Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Child maintenance

467 replies

Lalala1 · 20/02/2022 14:35

Posting here for traffic!

The amount of threads on mn surrounding child maintenance I’ve noticed there’s completely opposite opinions on it.
Some find the way it’s calculated fair some don’t.
Some say it doesn’t cover everything and “certain things should be split” out with cms.
Some say people get too much because they only get lower and are “greedy ex wives” so they should be grateful.
Some say the rules around calculations are wrong and should be changed.

So I’m curious if you were in charge of cms what would/should it be?
How should it be calculated?
Should it cover everything or not?
How would it or could it be changed to be fair for all children?
Or
Is the way it is set up and conducted fine as it is?

Just putting this for vote

YABU- cms is fine as it is no change
YANBU - cms should be changed and how?

OP posts:
Girlmumdogmumboymum · 20/02/2022 21:02

I'd like to see 50% of the basic costs of raising a child become the norm...it'll never happen, but it would be great if it did

DrinkFeckArseBrick · 20/02/2022 20:46

It's a fairly fixed proportion of their salary irrespective of how much they were spending on their children before the split. So if someone had 3 kids under 3 and was paying their half of £3k a month nursery fees before the split, which was effectively all their disposable income, just so both parents could keep working. After the split just pays a third of their salary or whatever which is usually way way less than childcare. Meaning the resident parent has to give up work or find a cheaper alternative.

Wineoclockx · 20/02/2022 20:33

It’s a very complex issue because there are sooo many variables in lifestyles, types of pay etc. But I am definitely in agreement with PP’s who say the amount they pay should NOT be lowered if they have another child living in their household. My XH’s amount was lowered when he moved in with new GF and her daughter. But why should he be paying less for his own children who he decided, along with me, to bring into this world?? His own children did not get any extra from anyone else to make up the deficit because I have been single since he left 12 years ago, so it’s not like the deficit made up from somewhere else somehow. Where does the ethos come from for this? It can so easily be manipulated!!

ChiselandBits · 20/02/2022 19:55

I don't think you could realistically get anywhere with the pension thing - you want as little co-dependence between exes as possible - hence the vast majority of "clean break" divorces now, but paying half for childcare so the RP can work, yes.

Willyoujustbequiet · 20/02/2022 19:41

It should be a criminal offence to not pay. Loss of driving licence etc .like in other countries.

It should be a realistic amount not the pittance it currently is and if the resident parent can't work then the nrp should make a contribution to her pension.

RedCandyApple · 20/02/2022 19:12

I wish there was actually punishments for not paying; my ex paid nothing for 3 years and told me they wouldn’t investigate because he “could be living off a partner” he wasn’t. He then was ordered to pay £7 a week for 4 kids because he went on benefits which he still never paid.

Theunamedcat · 20/02/2022 19:09

It's literally 14% for one child 16% for two honestly even I could pay that out of wages and still afford to live if I didn't have to pay for child care kids food fuel and I could work proper hours none of this "around the children" malarkey I would be laughing

nancybotwinbloom · 20/02/2022 17:41

@LovelyLovelyWarmCoffee

- all income should count, so dividends, investments etc should be included
  • payment still goes down if the NRP has more DC but not for partner’s DC even if they move in together.
  • non payment is treated as unpaid tax, HMRC pays the amount due to the RP and collects it from the NRP with added fees. It could be automatically taken from salary for ex.
I wish this happened.
ChiselandBits · 20/02/2022 17:35

absolutely. The new partner may well lose some single parent benefits by choosing to co-habit but that is for them to decide and do the sums. If they want their new partner to make up the difference, he needs to be able to do that NOT at the expense of his existing children. I'm more on the fence about new biological children but overall feel that they should not allow a reduction for "new additions". The argument that if the original couple had had more the pot would be divided in smaller portions doesn't hold because they would have made that choice together. With a 2nd family, the the 1st wife gets no input in that decision and is faced with either making up the drop in CMS herself or explaining to the children why they have to stop their hobby / go without whatever. It's rarely the father that has to have that conversation or bear the brunt of the childrens' reaction. Most often, the RP goes without to make up the difference, so she ends up contributing to the "new" family. How can that possibly be right?

Pinkyxx · 20/02/2022 17:32

The RP & NRP should each bear 50% of the cost of raising joint children whatever that might be. The cost to a woman's career is huge when a single parent especially with eow, the RP is free to get progress their career with no childcare responsibility..

Definitely remove the discount for new girlfriend /wives children & new children they might have. In our case, ex & his wife's new kids have 2 parents paying for them. Her children with her ex have 3 parents paying for them despite them spending less than 50% of their time in ex's household... My child has just one + child maintenance (which doesn't even scratch the surface). They take 4 holidays a year... in 10 years I've never taken DD away as I simply can't afford it. I've paid all the childcare, every cost as Ex considers his heavily discounted payment to cover ''everything'' - he's literally never contributed a penny beyond on this.. when he pays that is. It doesn't feel reasonable that for a payment gets reduced so a man can support children that aren't his who have a father of their own and new children he chooses to have. Just like couples who remain together have to consider if they can afford another child, seems reasonable to expect in this situation to as well.

