Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Child maintenance

467 replies

Lalala1 · 20/02/2022 14:35

Posting here for traffic!

The amount of threads on mn surrounding child maintenance I’ve noticed there’s completely opposite opinions on it.
Some find the way it’s calculated fair some don’t.
Some say it doesn’t cover everything and “certain things should be split” out with cms.
Some say people get too much because they only get lower and are “greedy ex wives” so they should be grateful.
Some say the rules around calculations are wrong and should be changed.

So I’m curious if you were in charge of cms what would/should it be?
How should it be calculated?
Should it cover everything or not?
How would it or could it be changed to be fair for all children?
Or
Is the way it is set up and conducted fine as it is?

Just putting this for vote

YABU- cms is fine as it is no change
YANBU - cms should be changed and how?

OP posts:
Getyourarseofffthequattro · 24/02/2022 15:08

@ChiselandBits

Quatro That's in your case, not all. if it was only a "few pounds" then just keep paying it and keep the moral high ground. And I'd be very surprised if the ex in your case, if she is RP doesn't provide a fuck ton of other stuff, or are you suggesting that your DP/DH is providing 100% of all the costs related to his child, despite being the NRP? That would be v v odd indeed and would mean his CMS must be massively high, like close to four figures, if the RP is paying the mortgage / rent / utilities / food / clothes / acitvities etc out of it. In which case, your DP must be a very high earner and what on earth are you caring about a few quid for?

And yes, for the sake of this dispute, taking all emotion out of it, a child is exactly like a mortgage. Its a fixed expense that you work out if you can afford before taking it on. And in the case of an accidental pregnancy, that's on the parents of the "child surprise" to pay for out of their existing means, it has nothing to do with the RP or child 1.

The moral high ground? Are you joking?

Sorry, no but the moral high ground is just bullshit in this instance. It wasn't much, no, but dss gets far more out of us than ds ever did or ever will, because of his mother. So no, she won't get an extra few pounds a week on top of everything else she demands because of the moral high ground. She can contribute to her own child, like I do for mine.
A child isn't a fixed expense. It varies. It changes over time. It adapts.

ChiselandBits · 24/02/2022 14:31

Quatro That's in your case, not all. if it was only a "few pounds" then just keep paying it and keep the moral high ground. And I'd be very surprised if the ex in your case, if she is RP doesn't provide a fuck ton of other stuff, or are you suggesting that your DP/DH is providing 100% of all the costs related to his child, despite being the NRP? That would be v v odd indeed and would mean his CMS must be massively high, like close to four figures, if the RP is paying the mortgage / rent / utilities / food / clothes / acitvities etc out of it. In which case, your DP must be a very high earner and what on earth are you caring about a few quid for?

And yes, for the sake of this dispute, taking all emotion out of it, a child is exactly like a mortgage. Its a fixed expense that you work out if you can afford before taking it on. And in the case of an accidental pregnancy, that's on the parents of the "child surprise" to pay for out of their existing means, it has nothing to do with the RP or child 1.

strivingtosucceed · 24/02/2022 14:23

HOnestly, I don't think it needs to be too difficult. It should work similarly to if you combined HMRC & SLC.
-There should be a minimum amount to be paid for each child up to the age of 18 (let's say £300 a month) reducing for each subsequent child until a minimum threshold is reached ( eg £250, £200, £150).
-The minimum amount should be linked to a threshold eg £18,000 and progressively increased like tax.
-Rather than paying as and when and being subject to the whims of deadbeat exes, it should be paid out like a benefit directly from the government.
-Then, rather than paying the RP, the NRP is paying the government directly from their salary what is essentially a debt to them in a manner similar to student loans & tax (which makes it more likely to be followed up & collected).

No concessions for step kids or future kids, every kid's upbringing is of equal value.

Getyourarseofffthequattro · 24/02/2022 14:14

[quote Pinkyxx]@Getyourarseofffthequattro are you being deliberately obtuse? It seems perfectly obvious that an adult need to meet their existing financial obligations before taking on new ones.

