Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To go NC???

39 replies

indiesearcher · 20/02/2022 23:26

Hi there,

Full disclosure, it's a long in-laws one... and I'll try not to drip feed but the issues have been there for years so I might forget something. Basically, there's form for this sort of behaviour that goes back a long time. We've had full and frank discussions about this issue and the upset their behaviour causes but it makes no difference, time and time again.

Anyway...

Last week sometime, MIL sends a group WhatsApp asking if any of us (our family and BIL family) would be up for going away over Easter. She said she was keen to get away and thought it would be nice for "us all" to book something.

MIL and FIL have had a rough few weeks caring for MIL's once estranged cousin who has just passed away. It was expected, and cousin wasn't a pleasant person - no great upset I understand. MIL is relieved we think, and we took her suggestion of a family holiday to mean that she was after a bit of a break - some down time, with all of the family. We have 2 DC's and BIL/SIL have one DD (the favourite first born GC). Everyone gets along like a house on fire. Kids especially.

So of course we replied saying yes, sounds lovely, but that we had booked three days away already during the 20 day school holiday period - not across Easter itself or the bank holidays. We told her the dates and said we'd love to do something anytime before or after.

BIL replied and said "great, we'd been thinking of a few days in X place" and that he could start investigating. He didn't mention any dates. We were sort of expecting to hear back with some options or pick up the chat this week.

Anyway, cut to today and DH called MIL to check in, for a general chit chat. Just as they were about to say goodbye, DH asked about Easter plans. MIL fumbled and informed him that she and BIL have already made a plan, booked travel/accommodation, but that they depart the day we get home from our trip. No consultation, no invitation to join them, no phone call to see if we could make dates work - nothing.

DH expressed his disappointment that it had been booked without our input and she jumped in defence and shouted, "well just come then". Charming.

DH is gutted. We've basically organised the last two family holidays for us all (totally inclusive of what worked for all, huge faff over covid etc), we just hosted Christmas for them all, and we basically involve and invite them all to everything. Yet we get left out time and time again.

They (BIL family and PIL) live closer to each other and live in each other's pockets. MIL does everything for BIL/SIL, and it's embarrassingly apparent that they are the favoured family. Numerous specific examples over the last few years of clear and hurtful favouritism that our DC have noted and been directly hurt by.

We've had several upsetting talks with both PIL and BIL about this over the years but clearly no one is listening. We simply can't keep doing it. MIL HATES confrontation and will bury her head in the sand over all of this. Will shout and cover her ears if you call out her poor behaviour etc. FIL oblivious.

Why would MIL suggest a holiday on a group chat and then ignore us?

What would you do? No contact feels extreme (we couldn't do the dates they wanted to do??) but DH is ready to walk away. I was ready years ago tbh.

Any thoughts really appreciated.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
TheUsualChaos · 26/02/2022 09:12

Sorry I added to wrong thread above 🤦‍♀️

PerditaPerdita · 26/02/2022 09:06

This must have been going on forever. This will be a very deep-seated family fault line. The brother must have been favouritised through childhood too. It's very possible your DH didn't totally notice it then, or wasn't able to call it, but now he can't ignore it.

The right course would be: we wanted to come too - they apologise/explain - a way round is found and you go too, a bit upset but then all having a nice time ... but now that's not really an option, as everything is too highly charged.

Drawing back is also an upsetting option. And will not resolve the hurt. One alternative is to take the lead: sit with MIL, say, right, this got messed up - DH is particularly hurt - not nice also for the kids - let's plan and set in stone some events/holiday(s) for the next 12 months. Maybe with BIL/SIL too.

I'm so sorry. These dynamics don't change. So the best your DH can do is take the lead a bit. There's no doubt he's loved, as I'm sure the children and you are. But favouritism is deep-veined and there's a pattern of exclusive communication that will always hurt DH. All you can do is try to protect him from it by making all arrangements very definite and well in advance, and turning a blind eye to anything else. They do love him. They're just insensitive.

It's a really tricky path. Totally understandable to want to cut them off. But I think ultimately that would be more damaging for him and the kids.

If he won't go for formal counselling, you could try to drip-feed it to him a bit ...

TheUsualChaos · 26/02/2022 08:19

*time alone

TheUsualChaos · 26/02/2022 08:19

I think this thread helps in that it makes me realise it's fairly normal to never get any time all e with young children. I seem to be surrounded by parents who get regular breaks and time to do their hobbies but our life just isn't like that atm.

