Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Child maintenance

467 replies

Lalala1 · 20/02/2022 14:35

Posting here for traffic!

The amount of threads on mn surrounding child maintenance I’ve noticed there’s completely opposite opinions on it.
Some find the way it’s calculated fair some don’t.
Some say it doesn’t cover everything and “certain things should be split” out with cms.
Some say people get too much because they only get lower and are “greedy ex wives” so they should be grateful.
Some say the rules around calculations are wrong and should be changed.

So I’m curious if you were in charge of cms what would/should it be?
How should it be calculated?
Should it cover everything or not?
How would it or could it be changed to be fair for all children?
Or
Is the way it is set up and conducted fine as it is?

Just putting this for vote

YABU- cms is fine as it is no change
YANBU - cms should be changed and how?

OP posts:
Getyourarseofffthequattro · 25/02/2022 07:50

@ChiselandBits

I think if they knew that if they didn't pay the minimum, the state would and they'd accrue it as a debt that doesn't get written off nrps might find the motivation to find that minimum. As said above the biggest problem for RPs is the barrier of childcare so they can work. Nrps largely don't have that in a typical eow scenario. Different arrangements would be needed for genuine illness etc but ti's comes back to the point of massive investment needed in providing a more tailored solution.
But some people genuinely won't be able to make that, is it fair to punish people based on their ability to earn? I'm not sure it is to be honest. Not just illness but some people won't have the qualifications etc to get a better job, and before you suggest two jobs as the solution, that's not right either, it's preventing these people spending any time with their children.

A more tailored solution I agree with, but demanding more money from someone who doesn't have it, and may have no means of getting it, leaving them in massive debt out of principle, is not the answer for me.

I think the biggest, best, probably easiest step in the right direction is to focus less on those who genuinely earn little (because the likelihood is they always have, and did when they were together with the person claiming and decided to have a child) and focus more on those who earn and don't pay anything, or those self employed who earn lots and declare little. Simple steps like only taking a certain level of pension contribution into account. It's really not rocket science, it is very irritating that they don't do this already.

Soopermum1 · 25/02/2022 07:39

Powerful stats from @Pinkyxx. It should become a cultural thing to abhor non or partial payment of CMS, like it has become with drink driving. I assume self employed NRPs, or cash in hand NRPs, or those who don't even make it on to the CMS books are not included. In other countries non payment is tackled much harder, why not in the UK?

ErinAoife · 25/02/2022 07:13

What I found hard is that cost is split 50/50, my eldest started university last year, I have to pay 50 % of his accomodation and ex paid the other half despite him earning nearly 2 x more than me, if it was fair he should contribute more than me. The maintenance he gave me for our youngest only cover half the cost of our childminder, every other expenses related to my youngest have to be paid entirely by me.

ChiselandBits · 25/02/2022 06:35

I think if they knew that if they didn't pay the minimum, the state would and they'd accrue it as a debt that doesn't get written off nrps might find the motivation to find that minimum. As said above the biggest problem for RPs is the barrier of childcare so they can work. Nrps largely don't have that in a typical eow scenario. Different arrangements would be needed for genuine illness etc but ti's comes back to the point of massive investment needed in providing a more tailored solution.

Getyourarseofffthequattro · 24/02/2022 18:47

@sparklyponies

There should be a minimum amount that they are forced to pay. Obviously there will be exceptions in cases of serious illness etc but we need to get rid of the part time / min wage / self employed ways of not paying when they are perfectly able to pay.
Like dps ex though, some people just are in minimum wage. What should happen? Demand more and tough shit if they can't afford it? Whilst it was a tiny amount which in reality didn't pay for much, you can't get blood out of a stone? You can't force someone to get a "better" job...
sparklyponies · 24/02/2022 18:42

There should be a minimum amount that they are forced to pay. Obviously there will be exceptions in cases of serious illness etc but we need to get rid of the part time / min wage / self employed ways of not paying when they are perfectly able to pay.

Pinkyxx · 24/02/2022 18:27

My case may sound bad & its possibly fair to say my ex is a particular breed of man who is not the norm, however the financial outcome I faced is not usual hence why I argue so passionately on this topic.

In 2019 49% of lone parents (>90% of which were women) were living in poverty.

Add to this ugly statistic:

Since 2012, when the CMS began, £421.5 million in unpaid maintenance accumulated. This amounts to 9% of all maintenance due to be paid since the start of the service.