Did you tell your mortgage lender and credit card providers that you plan to reduce your repayments because you decided to have another child too or do you recognize these are obligations which are fixed and therefore must be met? Why not?

Or is it just your partners obligation to their existing children which you feel should be pushed onto their mother to make way for the cost of your new child?[/quote]
It's really not my fault that you can't understand. A child is not comparable to a mortgage.

No, my "new child" probably missed out so the all important first childs mother didn't have to buy him a single piece of uniform, or pay for rugby training, or in fact anything at all. So yes his payment went down by maybe a few pounds but in reality his mum didn't have to pay for anything extra.

Escargooooooo · 24/02/2022 14:12

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk guidelines.

Pinkyxx · 24/02/2022 12:58

@Getyourarseofffthequattro are you being deliberately obtuse? It seems perfectly obvious that an adult need to meet their existing financial obligations before taking on new ones.

Did you tell your mortgage lender and credit card providers that you plan to reduce your repayments because you decided to have another child too or do you recognize these are obligations which are fixed and therefore must be met? Why not?

Or is it just your partners obligation to their existing children which you feel should be pushed onto their mother to make way for the cost of your new child?

ChiselandBits · 24/02/2022 12:56

thanks beachcity. Quattro. I AM NOT SAYING ONE IS MORE IMPORTANT THAN ANOTHER. They are not. Not in any way or shape. But you cannot take from one to give to another. If you cannot provide properly for child 2 without depriving child 1, then don't have them. If you do that, then YOU are the one saying child 2 is actually more important that child 1. Child 1 loses out for the benefit of Child 2, unless of course the RP makes up the difference, which they most likely will. If an NRP is desperate to have more, they absolutely can, but not at the expense of existing commitments. If that means getting another job or working more hours or seeking promotion, fine - an NRP can do that far more easily than an RP.

As for "bitter" - I wasn't accusing you of saying that, just that it is frequently used to shout down RPs as part of the "bitter first wives club" and discredit any argument that have on the grounds that they are jealous / bitter / greedy. Much easier to do that than justify why it is right for an RP to bear such a disproportionate share of the cost and burden of parenthood when the NRP elects for CMS only and EOW or less.

beachcitygirl · 24/02/2022 12:30

@ChiselandBits

quattro nowhere have I said that child one is more important or worth more than child 2. Literally nowhere. What I have said is that IF an NRP decides to have more children, that should not be at the expense of the first child. If that isn't feasible, then don't do it. You cannot keep saying "oh but that's just how it is with all siblings." A split household is a totally different set-up to a united one. Saying that one child is more important than another is an emotive, straw man position, and not one that I hold. I am not arguing on the basis of more important, but on the basis of existing obligations. As a pp said upthread, if you've maxed out your mortgage you can't just get the bank to give you another one because you just WANT one. if you can't afford it, you can't have it. I think there is a deep seated problem now with people thinking that they must always be allowed to have and do whatever they like and anyone who stops them or suggests they shouldn't do it for solid, practical reasons, like existing obligations, is just being mean, unfair or, of course, always, "bitter".
This. ^^ 👏🏻
Getyourarseofffthequattro · 24/02/2022 12:07

@ChiselandBits

quattro nowhere have I said that child one is more important or worth more than child 2. Literally nowhere. What I have said is that IF an NRP decides to have more children, that should not be at the expense of the first child. If that isn't feasible, then don't do it. You cannot keep saying "oh but that's just how it is with all siblings." A split household is a totally different set-up to a united one. Saying that one child is more important than another is an emotive, straw man position, and not one that I hold. I am not arguing on the basis of more important, but on the basis of existing obligations. As a pp said upthread, if you've maxed out your mortgage you can't just get the bank to give you another one because you just WANT one. if you can't afford it, you can't have it. I think there is a deep seated problem now with people thinking that they must always be allowed to have and do whatever they like and anyone who stops them or suggests they shouldn't do it for solid, practical reasons, like existing obligations, is just being mean, unfair or, of course, always, "bitter".
That's exactly what you're saying though? I've never used the word bitter, either. And you complain about overly emotive...
Getyourarseofffthequattro · 24/02/2022 12:06

@Finallylostit

Getoffyourarse - my Ex wanted 50:50 it last 1 month as the reality sunk in and his new DP did not want the DCS around. So not all done by the judges.

