Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Is outstanding always outstanding?

63 replies

Ann51abc · 21/02/2022 21:16

My child’s primary is classed as outstanding. This is in London, quite a affluent area just for context. I do not feel, after sending my child for 4 years it is very outstanding. I kept this to myself as I didn’t want to be too negative and picky but recently found out lots of parents feel the same!

So my question is if your school is outstanding what actually makes it outstanding? I suppose recent headings would count as I know a few in the area who last had an inspection 10+ years ago.

The issues I feel in my child’s school are: no communication at all, this year been told she was assessed wrong last year (by a teacher) so she’s actually very weak in a few areas, nothing has been done to catch her up even when I’ve requested - I’ve been told the school don’t have the capacity to do this. Other parents have hired tutors so I suppose this is the only help my child will get so I also need to do. Not important factor I suppose but the receptionist that works there is so rude! Trying to get any information from her regarding anything is always met with huffing and puffing

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
RestingStitchFace · 23/02/2022 19:40

What Ofsted look for and what parents look for are not necessarily the same.

I'm a school governor and I'd Absolutely echo this. Ofsted are obsessed with whether a school is meeting academic performance indicators - indicators themselves that have been set arbitrarily by the Government and have little reflection on what education specialists think are reasonable.

A decent school takes a holistic approach and doesn't just focus on meeting Government imposed benchmarks.

My son's school is rated good. It's very average for results in the league table because it has a mixed catchment with a lot of kids from more deprived backgrounds. However, the Head is amazing. The pastoral care is excellent. My kid, who has SEND and who we fully expected would need to transition to a special needs setting by now, is thriving there. Kids can't learn unless they feel happy, safe and valued. I would absolutely choose a solidly average school with amazing pastoral care over an outstanding school that was basically a grade factory any day of the week.

MedusasBadHairDay · 23/02/2022 14:51

My kids went on to an ‘outstanding’ secondary which whipped them to achieve grades but drained the life out of many.

I'm so wary of schools like that. I know the school I went to was very focused on academic achievement, and when I went from a high achieving pupil to one who was either failing or barely scraping through, they jumped straight to trying to force me to drop out rather than trying to find out what was causing the problems (serious depression and self harm) and I will always resent them for that.

Ionlydomassiveones · 23/02/2022 13:11

This reply has been withdrawn

This has been withdrawn at the poster's request.

Upamountain43 · 23/02/2022 12:07

Our local school is considered 'outstanding' by Ofsted but Children's Social Services do not want any foster children going there and cringe when they hear of a child there - due to rather blatant classism and less obvious but still there racism and ableism.

In other words unless you are white middle class then your child will be discriminated against - but its still outstanding!

SpiderinaWingMirror · 23/02/2022 11:47

My dd went to an outstanding school up to year 4 , then to a good school for 5 and 6.
Both were good schools. Maths was a disaster though as they introduced shanghai maths. Dd was already 2 years behind due to development delay. She was utterly thrown.
Luckily we moved house. In "good" school she progressed so quickly that by the end of year 6 she got level 4 in SATs.
That school had a head teacher who stood by the gate and greeted every child and parent by name. He also made sure that when assemblies etc were on, dd was working away 121 on building skills.
As I say, both were good schools.

x2boys · 23/02/2022 11:06

My sister was a primary school teacher for 25 years ,the school she worked in was in a deprived are when she first started working 90% were from a Pakistani background a lot of the children ,didn't speak English as a first language and some parents spoke very little English ,over the years the demographics of the school changed somewhat ,quite few immigrant families from Eastern Europe moved into the area for a lot of the time the population of the school was quite transient and pupils might only stay a year or two ,clearly issues like this are going to affect SAT results language barriers etc the school is never going to be on an equal footing ,with schools in a leafy middle class area with a stable population ,no matter how good the teaching is .

OnceuponaRainbow18 · 23/02/2022 10:48

My kids go to an outstanding primary school, judged outstanding 2019 and 2011.

The teachers are amazing, the kids behave well, they send us weekly newsletters what they are doing, lots of clubs, lots of extra support for kids that need it, good results, the kindest staff.