In the quarter ending June 2021, of 153,100 Paying Parents due to pay via the Collect & Pay service:

39,300 (26%) paid no maintenance
113,900 (74%) paid some maintenance:
36,300 (24%) paid up to 90% of the maintenance due for the quarter (further breakdowns of this group are available on Stat-Xplore)
77,600 (51%) paid over 90% of the maintenance due for the quarter

In other words, many NRPs do not even pay the pittance that CMS is.

Research further shows that:

High living costs – particularly rent and utility bills – play a part. Limits to single parents’ incomes are another major factor – especially barriers to enter and progress in work and the disproportionate impact of welfare reform.

Becoming a single parent can reduce you to a life of poverty, and as the stats show the NRPs are by a large margin not contributing. This is wrong, and no society should turn a blind eye to this.

cpag.org.uk/child-poverty/child-poverty-facts-and-figures#:~:text=The%20facts%20and%20figures%20show,child%20poverty%20in%20the%20UK.&text=49%20per%20cent%20of%20children,and%20pay%2C%20and%20childcare%20costs.

www.gov.uk/government/statistics/child-maintenance-service-statistics-data-to-june-2021-experimental/child-maintenance-service-statistics-data-to-june-2021-experimental

www.gingerbread.org.uk/policy-campaigns/living-standards-and-poverty/

QuirkyTurtle · 24/02/2022 17:45

You have my deepest sympathies for what is clearly an awful situation, and I'm sorry you had to deal with such a terrible person. I'm glad you've made it work which speaks volumes for your resilience and love for your child.

But I also think that your situation is not the norm (thankfully).

Pinkyxx · 24/02/2022 17:07

@Getyourarseofffthequattro at last something we can agree on!

Pinkyxx · 24/02/2022 17:03

@QuirkyTurtle

I just don't agree. We provide a home with a bedroom for my stepson. His mother also provides a home with a bedroom. My partner is not responsible for paying her mortgage any more than she is responsible for paying mine. He already contributes 50% of costs of housing the child by having a house.

It's really simple in my eyes. In a nuclear family, if there is a second child the first child's resources are reduced. This doesn't change because the first child's parents couldn't make it work. Their resources are reduced because they now have a sibling. Unless their mother is struggling to put food on the table and living paycheck to paycheck, this is just a fact of life you need to accept. But as previously pointed out, the reduction for subsequent children is so low that it shouldn't make the difference between eating and not eating. If that is the case, you are not living within your means.

@QuirkyTurtle when I became a single mum I had a child with severe health needs who needed specialized care so I could work. It costs me more than my net salary. I lost my home (which I jointly owned) because my ex changed the locks, used it as a base to meet with his mistress and later rented it out when they got their first place (his email informing me stated - I don't want you thinking you can live there). He refused to pay the mortgage. Not wanting to default, I had to pay it. I was homeless with a sick toddler. I had a full time job but frankly our child's medical needs had seriously impacted my ability to work. Ex had no involvement at all - ever. Literally didn't attend one hospital appt over the many years she went weekly then at least twice a month. He didn't pay a penny of child support for 2 years. I was at my Mum's with our child when he did it , we were left with the clothes on our back + nappy bag!! It took me 2 years to get my belonging back, or what was left of them I should say - he'd destroyed much of it. I had bought ever piece of furniture in that house and all the things our child needed. I lost pretty much my entire life that was in that house. He emptied our bank account. He left me to pay all bills until the tenant moved in (they were all in my name as he couldn't waste his time on that nonsense...). He then made abuse allegations which forced me to spend over 3 years in the family courts. I had no money to litigate on the finances so had to agree to whatever he said. The judge at the hearing told me I was insane to agree as I was effectively making myself and my child destitute and homeless. As I said to the judge, I can't afford a lawyer so I have no choice as a settlement must be agreed so the divorce can proceed as he wishes to re-marry urgently. He lied regards his assets and income, there was nothing I could do. He then converted his a large amount of his salary into pension contributions and other forms of income (like regular dividends/share s) reducing the CMS. He then reduced it for his partners kids, and then the new children. Sorry but I feel that's wrong.

You can't get blood out of a stone and there's was only so much I could do to ''live within my means''. Maybe you earn huge amounts and can stretch to cover everything yourself with literally pocket change, I couldn't.

knittingaddict · 24/02/2022 17:02

[quote Pinkyxx]@knittingaddict it leaves the parent with care unable to provide anything other than a much reduced quality of life. Their ability to work is significantly constrained resulting in their future earnings capacity being limited. The impact of this is felt by the child predominantly but will have a long lasting impact on the Mother's life. If a single mother re-marries there are distinct measurable financial advantages, as she and her children will take precedence as the ''new wife''. If she does not then she will have to do her best alone. That is not to say re-marriage to someone with children does not come without other significant downsides for a child.

