Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

WWYD - Renting from relatives

61 replies

jazzyoldjim · 21/02/2022 12:17

DH and I are on fairly low wages (NHS staff) we have two young children and we have always struggled financially, we have lived in 5 rented houses together in 9 years. A few years ago it was suggested (by them) that DH's parents could buy a house for us to rent back from them - help us out.

The terms were - it was going to be in a specific area chosen by in laws for investment purposes, it had to be a new build for ease of maintenance (by them) and they agreed to charge us less rent than market value. A house was chosen and they took us to view it - seemed fine, we were happy, they were happy. They made an offer on the house and got it, they bought it outright - no mortgage. They gave us a tenancy agreement, the rent is cheaper than the market value for a 3bed however it is still quite a lot, it is the same as we were paying in our previous private rental. This house is also a higher council tax band. We are not any better off financially here.

Fast forward, we have been living here for 3 years and we are not massively happy. Its not the best area for us in terms of getting to work / social aspects / things to do for the children. The house itself is very small for 4 people and the extension needs some serious repair work (that they have been promising to do since we moved in) we have decorated and made it really homely, but I am reluctant to pay for any structural work because we will not benefit from the return if the property is sold.

My DH approached his parents and asked what would happen if we wanted to move, his mum was annoyed and said we'd need to go back to private renting elsewhere. We have secretly put ourselves on the council house list but it seems very slow going.

I don't want to seem ungrateful at all, but I can't help but think its a bit of a raw deal, and we are kind of stuck in it.

WWYD?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Valeriekat · 18/04/2022 11:06

Your in laws are getting capital growth AND income AND reliable tenants.
A very good and easy investment from their point of view.

WeCouldBeSpearows · 18/04/2022 10:55

It's a new build, that they bought so it would be low maintenance, that somehow already has an extension that needs repairs?

Why would they buy something that needs repairs if they want something low maintenance?

This makes no sense.

mustlovegin · 18/04/2022 10:51

I don't understand the problem here.

OP, if you think you can get better value elsewhere just move.

I get the feeling you are resentful that they have bought this property TBH

PuddleR1ddle · 18/04/2022 10:38

People rent from a relative, there may be some emotional baggage attached to the transaction

People tent from an estate agency/private landlord, there should be no emotional baggage

Cherrysoup · 18/04/2022 10:20

So they have no mortgage and still charge you over a grand? Pure profit from their ds and dil? Think I’d move too!

NeedleNoodle3 · 18/04/2022 10:11

Zombie

WhereWasThatFrom · 18/04/2022 09:48

I don't think it was a bad deal for either party. OP got the house below market value and the in-laws got tenants they knew and wanted to help all be at at lower than market value.

I don't understand why the house needs work if it was a new build though?

If I was the in-laws I'd have wanted to choose the area too.

I don't think anyone is at fault. The in-laws have said if you move out then you will have to go back into private renting - this seems fair enough. Were you hoping they would say they would sell the house and buy you one in another area? That would seem a bit cheeky ?

newbiename · 25/02/2022 16:48

@Eightiesfan

The CFs are using you to top up their pensions! Do you know what their mortgage payment are? As landlords (and family) it is their duty to make sure the house is regularly maintained, you should not be considering doing any work. I hope you find an alternative place soon.
No mortgage
Malibuismysecrethome · 25/02/2022 16:35

Of course capital appreciation is real, if the property has increased in value then after tax, solicitors costs and estate agent fees the rest is profit.

Viviennemary · 25/02/2022 16:30

How is it a raw deal. You weren't forced into it. You now have the option of private renting which you don't want to do either.

SeasonFinale · 25/02/2022 16:23

@confusedlots Perhaps even the DS and OP thought as they were buying it mortgage free that they would give the property to them at some stage!

StoneofDestiny · 25/02/2022 15:46

They haven't done you any favours - you are paying a mortgage for them on their investment property. It suited them, it no longer suits you. Surely they did not imagine you'd be staying forever?
They have lost nothing - except their tenants, and they can get new ones.
Move to where it suits you and just live your lives without their 'help' in this way.

confusedlots · 25/02/2022 15:07

What are your longer term plans to get yourselves on the property ladder? You can't rent forever, or maybe you're hoping there will be a sizeable inheritance from your in laws one day?

If your in laws have spare cash they're willing to invest to help you, I would have looked into the possibility of them lending you the deposit for your own house which you would have then paid back (with some interest) over a period of time. Would have been much more beneficial for you rather than continuing to rent

Freddiefox · 25/02/2022 15:05

Surely you’ve got three choices.

Stay,

Rent elsewhere, maybe pay more maybe not, risk being moved on.

Wait for a council house.

You don’t owe them anything, but I understand why they might be upset. That doesn’t mean you need to stay there, but recognise they were trying to help you out.

