Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Dealing with racial microaggressions from white male manager

133 replies

Quirkyme · 21/02/2022 15:07

Hi,

There's so much going on at work now.

In addition to those issues , my manager has been making racial comments.

So started in this team a few months prior and I noticed in my first team meeting that he kept referring to a "black woman" in an advert, (he emphasised this about 3x) but her ethnicity had nothing to do with the point he was making about said advert.

Following that, every interaction after he would drop in the name of black rappers and singers he knew, despite the fact we weren't talking about rappers/singers or music or anything related to said artists.

These exchanges were via Teams.

Recently, we had a team lunch, in person, he asked me my heritage - and when I said it, he said he "knew it" because we all "looked the same and have the same features". I was taken aback by this visibly , and said "oh wow okay"

I replied saying along the lines of "actually, a lot of people don't often guess correctly where I'm from, some have thought I'm from "insert different regions of Africa" or that I'm Caribbean", he then was taken aback and said "Caribbean?!' - as if he was some expert on what Caribbeans look like.

He then went on to tell me his "best friend was black", that he has "black friends" and listed where all of them were from.

Wtf.

I'm literally waiting for him to tell me next that he has had "black girlfriends". It's weird as hell.

Has anyone dealt with this with management?

I've dealt with this before in the past with friends and white men who tried it on and I've very quickly nipped that in the bud, and left that there.

But this guy is my manager.
I'm tired of this.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
BornBlonde · 22/02/2022 01:22

OP that's shocking. I agree with highlighting this to HR or his manager with the examples given

nalabae · 22/02/2022 00:12

he seems to me he is tryng to fit in with you or he likes you and being totally cringe about it.

ShineTogether · 21/02/2022 23:04

@ChargingBuck
Agreed. Absolutely I don't get challenged on where am I "really" from. That is not something I have to put up with at all.
I was only referring to the people saying no one ever asks where they're from bc they're white. You and other pp are totally right that it's different tho.
Sorry if I've derailed.

And OP I hope you get supported at work to address this

Natty13 · 21/02/2022 20:09

@Burgoo

What an utterly bizarre individual!

Whilst I would always err on the said of caution when interpreting someone's behaviour - they are also a rather odd things to come out with. We can suspect the intention all we like and it may well be that he thinks this is a way of bonding and showing that he has interests that may appeal to you. Of course its crazy to think that you would like things just based on race but that doesn't take away from the fact that many of these people are completely clueless.

I can see why you feel dismayed and angry about this. You gave him a good response and he didn't seem to pick up the hint. It may well be that a more direct approach to this may be helpful. Bringing to his awareness that his comments have left you feeling uncomfortable. I'd like to assume that there is no malice in this and at the same time if you don't correct him he will likely do it again.

Its a tough one. He may be mortified and he may also shrug and say you have the problem. I don't buy diversity training's effectiveness; if people are inherently racist, no amount of education will change that. I've sat through a variety of trainings with people nodding and agreeing, then walking out and saying "that was a complete waste of time" and putting the resources in the bin.

It shouldn't be your role to give this information to him and at the same time if you don't then nothing will change.

Where are your colleagues in this? Had I been there I'd have politely taken him aside and gently mentioned to him that what he said may not be as reasonable as he thought it was. Why didn't anyone intervene? It may well be that they are intimidated and worried about their job. It may be a culture in the office of accepting it. Either way I'm more interested in how the whole team didn't bat an eyelid. Its rather astounding.

Good luck! It sounds a deeply painful place to be.

As depressing as it is, someone may have pulled him up on it. I have done this before and got brushed off so advised the member of staff next time to go to HR because a quiet word didn't work and clearly the manager thought they were in the right.
Natty13 · 21/02/2022 20:02

I want to say I'm sorry you have to deal with this. It isn't acceptable but its difficult to know how to navigate when he is in a position of power.

