Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

WWYD - Renting from relatives

61 replies

jazzyoldjim · 21/02/2022 12:17

DH and I are on fairly low wages (NHS staff) we have two young children and we have always struggled financially, we have lived in 5 rented houses together in 9 years. A few years ago it was suggested (by them) that DH's parents could buy a house for us to rent back from them - help us out.

The terms were - it was going to be in a specific area chosen by in laws for investment purposes, it had to be a new build for ease of maintenance (by them) and they agreed to charge us less rent than market value. A house was chosen and they took us to view it - seemed fine, we were happy, they were happy. They made an offer on the house and got it, they bought it outright - no mortgage. They gave us a tenancy agreement, the rent is cheaper than the market value for a 3bed however it is still quite a lot, it is the same as we were paying in our previous private rental. This house is also a higher council tax band. We are not any better off financially here.

Fast forward, we have been living here for 3 years and we are not massively happy. Its not the best area for us in terms of getting to work / social aspects / things to do for the children. The house itself is very small for 4 people and the extension needs some serious repair work (that they have been promising to do since we moved in) we have decorated and made it really homely, but I am reluctant to pay for any structural work because we will not benefit from the return if the property is sold.

My DH approached his parents and asked what would happen if we wanted to move, his mum was annoyed and said we'd need to go back to private renting elsewhere. We have secretly put ourselves on the council house list but it seems very slow going.

I don't want to seem ungrateful at all, but I can't help but think its a bit of a raw deal, and we are kind of stuck in it.

WWYD?

OP posts:
Hankunamatata · 22/02/2022 19:17

How does a new build need structural work? Surely that would be on the snagging list.

alwayslearning789 · 22/02/2022 18:24

I think you will find that the free rental market is a tad more brutal than when you left it.

The reality of your situation before this arrangement sounds like it was very difficult back then. 5 moves in as many years.

What others would give to have the security of your situation right now.

No immediate answers for you but do look before you leap.

Authenticcelestialmusic · 22/02/2022 18:24

You say it’s a new build but has been extended. Presumably it wasn’t brand new when they bought it if it had been extended. Does the extension work have a guarantee? It’s worth checking with the solicitor they used when they bought it .

Authenticcelestialmusic · 22/02/2022 18:21

How much under market rate is the rent? If you compare it to what is on rightmove today , same size house in the same area at 2022 prices?
It could be that the house cost £500000 and would rent for £2000 a month now. Meaning the parents may have made far more in shares or renting to strangers rather than putting all the money into a house. So in their eyes they are trying to help you.

Security and the ability to decorate etc would be a huge plus to me.

Exactly what repairs are required?

Can you afford to rent in the area you want? If it’s more suitable then move and let your PIL rent out on the open market.

LightfoldEngines · 22/02/2022 18:14

Yes it will be very slow going on any council list in the country right now because there a lot of people being made homeless, you are currently housed by relatives and so will not be a priority in any way.

I wouldn’t move to an area I didn’t want to just to live somewhere owned by family, especially if it was the same rent, more council tax and a rubbish area for your work and social needs.

Eightiesfan · 22/02/2022 18:11

The CFs are using you to top up their pensions! Do you know what their mortgage payment are? As landlords (and family) it is their duty to make sure the house is regularly maintained, you should not be considering doing any work. I hope you find an alternative place soon.

SeasonFinale · 22/02/2022 18:10

Presumably having tied up their capital in a property they use the rent as their income to live off otherwise they would have just left the capital amount in their pension/stocks and shares etc to earn an income that way.

If you are paying the same as before but it is less than market rent then that suggests uiu are renting a nicer property than you would otherwise be in. I am not sure where you live but round here getting a council house when not actually homeless would be nigh on impossible.

What did DH expect his mum to say? That she would sell and buy another house for him somewhere else?

What needs repair after 3 years? You have said they bought a new build.

RedHelenB · 22/02/2022 17:52

@ChoiceMummy

So they've paid for you to have home security? And now you wish to retract on the agreement? You should have talked through if you wanted out before letting them proceed imo.
This.
HTH1 · 22/02/2022 17:50

Yes it does sound like there was a mismatch between what OP thought they were offering “to help” and the reality.

As they are DH’s parents, he should be the one to have an open and honest conversation with them explaining that the rent is a real stretch and the property isn’t really right for you (which could be overlooked if the rent was right so that you could save for your own property). If they don’t budge and significantly lower the rent, time to find something else if you’re sure that there is something better out there within budget.

swirlsy · 22/02/2022 17:47

Whilst not havibg access to the considerable funds that they used to buy the house for them and could have been spending that money doing whatever they wish with!

Maybe there were always going to buy a BTL. They have benefited from having family as tenants.

swirlsy · 22/02/2022 17:45

I don't think they are being overly generous and you don't owe them anything.

agree

Whammyyammy · 22/02/2022 17:44

They've made £37k plus whatever the house has increased by over the last 3 years, move and don't feel guilty.

ChoiceMummy · 22/02/2022 17:36

@Danikm151

You're paying them a significant amount each month, they have enough money to pay for the structural work, after all they've had over £37k from you over 3 years. They don't need to pay towards a mortgage so they should be fixing what needs to be fixed, they're happy to let their grandchildren live in a place that needs work doing to it?