ChicCroissant · 25/02/2022 14:56

I'm struggling to believe this is real, which part of it is a raw deal for the OP? She's got a house below market rate that she approved before her in-laws bought it.

So was it a new build OP, if so when was the extension done?

Phormiumjester · 25/02/2022 14:38

They aren't making any profit until they've got back what they paid for for it plus all the associated expenses.

It's not £1k a month profit at all. It's just getting some of your investment back. When the cash to buy it came out of their savings.

I think it depends how the conversation went.

"We have nowhere to live"

  • well we can buy a house but it'll use our savings that we live off and so we will need you to pay rent on it to cover what we don't have now, monthly, in our savings.
We can't afford to buy something that's not saleable because if you or someone else isn't paying us a monthly rent, we can't live the life we've saved for. So it's going to be in an area that suits us. Also, we don't have spare for renovations. Does that work for you?

If it's that convo, you were able to say yes or no.

No?

WomanStanleyWoman · 25/02/2022 14:26

@LoveMyPiano

These kind of arrangements make me absolutely sick. They are greedy, at your expense...... Just a win-win for them. No-body ever did this when property prices were falling.

I always wonder what might happen if they should die....

(My shit of a "father" toyed with the idea, but retracted it beore it even got off the ground - which is typical MO for him.)

I’ve seen lots of comments like this on the thread - but I haven’t seen a single explanation of why the OP and her husband couldn’t have said ‘No’. Why, if it’s such a terrible deal, they agreed to it.

I don’t buy the greed argument either. The PILs didn’t take out a mortgage - they had the money in the bank. If they were only concerned about money, they could have just spent the money they already had on something else.

As for ‘No one did this when property prices were falling’ - why would they? Who invests in something they expect to depreciate?

SeasonFinale · 25/02/2022 13:44

@LoveMyPiano

These kind of arrangements make me absolutely sick. They are greedy, at your expense...... Just a win-win for them. No-body ever did this when property prices were falling.

I always wonder what might happen if they should die....

(My shit of a "father" toyed with the idea, but retracted it beore it even got off the ground - which is typical MO for him.)

It is hardly at their expense when the expense to them is a below market rent and with security of tenure. If the OP and her DH are not happy with the arrangement they are, of course, free to give notice and move somewhere else paying market rent and with the uncertainty as to whether a new landlord will serve notice to evict after 6 /12 months, whether the rents would be increased annually and whether that landlord would be a good one with regard to repairs and maintenance or a poor one.
LoveMyPiano · 25/02/2022 12:08

These kind of arrangements make me absolutely sick. They are greedy, at your expense...... Just a win-win for them. No-body ever did this when property prices were falling.

I always wonder what might happen if they should die....

(My shit of a "father" toyed with the idea, but retracted it beore it even got off the ground - which is typical MO for him.)

FairyCakeWings · 25/02/2022 11:42

Capital appreciation means precisely fuck all until the property is sold, and even then you can’t sell for free.

Malibuismysecrethome · 25/02/2022 11:37

Being a landlord is not just about the rent you receive there is capital appreciation on the property (or not) during the 3 years.

ChoiceMummy · 23/02/2022 07:52

And that fails to take into account the additional costs tied up with buying the property initially, surveys, solicitor fees, tax etc.

When you take that into account the likelihood could well be that they're barely breaking even 3 years in!

Not to mention that ultimately, the op's oh will no doubt benefit in inheritance from this!

And the op always had to pay rent, so imo the security this offered is better paid to family than someone else!

ChoiceMummy · 23/02/2022 07:48

@Whammyyammy

They've made £37k plus whatever the house has increased by over the last 3 years, move and don't feel guilty.
So approx 12k a year for all of their savings tied up in the op's home, to have to pay tax on, probably around 3k a year (modest guesstimate), be responsible for all repairs, need to pay insurance for.

At a reasonable guess, I'd say in real terms they'd be lucky if their "return" was even 6k at the end of it.

Dobt try to suggest they're rolling in it because they bought a home for the op and charged a lower than market value rent! They're not the "baddies" here.

WomanStanleyWoman · 23/02/2022 02:43

@Eightiesfan

The CFs are using you to top up their pensions! Do you know what their mortgage payment are? As landlords (and family) it is their duty to make sure the house is regularly maintained, you should not be considering doing any work. I hope you find an alternative place soon.
The pension lot would be much bigger if these ‘CFs’ charged market rent. Or hadn’t bought the house at all.

Yes, they can afford to buy the house outright - but that’s not cheap. They can’t draw on that money for their retirement. They need a rental income for the house. The OP has made it quite clear that they aren’t getting what they could - and she’s still not happy.

Hankunamatata · 22/02/2022 19:19

What is the market value of rent in the area? Perhaps discuss reducing rent slightly with inlaws?