My 2 DCs get £300 pcm from their DF in total.
His other EX gets £1500 because she does pay per view and he rolls over.
Does £150pcm per child cover the cost of bringing them up, providiing 100% child care - because random days when I have paid for care does notcount - still have to pay - does it hell!

i paid for my DCs to go on holiday with their DF - because otherwise they would not have gone. I subsidise his second EX by not claiming what is rightfully my eldest 2DCs. I sure as hell did not sign up for that

I didn't say that.....
QuirkyTurtle · 24/02/2022 09:42

If they would have benefitted from having a higher earner as a parent then they should still benefit after a split.

@Orangello - my partner and I are higher earners than my stepson's mum and her partner, which my stepson benefits from when he is here. But then we have 50/50 and mothers who believe their child should benefit from the higher earnings of the ex-partner should agree to 50/50 custody if the ex-partner wants it.

Pinkyxx · 24/02/2022 07:28

@knittingaddict it leaves the parent with care unable to provide anything other than a much reduced quality of life. Their ability to work is significantly constrained resulting in their future earnings capacity being limited. The impact of this is felt by the child predominantly but will have a long lasting impact on the Mother's life. If a single mother re-marries there are distinct measurable financial advantages, as she and her children will take precedence as the ''new wife''. If she does not then she will have to do her best alone. That is not to say re-marriage to someone with children does not come without other significant downsides for a child.

The UK is very poor at supporting lone parents hence why child poverty is so high. This is a very short sighted strategy as it impacts a child's life, health, education outcomes and employment prospects through adulthood as has been proven through countless studies. As is so often the case in the UK, it is left to ''personal responsibility'' for people to ''do the right thing'' - contrary to popular political perception, people do not appear to do the right thing, instead when given the chance they will self serve.

Orangello · 24/02/2022 06:19

How does that work with a huge difference in earning power?

I think the poster means that half the costs should be the minimum level and the parent is expected to find the money somewhere. As even if they decide not to work, children still need to eat. No more situations where it is assessed that NRP does not have to pay anything at all.

Of course parents who earn more should also pay more.

knittingaddict · 24/02/2022 05:20

@AnneElliott

I'd set the level at half what the basic costs are of raising a child. The NRP needs to fund half the cost regardless of their earning situation - so no reduction if they move in the girlfriends children or have more of their own. And the debt wouldn't die - it would come from their pension or lottery win/inheritance.

Childcare should also be included unless the NRP offers to do half of the childcare themselves. Women shouldn't be impacted in their ability to earn and make a career for themselves.

If we sorted out CMS we could make such a difference to child poverty in this country.

How does that work with a huge difference in earning power? My ex son in law earns 2 or 3 times what my daughter does and doesn't have to worry about day to day childcare. He might pay half of the child's cost but where does the lower earner find the money to fund the other half?

The idea of child maintenance is that the children shouldn't be massively disadvantaged by a divorce or separation. If they would have benefitted from having a higher earner as a parent then they should still benefit after a split.

Shazzatastic · 24/02/2022 04:05

45Dithercats

Reducing CM if you live with another woman with children - or if you have another child should be stopped.
Men should pay for their children regardless of who they go on to be with.

Agree with this, it has never made sense to me. As new partners income doesn't come into the calculation so why should her(usually but sometimes hìs) kids mean you as pwc get less

Finallylostit · 24/02/2022 00:51

Getoffyourarse - my Ex wanted 50:50 it last 1 month as the reality sunk in and his new DP did not want the DCS around. So not all done by the judges.

