Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

That the Gov & Post Office have been horrendous in the response to the Post Office scandal?

106 replies

FavouritePi · 20/02/2022 17:40

Listening to what happened on Radio 4 - people committed suicide, others imprisoned and gone bankrupt over shortfalls the Post Office had claimed were occuring but CEOs had been aware of a system issue years before. Compensation was then only menial in relation to how this has impacted people financially and mentally.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
1stWorldProblems · 28/11/2023 07:33

The whole thing is indeed a true scandal from start to finish - Fujitsu, the Post Offices legal & (a hang over from it being founded before the police) internal prosecution dept - so they didn't have to go via the CPS to prosecute, the managers at PO who sort to cover up the issues once it became clear there was a problem with Horizon and covered it up, then fought the enquiry all the way to the High Court (wasting more public money). The fact that those in charge have not been prosecuted for fraud & still hold directorships & other top jobs, whilst showing no contrition.

The bit that gives me the most rage is that when problems became regular with Horizon and Postmasters were refusing to sign off their accounts at the end of the day until the issues they'd raised were resolved, they changed the software so they had agree they were happy with the figures at the end of each day in order to keep using the system / running their post office & open the next day. The Post Office legal dept then prosecuted a load of them for fraud - saying they had knowing lied / committed fraud by ticking the end of day box! (Rather having to prove they had stolen the money which was impossible since they hadn't since the discrepancies were just in Horizon & not in the real world so there was no evidence of spending the "missing money" & no sports cars, foreign holidays, etc - the sort of evidence the CPS would have needed if they'd be in charge of the prosecution.)

Private Eye (with Nick Wallis and the MP Peter Bottomly ) have been tracking / unearthing evidence for ages - they don't put much online (as they want people to buy the mag) but here's the special report they put out a while back.

Private Eye - Justice Lost In The Post

Special Report: Justice Lost In The Post

CONCEIVED in 1996 as one of the first private finance initiative (PFI) contracts, between the Post Office and the Benefits Agency on the one hand and computer company ICL on the other, the Horizon IT system had an unpromising start. It had been set up...

https://www.private-eye.co.uk/special-reports/justice-lost-in-the-post

enchantedsquirrelwood · 27/11/2023 14:59

Also the people in that village should get their £36K back with interest (along with everyone else who lost money, quite apart from the ruined businesses).

enchantedsquirrelwood · 27/11/2023 14:59

Yes that came through quite clearly in Nick Wallis's book that in many cases the local community thought there was no smoke without fire but in other instances (probably later on as the internet took hold and people found it easier to join the dots, they realised something weird was going on) the local community supported the postmasters and mistresses and they received much lighter sentences.

But I am sure race played a role - no doubt.

Fieldofbrokenpromises · 27/11/2023 13:17

enchantedsquirrelwood · 27/11/2023 12:40

Yes indeed - not only did money disappear but yes, so many of them were cross-subsidising the post office from their savings or their other businesses like the shops that the post offices were in.

I also don't understand why the judge in the case above passed a custodial sentence, having more or less instructed the jury not to convict - he could have used his discretion to pass a less severe sentence.

The white woman convicted in similar circumstances (although not pregnant) got a 12 month supervision order. The people in her village raised £36k to pay off the Post Office.

enchantedsquirrelwood · 27/11/2023 12:40

Fieldofbrokenpromises · 27/11/2023 11:27

Also - has anyone actually found the "missing" money yet?

I'd love to know the answer to this - some of the victims gave the Post Office thousands from their savings to make up for the non-existent losses.

Yes indeed - not only did money disappear but yes, so many of them were cross-subsidising the post office from their savings or their other businesses like the shops that the post offices were in.

I also don't understand why the judge in the case above passed a custodial sentence, having more or less instructed the jury not to convict - he could have used his discretion to pass a less severe sentence.

Fieldofbrokenpromises · 27/11/2023 11:27

Also - has anyone actually found the "missing" money yet?

I'd love to know the answer to this - some of the victims gave the Post Office thousands from their savings to make up for the non-existent losses.

ProfessorSlocombe · 27/11/2023 11:15

They were told by PO that the IT system was solid, infallible

That is actually an impossibility under laws of nature. I know there is a current thrust to redefine facts, but I wasn't aware it was retrospective.

Fieldofbrokenpromises · 27/11/2023 10:59

The Post Office hired a forensic accountant who told them the system had a number of flaws. They buried his report.

PowerTulle · 27/11/2023 10:43

Just answered my own question about auditors. They were told by PO that the IT system was solid, infallible, so only look for either human error or stealing. So they audited only on that basis. Idiots.

Fieldofbrokenpromises · 27/11/2023 09:39

Sadly, the case of the pregnant woman sent to prison does appear to be straightforward racism.

Fieldofbrokenpromises · 27/11/2023 09:37

Sorry I meant PO not RM.

comfyoldcardi · 27/11/2023 09:29

pigsDOfly · 21/02/2022 15:07

@jcyclops

There is a lot of blame to go around. In some cases I am disgusted at the juries sitting in the criminal cases. Read this carefully and ask yourself if you were a juror and heard this, could you return a guilty verdict beyond reasonable doubt.

This quotation is from the judge's summing up in a 2010 case against a sub-postmaster:
“There is no direct evidence of her taking any money… She adamantly denies stealing. There is no CCTV evidence. There are no fingerprints or marked bank notes or anything of that kind. There is no evidence of her accumulating cash anywhere else or spending large sums of money or paying off debts, no evidence about her bank accounts at all. Nothing incriminating was found when her home was searched.”
The only evidence was a shortfall of cash compared to what the Post Office’s Horizon computer system said should have been in the branch.