I teach in an requirement improvement/inadequate school, teachers absolutely amazing, work so hard, kids just struggle to make progress as many speak 2 words of English when they arrive to our GCSE classes!

pytuqula · 23/02/2022 10:39

I was a secondary teacher (head of maths, teacher-governor) way back when HMI ('Her Majesty's Inspectorate') was killed off, essentially because it was independent of the government of the day and hence felt able to criticise policy on evidence. HMI were far from perfect, but were so much better than OFSTED. I had later experience of OFSTED as my career progressed. They started badly, and then deteriorated.

OFSTED are now worse than useless ... and the criteria they try to use to assess schools are themselves generally detrimental to education. We perhaps should not be surprised at any of this given the crazy situation we have in which those setting the criteria and appointing the organisation that applies them have mostly had no experience, either as pupils or parents thereof, of the schools under assessment, and indeed share a strong vested interest in maintaining the startlingly unequal provision of resources within the nation's educational establishment as a whole.

There are good schools in UK, and outstanding teachers and head-teachers. But these schools are good, these teachers outstandingly good educators, in despite of the depredations of OFSTED and its old-Etonian masters. Nor do OFSTED reports in any way tally with good educational principles or practice.

So, if you want an outstanding school for your children, ignore OFSTED reports. Ask parents; visit schools; talk to children. There are, indeed, some schools that severely let down their pupils; unfortunately, an OFSTED 'outstanding' rating does not preclude a school being one of those. But, again, there are schools that nevertheless, despite everything, work as well as possible given dearth of resources; finding such schools and some are genuinely very good in spite of everything is difficult but not impossible.

This is a nightmare for parents. But, well, I tell myself, we have democratic accountability; they (you, MN people included) voted for it. Deal with it.

GertrudePerkinsPaperyThing · 23/02/2022 10:14

My son’s outstanding primary hasn’t had an ofsted forever and a day. They really need one! There are lots of things they will probably need to improve if they are ever inspected.

My dd was in an outstanding secondary but it’s now been graded “needs improvement” after their first inspection in over 10 years. It’s good this has happened as now they will have something to work on.

Not inspecting outstanding schools for years was an absolute disgrace IMO

MedusasBadHairDay · 23/02/2022 10:09

The school my kids go to is rated "requires improvement" as far as I can tell this largely relates to grades achieved. Because they are wonderful with the children, especially their mental wellbeing - which after the last few years is so important. My kids are thriving there, more than I think they would at the "Outstanding" school down the road which gave me the impression that they were far more focused on grades than letting the kids just be kids.

Whatelsecouldibecalled · 23/02/2022 10:03

The school I work at is classed as 'outstanding'. It's not. By a long shot. Should we be inspected again any time soon it won't keep that rating for sure

Rosewaterblossom · 23/02/2022 09:53

My experience of working in schools is on the day/s that ofsted are visiting, they act like completely different schools. The head/some staff have spent the previous day running around tidying, sorting, preparing... you name it.

Imo Ofted should visit in the same way Environment Health do for catering establishments where they just turn up. They would get a much more accurate view of the school on a normal day.

My dcs primary was Outstanding and it really was when the old head was there. That rating was in 2008 though and the school rode that wave for years, even when the head left and the school went down hill. The school has recently been inspected and recieved a Requires Improvement rating.

TheMindBoggle · 23/02/2022 09:41

If I'd had my time again, I would have chosen a good school over outstanding for my kids.

The outstanding school they went to left them both broken due to their SEND. It was all about the figures and the pretence of the pupil wellbeing when they looked the other way and told me they didn't have any 'needs'. The secondary school spotted those 'needs' very quickly!

LondonQueen · 23/02/2022 09:21

Absolutely not, there was an outstanding primary in the news recently that has just been placed in special measures.

DameOctaviaOstrich · 23/02/2022 09:14

I worked in an outstanding school. Outstanding my arse. I worked in a failing school and that was the one I would have chosen. Staff were amazing with a great pastoral team. They didn't stage things for inspections

Metalguru22 · 23/02/2022 09:14

*"I am a school governor - as long as you have a head who can tick all the boxes then you will get outstanding. The boxes that need ticking have nothing to do with your child's well-being - they are just statistics that the government can use to say that they are doing something about education.

Our school is Good - this is because we insist that we only do the minimum of box ticking and that the staff spend as much time as possible enriching the children's lives.

But still the poor Head is sending me emails at 2 in the morning - he should be asleep not messing with figures."*

Absolute rubbish. If it was only that easy... If you really are a school governor maybe update yourself with the current inspection criteria.

The thing about Outstanding schools is that they are judged to be that on the day, drawing on various sources of evidence. The situation can change quite rapidly, so if a school hasn't had an inspection for several years who knows what judgement they would get now? (The HT will have a good idea and hopefully so will the governors).

sashh · 23/02/2022 08:57

Outstanding means the school know how to tick the right boxes and put the right pupils on show.

I'm not sure it would be possible for a school to be outstanding to all its pupils because needs differ.

StepAwayFromGoogling · 23/02/2022 08:56

I've been really sceptical since our awesome nursery slipped into 'improvement needed' from outstanding. The report sounded damning when you read it. But turned out the following:
'Nursery do not have adequate procedures in place to ensure the safety of children' = my very accident-prone no fear DD had one too many accidents in the playground which should have triggered a further risk assessment. The children were perfectly safe.
'Staff have no awareness of basic hygiene' = The automatic taps in the bathroom stopped working on the day of the inspection so the staff used a bowl of soapy water and flannels to clean the children's hands instead.
'Children are not properly safeguarded' = The staff interviewed did not know the exact procedure for reporting religious radicalisation within their setting - 'report it to my manager' not sufficient apparently. But FFS religious radicalisation among 3 and 4 year olds?!
I would be very sceptical of Ofsted ratings on that basis.
Both DDs LOVED their nursery. They were so happy there and so well looked after. Anything else at that age is irrelevant IMHO.

Aroundtheworldin80moves · 23/02/2022 08:20

I was a School Governor when the school went through Ofsted. They narrowly missed out on Outstanding overall. The teaching and opportunities etc were all considered amazing.. indeed to Early Years section was rated Outstanding. But the admin was a bit off and their communication with the parents sometimes fell short... which the school was working on and the parents agreed it was improving. The general thought with the parents was the headteacher was a bit weak (the deputy was amazing). It was interesting seeing something from that side.

Generally,as a parent I ignore any rating older than a couple of years. Always look at the date when taking something into account.

Blabla81 · 23/02/2022 08:15

My children’s school is a “good” school. Recently inspected and maintained its previous good rating.
In my opinion it’s an outstanding school - we all just love it - never had any complaints. I’m also a teacher so have always known what to look out for. I’d worry that official outstanding schools become complacent (many around this area have done).

SallyLovesCheese · 23/02/2022 08:13

It's always amazed me how much many parents are guided by the Ofsted rating. It can give an indicator of the school but nothing beats visiting and talking to people.

For me, the headteacher and SLT are everything about a school. Try and meet the head if you can. I worked for an outstanding primary in London for five years. They really were and are outstanding because the two heads (large school) are fantastic - approachable, open, hands on, supportive... Every morning they are at the school gates to get children (unless pre-arranged meeting). Every morning they visit each class to say good morning. Compare that to another school I worked in where you didn't see the head sometimes all day, shut up in their office doing paperwork - supposedly good but as a teacher it was an horrendous place to work.

Opal8 · 23/02/2022 08:00

There is a primary school near me rayed as outstanding which haant had an ofsted since 2008....

Mackmama · 23/02/2022 07:54

My children go to a school that’s rated good. I could have fought to get them into a faith school which is very close to our house and is rated outstanding, and I believe we’d have had a good chance of getting them in, but we loved the feel of the good school when we visited and decided to put that down as 1st choice. Our instincts have proven to be correct, our children benefit from brilliant teachers who really care about them. It’s not an outstanding school but from a parents perspective I can’t see how it could be any better.

PicaK · 23/02/2022 07:41

Ofsted has changed.
Ofsted has changed
Ofsted has changed
They don't even look at data anymore when they visit.
They do look at whether staff understand what they want to teach, how they want to teach it and how they'll check that kids are learning.
A recently inspected school that got outstanding? I'd send my kids there like a shot.

SirSamVimesCityWatch · 23/02/2022 07:36

There's lots of schools being inspected now that have been exempt from inspection because they got outstanding ten+ years ago and are now getting requires improvement. That's partly due to a different inspection framework but also because the relevance of an Ofsted grade awarded a decade ago to a school now is basically zero.