Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

criticisng/contradicting me...AIBU to feel upset or annoyed by this?

65 replies

Toocritical · 21/02/2022 07:27

I've been told by many people that I'm too sensitive to perceived criticism so I can't tell if this is me, if even it is criticism or if I'm overreacting. Ditto the contradicting me if that's the right term.

To give some examples

When I'm driving telling me to stop riding the clutch, or not to brake so sharply, or that I'm in the wrong gear. Admittedly I've not been driving for decades, but I have been driving for nearly 10 years with no issues.

I have a nervous habit of twirling my hair or scratching my hands. I've done it on and off for years but sometimes it's worse than others. Atm its quite bad and I've got some bad scratches on my hands which are quite sore. I don't consciously do it - telling me off about this, saying stuff like for God's sake will you just stop? And when I say I can't help it saying that I'm self defeating. I can force myself to stop of course but it feels very uncomfortable doing so.

When I'm doing any kind of practical household tasks, tutting and saying you look so awkward doing that (or you're not doing it properly) let me show you how to do it,

If I respond negatively I get told 'I'm not criticising. I'm just trying to help you'. However that's not how it feels

The contradicting is on things like places we've been - I'll say do you remember when we went to (place)? Response is to say we've not been to X, or to query if we have. Or the one that really got to me a few weeks ago, I'd given some advice to someone about something related to the (professional) job I do. I've done this job for more than 20 years and am bloody good at it. Going online spending 3 mins on Google and saying that my advice was wrong because this website said differently. Basically implying I can't do my job.

AIBU to be upset by this ?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Toocritical · 21/02/2022 22:55

I can accept written down it doesn't look great. He does have many good qualities, but this behaviour is getting me down.

OP posts:
ChargingBuck · 21/02/2022 20:13

I think he'd be mystified if I said I was upset when he was telling me how to do something...he wouldn't understand why I would find it upsetting. he'd probably say I was being overly defensive and not letting him help me, or that I was making it up or something.

He has big problems.
He is unable to see you - the woman he professes to love - as a separate human being with her own identity.
He doesn't believe your feelings are valid & he reckons he has the right to correct you when you tell him what you are feeling.

I hope you can see how ... dysfunctional that is.

Toocritical · 21/02/2022 19:22

Definitely no OCD traits. I don't know about insecure but he doesn't have the same inner self belief as me. He had quite a difficult relationship with his family, has suffered from depression on and off for many years, has had a few health/ money/personal problems in the past though doing better now. Life hasn't been very fair to him and he is quite bitter about that.

I think he'd be mystified if I said I was upset when he was telling me how to do something...he wouldn't understand why I would find it upsetting. he'd probably say I was being overly defensive and not letting him help me, or that I was making it up or something.

OP posts:
Cherrysoup · 21/02/2022 19:04

Is he very insecure that he has to criticise you? Does he display symptoms of ocd? What happens if you stop what you’re doing and tell him very plainly that he’s upsetting you with his constant nit picking?

Calennig · 21/02/2022 18:46

If I handed it over to him he'd refuse and say I'm being self defeating and I can do it, he'll show me and I can follow what he does.

I'd practise handing over said task to him - - oh you show me then wonder off or well you'd better get on with it- and/or stopping entirely and walking away and doing it later.

Would he stop if you - do you want to do it then - said with attitide?

Or you could do it back to him by question why he way is better till he loses it then use his phrases back to him.

Honestly though he really doesn't sound great or very good for you.

334bu · 21/02/2022 18:38

exception of my parents that I felt I could rely on, I can rely on him. He's been the only person whose support I've known I always have.

How does he support you? The only thing you can rely on is him constantly undermining you. There is no support there, just abuse.

Toocritical · 21/02/2022 17:20

Honestly I've never had anyone in my life with the exception of my parents that I felt I could rely on, I can rely on him. He's been the only person whose support I've known I always have. So whilst I get that it's maybe not a high bar for some, when you've never had that from anyone else it is more of a big deal.

That said, things definitely aren't great at the moment and if this is now how things are indefinitely or forever, they won't change or improve, that doesn't bode well.

OP posts:
YellowHpok · 21/02/2022 16:53

Following with interest, all sounds alarmingly familiar

ChargingBuck · 21/02/2022 16:52

@Toocritical

He does have good points. We have a similar view of the world, we have lots of likes in common. He can be very supportive - if I said I was applying for a new job, moving into a different field, taking an additional qualification or anything like that, any kind of self improvement, he'd be totally supportive and encouraging. He's helped my family (and friends) with many things over the years, given up his time willingly. He's definitely not all bad. But over the last couple of years, and especially since the start of the year things haven't been great.
OP, even the good points are quite a low bar to set. They are all perfectly 'normal' traits to expect from a friend or a lover - nothing to rave about.
Rainbowshine · 21/02/2022 16:44

You’re really not selling him to us here @Toocritical! He’s making you feel unhappy and that’s the bottom line of it. You have a choice: stay with him knowing that he won’t change, or might get worse, or leave him. Changing him isn’t an option as you don’t control that. He’s continually negging you. That’s not an attractive trait. You wouldn’t continue dating someone that did this so why put up with it just because you’ve been together for longer? That’s where the sunken cost fallacy might be playing a part. But please don’t feel like you have to put up with this, you are worth more and those that do you down are those that don’t like seeing you succeed, which isn’t very loving or kind.

