Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

The way the Tory government are acting now makes it feel like all the lockdowns were a waste of time

366 replies

Poetrypatty · 21/02/2022 17:24

Just lifting all the restrictions as if it was all a waste of time. It makes me feel like a mug for everything we went through, especially as they were having their parties and not even following the rules. I think it's bad for peoples mental health as well.

OP posts:
toomuchlaundry · 22/02/2022 12:09

Surely it is wise that the people visiting vulnerable people have access to tests too. Surely better to prevent them getting it in the first place

VikingOnTheFridge · 22/02/2022 12:08

We need to ensure that those who are most clinically vulnerable have access to as many free LFTs as they need, which may include when asymptomatic. Some of the savings made by not providing constant free access to asymptomatic lower risk people, which is a good thing, ought to fund this. I'm not up for continuing to subside people who think it's unethical to go to Tesco or get on a bus without one, but we need to ensure we provide what ECV people need.

FairyCakeWings · 22/02/2022 11:57

It’s not dismissive of people’s anxieties or wariness to stop free testing. Those people can continue to test for free for at least another month and when it’s properly Spring, if they want to test they can pay for it. If it’s not medically indicated, then there’s no reason why the state should pay for it.

toomuchlaundry · 22/02/2022 11:56

I would worry about not testing before seeing a vulnerable relative in nursing home/hospital, but I guess I need to adjust my mindset. Would avoid visiting DF pre COVID when he had cancer if we had illnesses or had been knowingly around people with a contagious bug. But obviously we could have been around him after being with someone else who had been asymptomatic, I just wasn’t as aware that was a possibility, as everyone always said you would know if you had flu, but actually that isn’t the case

Cornettoninja · 22/02/2022 11:52

But very few people will need to test - the vast majority of people who want to carry on testing are doing so to appease their own anxiety, so this really isn't relevant here

Again, the recent major usage of tests was due to government policies of early release for the infected from isolation and 7 day contact testing. Remove those requirements and the demand for LFT’s would reduce substantially, particularly without a legal requirement to isolate if infected, people who have no intention of changing their routines haven’t been testing anyway and they still won’t.

I think you’re dismissing people with general anxieties along with those who are wary for good reason. I think there are many more in the latter group than the former but that’s not provable either way.

MarshaBradyo · 22/02/2022 11:46

But very few people will need to test - the vast majority of people who want to carry on testing are doing so to appease their own anxiety

I agree with this. After the messaging we’ve had for two years I get it’s hard but it’s costing an absolute fortune, plus other downsides to isolation.

FairyCakeWings · 22/02/2022 11:41

We should also be discouraging pointless testing because of the obscene amount of plastic waste they create. Providing them for free isn’t cost effective for the country any more. The amount they cost to provide doesn’t give good value for money anymore compared to the benefit they have to the population as a whole.

Giveaschitt · 22/02/2022 11:41

@Poetrypatty

You can continue to test until the end of March for free, and then after that, you can pay for tests if you feel you need to know whether your illness is covid or a different virus. They just won't be free anymore

We live in a country where at least 4.3 children live in poverty. People have to use food banks and can't afford heating. So they won't be able to afford tests either, and the poorest will be clobbered.

But very few people will need to test - the vast majority of people who want to carry on testing are doing so to appease their own anxiety, so this really isn't relevant here.
Dragongirl10 · 22/02/2022 11:35

and why will the poorest be clobbered?

The economy will move forward, the jobs market will continue to improve, schools will be open, the result of the economy growing again is more tax receipts....so your comment is just silly.

There is no magic money tree we all have to get back to work!

Cornettoninja · 22/02/2022 11:31

@Giveaschitt

What benefit do you think there is in people continuing to test for every cold? It's costing a fortune and it is no longer providing the benefit it did before. If you're ill, why do you need to know if it's covid or not?!

I don’t think that ‘everyone’ would test for every little cold for a start, there’s already a shift in people doing that. However, for people who covid does present a risk for the treatments that are available time is of the essence. People delaying diagnosis impacts the effectiveness of what treatments we do have available.

Ending access to LFT’s in April means that there will be people who will be further into disease progression before they’re able to access a diagnosis and reduce the effectiveness of what we do have available. That impacts the poorest, a substantial number of whom will be elderly/disabled if the costs of tests are prohibitive or difficult to access.

