Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think that a flat in a good area is better than a house in a bad one?

55 replies

Readr · 20/02/2022 19:26

A friend is thinking of buying property and has the money (with a mortgage) to get either a flat in a relatively good area, or a house in a sh*tty one (drugs, high crime and anti-social behaviour, several generations unemployed kind of bad area). I get it that with a flat you are forever tied to service charges and lease, while a house is freehold, but still, in this situation AIBU to think that a flat in a better area would be a better choice?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
YankeeDad · 25/02/2022 17:48

Could she buy a flat with a share of freehold?

scoobydoo1971 · 25/02/2022 17:02

I have lived in flats that I bought, I have lived in houses that I bought...the key to happy or unhappy outcomes in both has always been the neighbours. I strongly advise anyone thinking of buying to sit outside 'dream' property weekdays, weeknights and weekends...get a jist of the parking issues, the neighbours noise and how much traffic passes by. If brave, knock on the next door neighbours door for a little chat about the area and to get an idea of who they might be.

Odoreida · 25/02/2022 16:51

We have a house in what was a shitty area 15 years ago and is now much nicer with good cafes and shops. It's great having the house and the garden.

TwoCoffeesPlease · 25/02/2022 16:48

I would get the house every time

onlychildhamster · 25/02/2022 16:42

I am in a 1930s flat in an expensive area. I would go for flats with share of freehold or where the flat freehold is owned by residents (even if your own is leasehold) so there is more control over costs. Thinking of upsizing to a bigger flat instead of a house in a worse area (as worse area would come with higher transport costs for DH and I). And transport costs are higher than reasonable service charges.

Mushrooms0up · 25/02/2022 16:37

We have a flat in a nice area (no kids, hate gardening).

We own a share of the freehold so we set the service charge for the building (it’s just us and upstairs flat) so we’re not at the mercy of a management company. Always worth checking the terms of the lease.

Moonandstar5 · 25/02/2022 16:31

If your friend is 50 and is single with no children, not into gardening and not into DIY then why buy a house? You mean to get on the property ladder? It would make sense to buy a flat then in a decent area. And like other posters have mentioned, it would depend on their lifestyle needs. Are they wanted to have a fresh start in life, move closer to family, etc.

Ozanj · 25/02/2022 16:26

The best house you can afford in the best area is the way to make money when you know you may need to move 2-3 times to get the property of your dreams. But if your dream house is in a shit area and you don’t mind then go for it.

aLilNonnyMouse · 25/02/2022 16:24

It depends on how much time you spend at home vs how much you would spend in nearby areas. I would always take the bigger/nicer house in a worse area as I'm disabled and rarely able to go out.

However if your home is basically just where you sleep, while you are out and about all day then a nicer area will give you a bigger benefit.

What sort of lifestyle do you have?

MintJulia · 25/02/2022 16:13

Everyone has different priorities. Personally I hate flats, I need outside space and greenery and feel like I'm suffocating if it isn't there.

The only flat I've owned was a maisonette with a 70' garden

But other people are nervy of rowdy neighbours. Each to their own.

redlabeltea · 25/02/2022 16:10

I'd prefer more space.

Thirkettle · 25/02/2022 16:08

I'm amused now at the idea Ickypeas spent her life buying up the best houses in the shittest areas and, while her beautiful gardens were flytipped and her car stolen, wondered where she'd gone wrong.

Readr · 25/02/2022 16:00

Thanks again, everyone, for the input!

OP posts:
Rubyupbeat · 20/02/2022 22:29

Hey, maybe if everyone bought a house in a bad/deprived area, then those areas would gradually become up and coming, then priced out the market, extreme I know, but it's worked in London.
Notting hill was a shit area 40ish years ago, look at it now. Brick lane, Spiralfields, Hackney, Bethnal green Stoke Newington, people left those areas in droves, as soon as they were able to, again around 30 to 40 years back. Same is happening in forest gate, poplar now all up and coming.
So maybe not a bad idea to take a gamble.
Oh, and I was born and bred in one of the above area's from early 60s , so do know personally how things massively changed.

Avarua · 20/02/2022 22:27

Buy in bridesmaid suburbs. The ones immediately adjacent to the good area.
Or buy one road back from a main road, max 10 mins walk to services.
Property developers secret formula.

Londondreams1 · 20/02/2022 22:24

For me, location is everything . Not necessarily area. I’d take a flat on a street with a nice atmosphere over a beautiful house in a place that looks depressing. I’m more impressed with flats, generally, though. Houses often seem gloomy and drafty unless new.

FitAt50 · 20/02/2022 22:22

@IckyPeas

Buy the best house in the worst area
You should always buy the worst house in best area.
Readr · 20/02/2022 22:17

@tillyandmilly

I live in a flat in a lovely area - couldn’t afford a house in the same area but am happy - although being leasehold does have its downsides ie £3,000 pa maintenance!
@tillyandmilly, that sounds an awful lot. Shock
OP posts:
Woahthehorsey · 20/02/2022 21:35

@IckyPeas

Buy the best house in the worst area
Totally the wrong way around 😆
Kite22 · 20/02/2022 21:18

she is not looking at a specific flat right now, she is trying to figure out whether she should look at flats or houses depending on the above dilemma.

So, she should look at both, and other options too.
It is very rarely only one option or only a completely contrasting option. pp is right about casting the net wider. I wouldn't buy a house on a 'saying'.

CrikeyPeg · 20/02/2022 21:10

@IckyPeas

Buy the best house in the worst area
I reckon it would be better to go the other way. If you buy the worst house in the best street, you can always add value to the house/property but you can't make the street any better, as in the OP's OP of drugs, high crime and anti-social behaviour, several generations unemployed kind of bad area.
tillyandmilly · 20/02/2022 21:00

I live in a flat in a lovely area - couldn’t afford a house in the same area but am happy - although being leasehold does have its downsides ie £3,000 pa maintenance!

SpikeySmooth · 20/02/2022 20:58

I live in a flat in a nice area. It's worked out well because it's safer, has better amenities and transport links, and better schools.

Staffy1 · 20/02/2022 20:58

@WomanStanleyWoman, because they are clearly not happy with A or B and maybe haven’t thought of C.

labyrinthlaziness · 20/02/2022 20:56

Always prioritise area over property.