The UK is very poor at supporting lone parents hence why child poverty is so high. This is a very short sighted strategy as it impacts a child's life, health, education outcomes and employment prospects through adulthood as has been proven through countless studies. As is so often the case in the UK, it is left to ''personal responsibility'' for people to ''do the right thing'' - contrary to popular political perception, people do not appear to do the right thing, instead when given the chance they will self serve.[/quote]
It was a question for the op I quoted really, although I appreciate your reply. I do know how it works because my daughter is a single parent. She is in the fortunate position of having a relatively high earning ex, but he would not pay a penny extra on top of what the CMS expect. He doesn't buy a stitch of clothing, doesn't pay towards extra curricular activities, birthday parties, shoes or anything else. He resents every penny that he has to send and tries to control how she spends it. That's the reality for many women.

Getyourarseofffthequattro · 24/02/2022 16:49

[quote Pinkyxx]**@Getyourarseofffthequattro* If she works based on her CMS payment to you it sounds like she earns NMW. If rather than being incapable of earning more she chooses* to do that because she knows your DP will put his hand in his pocket and pay then she's just as bad as the Fathers I'm referring to who pay next to nothing (discounting it for good measure). Her choices impact YOU and YOUR household. Back to my premise: neither the RP nor the NRP have any right to impact each other. It works both ways.

While this thread is about CMS and I'm talking about a single mum's position because they are overwhelming the RP in receipt of CMS, just like some Fathers are dicks so are some mothers. If you have been so unfortunate as to have to deal with the female equivalent of my ex husband in the form of your DPs ex-wife then you have every sympathy and commiserations for the shit she had no doubt caused in your life. If you want to start a thread about the crap 2nd families deal with dealing with exploitative ex spouses who get the house (mortgage paid), believe in ''pay per view'', cancel contact because Jonny has a sniffle and can't possible visit, send emails offensive texts / emails all day and night with the latest list of expenses / complaints, tell their DP's new partner to ''butt out'' when they discipline the child during contact (because god someone needs to), complain when the SM says she needs 72hrs post birth to recover from a c section so could we just move contact this once (dramatically suggesting the children will be permanently damaged by this selfish act), expect maternity leave to be ''free childcare for me months'' and generally do all they can to extort every drop of money they can out their ex spouse, I'll happily come along, bring a bottle of gin and fight your corner. This needs to change as well as it is wrong too. It shouldn't happen, it shouldn't be possible.

I used to have a friend who did that to her ex-spouse (she had an affair, he left heartbroken - still is). I am no longer friends with this person as I found her behavior to be repulsive and damaging to her children - and I told her as much. Ironically she found me offensive too.[/quote]
Thank you. I could start a thread, but there is no point. Mothers can do no wrong in most of mumsnet's eyes.

It is just frustrating for me that all father's are tarred with the same brush as arseholes like your ex. The system certainly needs an overhaul which stops any parent being an exploitative twat or avoiding paying for their children.

Pinkyxx · 24/02/2022 16:46

@Getyourarseofffthequattro If she works based on her CMS payment to you it sounds like she earns NMW. If rather than being incapable of earning more she chooses to do that because she knows your DP will put his hand in his pocket and pay then she's just as bad as the Fathers I'm referring to who pay next to nothing (discounting it for good measure). Her choices impact YOU and YOUR household. Back to my premise: neither the RP nor the NRP have any right to impact each other. It works both ways.

While this thread is about CMS and I'm talking about a single mum's position because they are overwhelming the RP in receipt of CMS, just like some Fathers are dicks so are some mothers. If you have been so unfortunate as to have to deal with the female equivalent of my ex husband in the form of your DPs ex-wife then you have every sympathy and commiserations for the shit she had no doubt caused in your life. If you want to start a thread about the crap 2nd families deal with dealing with exploitative ex spouses who get the house (mortgage paid), believe in ''pay per view'', cancel contact because Jonny has a sniffle and can't possible visit, send emails offensive texts / emails all day and night with the latest list of expenses / complaints, tell their DP's new partner to ''butt out'' when they discipline the child during contact (because god someone needs to), complain when the SM says she needs 72hrs post birth to recover from a c section so could we just move contact this once (dramatically suggesting the children will be permanently damaged by this selfish act), expect maternity leave to be ''free childcare for me months'' and generally do all they can to extort every drop of money they can out their ex spouse, I'll happily come along, bring a bottle of gin and fight your corner. This needs to change as well as it is wrong too. It shouldn't happen, it shouldn't be possible.