Toocritical · 21/02/2022 16:37

He does have good points. We have a similar view of the world, we have lots of likes in common. He can be very supportive - if I said I was applying for a new job, moving into a different field, taking an additional qualification or anything like that, any kind of self improvement, he'd be totally supportive and encouraging. He's helped my family (and friends) with many things over the years, given up his time willingly. He's definitely not all bad. But over the last couple of years, and especially since the start of the year things haven't been great.

OP posts:
ChargingBuck · 21/02/2022 16:33

@Toocritical

If I handed it over to him he'd refuse and say I'm being self defeating and I can do it, he'll show me and I can follow what he does. Thing is I do things my way, I don't care if his way is better, I do things as I can do them. Him demonstrating how to iron a shirt (this is just an example, I don't iron very often nor does he) doesn't suddenly make me able to iron like he does (if he was for example, a good ironer). I can't just follow what he shows me and do it in that way, partly because I often can't see what I'm doing is different anyway, and partly because the way I'm doing the job is fine for me.

So if I said you do it, he'd say no I'm quite capable. And if I asked him to stop telling me how to do it, he'd say he's trying to help and I'm too defensive and need to accept criticism when I'm doing things wrong or making life harder for myself.

To which I'd probably say I can't win - which apparently is the wrong thing to say because it's not about winning and I always have to have the last word blah blah (which is also what one of my Exs used to say about me).

So when he's not actively criticising you, he carries on criticising by stealth, like he's some kind of genius Pygmalion whose wordly wisdom is so much greater than yours ...

He is so arrogant & condescending.
Next time - he'd say he's trying to help and I'm too defensive and need to accept criticism - try biting back. Hard.
"I don't need to accept criticism you patronising arsehole, I need you to fuck off with your terrible attitude & stop imagining you know how to live my life for me."

Oh, & then LTB.
You are on a hiding to nothing with this awful man Flowers

Nanny0gg · 21/02/2022 16:30

@Toocritical

And if I stopped the car, or said he should drive himself, he'd tell me I was defensive or being deliberately argumentative or antagonistic, he's doing this for my own good to make me a better driver/ save me from damaging my car etc.
The reply, 'Thanks, but I'm fine as I am. Off you go'

You're a fully functioning adult. You don't need improving to his standards

Any good points?

Toocritical · 21/02/2022 16:27

And if I stopped the car, or said he should drive himself, he'd tell me I was defensive or being deliberately argumentative or antagonistic, he's doing this for my own good to make me a better driver/ save me from damaging my car etc.

OP posts:
Toocritical · 21/02/2022 16:25

If I handed it over to him he'd refuse and say I'm being self defeating and I can do it, he'll show me and I can follow what he does. Thing is I do things my way, I don't care if his way is better, I do things as I can do them. Him demonstrating how to iron a shirt (this is just an example, I don't iron very often nor does he) doesn't suddenly make me able to iron like he does (if he was for example, a good ironer). I can't just follow what he shows me and do it in that way, partly because I often can't see what I'm doing is different anyway, and partly because the way I'm doing the job is fine for me.

So if I said you do it, he'd say no I'm quite capable. And if I asked him to stop telling me how to do it, he'd say he's trying to help and I'm too defensive and need to accept criticism when I'm doing things wrong or making life harder for myself.

To which I'd probably say I can't win - which apparently is the wrong thing to say because it's not about winning and I always have to have the last word blah blah (which is also what one of my Exs used to say about me).

OP posts:
Nanny0gg · 21/02/2022 16:24

@Toocritical

He has encouraged me to do lots of things - promotion at work, pass my driving test (and buy a car), make changes to my appearance, do some travelling. It's not all negative, or at least it wasn't. The last 2 years have been hard I think, I work from home now and really love it, but he finds it quite isolating and lonely as he doesn't really know many people outside of work and so going out to work was a kind of social opportunity for him.
As to the driving issue, I'd just stop the car and tell him to get out as he wasn't happy with my driving.

And refuse to drive him in the future

MischievousBiscuits · 21/02/2022 16:16

This is the absolute worst. Next time he says you're not doing something right, be it hoovering, doing the dishes, whatever it is, hand it to him and tell him to do it as he knows so much more!