My 2 DCs get £300 pcm from their DF in total.
His other EX gets £1500 because she does pay per view and he rolls over.
Does £150pcm per child cover the cost of bringing them up, providiing 100% child care - because random days when I have paid for care does notcount - still have to pay - does it hell!

i paid for my DCs to go on holiday with their DF - because otherwise they would not have gone. I subsidise his second EX by not claiming what is rightfully my eldest 2DCs. I sure as hell did not sign up for that

Finallylostit · 24/02/2022 00:42

Glittery - are you serious
But as a temporary measure I really don't think it's that bad if the RP picks up the cost until the dad is back paying the normal amount. He will still be contributing to his children, just not as much for that time

But it won't go back to normal because there is another child - can you not see that.

It is downright cruel to tell a chid no football because you have a new borther/sister. Your average 9 yrold would resent the new sibling for depriving them of their activity.
How you can not see that the RP by paying to ensure the child is not disadvantaged because the NRP wanted more DCs but did not think it through is not the RP supporting the NRPs household.

I married the Dickhead and we separated - I did not sign up for supporting his new family because he wants to focus his monies on them rather than supporting his existing commitments.

ChiselandBits · 23/02/2022 23:29

quattro nowhere have I said that child one is more important or worth more than child 2. Literally nowhere. What I have said is that IF an NRP decides to have more children, that should not be at the expense of the first child. If that isn't feasible, then don't do it. You cannot keep saying "oh but that's just how it is with all siblings." A split household is a totally different set-up to a united one. Saying that one child is more important than another is an emotive, straw man position, and not one that I hold. I am not arguing on the basis of more important, but on the basis of existing obligations. As a pp said upthread, if you've maxed out your mortgage you can't just get the bank to give you another one because you just WANT one. if you can't afford it, you can't have it. I think there is a deep seated problem now with people thinking that they must always be allowed to have and do whatever they like and anyone who stops them or suggests they shouldn't do it for solid, practical reasons, like existing obligations, is just being mean, unfair or, of course, always, "bitter".

Hiphopboppertybop99 · 23/02/2022 22:34

Apologies if i am repeating, I have not RTFT.

The problem actually lies with the large % of parents (be it mum or dad) who the child(ren) live with for the lesser amount of time (if any) who do not want to support their children. Once they are separated they do not want to give money to their ex partner - this is part of the problem they see it as giving the other parent money, and their mindset is not trained to think I must financially support my child.

Money is always a sensitive matter, there may have been acrimonious divorce / separation proceedings and this then continues into the maintenance aspect.

If the mindset of parents was different then the services of CMS would not be required. Except maybe in some certain situations.

However, again if the mindset of parents was different, I.e. they paid CMS amount, did not put barriers up to enable the CMS to do their work, we're not difficult / uncontactable then again the service provided by the CMS would probably greatly increase.

With regard to high earners, whereby, the RP definitely knows the PP earns more from the time they were together- due to their bills, spending, holidays, cars lifestyle etc. Yes in theory they are 100% correct, however, the way in which the PP probably declared their income (ie not all of it to HMRC) highly likely hasn't changed since the time they were together as a couple - it more than likely wasn't discussed and maybe the RP was unaware of this. Or if they were they suddenly want the CMS to be able to prove this.

Turning to what is the fair / right / correct amount for the PP to pay to support a child - well who knows?? Even the CMS has changed the way they calculate maintenance over the years.

A PP very early on said it should be a minimum of £300 per month per child. This may well be unaffordable, I know I certainly wouldn't like it if I was told that everyone will pay the same amount of tax regardless of what you earn (maybe not a great example- but couldn't think of another). So one person earning £18,000 p.a will pay the same as someone earning double them??

Hence I believe (from reading other threads) on here that's why, it is a % of the PP earnings, the same reasoning behind how we pay our tax - a % of our income, relative to what we earn.

I may think £50 per week per child is fair. That's roughly £400 per month per child assuming the RP matches the PP contribution, if as so many people say it should be half of a child's needs paid by the PP. Someone else may think it should be £100 per week per child, that's £800 per month for the child's needs.