I used to have a friend who did that to her ex-spouse (she had an affair, he left heartbroken - still is). I am no longer friends with this person as I found her behavior to be repulsive and damaging to her children - and I told her as much. Ironically she found me offensive too.

QuirkyTurtle · 24/02/2022 16:27

I just don't agree. We provide a home with a bedroom for my stepson. His mother also provides a home with a bedroom. My partner is not responsible for paying her mortgage any more than she is responsible for paying mine. He already contributes 50% of costs of housing the child by having a house.

It's really simple in my eyes. In a nuclear family, if there is a second child the first child's resources are reduced. This doesn't change because the first child's parents couldn't make it work. Their resources are reduced because they now have a sibling. Unless their mother is struggling to put food on the table and living paycheck to paycheck, this is just a fact of life you need to accept. But as previously pointed out, the reduction for subsequent children is so low that it shouldn't make the difference between eating and not eating. If that is the case, you are not living within your means.

Getyourarseofffthequattro · 24/02/2022 16:21

[quote Pinkyxx]**@QuirkyTurtle* my arguments pertain to the OP and the details Quattro shared not Quattro's personal situation which she has only just clarified. I can't consider what I don't know... I don't actually agree with the RP in @Getyourarseofffthequattro* case paying what she did, however I maintain she must have very little income to be assessed to such a low payment. If the RP in Quattro's case simply won't work (hence lack of income) and thinks her former spouse should fund her life because she wants him to then that is just as bad as a NRP not supporting the RP. I also never said that an NRP said pay an RP's mortgage or rent, I said they should contribute to the cost of housing their child.

I think mothers should pay 50% and so should Fathers as I've stated many times. I don't think mothers should bear a disproportionate majority of the costs of raising a joint child which is the premise from which I am arguing. I do however recognize some Mothers may have limited earning capacity and or childcare responsibilities that prevent them earning sufficient to ever hope to cover 50% of the cost rely on the CMS for basic needs. This is especially where the NRP chooses to do very little parenting. That is what I am talking about. I find it offensive to suggest a father can leave their child with a mother who has no means to raise that child so this man can go off and get a new family. Children come before adults in my world. You are free to find my opinion offensive, and to take a different view however I will defend the rights of women left to care for children alone to expect support from ex partners for the children they leave behind.[/quote]
She works. Hth.

Pinkyxx · 24/02/2022 16:18

@QuirkyTurtle my arguments pertain to the OP and the details Quattro shared not Quattro's personal situation which she has only just clarified. I can't consider what I don't know... I don't actually agree with the RP in @Getyourarseofffthequattro case paying what she did, however I maintain she must have very little income to be assessed to such a low payment. If the RP in Quattro's case simply won't work (hence lack of income) and thinks her former spouse should fund her life because she wants him to then that is just as bad as a NRP not supporting the RP. I also never said that an NRP said pay an RP's mortgage or rent, I said they should contribute to the cost of housing their child.

I think mothers should pay 50% and so should Fathers as I've stated many times. I don't think mothers should bear a disproportionate majority of the costs of raising a joint child which is the premise from which I am arguing. I do however recognize some Mothers may have limited earning capacity and or childcare responsibilities that prevent them earning sufficient to ever hope to cover 50% of the cost rely on the CMS for basic needs. This is especially where the NRP chooses to do very little parenting. That is what I am talking about. I find it offensive to suggest a father can leave their child with a mother who has no means to raise that child so this man can go off and get a new family. Children come before adults in my world. You are free to find my opinion offensive, and to take a different view however I will defend the rights of women left to care for children alone to expect support from ex partners for the children they leave behind.

QuirkyTurtle · 24/02/2022 15:55

@Pinkyxx you are being incredibly offensive not only to the person you are arguing with on here, but to women everywhere.

Stop removing responsibility from mothers to step up and provide for their children after a separation. A NRP is not responsible for paying a RP's rent or mortgage, when they too have to provide a home for the child.

I think quattro has explained very very clearly that her circumstances more than warranted the CMS being reduced and if you can't see that, you are part of the problem.

Getyourarseofffthequattro · 24/02/2022 15:51

[quote Pinkyxx]@Getyourarseofffthequattro No I won't stop challenging your view that it is justified that first children receive less in order to allow 2nd families to have the children they want.