Mix56 · 26/02/2022 07:20

Your husband is going to get hurt repeatedly
His mother not really knowing about this, (excluding one side of the family on a joint family holiday)
How can she not have realised? She may not have set out to intentionally reject him/you all. But she just carried on anyway.
It is just blather. & your DH is so desperate to be included by his "family" he accepts it over & over.
He does need counseling.

Ohhelpicantthinkofaname · 24/02/2022 17:21

I wouldn’t go no contact over it, that’s a bit extreme. But I would stop putting in so much effort. Lower my expectations and generally be less invested.

indiesearcher · 24/02/2022 17:16

Thanks @Crepusculum - yep, I think we are in a similar territory. My proposed way forward is as you suggest, but DH definitely won't consider counselling unfortunately 😞

OP posts:
Crepusculum · 24/02/2022 17:00

Honestly @indiesearcher - I don't know. I've got a similar situation with my DH in terms of how badly his family affect his mood, for similar reasons to yours.

What your DH probably needs, as does mine, is a good bout of counselling. Mine recognises this sometimes.

We may be a few years further down the line that you (now late forties/early fifties) and DH is pretty immune to their hoovering and very clear that they only push the relationship to keep up appearances and secure his continued help. It doesn't mean that any interaction with them at all doesn't tank his mood though. Twenty years of this has had a draining effect on our marriage and has definitely affected our DC, I'm appalled to admit (my parents died before they were born so I think I hung in there a bit too long).

I started slowly putting down the rope a few years ago and no longer play host at all or suggest any kind of contact with them at all. Most recently I don't even mention them and if he does I try to commiserate without saying anything and then gently change the subject. Let him repeatedly rant, and sometimes joining in, got us precisely no where so I'm seeing how this goes. He knows that I will support him by coming with him to see them, if he asks. He knows I will help practically as they get older, to a certain extent - but that's it.

Flowers
indiesearcher · 24/02/2022 15:39

Resurrecting this thread as I need to help DH...

He's had an apology from his mum, she seems genuinely remorseful and he was grateful for the call - relieved to hear it wasn't intentional etc. Not sure I but it but anyway...

He stood his ground on the call - made his points about it being repeated pattern of behaviour, nail in coffin etc. But he seemed happy she had called and he said he wanted to move on.

Two days later and DH is all over the shop again, highly emotional, his brother is in defensive mode (can't see what the problem is) - I think DH blames his brother for this more than his mum.

His mum called again (she's worried about the family being 'broken up'). They covered the same ground again and the conversation went around in the same circles.

DH can't seem to get comfortable with the fact that this kind of hurt can take time to heal. He's said he wants to move on and doesn't want to go NC at all, but it's like he's expecting to feel fine about it all already.

He's moping around, full of sorrow. My heart is breaking for him but I've said that families fight all the time, it'll take time etc. If indeed it ever gets back to the way it was.

How can I help him?

OP posts:
indiesearcher · 21/02/2022 11:55

*firm line!

OP posts:
indiesearcher · 21/02/2022 11:52

It's so hurtful and we are still in some kind of processing shock I think.

I'm sort of glad it's happening though as it's allowing me to finally draw a very form line in the sand from my end. If DH wants to resolve it in time that's up to him but I'm firmly out of this now.

Thanks everyone for your advice and sharing your stories. People are so weird.

OP posts:
cooldarkroom · 21/02/2022 09:10

Its very painful, Ive had this with my PIL. I used to live on the same property, & would constantly lend a hand, do their shopping, drive to dr appointments etc. Then I'd pop in on a Sunday lunchtime & find them with their other 2 sons & dils sitting around the table having a 3 course family lunch..
It was such a slap in the face.
I dropped the rope.
I still havent been to say Happy New Year. MIL is probably very disgruntled, & point it out to the rest of the family
(My H goes everyday, that should be enough.)
Just fizzle out. Is my advice, your H can respond on WhatsApp, or not.

brainhurts · 21/02/2022 08:53

I would take a huge step back . No comment on what's app, should they make contact be very vague with answers .
Don't offer to host or meet up , move on with your life and accept BIL and his family are the favourites.

YouMuckyDuck · 21/02/2022 08:28

Walk away and get on with your life. They are never going to change. It's cruel and hurtful but they know precisely what they are doing and don't care
Your poor child too

RubyRedNails · 21/02/2022 08:27

Drop the rope OP and lower your expectations. It's hurtful but it gets easier once you take a step back. I did it a few years ago with my mother and sister and I'm far less bothered by their exclusionary antics now.