As I’ve already said, we can’t make any meaningful predictions on the standard projection of disease prevalence but currently it’s much higher than flu/measles/chicken pox etc. prevalence of covid alone is justification for easy access to LFT’s for a further period of time, certainly until we have a significant period of stability whether that’s at higher or lower numbers.

Dragongirl10 · 22/02/2022 11:31

Ya b completely unreasonable.
We had restrictions at times when the virus was rife, there were large numbers of deaths and hospitals were being over whelmed.
Now none of the above is true and the virus is milder than previously.
I appreciate that a lot of masochists are desperate for restrictions to go on forever but most people just want life to go back to normal.

This ^

And the most important thing, we have all had the chance to be vaccinated three times which reduces our chance of dying (or ending up in intensive care) massively.

FairyCakeWings · 22/02/2022 11:30

We live in a country where at least 4.3 children live in poverty. People have to use food banks and can't afford heating. So they won't be able to afford tests either, and the poorest will be clobbered

Why will they be clobbered? Testing is completely optional unless for work, in which case employers can pay for the tests. People will just do what they’ve always done when they have colds or flu or chest infections etc. Plenty of people haven’t used tests at all, or only very occasionally and their lives are still continuing fine.

Brefugee · 22/02/2022 11:26

Oh no, i get it about measles. I was thinking it's more the mindset rather than measels actually being comparable (in any way apart from we have a vaccination against it) to Covid.

I think some good courses in risk perception would be good - it would help in so many areas where a panic outbreaks because a headline says something like "people who X are 25% more likely to get a boil on their bum compared to the rest of the population" where the chances of a boil on the bum are already vanishingly small (or relatively small, i have no idea) wher 25% of vanishingly small is still vanishingly small. If we all understood risk evaluation and statistics better it would be better for us all.

Cornettoninja · 22/02/2022 11:21

As we see with measles though, people still refuse the vaccination because they personally don't have experience of how bad it can be

Sorry to butcher your post in pieces @Brefugee but on this point I think it’s pertinent to point out that measles isn’t circulating anywhere near the scale that covid is. There is still an impact on measles outbreaks from people choosing not to vaccinate but it isn’t the same risk profile as choosing not to vaccinate for something that’s circulating in the numbers covid is. If covid had similar projections to the current status of measles (I had a quick look for the UK which projects 600k cases of measles annually) I would be all in for the measures the UK is currently implementing but vice versa I would be expecting action from the government if measles cases were as high as covid.

We just seem to swing wildly in our perspectives of the risks covid presents at any one time. Things have absolutely changed over the course of the pandemic but that’s why it makes no sense to me that the aim is to return to the exact same scenario prior to Covid’s existence. It does exist and it’s having an impact; dismissing it as comparable to the flu (which also impacts massively on healthcare provision and economically) also veers people away from questioning the government on how they’re going to build in permanent healthcare provision for the serious cases we do have and should expect from this point forward.

Poetrypatty · 22/02/2022 11:19

You can continue to test until the end of March for free, and then after that, you can pay for tests if you feel you need to know whether your illness is covid or a different virus. They just won't be free anymore

We live in a country where at least 4.3 children live in poverty. People have to use food banks and can't afford heating. So they won't be able to afford tests either, and the poorest will be clobbered.

OP posts:
Giveaschitt · 22/02/2022 11:16

[quote Cornettoninja]@Giveaschitt an example of a reduction would be to end seven day contact testing and encourage use of LFT’s for symptomatic cases only. PCR’s could be reserved for those who are very ill and ordered by a doctor for confirmation for treatment purposes. There are steps available between testing at the current level and not testing at all.[/quote]
But that is essentially what is happening? You can continue to test until the end of March for free, and then after that, you can pay for tests if you feel you need to know whether your illness is covid or a different virus. They just won't be free anymore. Doctors will still be able to test in hospitals just as they do for flu.
What benefit do you think there is in people continuing to test for every cold? It's costing a fortune and it is no longer providing the benefit it did before. If you're ill, why do you need to know if it's covid or not?! You wouldn't go spreading your awful stinking cold around your vulnerable relatives just because "it's not covid" would you? So if you're ill, you're ill. The only reason to move even more gradually than we are is purely to ease people's anxiety.

