Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

That the Gov & Post Office have been horrendous in the response to the Post Office scandal?

106 replies

FavouritePi · 20/02/2022 17:40

Listening to what happened on Radio 4 - people committed suicide, others imprisoned and gone bankrupt over shortfalls the Post Office had claimed were occuring but CEOs had been aware of a system issue years before. Compensation was then only menial in relation to how this has impacted people financially and mentally.

OP posts:
Gasp0deTheW0nderD0g · 26/11/2023 16:53

Polyanthus2 · 23/02/2022 08:59

Many were Asian - I'm sure there was racism in this too

I know this is an old thread but I've just been listening to the podcast for the first time. It's been updated several times and there are now 17 episodes. I am so angry about it all. I knew about this scandal before but the details are heartbreaking. At least five people caught up in it have killed themselves, IIRC, and many have died before having their convictions overturned or getting the paltry compensation for having their lives ruined.

Anyway, it now looks as if there was without any doubt at all a racist element to this. https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/uk-65730464 No words for this. Not even an ancient document that nobody had thought to get rid of. Introduced no more than 15 years ago! What possible explanation could there be for this racial profiling other than racism?

Also, I think it was a whistleblower from Fujitsu who said when calls from desperate postmasters came into the open plan office where the Horizon helpline staff worked it was common to hear the staff say 'I've got another Patel on the line!' and it was all a big laugh.

The guidance, which was reportedly published between 2008 and 2011, required investigators to give sub-postmasters under suspicion a number, according to their racial background. The numbered categories on the document include 'Chinese/Japanese types', 'Dark Skinned European Types' and 'Negroid Types' - an archaic and offensive term from the colonial era of the 1800s that refers to people of African descent. A Post Office spokesperson described it as a "historic document" but said the organisation did not tolerate racism "in any shape or form" and condemned the "abhorrent" language. "We fully support investigations into Post Office's past wrongdoings and believe the Horizon IT Inquiry will help ensure today's Post Office has the confidence of its Postmasters and the communities it supports," the spokesperson added. The document was discovered as part of a freedom of information request from a campaigner supporting the more than 700 branch managers who were prosecuted between 1999 and 2015 on theft, fraud and false accounting charges.

A stock image of a Post Office sign

Post Office used racist terms for sub-postmasters in official guidance

A document shows racist language was used to describe sub-postmasters being wrongly investigated.

https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/uk-65730464

PermanentTemporary · 23/02/2022 21:59

Finished the podcast. It's almost unbelievable how much the victims suffered and how hard they tried to jump through the hoops held with zero justification by the Post Office.

JustinOtherdad · 23/02/2022 15:20

Not at all unreasonable, it's a national scandal and a gargantuan miscarriage if justice. The PO, Fujitsu and their auditors face massive failings to answer for.

Various actions by the offending parties constitute fraud, breaches of employment and contract law, and perverting the course of justice. Anyone who pursued these cases while misrepresenting facts deserves a prison sentence.

In case it's not clear, the whole thing angers and upsets me greatly.

pigsDOfly · 23/02/2022 14:59

People wrongly convicted are required to pay the Home Office for the cost of staying in prison out of any compensation awards.

I didn't know this either.

That's bloody mad.

So if you're actually a criminal in the eyes of the law, you get to stay in the prison for nothing. However, if there's been a miscarriage of justice and it's later proved you're not guilty you have to compensate the Home Office for your stay.

Beggars belief.

ProfessorSlocombe · 23/02/2022 13:05

@FavouriteFortnight

Also don't forget that you have to pay for your board and lodging in prison out of your compensation. Presumably if you were imprisoned in a fancy jail you could end up owing money to the Home Office.

Sorry WHAT? Shock

Did you not know ?

People wrongly convicted are required to pay the Home Office for the cost of staying in prison out of any compensation awards.

Given how hard it is to get compensation for wrongful convictions now there is a possibility that you could end up owing the Home Office for your stay.

www.dailymail.co.uk/news/article-458006/Man-wrongly-jailed-years-charged-7-000-Home-Office-board-lodging.html

Instead, he was flabbergasted to learn the Home Office now intends to charge him nearly £7,000 for "board and lodging".

The money is for the cost of food and accommodation while he was behind bars, and will be deducted from whatever compensation he receives for wrongly imprisonment.

for example.

FiveShelties · 23/02/2022 09:28

@Polyanthus2

Many were Asian - I'm sure there was racism in this too
I am not sure there was racism, they appear to have treated everyone badly and still are by making sure compensation is not fully paid now. Although, I have no idea how you could compensate someone for the trauma of this.
Iamthewombat · 23/02/2022 09:25

@jcyclops

There is a lot of blame to go around. In some cases I am disgusted at the juries sitting in the criminal cases. Read this carefully and ask yourself if you were a juror and heard this, could you return a guilty verdict beyond reasonable doubt.

This quotation is from the judge's summing up in a 2010 case against a sub-postmaster:
“There is no direct evidence of her taking any money… She adamantly denies stealing. There is no CCTV evidence. There are no fingerprints or marked bank notes or anything of that kind. There is no evidence of her accumulating cash anywhere else or spending large sums of money or paying off debts, no evidence about her bank accounts at all. Nothing incriminating was found when her home was searched.”
The only evidence was a shortfall of cash compared to what the Post Office’s Horizon computer system said should have been in the branch.

The jury returned a guilty verdict, and the pregnant sub-postmaster was sentenced to 15-months for stealing £74,000

And this, from another poster:

it was followed by this question from the judge: “Do you accept the prosecution case that there is ample evidence before you to establish that Horizon is a tried and tested system in use at thousands of post offices for several years, fundamentally robust and reliable?” It was almost like he was recognising no evidence as far as the defendant was concerned, but then directing the jury to deliver a verdict based on the guilt of the system, not the defendant. If this is how it happened, I can understand how a jury found her guilty, based on the direction they were given.