If the council is slow going, apply for housing association places as well, you might get lucky and that will give you more stability.

Whilst not havibg access to the considerable funds that they used to buy the house for them and could have been spending that money doing whatever they wish with!
WomanStanleyWoman · 22/02/2022 12:17

I agree with @FairyCakeWings. The only area where the in-laws are at fault is with the repairs. They should have sorted that long ago.

Otherwise, the OP and her husband saw the size of the house, the location of the house and were presumably informed of the asking price in rent for the house. At ANY point they could have said ‘Thanks, but it’s not really going to work for us’. They didn’t.

My DH approached his parents and asked what would happen if we wanted to move, his mum was annoyed and said we'd need to go back to private renting elsewhere.

I’d be interested to hear the motivation for this question. Was ‘You’ll need to go back to private renting elsewhere’ an unexpected answer? If so, what was the expected answer? Maybe ‘We’ll look at reducing the rent’ or even ‘Maybe we could look into selling up and buying somewhere better for you’?

From all the references to how the rent isn’t that much below the market rate and the fact that the in-laws could buy the house outright, I’m guessing OP and her husband think they should be getting a bigger break on the rent, or some other level of financial help. I suspect the house got smaller and the area more inconvenient once the reality of the rent they agreed to kicked in.

FairyCakeWings · 22/02/2022 11:37

But they didn’t have to agree to the area where the property was going to be bought, no one forced them into this deal. They could have said no thank you and chosen to live wherever they wanted within their budget.

The in laws were clearly trying to help. If it ends up that this arrangement doesn’t work out then fair enough, but I think the implication that the in laws were trying to profit from or control the son and his family are unfair.

Obviously as there’s a proper tenancy agreement the in laws should be making the repairs necessary for the property, but we have no idea of their reasons for not having it done quickly.

Theunamedcat · 22/02/2022 11:29

@FairyCakeWings

How is it a raw deal?

You got to see and agree to the property before it was bought, you're paying less than market rent and you have complete security. I don't see how that's a bad deal. Your in laws were trying to help, how much else do you think they owe you for it to be a good deal for everyone involved?

If you've changed your mind about the property suiting your family then fair enough. These things change and one of the benefits of renting is that you can move on more easily.

I'm not sure what the problem is on your side tbh. Of course if you don't want to stick with the agreement you'd have to go back into renting elsewhere, what else would you expect?

Less than market rent for that area which is inconvenient for them and not where they wanted to live and no maintenance done?
Danikm151 · 22/02/2022 11:07

You're paying them a significant amount each month, they have enough money to pay for the structural work, after all they've had over £37k from you over 3 years.
They don't need to pay towards a mortgage so they should be fixing what needs to be fixed, they're happy to let their grandchildren live in a place that needs work doing to it?

If the council is slow going, apply for housing association places as well, you might get lucky and that will give you more stability.

FairyCakeWings · 22/02/2022 10:33

How is it a raw deal?

You got to see and agree to the property before it was bought, you're paying less than market rent and you have complete security. I don't see how that's a bad deal. Your in laws were trying to help, how much else do you think they owe you for it to be a good deal for everyone involved?

If you've changed your mind about the property suiting your family then fair enough. These things change and one of the benefits of renting is that you can move on more easily.

I'm not sure what the problem is on your side tbh. Of course if you don't want to stick with the agreement you'd have to go back into renting elsewhere, what else would you expect?

Malibuismysecrethome · 22/02/2022 10:19

Just move out. Let them have the reality and expense of tenants.

DingDongDenny · 22/02/2022 10:11

I don't think they are being overly generous and you don't owe them anything. It would have been kinder to take into consideration your needs when it came to the area to buy in. It also sounds as if they aren't out of pocket financially, given the rent you are paying. You can't put your life on hold due to a perceived favour which doesn't really exist

HappyDays40 · 22/02/2022 09:17

I think you re being fair OP they have not kept to the Tennancy Agreement. Its not like you are expecting them to buy you another house is it.

Totalwasteofpaper · 22/02/2022 09:17

You made a mistake 3 years ago.

Insisting on areas etc. Isn't particularly reasonable and I wouldn't have agreed on that basis. The rent isn't helping you get on the ladder and it's set at a level that doesn't enable you to save or save faster.

They are profiteering off you and it sounds like although there is a contract they are not fulfilling their obligations as a landlord.

Private tenants would involve maintainance, annual checks, betterment and letting agent fees. They are doing well off of you.
I'd move out personally.

Theunamedcat · 22/02/2022 09:15

I dont think it should be free but I do think basic maintenance and acting like actual landlords if your paying real rent not a token amount

GizmosEveningBath · 22/02/2022 09:11

*pull thier socks up

GizmosEveningBath · 22/02/2022 09:11

Don't feel bad about considering a move. Yes it was less than market value but it doesn't sound like anything near peppercorn rent either. If they let it to private tenants then they would have to pull thier socks of and maintain the house properly, pay an agent etc and at least they know you are looking after the place. All things considered they may be financially better off letting to you. It doesn't sound like much of a favour tbh.