CMS also needs to consider all forms of income (not just salary), factor in housing, childcare, university costs etc - i.e. the real cost of raising a child. There seems to be an assumption that the wife got the house or is eligible for housing benefit. That isn't always the case, certainly isn't for me. I didn't get the house and I don't qualify for housing benefit. Clarity on what it covers and what parents should share the cost of would also help. Childcare is often the RP's problem and uni well.. no responsibility there either.

Mumofsend · 20/02/2022 17:28

I understand the need for the NRP to still be able to live as well as pay matinence. However it does give me the rage that if they move in with a woman who has children or they have new children it reduces the amount they have to pay by a good chunk.

That should be stopped as both are active choices.

Lalala1 · 20/02/2022 17:12

[quote arethereanyleftatall]@Lalala1
I'm not sure if you've not been round long but there really isn't opposite opinions on this. Yes, there is currently one thread going where the father does actually appear to be being reasonable but that is extremely unusual. Most, as evidenced by this thread, are appalled by how little the NRP frequently gets away with paying, or more accurately, not paying. [/quote]
I haven't been around mn for long granted but I've read through some past (years) posts and I've seen some people posting things like
" you get enough stop being greedy"
" well what do you expect him to do if they can't afford it"
" you shouldn't rely on cm"
And I'll probably get shot down in flames for this one but posts from current partners of NRPs complaining about their DH " having to pay more cm to their greedy ex and we are struggling"

I'm not saying most posters on mn are saying NRPs shouldn't pay. I started this thread as to see what would people change about the current cms so that it was fair for children but at the same time RPs wouldn't need to be saying their children don't get enough and NRPs wouldn't be saying they pay too much.

On various other sm sites there is different views around cms RPs not getting cm or enough cm from NRPs and then on the opposite end of the scale NRPs and sometimes their partners complaining that they pay too much.

Some people say cms is it and don't ask/ pay for anything else coz it's greedy and the some who say it's a minimum and other things like childcare/ school should be on top of cm.

Some mention that the ex now has a new partner so they aren't struggling yet some go nuts when the RP says the same.

There's lots of examples on MN of both sides so what would people change so there's no reason for RPs and NRPs to complain

OP posts:
LovelyLovelyWarmCoffee · 20/02/2022 16:58
  • all income should count, so dividends, investments etc should be included
  • payment still goes down if the NRP has more DC but not for partner’s DC even if they move in together.
  • non payment is treated as unpaid tax, HMRC pays the amount due to the RP and collects it from the NRP with added fees. It could be automatically taken from salary for ex.
Starlightstarbright1 · 20/02/2022 16:39

I get £7 a week but only probably a couple of years left anyway.

What i would like them to tackle is self employed/ and none payers.

I also disagree with the reduction for step children .. these children should be getting maintenence from their Dads.

The cms was supposed to be superior to csa.. it seems no better just has charges for setting up and collecting.

Theunamedcat · 20/02/2022 16:10

No reduction for living with other people's children why should they have three peoples income and other children get one and a fucking donation?

Fines for refusing to cooperate my ex has refused to declare his income since October they are only now going to hmrc why? What is the delay? Log in look up match the numbers bill him

You would get a lot more people hoping for 50/50 to avoid paying a measly 16% though which would lead to my other point if your going for 50/50 it should mean 50/50 no dropping them back to mum so you can work both parents paying for clothing childcare and leisure activities both parents being equally responsible for this financially and physically and a brand new government department who will deal with it can you imagine someone adding up appropriate monthly expenses for the child and billing the family each month everything extra split new school shoes paid for by parent a? Parent b gets a bill new uniform paid by parent b? Parent a gets a bill casual wear kept at the house wouldn't be included but needs like uniforms school food school trips split

arethereanyleftatall · 20/02/2022 16:06

@Lalala1
I'm not sure if you've not been round long but there really isn't opposite opinions on this. Yes, there is currently one thread going where the father does actually appear to be being reasonable but that is extremely unusual. Most, as evidenced by this thread, are appalled by how little the NRP frequently gets away with paying, or more accurately, not paying.

3peassuit · 20/02/2022 16:05

My grandchild’s father has only just started paying maintenance. He was able to own a house in central London, change his car annually and take twice yearly long haul holidays with no apparent source of income for 4 years. Assets should be assessed for maintenance and lifestyle incompatible with income ought to be investigated.

Rainbowqueeen · 20/02/2022 16:03

There should be links between the various government departments to assist CMS in collecting. Turn up at the airport to fly abroad and your passport scan reveals arrears? Can’t go until they are cleared.

Car rego office shows purchase of new vehicle all whilst you say you have no income for the year? Automatic tax audit

No deduction in amount payable for moving in with someone with kids
Any self employed person with cms claim against them is audited by tax office.