The problem is that most (not all) juries aren’t clever or knowledgeable enough to form a sensible view on complex fraud cases like this.

The judge was telling the jury that they had to decide whether the prosecution’s case - which was that Horizon was robust and infallible - was solid. That was the fundamental question, so I don’t see a problem with the direction he or she gave.

The difficulty is, if you have a bunch of average people sitting on a jury, how are they supposed to have the insight or experience to know that computer systems can be full of holes, or only as good as the people writing the software?

Generally speaking, they won’t. Computer says no (or computer said yes, in this case). If you had a jury of accountants, criminal solicitors, academics and software engineers, it would have been very different, because those people are either trained to question statements and examine evidence, or they are subject matter experts. You don’t get many of those people sitting on juries though. They might be called, but I suspect (but don’t know) that quite a few opt out.

I think that for certain types of trial, we should have juries chosen from a subset of the population who can understand the subject matter.

Polyanthus2 · 23/02/2022 08:59

Many were Asian - I'm sure there was racism in this too

FiveShelties · 23/02/2022 08:57

It was shocking, the podcasts are so sad and it is amazing how the story came out.

People lost their homes, their reputation, their business and the PO knew there was a problem as did Fujitsu - absolutely dreadful. They were completely let down by everyone, even their own Union.

rubbishatballet · 23/02/2022 08:45

I've just listened to the podcast and too found it completely chilling - the postmasters were even thrown under the bus at the select committee by their own union!

FavouriteFortnight · 23/02/2022 08:37

Also don't forget that you have to pay for your board and lodging in prison out of your compensation. Presumably if you were imprisoned in a fancy jail you could end up owing money to the Home Office.

Sorry WHAT? Shock

bellabasset · 23/02/2022 08:24

It's heartbreaking to hear those stories, they were quick enough to accuse, not so quick to compensate those who were wrongly accused. One woman had notice of being investigated on her daughters wedding day. People were intimidated into confessing to something they didn't understand.

ProfessorSlocombe · 23/02/2022 07:47

@StoneofDestiny

I hope these people or their families get enough compensation to start their lives again. They have been through hell, made pariahs in their own communities and lost their reputations and occupation. Of course some have died or taken their own lives - but their families should be compensated to the full. Money won't make up for it, but it will send a gigantic message to these companies that human beings matter over profit.
It depends if they are innocent enough. The bar for compensation for wrongful convictions has been raised considerably the past few years.

Also don't forget that you have to pay for your board and lodging in prison out of your compensation. Presumably if you were imprisoned in a fancy jail you could end up owing money to the Home Office.

This case appears to be following the "Windrush" strategy of hoping a lot of people die before they come up for redress.

wombat1a · 23/02/2022 07:38

The thing is though in nearly all cases they were in fact 100% guilty of what they were (cleverly) charged with. Nearly all of them admitted they tried to make up the losses from their own pocket to begin with and so committed false accounting. Many were charged with that and were advised to plead guilty because they were and would be found guilty anyway and so would get a smaller fine.

How it got that far is the scandal and is disgusting and those who decided to prosecute need to be held accountable.

Muckymaisonette · 23/02/2022 07:32

I hate it that the government/post office are basically waiting for people to die so they don’t have to pay compensation (as for Windrush scandal)

PearPickingPorky · 23/02/2022 07:25

I listened to the podcast a couple of years ago. I found it shocking and very upsetting.

It's unbelievable how so many have been able to get away with it.

overthethamesfromyou · 23/02/2022 07:06

The link between government and Fujistsu is explained below: apologies for DM link

www.dailymail.co.uk/news/article-10529489/Post-Office-chiefs-FINALLY-sue-Fujitsu-scandal-jailed-postmasters.html

Gillian Keegan, a minister, is married to Michael Keegan, the ex CEO, who now advises the Cabinet Office

Polyanthus2 · 23/02/2022 06:29

Everyone responsible for this fuckup needs to be prosecuted and proper compensation provided to the victims.

With the UK as it is today I bet this doesn't happen - NO ONE is ever responsible for anything - but they still take the money. We are a corrupt country.

CousinKrispy · 23/02/2022 06:06

Paula Vennells was CEO at the time.

CousinKrispy · 23/02/2022 06:06

"Wasnt the woman at the helm also high up in the church at the same time?"

Oh she went on to head up an NHS trust in London and is also a priest. The hypocrisy is disgusting.

Everyone responsible for this fuckup needs to be prosecuted and proper compensation provided to the victims.

Svalberg · 23/02/2022 03:29

The journalist on the local radio station who started investigating it was Nick Wallis, who also did the podcasts. He's live tweeted as much as he's allowed from all the court cases.
There's a book that he's written called The Great Post Office Scandal, and he's diverting profit from this into some hardship funding for the wronged postmasters.

FavouritePi · 23/02/2022 02:14

Yes, what upsets me is those involved and the government who would responsible for fixing this will expect it to go away and just be brushed under the carpet.

OP posts:
HashtagShitShop · 21/02/2022 16:38

Isn't it amazing what those with money, power and top lawyers can get away with compared to those poor poor innocent postmasters/mistresses and families still without compensation for what they went through.)

One rule for them and another for Joe public.

Wasnt the woman at the helm also high up in the church at the same time?

ChristmasCrackered · 21/02/2022 16:18

It’s so heart-breaking to hear the stories, hundreds of lives destroyed.

I find it terrifying that something like this could happen and be covered up for so long.

CloudPop · 21/02/2022 16:12

It's absolutely outrageous. I can't believe some of the stories. And why are they still investigating - surely they should just be agreeing the size of the compensation? Peoples lives were ruined. It's beyond scandalous.