What do you think about saying "you dont need to bring up my race in every conversation you know" with a sme or a wink. I'm usually a very direct person (and get away with murder because I say everything with a genuine smile) so this is as hinting as I could bear to be.

HappyDays40 · 21/02/2022 19:58

Sorry not price "prick"

HappyDays40 · 21/02/2022 19:57

He is trying to prove that he isn't "racist" although name dropping some black rappers and saying he has black friends is like the classic white person racist statement. What a price. Could you speak with another manager or HR?

Burgoo · 21/02/2022 19:25

What an utterly bizarre individual!

Whilst I would always err on the said of caution when interpreting someone's behaviour - they are also a rather odd things to come out with. We can suspect the intention all we like and it may well be that he thinks this is a way of bonding and showing that he has interests that may appeal to you. Of course its crazy to think that you would like things just based on race but that doesn't take away from the fact that many of these people are completely clueless.

I can see why you feel dismayed and angry about this. You gave him a good response and he didn't seem to pick up the hint. It may well be that a more direct approach to this may be helpful. Bringing to his awareness that his comments have left you feeling uncomfortable. I'd like to assume that there is no malice in this and at the same time if you don't correct him he will likely do it again.

Its a tough one. He may be mortified and he may also shrug and say you have the problem. I don't buy diversity training's effectiveness; if people are inherently racist, no amount of education will change that. I've sat through a variety of trainings with people nodding and agreeing, then walking out and saying "that was a complete waste of time" and putting the resources in the bin.

It shouldn't be your role to give this information to him and at the same time if you don't then nothing will change.

Where are your colleagues in this? Had I been there I'd have politely taken him aside and gently mentioned to him that what he said may not be as reasonable as he thought it was. Why didn't anyone intervene? It may well be that they are intimidated and worried about their job. It may be a culture in the office of accepting it. Either way I'm more interested in how the whole team didn't bat an eyelid. Its rather astounding.

Good luck! It sounds a deeply painful place to be.

VivX · 21/02/2022 19:14

@starfro
I am a more positive person and try to see the good in people.

Most people are nice and try and get along with others. Almost all of the time disagreements happen inadvertently rather than maliciously.

Why are you trying to make excuses for OP's racist manager?

His remarks are racist. It doesn't matter if he was "inadvertently" racist. It is still racist.

But do you really believe that the comment all "looked the same and have the same features" was him being "nice"?

Daydreamsinsantafe · 21/02/2022 19:04

@Jammysod you suggested she ‘raise it with him and discuss how it’s coming across’.
I made the assumption that you would be speaking to him calmly to convey her point. I apologise if you didn’t mean that.
A conversation with what we all agree to be a racist is fruitless. At this point she should only be considering herself & not assisting with his understanding of his own behaviour.

VivX · 21/02/2022 18:59

Where are you really from? :

Jammysod · 21/02/2022 18:55

At what point did I say 'help the racist', or even make the conversation polite. I said address it...if you can't do it directly with the person responsible, do it via the official channels at work.

Muckycat · 21/02/2022 18:53

Christ what an awkward and embarrassing man. I'm not sure whether his motivations are ingratiating himself or deliberately othering you, but he seems to have been asleep for the past decade if the thinks that 'all people from X look the same' etc is acceptable.

I would advise against addressing this with him face to face without seeking advice first. He will likely take offence, attempt to minimise and justify his comments, and this could have repercussions for your work environment.

Instead, I would make a list of all of these comments and incidents, with rough dates in order to show the full picture, and arrange a call with HR or the diversity lead to plan next steps, hopefully extra training will be offered to him. Follow this up in writing.

In the meantime, why not try and make him feel more included by breaking into a bit of Cliff Richard or Englebert Humperdinck whenever he is nearby?

Daydreamsinsantafe · 21/02/2022 18:49

@Jammysod with all due respect no one would suggest OP have a quiet word with the guy at work who was sexually harassing her. ‘Maybe tell him you prefer him not to slap your arse as you walk by’.

