Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Lending money to friends

39 replies

1stevernamechange · 21/02/2022 09:20

To give some context, there are three people, A,B and C. B and C are in a relationship and are both close friends with A.
B is setting up his own business, and in September, asked A to lend them £300 for an unexpected insurance bill. A at that time wasn’t too bad for money so happily lent it. B replied that they would set up instalments to pay it back ASAP. A then told B that there was no rush.
It was never mentioned again, A went on many shopping trips with B where B spent a lot of money on their hobby, Christmas came, and A told B and C how money was getting tough and that they were in their overdraft by a lot.
A spoke to C to ask how they should broach the subject of the loan with B , as it had not been mentioned, C replied to find a quiet moment and ask it B had remembered. A got nervous each time as they didn’t want to make B feel awkward, and had received some money, so it wasn’t as urgent a situation now.
B found out that A had talked to C about it ( even though B had told C about the loan at the time) and was angry and upset and now isn’t talking to A, saying they will pay it in full this week, even though A has told them they do not need to.
AIBU to think that B should have spoken to A in the meantime to say that the loan hasn’t been forgotten?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Missey85 · 21/02/2022 20:04

Never lend money to friends it never ends well you either don't get paid back or you lose a friend

CulturePigeon · 21/02/2022 12:17

I'm not rich and my friends aren't rich but - since being teenagers we've never borrowed or lent money to each other. Why do people do it? A bus fare or a cup of coffee here and there, yes, but I just can't get my mind round using friends as a bank. How would you even broach the question?

If you need the money, surely close family are your first call, if you really can't get a proper loan and....dare I say it...perhaps, if you can't afford it, maybe you shouldn't have it? There's so much on MN about the problems caused by lending to friends and the amounts and reasons are not trivial, so it's not as though someone's short of a bag of groceries or a train fare - they are often considerable sums for a quite 'optional' reason - not emergencies.

KosherDill · 21/02/2022 11:29

Why does A keep sending the message that repayment isn't important, if she wants the money back?

topcat2014 · 21/02/2022 11:28

I happily lend money to a very longstanding friend. He is hard working, but average earner.

I am fortunate to be a higher earner.

Hence a few hundred pounds can make a big difference to him and I would cope without it.

However if our earnings levels were similar I wouldn't do this.

BarbaraofSeville · 21/02/2022 11:12

@zingally

I'm regularly surprised by the number of people who seemingly never learnt the lesson about not lending money to friends.

I learnt this lesson aged 12, with a CF friend who always wanted small "loans" of a quid here, quid there, just to buy typical teenage tat. She never paid me back without an argument, so I simply stopped lending. Problem solved.

Never lend to anyone, unless you're happy to accept it's actually a gift.

Talk about victim blaming.

There's always a sob story and you're always made to feel like a selfish bastard if you refuse.

The loan is always for some essential like insurance, food for DC, electricity, so it's incredibly hard to see a friend or family apparently not be able to cover essentials, especially when you could help them, and they beg and promise to repay the money.

Save your surprise for the number of people who guilt family and friends into 'lending' them money and not bothering to pay it back while shamelessly spending on non-essentials.

MintyFreshBreath · 21/02/2022 11:06

I’m lost here and don’t understand your tale of woe. Best thing is not to lend money to anyone and expect to get it back.

zingally · 21/02/2022 11:02

I'm regularly surprised by the number of people who seemingly never learnt the lesson about not lending money to friends.

I learnt this lesson aged 12, with a CF friend who always wanted small "loans" of a quid here, quid there, just to buy typical teenage tat. She never paid me back without an argument, so I simply stopped lending. Problem solved.

Never lend to anyone, unless you're happy to accept it's actually a gift.

BarbaraofSeville · 21/02/2022 10:58

Exactly @DropYourSword. A has done B a huge favour and then had it thrown back in their face.

It's shit like this that stop people from lending money when it is really needed, because piss takers so often prioritise their own frivalous spending over paying back the kind person lent them the money.

And people shouldn't 'not expect it back' when they've been asked for a loan. Loans are requested and made with the intention of repayment. If the person asking to borrow is so entitled that they expect to be given money and not have to pay it back in a reasonable timescale, they should own it and ask outright for the money as a gift. Then poor sods like A will rightly be able to decide with their eyes open, and probably refuse.

Georgeskitchen · 21/02/2022 10:57

@ThatsNotMyGolem

Neither a borrower nor a lender be! It's a recipe for disaster.
That was my late father's favourite saying and still as true as ever!!
DropYourSword · 21/02/2022 10:44

Honestly, B should have paid back the money as soon as possible.

It's really fucking RUDE not to repay money you've borrowed as soon as you can.

A and C should not have even had to consider worrying about hurting B's feelings if B had just done the right thing in the first place. B has no moral high ground here at all.