MarshaBradyo · 22/02/2022 11:13

@MrsSkylerWhite

Yesterday 17:36 Poetrypatty

I appreciate that a lot of masochists are desperate for restrictions to go on forever but most people just want life to go back to normal.

Going back to normal isn't pretending the virus has gone away or not monitoring it any more though. This is to save Boris Johnson's job.

I want normality as much as everyone else.“

Was reported on PM yesterday that the ONS survey will continue, which is the best monitoring tool we have.

I agree. The line pretending it’s over isn’t what applies here.

Surveillance will continue

MarshaBradyo · 22/02/2022 11:12

[quote Poetrypatty]**@Giveaschitt an example of a reduction would be to end seven day contact testing and encourage use of LFT’s for symptomatic cases only. PCR’s could be reserved for those who are very ill and ordered by a doctor for confirmation for treatment purposes. There are steps available between testing at the current level and not testing at all.

That kind of thing is a good common sense approach. I'd like scientists and doctors to be at the forefront of decision making, not the right wing of the Tory party.[/quote]
Did you listen to Whitty and Vallance?

Even Chris Whitty says it was a mistake to think of this as sudden rather than gradual.

Have a listen - he talks about it being a steady approach

Poetrypatty · 22/02/2022 11:04

@Giveaschitt an example of a reduction would be to end seven day contact testing and encourage use of LFT’s for symptomatic cases only. PCR’s could be reserved for those who are very ill and ordered by a doctor for confirmation for treatment purposes. There are steps available between testing at the current level and not testing at all.

That kind of thing is a good common sense approach. I'd like scientists and doctors to be at the forefront of decision making, not the right wing of the Tory party.

OP posts:
MrsSkylerWhite · 22/02/2022 10:50

Yesterday 17:36 Poetrypatty

I appreciate that a lot of masochists are desperate for restrictions to go on forever but most people just want life to go back to normal.

Going back to normal isn't pretending the virus has gone away or not monitoring it any more though. This is to save Boris Johnson's job.

I want normality as much as everyone else.“

Was reported on PM yesterday that the ONS survey will continue, which is the best monitoring tool we have.

Cornettoninja · 22/02/2022 10:50

@Giveaschitt an example of a reduction would be to end seven day contact testing and encourage use of LFT’s for symptomatic cases only. PCR’s could be reserved for those who are very ill and ordered by a doctor for confirmation for treatment purposes. There are steps available between testing at the current level and not testing at all.

GirlInACountrySong · 22/02/2022 10:48

covid 2020 and covid omicron 2022 are very different

GirlInACountrySong · 22/02/2022 10:46

@Poetrypatty unfortunately that has got to happen....omicron is so mild theres no point people using up a sickness on it and leaving their colleagues short staffed in the workplace. we no longer have the resources

Cornettoninja · 22/02/2022 10:46

So basically you want to live in a virus free world. Not scientifically possible is it?

That’s not what they said is it?

Do you take the same view of the seasonal flu too? Omicron is milder that that

Seasonal flu isn’t particularly mild in a real life sense of the word, it’s certainly something people take time off school/work for and can take a long time to recover from even at the mild end of the scale. It’s also not as prevalent in community generally, annual flu cases are generally projected in the thousands, covid had been consistently in the millions for two years.

Giveaschitt · 22/02/2022 10:44

@Poetrypatty

One of the concerns I've got is that as yet we don't know that with Covid you just build up immunity and that's it. The virus will mutate and we don't know what will happen next yet. Also, people can catch it over and over again.

I think we need sick pay to be widespread and we need people to be staying at home if they have the virus. I don't want to be out and about eg at the dentist say, and the dentist has covid but is still working. That's what could happen come April 1st. To me that makes no sense.

They should ease off restrictions more gradually and we need to have a society where people who are sick can be supported to stay home for a few days.

How much more gradually do you want the restrictions to be eased?! We've only isolation and testing left now as everything else was gradually reduced. And testing had already been gradually reduced to just lft for majority of people. Isolation has been gradually reduced from 10 to 7 to 5 days. Do you want them to go even slower until we're down to isolating for hours?!