Please show me where have I said you shouldn't have had your child? I've stated it is every individual's right to have as many children as they want provided they do not neglect their existing financial commitments and responsibilities. I've also said that if that choice made your or your child's life difficult financially that is your responsibility to accept. You stated that you had never been so ''skint'' and then that your child missed out as justification for the reduction and to evidence the duress your household faced. I simply responded to your comments. I've said your decision to have a child took money away from the parent who supports that child. You have acknowledged this to be a fact repeatedly and defend that it is just to do so. I simply take a different view and find it bizarre you did not anticipate a reduced income might be problematic for the RP... most people struggle when their income is reduced. In any event, I can see you'd rather interpret in the way you have as it suits your narrative.

I've also not said you do not care about your step son, I don't know you but would assume you are loving and caring towards him?

If your DP pays for the extras you suggest then he is certainly doing a lot more than most - rightly so. I'm sorry you resent him supporting his first child, but it's what a decent Father does. Contact is the right of the child, therefore if she withheld it, I'm not sure why you didn't apply for to the courts for enforcement, the court fee would have perhaps been less expensive? That said, I am not sure how you can be the judge of the impact of the CMS reduction on the RP. It benefited you and impacted her - I would argue only she could elucidate as to the impact to her life and ability to care for your step son. The fact she was assessed to pay only £26 CMS suggests she has very limited income indeed therefore I would be surprised if the loss of the ''small %'' was not actually very difficult for her.[/quote]
Haha. So it's okay for her to pay a pittance because she's a low earner. But if a man paid that it would be pathetic etc and how could anyone expect to raise a child on it bla bla bla. But a woman paying it? That's absolutely fine.

I've had enough of engaging with you. You're so narrow minded it's embarrassing.

Pinkyxx · 24/02/2022 15:40

@Getyourarseofffthequattro No I won't stop challenging your view that it is justified that first children receive less in order to allow 2nd families to have the children they want.

Please show me where have I said you shouldn't have had your child? I've stated it is every individual's right to have as many children as they want provided they do not neglect their existing financial commitments and responsibilities. I've also said that if that choice made your or your child's life difficult financially that is your responsibility to accept. You stated that you had never been so ''skint'' and then that your child missed out as justification for the reduction and to evidence the duress your household faced. I simply responded to your comments. I've said your decision to have a child took money away from the parent who supports that child. You have acknowledged this to be a fact repeatedly and defend that it is just to do so. I simply take a different view and find it bizarre you did not anticipate a reduced income might be problematic for the RP... most people struggle when their income is reduced. In any event, I can see you'd rather interpret in the way you have as it suits your narrative.

I've also not said you do not care about your step son, I don't know you but would assume you are loving and caring towards him?

If your DP pays for the extras you suggest then he is certainly doing a lot more than most - rightly so. I'm sorry you resent him supporting his first child, but it's what a decent Father does. Contact is the right of the child, therefore if she withheld it, I'm not sure why you didn't apply for to the courts for enforcement, the court fee would have perhaps been less expensive? That said, I am not sure how you can be the judge of the impact of the CMS reduction on the RP. It benefited you and impacted her - I would argue only she could elucidate as to the impact to her life and ability to care for your step son. The fact she was assessed to pay only £26 CMS suggests she has very limited income indeed therefore I would be surprised if the loss of the ''small %'' was not actually very difficult for her.

Getyourarseofffthequattro · 24/02/2022 15:36

I'll re word that. She was abusive to us, and probably psychologically to her child, but not physically or neglectful. Social services couldn't care less!

Getyourarseofffthequattro · 24/02/2022 15:34

@ChiselandBits

Quattro if the RP in your case is that bad, why is she the RP? Why hasn't your DP gone for full residency? If the child is old enough to have a girlfriend he can choose who to live with. I think we are slightly at cross purposes here anyway as you are talking about over and above CMS causing problems. I am talking about someone being allowed to reduce the basic CMS due to future children. While I think the CMS rates are appalling and other things should be factored in, I agree that "extras" are going to have to be done case by case. If the RP in your case really wouldn't provide heat, clothes etc, you should have got SS involved and gone straight to court for contact if she was obstructive. Your situation is difficult but there are other answers than pulling funds from one to the other. And please don't take the comments about not having a child personally. We're talking about general principles here, and one off examples aren't really helpful in the context of the wider discussion about how CMS should be managed.
The child in question did live with us for a period of time. Unfortunately he got a girlfriend and we imposed rules. He therefore decided to move back in with his mother who thinks it's A-OK for him to sleep at his teenage girlfriend's house 5 to 6 nights a week. This worked for him, and as he is a teenager there is no point going to court because they will (rightly) support his wishes. It's a difficult situation and not one either of us are particularly happy about.