It’s exhausting living with racism. What energy is left shouldn’t be spent on helping out the racist. OP doesn’t owe him a polite conversation of any sort. I can guarantee that if she went down that route he would take great pleasure in gaslighting her.

Cherrysoup · 21/02/2022 18:48

‘You all look the same’?! Holy hell, that’s massively objectionable! Seriously, get yourself to HR!

mummykel16 · 21/02/2022 18:43

@Jammysod

Regardless of whether he's trying too hard to be inclusive or just plain old racist, it needs to be addressed.

If you feel comfortable, could you raise it with him & discuss how it's coming across?
If you don't feel like he can be challenged, raise it with HR.

Nobody should be made to feel that way.

Hopefully he'll be open to the conversation & take on board what you're saying.

Best comment
titchy · 21/02/2022 18:14

Almost all of the time disagreements happen inadvertently rather than maliciously.

Inadvertent racism is still racism. And should be called out.

WouldIwasShookspeared · 21/02/2022 18:12

How is "you all look the same" not racist?

Honestly, some people seem to think nothing short of setting a cross on fire on someone's front lawn can be considered racist.

No. Fucking. Clue. 🙄

Zillamop · 21/02/2022 18:11

Next time he blathers on about a random black person he once met, tell him about a random white person you met. Continue every time he mentions ethnicity for no reason. He went shopping with his aunt's black boyfriend? You went shopping with your Indonesian half brother, your South African second cousin twice removed, your Japanese next door neighbour and your black cousin. After a while he will ask why you're telling him this. You say 'You always say what ethnicity everyone is so I thought it was especially interesting to you'. He might not do it again after that.

starfro · 21/02/2022 18:05

[quote Daydreamsinsantafe]@starfro I answered the question you asked. Now you are asking another and going off on a tangent to be deliberately obtuse.

Perhaps a more relatable example to yourself is the commitment of some to defend racism. I find those to be equally as offensive as the overt ones.[/quote]
You're the one that brought up "raping black women". I'm not sure you really meant to do that.

You are perfectly entitled to find anything you want to offensive. You can think that the whole population is full of evil people trying their best to be as horrible to each other as possible. I am a more positive person and try to see the good in people.

Most people are nice and try and get along with others. Almost all of the time disagreements happen inadvertently rather than maliciously.

Quirkyme · 21/02/2022 18:04

@RickRude

starfro

Wow, just wow. I can’t tell if you’re being deliberately obtuse or if you really feel like that. Don’t know which ones worse.

Agree @starfro give it a rest and stop taking the piss. Interesting how you chose to ask a Q comparing what you did, but ignored what the person had also mentioned about their family members.

Seriously, give it a rest.

OP posts:
LakieLady · 21/02/2022 18:03

@Member869894

isn't he just being a bit dim rather than racist? '
The two aren't mutually exclusive. In fact, they often go together.
VivX · 21/02/2022 18:03

My sympathies, OP. It's definitely racist. He needs to be taken aside and have it explained to him.

For those who don't think it's racism, or that this person was being "friendly" or somehow mean well, think yourselves lucky you've never been on the receiving end of such BS.

Ignorance is never an excuse or defence for racism.

Also, most comments that start with, "My friend/best friend/neighbour/whatever is black/asian/brown and so on... because of course, you can't be racist if you know a black person, can you Hmm

iklboo · 21/02/2022 18:01

I know he is an arsehole but you probably want to keep your job and not upset your boss. It's difficult to know what to say or do which won't fire him up and make him worse.

The Equality Act 2010 would know what to say. OP shouldn't raise concerns because she 'wants to keep her job'? She shouldn't speak in case it 'makes him worse'.

Jesus fucking Christ. OP, best keep you head down to stop rocking the boat. Know. Your. Place.

RickRude · 21/02/2022 18:01

starfro

Wow, just wow. I can’t tell if you’re being deliberately obtuse or if you really feel like that. Don’t know which ones worse.