We hosted Christmas for years, and other events too. Nobody else hosts. Then a few years ago I found out they were all going out for my mother's birthday without us. I phoned my sister to ask why we weren't invited. She was flustered but said mum couldn't afford to pay for everyone and felt bad expecting us to pay for ourselves. This was bollocks as we'd happily pay for ourselves. They didn't want us there. Then the final straw, after hosting Christmas for 23 years I said I didn't fancy doing it and we'd be going out for Christmas lunch if they fancied joining us. We'd even pay as their Xmas present. A firm no - it's too expensive, it's to much food, it's all precooked and reheated, blah blah. Then my brother made a surprise visit from abroad and guess what, they all went out for Christmas lunch, and oh it was so lovely, the best Christmas meal ever.

That did it. Huge step back taken. No more hosting, no more trying to understand their behaviour, getting upset etc. I'm polite and friendly when I see them but don't disclose much and have zero expectations. It's very freeing.

Totalwasteofpaper · 21/02/2022 08:15

On reflection I am inclined to say don't bother to message the group or say anything.
It only really gets you upset and gives you mil the chance to act like the injured party/victim

I wouldn't get Fil involved at all
Its just more drama and it won't change the dynamics (too many players want to maintain the status quo)
If he does talk mil into reaching out respond totally in a totally vanilla Teflon non commital way.
Grey rock is your friend.
I now get great pleasure trolling my mil with this and have perfected my "pleasantly bland face".

"Oh right. Well let's see"
"Oh a visit? That's a shame as we can't then. Let's reschedule for another time"

gamerchick · 21/02/2022 08:07

Let your bloke lead the way, if he wants to go NC then that's up to him. Just stop.

On the plus side, he gets out of all the wiping his parents arses in time, that can all to to his brother and co.

Womencanlift · 21/02/2022 08:00

So going by your last post your FIL isn’t oblivious as he realised last time that something had to be fixed.

So you/your DH could raise with him and basically say we have had enough and will be stepping back. He may be the one that knocks sense into the others

Tigersonvaseline · 21/02/2022 07:58

Don't flounce from the what's app group.
Just don't read it for ages then be prepared to block it.

There is no way I would allow pils to drop in to see gc.

Gc are a bloody privalige! It sickens me how people take them for granted when many people want DC and can't have them, or don't meet the right person etc.

They get taken for granted all the time!

Pull hack and if pil mention in months time say it's not possible because you treat the GC different just as you do the son's and it's not going to be tolerated.

indiesearcher · 21/02/2022 07:53

@Tigersonvaseline - I didn't. I kicked off, I went low contact at that time too. FIL bridged the relationship and coerced MIL into talking to me - she just didn't want to hear it. It's bubbled away since but this is a final straw.

OP posts:
Tigersonvaseline · 21/02/2022 07:51

DH is ready to walk away,
I was ready year's ago

DC have been directly Hurt by favouritism

Go low contact!!

Don't make a fuss!! Don't announced it just gradually fade away, don't instantly respond to messages, don't respond to emails.. start to be unavailable....

I can't believe you let your DC be treated differently

girlmom21 · 21/02/2022 07:37

I think going NC is extreme.
Why doesn't DH just call his brother and ask why he chose that specific date without consultation?

If MIL hates conflict it's probably him who picked the dates - it might have just been the cheapest flights or whatever.

indiesearcher · 21/02/2022 07:16

Thanks much everyone there's some really good advice here.

Tempting as it is to say how I feel in the group chat I don't think I will. They are poor communicators and I think it'll either be ignored because no one wants to take responsibility, or there'll be some veiled apology- it'll just be another disappointment! DH has asked me to hold his phone for a while so he doesn't say anything he will regret. So silence is the way for now.

Dropping the rope and being led by DH - absolutely. Letting PIL drop in the see DCs, definitely, but I'm done with the fake close relationship.

I also 100% agree that BIL is complicit - DH is devastated.

OP posts:
Antsgomarching · 21/02/2022 07:12

Mute the chat, ignore, don’t mention anything and stop doing stuff for/with them.

Totalwasteofpaper · 21/02/2022 06:35

Oh while I'd message and call out their crappy behaviour I wouldn't leave the group orvgo NC now.

I do agree with going very low contact and no effort.
You can grey rock and ultimarely fade to NC over time if desired.