Social services don't care about broken boilers, btw. They don't care if you kick your child out if they've another loving home to go to. They don't care if your teenager sleeps at his girlfriend's house. She's not abusive, she's just lax. She has different priorities than me but nothing any authorities will do abything about, unfortunately. We tried. He did go through mediation and applied to court when she decided to grant regular access again. I don't know what else we were supposed to do. Clearly though, we are awful for reducing maintenance and shouldn't have had any more children.

I still think the reduction for other children is fine (not step) but also believe maintenance should be calculated differently, so...

ChiselandBits · 24/02/2022 15:29

Quattro if the RP in your case is that bad, why is she the RP? Why hasn't your DP gone for full residency? If the child is old enough to have a girlfriend he can choose who to live with. I think we are slightly at cross purposes here anyway as you are talking about over and above CMS causing problems. I am talking about someone being allowed to reduce the basic CMS due to future children. While I think the CMS rates are appalling and other things should be factored in, I agree that "extras" are going to have to be done case by case. If the RP in your case really wouldn't provide heat, clothes etc, you should have got SS involved and gone straight to court for contact if she was obstructive. Your situation is difficult but there are other answers than pulling funds from one to the other. And please don't take the comments about not having a child personally. We're talking about general principles here, and one off examples aren't really helpful in the context of the wider discussion about how CMS should be managed.

Getyourarseofffthequattro · 24/02/2022 15:20

@Pinkyxx

It's really not my fault that you can't understand. A child is not comparable to a mortgage.

No, my "new child" probably missed out so the all important first childs mother didn't have to buy him a single piece of uniform, or pay for rugby training, or in fact anything at all. So yes his payment went down by maybe a few pounds but in reality his mum didn't have to pay for anything extra.

@Getyourarseofffthequattro As I said before, you ought to have considered the affordability of another child before having one. If you reduced the CMS and your child still missed out then it is 2 children who have been disadvantaged by your choice.

Money is a finite resource. It can only stretch so far this is why responsible adults consider whether they have the income to still meet their existing commitments before taking on new commitments. A child is known to be a considerable expense. A child is exactly like a mortgage, you don't have 2 mortgages unless you can afford to pay both.

Your choice left the RP with less money to care for your DP's existing child so you claw back money to allocate to your household. Your DP's child already existed and was a commitment & responsibility that superseded adult wishes and which deserved to be factored into your decision. You choose to reduce the income available to the RP caring for that child. She had no say in the matter, your choice enforced that outcome on her. If you put your own child in that situation then that's on you & your DP. Not a choice I would make.

Can you please stop telling me I shouldn't have had my child? It's vile and offensive. My child is not currently missing out, but did miss out because of dps ex and her demands. Ie pay this or don't see your child. That's really not my fault and no, weirdly I didn't know that was going to happen when I decided to have a child. If you have a crystal ball please send me it.

His child was clearly factored in to the decision. Same as he was when we bought a house with a bedroom for him, moved closer to his school etc etc. You can make me out to be the big bad step mother who doesn't give a shit about him if you want, but you're talking utter bollocks. It's embarrassing. He lived with us as well can you bloody believe that! His own mother kicked him out but I suppose that's my fault too. And guess what! She paid us a whole £26 in maintenance! I suppose that's absolutely fine, though. Of course it cost us much less to look after him Hmm

i haven't put my child or anyone elses child in any kind of detrimental situation. I would appreciate it if you keep your frankly offensive, stupid and I'll informed opinions to yourself, unless you know the full situation, which clearly you don't.

Pinkyxx · 24/02/2022 15:14

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk guidelines.

Getyourarseofffthequattro · 24/02/2022 15:11

His CMS is whatever he gets told to pay. The extras are what make it expensive. His ex will not pay for uniform, school trips, clothes, nothing. So she feeds him (sometimes, he spends most of his time at his girlfriend's house. I suggested maybe we should pay her instead) and he uses water. She doesn't pay to keep him warm because their boiler doesn't work and she won't pay to fix it. He uses her electric when he's there. I would be very surprised if he actually costs her more than what dp pays. Her mortgage is tiny because for years (post split) dp paid that as well and took a very, very small think single digit percentage around half a decade after he left.

So forgive me if I am not crying into my cornflakes every morning because his ex and child are soooooo poor.