Moral of the story - never borrow money from or lend money to friends. Never.

FuzzyPuffling · 21/02/2022 10:43

A is a weedy wet.
B is a cf.
C is excess to requirements.

Arabellla · 21/02/2022 10:42

B is bring a twat and should have returned the money instead of putting A in the awful situation of having to ask for it, either from B or C.

B never had any intention of repaying it and is annoyed you have raised it.

A needs to be more assertive and stop telling borrowers ‘there’s no need to repay it quickly.’

I’m guessing you are A, OP. Just say that, why all this subterfuge?

Honeyroar · 21/02/2022 10:40

A is a bit of a wimp.
B is self centred and thoughtless. They ought to be embarrassed, not lashing out at people for talking about the money. Nobody would be talking about them if they’d repaid it…

MrsWinters · 21/02/2022 10:39

No one forgets about £300.
You don’t lend money you can’t afford to lose…. But if you borrow money and don’t pay it back you can’t get sniffy about people’s lack of discretion.

KindredKeely · 21/02/2022 10:38

p.s. if B and C were good friend,s they also wouldn't have put A in this sitaution - they should have repaid it immediately when they could. frankly it's cheeky to ask to borrow cash for something as predictable as an insurance fee anyway. it all stinks of really poor financial management, from EVERYONE involved.

KindredKeely · 21/02/2022 10:37

A needs to stop dithering.

WHy all the mixed messasges?

You don't go into your overdraft then mix up the loan situation by saying there's no rush to give it back. Either there is or there isn't.

A thinks s/he is trying to be friendly and helpful, but isn't in a financial position to say "it doesn't matter" - yet she has been saying in words "it doesn't matter".

A needs to grow a backbone and not loan out money she can't afford to loan out, basically.

BlingLoving · 21/02/2022 10:35

A is being an idiot.

When B offered to set up a payment plan, A should have accepted that. Or, if A did NOT accept that, A had no right to then be a bit twitchy about not being paid.

When A needed the money, A should have been mature enough to say to B, "hey B, can we talk about that instalment plan now as I really do need the money with all the Christmas expenses."

And A now telling B that the money is not needed is ridiculous. A has made a song and dance about the money.

Having said all that, B should have just bloody paid it back without needing to be asked. And should have ignored A's passive aggressive, "no no, I don't need you to pay now".

ChimChimeny · 21/02/2022 10:32

Also hinting with people like B clearly isn't going to work as they are a C.F. and don't really want to repay the money.

A needs to be much more assertive, even if it's a text rather than face to face and say they need the money back by friday, no apology, pussy footing around or hints

NoSquirrels · 21/02/2022 10:31

A should not lend any money at all if they can’t bring up the subject of repayment without ‘feeling awkward’. A shouldn’t have discussed it with C if it wasn’t a joint loan.

B should have repaid the loan quicker.

C didn’t do anything.

duvetdayforeveryone · 21/02/2022 10:26

I couldn't understand what you wrote on a Monday morning.

All I know is you don't lend to friends or family. You either give them the money as a gift or say no.
If you said no, for £300 they could have put it on a credit card or sold belongings.

Ttcfinalbub · 21/02/2022 10:21

Mixed messages and damaged egos.
A should have set out repayment right from the start. ' don't worry about it puts everyone in an unknown situ '
A should have spoke to b directly .. b possibly felt embarrassed by a going to c instead.. making it seem like b wasn't approachable.

B should have just paid it off to get the air clear
B should not be stroppy if a was a good enough freind to lend money it should be a good enough friendship to survive paying it back !

A b nor c should lend money to freinds

Thewindwhispers · 21/02/2022 09:58

B has no right to be angry! They should have paid or back as soon as they had the money, not gone off shopping for hobby. It’s irrelevant that A said ‘no rush’ that was just A being polite.

A shouldn’t have spoken to C about it, wouod have been better for A just to remind B. But B should not have needed reminding!

C shouldn’t have got involved…

As for B ‘not speaking’ to A wtf! B has zero chance of running a successful new business if B can’t manage to get on with a helpful old friend.

Sounds like everyone is age 12.

girlmom21 · 21/02/2022 09:45

@CareBear50

Why not use fake names. I hate posts with A B C....can never rem who is who. So no idea
Just pretend that their names are A, B and C then
cadburyegg · 21/02/2022 09:43

I transferred £500 to a friend before Christmas. Technically it's a loan because that was the only way she would agree to it but I doubt I'll ever get it back, so in my head it's a gift and if I ever see it again it'll be a bonus. I don't lend money, I found that out the hard way once. It's the only way to do it and maintain the friendship if the person then can't repay for whatever reason.

The person who lent money needs to make peace with not getting it back.

CareBear50 · 21/02/2022 09:38

Why not use fake names. I hate posts with A B C....can never rem who is who. So no idea