[quote GlitteryGreen]@Pinkyxx Jeez, sorry your ex was so brutal about 'the family he wanted', that's awful.
Financially, I just think the whole thing is so hard and fraught with emotion weaved through it as well. Nobody wants to feel that their child is being short-changed or sidelined because another baby is born, and I can see how a drop in CM could feel that way. People also wouldn't want to feel that their child has a far lesser standard of living on their side of the fence and I can see it must be hard when an ex is wealthy and able to offer so much more.
I'd also say though that there can be complications in that many (not all of course) mums would not want 50/50 or similar even if it was offered and I can understand that feeling - I know for a fact my mum and the majority of my friends who are mothers would never want to be without their child 50% of the time, or close to. I think I would massively struggle with it too. But then this obviously impacts on their ability to work and earn, and leaves them at a disadvantage there. And can also breed feelings of resentment over having to shoulder most of the care burden alone.
As for CM being/not being 50%, I guess that is hard one too because realistically there is highly unlikely to be an overall agreement on how much will be spent on the child each month (obviously as it's just not practical to even attempt that) and the NRP does tend to lose some influence over that side of things due to not being present for much of the time. There is also the fact that a lot of the child's essential living expenses are enmeshed completely with the RP's - housing, electric, heating, food etc. So if you took those things away, perhaps it would be 50%? But obviously those things can't be taken away, they are essential and inseparable, but do also need to be borne by both parents on their own sides of the fence.
The whole thing is just a minefield and I think there will never be a one-size-fits-all or definitely right/definitely wrong approach.[/quote]
@GlitteryGreen despite all my ex's flaws, he is our child's father. Our child deserves her Father in her life. I would have hated to be apart from her 50% of the time without a doubt, but to stand in the way of a relationship with her Father for my own comfort would be something I could not have lived with. I would have greatly preferred an arrangement that was not to my personal preference to the 10+ years of watching our child try to reconcile why her Father wants so little to do with her and treats her so differently to her half / step siblings (this is not just a financial thing...). As it happens his mistress lived a significant distance from us, and wanted to stay there given her children were there as was her ex (obviously understandable). He moved to where she wanted, weekend contact was the only feasible approach. This left me no choice whatsoever in the matter, it didn't help he changed the locks on our jointly owned home and rented it out thus making me homeless at the same time. He did vow that if I refused to move to where his mistress lived (100's of miles away from our home) that he would ensure I suffered financially in every possible way he could inflict upon me, and he has been true to his word. If I complied, he would pay 50% of everything until she was independent post uni. As he has reminded me many times over the years it was my ''choice'' to be in the situation I am in - I could have done as I was told and all would have been so different. Justice is the reserve of the rich and I certainly didn't have the money to fight him or the energy. I was already broken from years of being assaulted.
I accept my case is perhaps not the norm, but my point is any system that enables and encourages this is fundamentally not fit for purpose. You will find many stories of children living in poverty due to irresponsible NRPs leaving a trail of children in their wake citing exactly various justifications seen on this thread for not supporting them financially. We'd all like to live our ''best life'' and the NRP has no more right to his than the RP which is why I speak of 50% of costs. While costs are enmeshed, data exists which could be used to quantity these costs and extrapolate to a payment, there is simply no will to invest this level of effort to make NRPs accountable. A complete societal shift is needed and I don't believe this will ever happen.