Claims are never cancelled or arrears wiped. They are a debt against the estate of the non payer and go to their ex partner or their child

Any 50-50 order in court states that this includes costs of clothing, clubs, etc and is enforced.

FatFredsFriedEgg · 20/02/2022 15:55

@newbiename

It should be socially unacceptable to not pay. Take passports off them. I never had a penny.
It should be impossible not to pay. We have a functional tax system and it could be collected through adjustments to tax codes.
ChiselandBits · 20/02/2022 15:55

its ok raisin - yes there are instances of female absent parents but the statistics massively bear out the FACT that the vast majority of NRPS are male and the millions, owed in unpaid maintenance is overwhelming owed by men. And no, this is not because all "crazy, bitter ex wives" deny access or restrict contact. I would LOVE my ex to do 50/50 and never take a penny from him, but he doesn't want it and nor do the vast majority of the exes I know from my single mum friends. Not one of them is saying "no, you can't have the kids more, I don't need a break, I'm fine doing 26/30 days without a break". In the cases where they the exes have taken up more contact, its lasted a month or two and then reverted as the NRP "is busy" "has an extra shift" "is entitled to a life", or they are asked to buy new shoes, or sort a haircut or a brownie uniform and fuck it up, or forget and the RP has to swing in with an emergency fix. So lets please not have this thread descend into "but what about...." CMS is shit in SO SO many ways. That really can't be argued with. The real question is which party / MP or prospective MP is going to have the guts to really stand up on this? At present, none, because the status quo suits the (male) power base in all parties far too well.

newbiename · 20/02/2022 15:52

It should be socially unacceptable to not pay. Take passports off them. I never had a penny.

maiafawnly · 20/02/2022 15:49

Cms should be forcible and have consequences for non-payment. My ex would wait til calculations were done, till they were just about to start collection from his pay, then quit that job and move on. It would take 6 months for cms to act on this, recalculate arrange collection, he would change jobs again. Regardless of how it is calculated, first and foremost they should be made to pay and contribute. I have 3 children, planned children, from a marriage, that I left in 2014, he stopped contact in 2015, I've never received anything from cms. At all. I have to work my socks off to provide everything they need and want 100% of the time and the current system doesn't see this as an issue. That needs rectifying more than amounts. IMO

Raisinsun · 20/02/2022 15:42

I think that the rates are too low and unrealistic especially with the rising cost of living. I get aeasley 40 a month (albiet more than most may get) how can they seriously say kids cost 40 a month? I think if a partner is with you through conception, pregnancy and birth there should be some sort of legal document that you too planned qnd agreed to this pregnancy so things should be split 50/50. I wouldnt mind 40 if he even seen his child but he doesnt at all. Furthermore i know he now has a new better paid job and hasnt declared that so hoping for a rebate when the yearly review comes round (that too needs sped up). Perhaps parents could submit receipts or the government looks at the average monthly cost of raising a child ans they have to pay a percentage of that. A fair one at that why does the mother often get stuck raising the child alone the dad can walk away scott free and get away with 40£ a month how is that fair? I have every tear, every sick day, everyday off work when hes ill, every tantrum, every activity, everything. This should be taken into account. You would never see the benefit system handing unemployed 40 a month to live on so how is that enough to feed, cloth, heat, nurture a child on? Apologies aswell to the single dads out there im not saying its always the mum who has the main caring responsibility.

Momijin · 20/02/2022 15:37

@FatFredsFriedEgg yes. At the moment the way it works is that he gets to splash out on the kids. His brother is disgusted by him because he can afford it and she is a good mother and was a good partner to him - I think in the future her kids will realise just what a shit he is and it'll come back to bite him. During their relationship (and part of the reason of their breakup) he was very much he earns the money so it is his. He said he paid her every month when in fact he only paid her just enough to cover food and essentials. He didn't understand that he wasn't paying her, he was covering costs and that the only reason he could earn the money he did was because she covered everything else. He now does 50/50 but that's because the older ones essentially babysit when he works and leaves them to fend for themselves.

ChocolateMassacre · 20/02/2022 15:36

@ChiselandBits

oh and there should be a mandatory minimum (not the £7 p/w it currently is for NRPs on benefits, or £0 if they are staying at home caring for step kids or second family kids), paid by the state to the RP and racked up as a debt to the NRP which is enforced the same way that HMRC chase tax owing.
I agree with this. There should be a minimum payment of £300 per month per child. If the NRP cannot afford to pay this from their income, it should either be -
  • taken out of their assets (so added as a charge on their mortgage, taken from savings etc.), or
  • paid by the state and deducted from the NRP's state pension when they reach retirement age.

It should not be possible for one parent to float through life without making a decent contribution to the financial upkeep of their child/ren. £7 per week just doesn't cut in, no matter what the NRP's circumstances are.

Furthermore, the percentages should be much higher and NRPs should be on the hook for half of childcare costs if the RP has to use childcare to work.