The jury returned a guilty verdict, and the pregnant sub-postmaster was sentenced to 15-months for stealing £74,000

This whole situation is bizarre.

The judge in the above quote was clearly telling the jury not to convict. Why did they not listen?

The PO used this software and suddenly there seems to be an outbreak of thefts from previously honest post master and post mistresses.

Would any sensible person conclude that they'd sudden all conspired to steal from the PO, or would they take a careful look at the software?

All those people's time in prison, all those ruin lives, the powerlessness they must have felt. It just makes me so angry.

Where does it go from here?

When are the massive compensation pay outs going to be made? Obviously, nothing can really compensate them though.

And are the people who were responsible for destroying so many lives actually going to be held to account?

I worry about trial by jury for this reason. In theory it sounds like a good thing but there are some people who just aren't capable, yet they are given this huge responsibility.

Fieldofbrokenpromises · 27/11/2023 09:18

Private Eye deserves a mention for their coverage of Horizon and the Chinook crash

Fieldofbrokenpromises · 27/11/2023 09:12

ProfessorSlocombe · 27/11/2023 07:32

That was exactly my point. We didn't have "control" then. And we don't now.

Because that is how international trade works.

Except we could have control if the people in charge had any guts or decency. We didn’t have to accept being blackmailed - that was a choice.

RM, the government, and the courts are all scum on this.

enchantedsquirrelwood · 27/11/2023 09:08

The whole thing is outrageous. Few people have covered themselves in glory in this sorry scenario except for a couple of MPs past and present (eg James Arbuthnot - there appeared to be a cluster of cases in his constituency and he was also aware of the "computers "can't" make a mistake after a Chinook helicopter crash in the 90s and RAF Odiham was in his constituency)) and the lawyers who fought hard (and are still fighting hard) for their clients.

But so many others - MPs who ignored their constituents, post office staff who simply lied (and should be prosecuted for contempt of court and perverting the course of justice), lawyers who lied or were negligent and should be subject to regulatory action, current judges who refuse to simply rescind the convictions...the list goes on.

Also - has anyone actually found the "missing" money yet?

If you've not read it, it's well worth reading Nick Wallis's book.

PowerTulle · 27/11/2023 09:01

*their

PowerTulle · 27/11/2023 09:00

The PO, Fujitsu and their auditors face massive failings to answer for

Good point about auditors. Isn’t this there actual job? Who audits the PO?

Polyanthus2 · 27/11/2023 08:32

Can anyone explain why Fujitsu haven’t been sued for millions for denying there was a problem - I would have thought that money could have compensated the post office staff.

ProfessorSlocombe · 27/11/2023 07:32

jcyclops · 26/11/2023 22:45

Perhaps you should look closely at when this happened and realise which government was responsible when the communication from Tokyo was received. That government was responsible for this for at least the following 12 years.

"In 1998, following a meeting between the British ambassador to Japan and Fujitsu executives, the British embassy in Tokyo wrote to the UK government warning it of serious economic repercussions, including UK job losses and reductions in trade, if Fujitsu’s software contract with the Post Office was cancelled."

That was exactly my point. We didn't have "control" then. And we don't now.

Because that is how international trade works.

jcyclops · 26/11/2023 22:45

ProfessorSlocombe · 26/11/2023 18:52

Apparently the UK ambassador to Japan had a visit from the CEO of Fujitsu who pretty much threatened to close the UK subsidiary if the Horizon contract were to be cancelled.

So much for "taking back control" eh ?

Perhaps you should look closely at when this happened and realise which government was responsible when the communication from Tokyo was received. That government was responsible for this for at least the following 12 years.

"In 1998, following a meeting between the British ambassador to Japan and Fujitsu executives, the British embassy in Tokyo wrote to the UK government warning it of serious economic repercussions, including UK job losses and reductions in trade, if Fujitsu’s software contract with the Post Office was cancelled."

ProfessorSlocombe · 26/11/2023 18:52

Apparently the UK ambassador to Japan had a visit from the CEO of Fujitsu who pretty much threatened to close the UK subsidiary if the Horizon contract were to be cancelled.

So much for "taking back control" eh ?

Gasp0deTheW0nderD0g · 26/11/2023 17:09

It does. Apparently the UK ambassador to Japan had a visit from the CEO of Fujitsu who pretty much threatened to close the UK subsidiary if the Horizon contract were to be cancelled. So many of those big IT contracts went very badly wrong. The senior staff at the PO knew that Fujitsu were having problems for years but signed it off and went live with it anyway. They seem to have done everything they could to prevent being open about this.

I don't think I could live with myself if I knew that a pregnant woman had gone to prison, leaving her young children and her husband behind, and given birth there because I had covered up the real reason her post office accounts wouldn't balance.

AgnesX · 26/11/2023 16:58

It beggars belief that noone thought to look closely at the software. The company that wrote the code should be hammered especially their management.

Gasp0deTheW0nderD0g · 26/11/2023 16:56

Oh yes, and then the Post Office just put the cherry on the top by awarding senior managers substantial bonuses for doing what they are legally required to do and giving evidence to the statutory inquiry.

https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/business-65963710

Post Office chief executive Nick Read

Post Office bosses told to repay mistaken bonuses

The money was paid for completing an Inquiry which still hasn't finished

https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/business-65963710

WTF475878237NC · 26/11/2023 16:56

Unbelievable isn't it? And what's worst of all is the victims are STILL fighting for justice and compensation.