YNK · 21/02/2022 15:10

@Toocritical

He did start off as concerned but he seems to think I'm not trying to stop doing it. I don't think he gets that it's quite difficult to not do it, and frankly I've got enough to be worrying about without having to think about whether or not I'm scratching all the time. Him saying it makes him feel ill etc really doesn't help.
So you need to pay attention to his feelings and ignore your own? My ex did this to me throughout a long serious illness, telling me my own doctors didn't believe me. I found an entry in my GP records showing he was discussing me with my GP 'alone' without my knowledge (or consent) at that time. Years later an MRI showed I'd had had a stroke. Get away from this gaslighting creep fast - he's ramping up the control now! Also call womens aid
Orgasmagorical · 21/02/2022 14:57

he finds it quite isolating and lonely as he doesn't really know many people outside of work and so going out to work was a kind of social opportunity for him

You're almost writing my life story. OP. There had been incidents over the years but when my husband retired the little 'well meant' criticisms and other behaviours became more and more frequent. He had enjoyed the social stimulation attention he got from his colleagues but didn't have any friends outside of work and the attention I gave him wasn't good enough. He was very good at making it look like he was helping me with his behaviours but they were all designed to make me doubt and feel shit about myself.

Are you ever out in company with other people together? How is he then?

EerieSilence · 21/02/2022 13:55

You sound like a frog who was thrown into cold water that's now on the hob and getting hotter and hotter by the day.
He's emotionally abusive, belittling and humiliating you. Get rid.

Ileflottante · 21/02/2022 13:42

I can’t work out if your mindset of “I’m probably arrogant, I know I’m special, but people think I think too much of myself and need taking down a peg or two, but also they say I’m too sensitive to criticism,” is refreshing self awareness or the total opposite. 🤷🏼‍♀️

Toocritical · 21/02/2022 13:32

He did start off as concerned but he seems to think I'm not trying to stop doing it. I don't think he gets that it's quite difficult to not do it, and frankly I've got enough to be worrying about without having to think about whether or not I'm scratching all the time. Him saying it makes him feel ill etc really doesn't help.

OP posts:
incognitoforthisone · 21/02/2022 12:03

Some people definitely are too sensitive to perceived criticism - but what you're describing really doesn't sound like that. Being constantly scrutinised and told you're doing things wrong is not only annoying but also incredibly draining.

My boyfriend and I are both slightly inept at certain things and we'll joke with each other about that - but it's good-natured and equal. What you're describing just sounds like constant nit-picking, and that's just exhausting when you're hearing it day in, day out. It sounds like he's actively looking for things to criticise.

I completely get that repetitive habits - scratching, nail-biting, hair-twiddling, knuckle-cracking etc - can be annoying for other people, but we all do things that are sightly irritating from time to time, and if you're scratching your hands to the point where it's sore, your partner should be sympathetic and concerned, not snapping at you.

longtompot · 21/02/2022 11:09

@Quantity5

Your partner has one job. To like you best. That’s it. They then show this in lots of different ways depending on their style. Contemptuous put downs are not part of a loving relationship.
This in a nutshell.
BBCONEANDTWO · 21/02/2022 11:01

@Toocritical

I've been told by many people that I'm too sensitive to perceived criticism so I can't tell if this is me, if even it is criticism or if I'm overreacting. Ditto the contradicting me if that's the right term.

To give some examples

When I'm driving telling me to stop riding the clutch, or not to brake so sharply, or that I'm in the wrong gear. Admittedly I've not been driving for decades, but I have been driving for nearly 10 years with no issues.

I have a nervous habit of twirling my hair or scratching my hands. I've done it on and off for years but sometimes it's worse than others. Atm its quite bad and I've got some bad scratches on my hands which are quite sore. I don't consciously do it - telling me off about this, saying stuff like for God's sake will you just stop? And when I say I can't help it saying that I'm self defeating. I can force myself to stop of course but it feels very uncomfortable doing so.

When I'm doing any kind of practical household tasks, tutting and saying you look so awkward doing that (or you're not doing it properly) let me show you how to do it,

If I respond negatively I get told 'I'm not criticising. I'm just trying to help you'. However that's not how it feels

The contradicting is on things like places we've been - I'll say do you remember when we went to (place)? Response is to say we've not been to X, or to query if we have. Or the one that really got to me a few weeks ago, I'd given some advice to someone about something related to the (professional) job I do. I've done this job for more than 20 years and am bloody good at it. Going online spending 3 mins on Google and saying that my advice was wrong because this website said differently. Basically implying I can't do my job.

AIBU to be upset by this ?

The driving is annoying and could be dangerous if he keeps going on and on. When he says about the clutch or brake just ignore him or say I know - but I'll get there. (the will annoy the hell out of him).

Hair and scratching yourself - Don't say you can't help it - say something like - sorry if you're irritated - imagine how I'm feeling and then ignore.

Household tasks. When he says he'll show you how to do it - say - it's OK, unless you want to take over?

Criticising - don't give him the satisfaction of the you feel he is criticising you.

The gaslighting - just agree with him - he won't know what's hit him - but if I were you I'd probably plan a way out.