Best decision ever.

Im slightly obsessing now abiut secondary and getting/remaining in catchment for the feeder secondary school, which happens to be Outstanding, so it is very popular. I just hope our luck remains.

SpidersAreShitheads · 21/02/2022 22:08

I also think it's worth considering what your child needs.

So, for example, my DS in particular needed a SEN setting and eventually a SEN school. We had to go through the rigmarole of trying and failing at mainstream to get the LA to agree.

My DD - also SEN but capable in the right mainstream - needs time, support and extra help. A school that is tightly focussed on rapid progression and getting the highest possible scores wouldn't give her what she needs. Other schools which were deemed to be outstanding according to the OFTSED priorities would have been a disaster for my DD - she wouldn't have been able to cope.

Not every child needs the same kind of learning environment - and that's a concept that OFTSED and the government don't quite seem to grasp. The quest for homogenised, identical schools which tick boxes but only work if your child fits neatly into the box is so depressing.

Mumofsend · 21/02/2022 22:05

I have been in a LOT of schools over the past 2 years with my job. I am parent of two autistic children.

Unless your child is the perfectly round peg ready to fit in the hole I would avoid ofsted outstanding schools like the plague. As someone else said, what ofsted view as outstanding really aren't what parents want or look for.

SpidersAreShitheads · 21/02/2022 22:04

I was a school governor for 5+ years. Our school went from being outstanding - and almost the poster example of what schools should look like - to being put in special measures.

The OFTSED inspections change their criteria regularly to follow current government priorities. In many ways it doesn't reflect the things which are meaningful about a school.

Our school had a particularly high % of SEN pupils, and we had many children come to us after they'd been expelled/failed elsewhere. The amount of money and support that was poured into supporting these kids was amazing. Way, way beyond the statutory requirements. And I also speak as a parent with SEN DC who benefitted from this approach. The OFTSED report talked about the kindness and great community spirit of the school, and said that the way the pupils treated each other was exceptional. Our SEN kids weren't excluded from party invitations etc, it was a lovely place for children to learn about inclusion and acceptance. The OFTSED report said lots of very positive things about the school - but still put us in special measures. And it wasn't all just fluffy stuff either - our Phonics programme was acknowledged as being outstanding.

There absolutely were things which could be improved, and it no longer warranted an Outstanding. But the special measures judgement was rubbish - and we spent two years jumping through hoops to produce metrics to show that the school was competent. We did it, but the methods changed and it wasn't such a friendly, warm place for teachers or the pupils - and I can't say that it made much difference to the learning. Stats, stats and more stats, with even more red tape and pressure for the teachers and pupils alike. Rubbish.

The current way schools are inspected is awful and blows hot and cold with the latest government trends. It doesn't help the teachers deliver what they're trained to do, and it's not conducive to creating a warm, creative space for children to learn in the best way possible.

ItWasARayGun · 21/02/2022 22:04

We chose a good school 2 miles away over an outstanding school half a mile away. It just seemed far more holistic and child centred, whereas I really didn't take to the head at the outstanding school, she seemed really inflexible and results focused. 5 years on we're still really happy with that choice.

ItsSnowJokes · 21/02/2022 22:02

We are just moving our child from an "outstanding" school to a "good" school. We have not been impressed at all, and if they were inspected tomorrow I think they would fail badly. New headteacher has fucked it all up.

OfstedOffred · 21/02/2022 21:58

Tbh all school rating stuff fades away in reality when you realise that a) the schools objectives aren't necessarily aligned with yours as a parent, especially if your child is either end of the ability spectrum b) the governments aims almost definitely aren't and they are what drives Ofsted targets etc.

NandorTheRelentlessCleaner · 21/02/2022 21:52

I chose a "good" over and "outstanding" too Grin

Not to be contrarian, but I liked it more, had a more relaxed feel, and seemed to treat the kids more as individuals rather than products that have to come out with certain grades.

Visiting schools is the best way to get a feel for a place, IMO, and a chat with teacher/HT

Ofsted to be taken with grain of salt

FriedTomatoe · 21/02/2022 21:52

Having worked in an outstanding school and a good school, I feel the difference is the level of gloss and ability to keep good records. The atmosphere in my good school is really special and conducive to learning. All the kids and parents and really happy. In the outstanding school everything had to be evidenced perfectly (it's a good thing), the kids were reasonably happy but I don't think they were any better off educationally and the teachers were always bickering.

BendingSpoons · 21/02/2022 21:51

My DDs school is outstanding, inspected 2 years ago when it moved up from good. What I like about the school:

  • I believe in their teaching methods. They have regular parent meetings e.g. about how they teach maths or phonics and why (backed up with data). I'm not a teacher but have read quite a lot and trust they are doing a decent job.
  • They put the children first. Little things that makes them happy e.g. a writing area with sparkly gel pens they can use at lunch, fun Fridays after COVID where they can wear odd socks etc
  • Good communication. I can email the class teacher directly or the office and usually get a reply within a few hours. (I don't email much!)
  • I rate the head. She has been there a good while. She seems to support her teachers and works hard to get to know the children e.g. the senior staff were on the entrance gates throughout the COVID period to welcome the children.

Things aren't perfect of course. But it is still a state school with 30 kids in a class, SEN, limited funding etc.

FWIW The school has a mixed demographic economically, not the most deprived but not the most affluent either. At the same time the other school right nearby that is favoured by the middle classes in the area moved from Outstanding to Good. They will probably seesaw back in the future.

TempsPerdu · 21/02/2022 21:46

As a teacher, I'd probably rather send my child to a good school than am outstanding one. What Ofsted look for and what parents look for are not necessarily the same.

Adding to all the comments above about actively choosing an Ofsted ‘good’ school over an ‘outstanding’ one. Former primary teacher here and we have done this with DD, who starts Reception in September. In my experience outstanding largely means ‘good at paperwork, jumping through hoops and parroting Ofsted’s latest buzzwords’. It does not necessarily mean that schools are focused on pupil wellbeing, or delivering a broad and balanced curriculum. And most of the staff I know who work in outstanding schools are burnt out and disillusioned with teaching.

In my area it’s quite striking that the vast majority of the schools that have recently been judged outstanding are either academies or free schools that closely track the government’s current priorities (super-strict ethos; laser focus on key skills like phonics etc). It seems to be nigh on impossible to achieve an outstanding rating as a plain old community primary.

Ann51abc · 21/02/2022 21:44

@Pinkflipflop85

I worked in an 'Outstanding' school.

You couldn't have paid me to send my child there.

Could you share the things you felt weren’t what you expected of outstanding?
OP posts: