Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

The way the Tory government are acting now makes it feel like all the lockdowns were a waste of time

366 replies

Poetrypatty · 21/02/2022 17:24

Just lifting all the restrictions as if it was all a waste of time. It makes me feel like a mug for everything we went through, especially as they were having their parties and not even following the rules. I think it's bad for peoples mental health as well.

OP posts:
sst1234 · 22/02/2022 10:41

@Poetrypatty

One of the concerns I've got is that as yet we don't know that with Covid you just build up immunity and that's it. The virus will mutate and we don't know what will happen next yet. Also, people can catch it over and over again.

I think we need sick pay to be widespread and we need people to be staying at home if they have the virus. I don't want to be out and about eg at the dentist say, and the dentist has covid but is still working. That's what could happen come April 1st. To me that makes no sense.

They should ease off restrictions more gradually and we need to have a society where people who are sick can be supported to stay home for a few days.

So basically you want to live in a virus free world. Not scientifically possible is it? Do you take the same view of the seasonal flu too? Omicron is milder that that.
Cornettoninja · 22/02/2022 10:41

For sure this period in time is going to provide study fodder for decades to come!

Ain’t that the truth! I’m preparing to be interviewed by my grandchildren for homework Wink

Poetrypatty · 22/02/2022 10:37

One of the concerns I've got is that as yet we don't know that with Covid you just build up immunity and that's it. The virus will mutate and we don't know what will happen next yet. Also, people can catch it over and over again.

I think we need sick pay to be widespread and we need people to be staying at home if they have the virus. I don't want to be out and about eg at the dentist say, and the dentist has covid but is still working. That's what could happen come April 1st. To me that makes no sense.

They should ease off restrictions more gradually and we need to have a society where people who are sick can be supported to stay home for a few days.

OP posts:
sst1234 · 22/02/2022 10:37

@GirlInACountrySong

Sick pay is for sick people too sick to work

Not so they can sit at home feeling fine.

This needs to be repeated over and over.
Brefugee · 22/02/2022 10:35

i think the comparison with flu is ok because of the pandemic in 1918 - when Covid-19 first broke out i read a lot about the pandemic, from an economics pov because that's where i have more experience, and i have been prepared for it to go on for 2-3 years of lockdowns and measures to hopefully prevent the spread.

I agree that from a medical pov something like chicken pox is a better comparison. In fact chicken pox can be deadly, can be relatively easy and spreads like wildfire (in German it's "Windpocken" which means literally wind-pox, because of how easy it is to catch). If covid had spots like that, maybe people would be more careful? who knows

As we see with measles though, people still refuse the vaccination because they personally don't have experience of how bad it can be. I'm probably in one of the last generations who didn't get MMR as a baby (not invented then) and had to have a rubella jab at 12 because it was recognised how serious it was (in my cohort at school it was 100% uptake).

I think in places where governments aren't distrusted as much it's not as difficult to persuade people about public health measures? I may start to investigate that.

For sure this period in time is going to provide study fodder for decades to come!

Cornettoninja · 22/02/2022 10:23

@Brefugee I don’t disagree with your very considered post, pretty much exactly what we’re missing from our leaders right now imho. From Boris yesterday:

“Today is not the day we can declare victory over Covid, because this virus is not going away.

But it is the day when all the efforts of the last two years finally enabled us to protect ourselves while restoring our liberties in full."

You can see how widely that has been interpreted which is no good when we all need to have an unambiguous understanding of the current status of things.

As an addition, I don’t really like the comparisons with flu, most diseases could be compared with flu if we take the milder end of symptoms but that’s not the bit we’re concerned about. Imho covid is one to add to the same categories as measles, chicken pox, rubella etc. By that logic I would be just as concerned about any of those at similar levels of infections around the country.

Brefugee · 22/02/2022 10:21

You only get a RAG 3 rolling sicknesses where I work. So no. I will not be wasting one on feeling fine.....when 2 weeks down the line I may need the next for a genuine illness. The third sickness triggers a disciplinary

Well @GirlInACountrySong if you had read any of my posts (horribly long, i know) you would realise that i have not at any point said that people should risk their livliehoods to stay home when sick.

What i have repeatedly said (not just today but on any occasion it's been discussed) is that the UK (and other countries) need to rethink their attitude to sickness and sick pay and not force people to put themselves (health and livlihood) or others (health) at risk because they can't afford to stay home.

Personally, I'm in a nice m-c job with a nice m-c employer and it's not shit at all. Currently am, as required by employer, at home (working= due to my office buddy testing positive the other day. The other person who was with us that day is now also positive and WFH again, having taken a few days off due to feeling rough.

The difference being that i fully recognise the privilege of being able to do that and instead of a glib "people should get jobs with better conditions" i ask people to vote for better governments who would enable that. And have the utmost sympathy and understanding for anyone who is having to work when they really shouldn't be.

GirlInACountrySong · 22/02/2022 10:07

Also, the stress and mental health of those left in the workplace running round trying to cover these isolators is too much now

So to protect THEM it's right that otherwise healthy people are working doing their share

GirlInACountrySong · 22/02/2022 10:06

No @Brefugee

You only get a RAG 3 rolling sicknesses where I work. So no. I will not be wasting one on feeling fine.....when 2 weeks down the line I may need the next for a genuine illness. The third sickness triggers a disciplinary

Some people lose their job at this stage

Brefugee · 22/02/2022 09:58

I'm not sure of the exact requirements, but that is the next step from a pandemic.

We live with flu. It is easy to dismiss flu as a heavy cold, but it can be fatal. The flu jab is offered to certain sections of society, and i think that is the least we should be doing, as well as not carrying blithely on with our lives when we have it. (yes, asymptomatic people are a risk with any disease that may present like that)

So even if we're not technically at endemic stage, that's where we're heading and governments will follow their own paths towards how they handle it, hopefully using sensible unbiased medical advice.

Part of the problem that we have in developed democracies is our ability to question government decisions. And governing like policing is by consent: we agree to the rules for the most part but there are always some who laugh in the face of rules.

Unfortunately from where I'm watching, people in the UK seem to be very polarised around what has been going on, there doesn't seem to be much middle ground whether it's marmite, the PM or the rules around Covid-19. The MSM don't help there much, tbh.

And it's not that we don't have issues here in Germany, because oh boy we do.

Cornettoninja · 22/02/2022 09:43

The pandemic was always going to move to endemic at some point. Maybe we're there, maybe not

Doesn’t a disease need to be predictable to be defined as endemic? I don’t think we’re there yet personally, we have no idea what level of infection to expect over summer or next winter.

Cornettoninja · 22/02/2022 09:40

Oh god the naivety

You’re basing that comment on what? The medical judgement of a paper written by economists?

If so, whilst I don’t argue against the harmful effects of lockdowns, trying to give those facts more credibility by disparaging the effects on health, more specifically the spread of an infectious disease, is an odd stance to take. It’s not either/or, it’s both.

Brefugee · 22/02/2022 09:30

Sick pay is for sick people too sick to work
Not so they can sit at home feeling fine.

Alternatively, in a pandemic, it is to keep the asymptomatic but sick away from the healthy and vulnerable and sickpay enables that?

I remember very very early on in the pandemic, when it was still a worrying thing in China, that one of my Taiwanese (but worked in China) colleagues said "it's easy to have a proper lockdown in a dictatorship, good luck in the liberal west!" and when i think about that, i do wonder why people think that any Western-style democracies went into lockdown?

And the reason they give, and i choose to believe it because it makes sense, is that they wanted to do their best to stop a disease rampaging round society like the Black Death and overwhelming hospitals (which weren't a great option at the time of the Black Death, tbh)

Incidentally, as to rethinking our society. The Black Death is a great example. 10% of the population died during that wave. As a result tradespeople managed to get more rights and money, because they were needed and in short supply.

Join a union. Grin

AllOfUsAreDead · 22/02/2022 09:23

@Brefugee

Agree with everything you said. Our society is a bit shit and would hope that it would get better, but I'm not sure it will.

Tigersonvaseline · 22/02/2022 09:18

There may be more problems down the road, right now,we are GO!!

It's critical that we get out and live whilst we can!!

GirlInACountrySong · 22/02/2022 09:16

Sick pay is for sick people too sick to work

Not so they can sit at home feeling fine.

Brefugee · 22/02/2022 09:10

I don't think I ever did get confirmation of another country where they were provided for free, but you always had to pay in France, Spain and ROI (the ones I happen to know).

In Germany LFT are free as are PCR if you are sent for one (AFAIK) they stopped being free last year at some point, but were reintroduced when the next wave arrived.

TBH because i have a lovely middle class laptop wfh job, i didn't find the lockdowns here that onerous. Lucky me.

I think we all need to take a bit of a step back, a deep breath and look at what we are actually going to do. One thing the pandemic may finally have driven home is that it is utterly ridiculous, unless you really can't avoid it, to have any illness and walk around blithely spreading it.

If the reason that you can't avoid doing that is because you have a job that doesn't have good sick pay - we really ought to ask ourselves, as a society, if that is really what we want? Forcing low paid workers to a) work while sick and b) spread an infection unnecessarily for want of better terms and conditions.

One of the other things is things like the health service. People were still going to A&E for literal A&E events, and were seen quicker. Maybe we need to consider why so many people use A&E for non A&E cases and overhaul not only the NHS (or wherever you are) but also our attitude to health. And sometimes a bit of self-help can go a long way.

And if we have to go out and about while sick (colds, flu, D&V whatever) maybe it isn't too much to ask that we wear a mask? As pp have repeatedly pointed out, this is standard in many countries, there is no reason why it couldn't take off in Europe.

The precariousness of many jobs/industries has been thrown into relief. As have supply chain issues. Maybe having all manufacturing in one region (mostly Asia) isn't as good as we thought it was. Our rates of consumption are something always worth thinking about.

Early on in the pandemic in so many places there were real instances of excellent community support, it would be a shame if that completely vanished. There were some real instances of appallingly selfish, profiteering behaviour. We know who they were. I hope they feel real consequences of that.

The pandemic was always going to move to endemic at some point. Maybe we're there, maybe not yet (maybe we already passed it) but what we need to do is not react to things like this in extreme ways. We also need to realise that if you got a letter saying "you are CEV STAY HOME OR YOU'LL DIE" (or words to that effect) it's not something that everyone can simply put behind them because some wild-haired chap said it on TV. A bit of empathy goes a long way.

I would also hope that in countries where governments were shown to be a bit cronyish, and not obeying their own rules, the people voting in the next government bear that in mind when they go to the polling stations.

What we have now is a bit like a post-war period. How we handle that up is up to us. But turning on each other and implying that people who don't agree with you are idiots isn't going to end well, is it?

ImprobablePuffin · 22/02/2022 08:45

@LadyMuckOfCowshitFarm

When will people learn that 2022 covid is NOT the same beast as 2020 covid. You wouldn't test all the time for a common cold so why this. Just get on with your lives and stop this nonsense. You don't need to fork out for tests because you don't need to test. Just like you don't for all the other mild virus

@ImprobablePuffin when will people learn that for CEV people covid is, if not the same, a very similar beast to 2020 Covid?

We can't rely on vaccines, and now we won't have the reassurance that people will be isolating if ill. The latter is fine - as long as we have access to free LFTs, which have been our first line of defence. Without them, we're a bit fucked.

We do need to test and we can't 'get on with our lives'.

I apologise. My comment was written quickly and not well thought out.

What I mean is, pre covid people who are vulnerable (of which I am one) could t test or be vaccinated for mild virus' so whatever we did before covid to protect ourselves is what we should be doing now. It's not everyone else's responsibility to look after me.
And also I didn't acknowledge that of course some people will have to test regularly for work etc but will those rules change if people can't access tests I wonder.

HesterShaw1 · 22/02/2022 08:41

@BoldMove

It wasn't a waste of time as its saved lots of lives. The time wasters are the ones who haven't been vaccinated or following the rules. We'd have been a lot further forward then.
Oh god the naivety.
luckylavender · 22/02/2022 08:35

@Bollindger - also Sweden is not as densely populated, there's more space. Not comparable.

Ogel · 22/02/2022 08:24

[quote Cornettoninja]@ogel don’t forget you have to factor that 2bil against the cost of contact isolations and infected isolations previously.

We’ve just come through a peak of Omicron and advice to test for seven days as a contact and people testing to release early from day 5 of infections. Regardless of whether you agree with that tactic personally or not I don’t like the way this figure has been presented as something that indicates peoples wastefulness rather than following government policy (which you would hope someone sat down and did the projected figures for before they implemented it).[/quote]
People have been wasteful as well, either through organisations making up their own rules and them having to comply to access services or by whatever you want to call it. Of course not all of them, but probably countered in part by the people who were supposed to test and didn't bother.

AllOfUsAreDead · 22/02/2022 08:24

@Bollindger

I was just listening to a person talking about Lockdown, 17,000 people actually died of Covid, not WITH covid, and the average age was 80, also flu deaths were down by oh about 17,000. Sweden did no lockdown and their figures, get this the same as ours. So was it worth it?
I wouldnt say that's a good argument for was the locks owns necessary.

Sweden have a population of 10million. Britain is around 70million. So Sweden looks way worse for having had the same amount of deaths as us.

I thought all the scientists and health workers were saying this is a bad idea anyway? Guess we will find out won't we?

luckylavender · 22/02/2022 08:20

@Lazypuppy

You can still get testibg i'm sure, you just have to pay for it, as it should be now after 2 years.

Sick pay, work for a company who offers good sick pay, as plenty of people tried to do before covid. There are other illnesses other than covid

So glib. I'm alright Jack. People can't afford food / heating, let alone tests. And of course everyone would like sick pay but only 19% get it.
sst1234 · 22/02/2022 08:11

People who believe lockdowns saved lives are so badly fooled, it’s unreal. Lockdowns had a marginal impact on mortality, John Hopkins study is the latest to show this.
But lockdowns will cost millions of lives on this country alone in this country alone - from poor mental health, poor educational outcomes for children whose life chances are permanently damaged due to school closures, peoples standard of living impacted by the rampant inflation caused by money printing the world over.

NETSRIK · 22/02/2022 08:11

It has been 2 years!! How long do you want covid to be the only thing we focus on?