What should be included as part of a child's needs ? Childcare costs ?, clothes, toys, uniforms, school trips, activities, gadgets for older children?

Childcare costs - MN consensus seems to be that childcare costs should be split to enable the RP to work, not fall behind in their career. What if, when the child is young PP also needs Childcare when they have the child with them. What if the PP doesn't need child care, but would like to pay for an activity whilst the child is with them? How would that work?

Reduction for children living with the PP - this is always a divider. If happy couple have child, and can afford a certain level of lifestyle, but when a second child comes along, they maybe can't afford a takeaway twice a week, now its ony twice a month, or instead of spending £100 on new shoes, it has to be reduced to £50, they have to reduce their outgoings to enable them provide for everyone. In certain ways this is similar to a biological child of the PP with a new partner. Just because child 1 was here first, doesn't mean they are entitled to more.

A little more difficult is the PP living with children of their partner, whilst in theory they are probably providing for the child(ren) - should a reduction be allowed? I honestly don't know what the right answer to this is.

I don't think there will ever be a right / wrong, fair or not way of working out how much a PP should pay.

Getyourarseofffthequattro · 23/02/2022 20:28

@Finallylostit

Where does society think it is OK for an NRP to toss the RP - £5, £20, £200 pcm and think that covers the raising of a child.

Whilst they waltz off, build a new life and become drop in occasionally parents.

It should be illegal to not support your DCs and the punishments should be harsh.

Waltz off and drop in occasionally?

The standard court ordered contact is generally eow and one night a week, so perhaps blame judges for all the dropping in occasionally?

I agree, it's shit, but for some people it's not a choice it's what they get given by either the RP or a court.

Some, clearly, are shits who can't be arsed, but I'm not sure it's in a child's best interest to have someone forced to spend time with them who clearly does not want to be there... Speaking from experience with my own dad there.

Finallylostit · 23/02/2022 20:24

Where does society think it is OK for an NRP to toss the RP - £5, £20, £200 pcm and think that covers the raising of a child.

Whilst they waltz off, build a new life and become drop in occasionally parents.

It should be illegal to not support your DCs and the punishments should be harsh.

caringcarer · 23/02/2022 19:48

It is not fair for purpose. 1. A man who moves in with another woman who has children with someone else should not mean child 1 gets less maintenance. It is different if man goes on to have another child of his own.

  1. Allen should be forced to pay for any children they father. Punishments should be dished out to make that happen. Take away driving licence and passport are powers that CM have but very rarely use.
  2. Money should be taken out of wages by employer and paid across to person who cares for child.
  3. Non resident parents should have to pay half towards school trips and uniform, including shoes.
Pinkyxx · 23/02/2022 19:17

[quote GlitteryGreen]@Pinkyxx I am really sorry to read your story and to see that your ex has been such an arsehole to you, and to your DD too. You sound like you've done a fab job without him in any case x[/quote]
@GlitteryGreen thank you, that's very kind of you.

Getyourarseofffthequattro · 23/02/2022 19:08

@ChiselandBits

quattro oh I know they're not comparable, just trying to put some real terms in instead of abstract ideas. I still disagree that the it's acceptable for the nrp to reduce funds available to the RP for the joint child for a decision that dies not involve the RP or the child. Realistically the RP will almost always make up the difference and the nrp gets to hide behind the rules that they're doing nothing wrong. I think they are, you think they're not. We might have to leave it here as we're not going to agree.
Well you can think what you like really! It's not hiding behind the rules, it's life isn't it? No we aren't going to agree, because you cannot understand that the first child isn't more important than subsequent children. I'll never agree that one child is superior to another, either way.
LacasadeBernadaAlba · 23/02/2022 19:05

It's not the RP who is screwed over, it's the children

Totally disagree. Having not received maintenance for many years, it is me that has paid the price. I stopped making pension contributions because I could no longer afford it so long term, the impact on me will be massive. Better hope I drop dead sooner rather than later. My children have not gone without and I have kept a roof over our heads. But there is a price for that.