Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Child maintenance

467 replies

Lalala1 · 20/02/2022 14:35

Posting here for traffic!

The amount of threads on mn surrounding child maintenance I’ve noticed there’s completely opposite opinions on it.
Some find the way it’s calculated fair some don’t.
Some say it doesn’t cover everything and “certain things should be split” out with cms.
Some say people get too much because they only get lower and are “greedy ex wives” so they should be grateful.
Some say the rules around calculations are wrong and should be changed.

So I’m curious if you were in charge of cms what would/should it be?
How should it be calculated?
Should it cover everything or not?
How would it or could it be changed to be fair for all children?
Or
Is the way it is set up and conducted fine as it is?

Just putting this for vote

YABU- cms is fine as it is no change
YANBU - cms should be changed and how?

OP posts:
DifficultBloodyWoman · 21/02/2022 04:18

First, we need a realistic assessment of what it costs to raise a child.

Then, recognition that it doesn’t change even if NRP is living with other step children or subsequent children.

Both parents need to contribute equally to the absolute basics of raising a child. That means food, clothing, shelter, and childcare where applicable.

People who do not support their children should be stigmatised. I have no objection to using the phrase deadbeat dad (or mum) when appropriate.

If people are on UC, they still need to pay 50% of their child’s basic costs. No exceptions! That may require a review of UC elements, for example, adding a parenting payment alongside housing or PIP.

And enforcement. It should be a criminal offence to not support your children. Loss of passport or driving licence as in other countries, right up to jail time.

It should be a debt that doesn’t die and remain payable through bankruptcy, no matter how old the children get.

Meh2020 · 21/02/2022 02:03
  • no reduction if the NRP has more children or moves in with other children
  • inclusion of what it costs the resident parent to house the children (I say this as a person who lives in London)
  • inclusion of school uniform, school lunches and nursery/wrap around care
  • inclusion of cost of university so that the children are able to continue their education without major disruption.

I can’t help feeling that children are not at the heart of the current way CM is calculated. I’ve suffered much financial hardship (despite me working full time in a fairly well paid job) due to a unique set of circumstances that in no way are taken into account as ‘he pays what the CMS calculator says’.

Labracadabradoodle · 21/02/2022 01:40

Never received a penny. Raised 3 on one wage and my kids have grown up being proud of who we are as a family.
It's been hard though.

TheresSomebodyAtTheDoorNeil · 21/02/2022 01:37

My friend won't take any money off her ex as thanks to covid he's currently earning less than £200 a week. He's barely had any work, she knows what it's like as they work in the same industry but she's been lucky to find work elsewhere.

He pulls his weight in other ways tho and as he's hardly in work these days does all the childcare.
I think id do the same if my ex and I were to split and he found himself in a crap situation but if they can pay they absolutely should do.

BobMortimersPetOwl · 21/02/2022 01:29

I don't think partners should factor into it at all, likewise step children. I do think biological children should be considered though because I don't think it would be right to say 1 child should take priority over another.

Lalala1 · 21/02/2022 01:06

@AlmostAJillSandwich

What about when a NRP suffers a long term illness or disability after having the child resulting in complete inability to work, assesed to get minimal benefits (just standard UC of £324 a month, no housing element due to who they are staying with owning outright)? Barely scraping by on the essentials to live, with literally nowhere they can cut costs to make any contribution, and no foreseeable changes in circumstance on the horizon?

I appreciate these circumstances will be the minority, but (as is the case with a friend of mine) it does happen. He has to pay for his room, food, towards utilities etc and is counting pennies every month with no luxuries what so ever. He adores his DC and wishes he could contribute, but as the saying goes, you can't get blood from a stone, and he has no viable options to generate any extra income, nothing to sell etc.

A lot of RP are barely scraping by on the essentials to live also but they still need to feed their children, they are still financially responsible for the children they don’t just say “can’t get blood from a stone” they still pay all the things your friend pays and a lot of them don’t have “luxuries” either. A NRP has the same responsibility even if they are on benefits( health related or not) so your friend should be paying his £7 a week contribution which quite frankly is the most ridiculous cms amount there is and one thing that really needs changing with the system!
OP posts:
sofakingcool · 21/02/2022 00:44

@IstayedForTheFeminism

Like others have said the reduction when the NRP moves in with step DC/has more DC is unfair.

When my ex moved in with his now wife and her 2 DC my maintenance reduced. I then found out he had moved back out of her place and into a flat as she lost benefits when he moved in. I told the CMS and they said it was my job to prove it. The messages i sent apparently didn't count so the reduction remained. Surely the gov can cross reference and see that she was claiming as a single parent and he was paying bills elsewhere.
He moved back on with her and they went on to have more dc. He quit his job because she apparently couldn't cope with so many dc Hmm. He hasn't paid a penny in 8 years. He's working again now. And one again the CMS have asked me for evidence. Her income is irrelevant (not that she has any, but hypothetically speaking) when assessing maintenence.

OTOH when I had a partner living with me we had to decide before he moved in if he could and would cover my loss of benefits and therfore effectively pay towards my dc.

That's slightly unfair. Exes new DP has no responsibility towards my dc. My new DP did.

Agree very much with your last point. My DS is off to Uni later this year, he will get minimal loan due to his step dads wage, yet when his Dad was married, his wife's income meant nothing - not that I would have wanted it, but I don't get the double standards
IstayedForTheFeminism · 21/02/2022 00:32

Like others have said the reduction when the NRP moves in with step DC/has more DC is unfair.

When my ex moved in with his now wife and her 2 DC my maintenance reduced. I then found out he had moved back out of her place and into a flat as she lost benefits when he moved in. I told the CMS and they said it was my job to prove it. The messages i sent apparently didn't count so the reduction remained. Surely the gov can cross reference and see that she was claiming as a single parent and he was paying bills elsewhere.
He moved back on with her and they went on to have more dc. He quit his job because she apparently couldn't cope with so many dc Hmm. He hasn't paid a penny in 8 years. He's working again now. And one again the CMS have asked me for evidence. Her income is irrelevant (not that she has any, but hypothetically speaking) when assessing maintenence.

OTOH when I had a partner living with me we had to decide before he moved in if he could and would cover my loss of benefits and therfore effectively pay towards my dc.

That's slightly unfair. Exes new DP has no responsibility towards my dc. My new DP did.

sofakingcool · 21/02/2022 00:21

My biggest gripe is that the NRP can go on and have more children elsewhere, thus reducing maintenance to his other children.

Made even worse when they move in with someone else - so suddenly that child has its parents plus step parent supporting them, yet previous children don't get as much? What is that all about?

I remember many years ago a work mate rubbing her hands together that her "darling" husband didn't need to pay as much maintenance to his first born as they'd just had a baby together and also had her first born living with her. Suffice to say, she didn't bring it up in front of me again...

Willyoujustbequiet · 21/02/2022 00:21

@AlmostAJillSandwich

If he has a disability he's entitled to the disability element of UC (£343) and anything up to £600 with PIP so that's almost an extra £1000 potentially.

Children can't just not eat regardless of NRP circumstances.

sofakingcool · 21/02/2022 00:17

@ABCeasyasdohrayme

One of my irritations with it is that ex gets a hefty discount because his girlfriends kids live there so essentially they have 3 people paying towards them.

He also cut his hours at work to look after them so his girlfriend works full time now.

If they allow maintenence to be influenced by household decisions then household income needs to be taken into account.

Either new partners are responsible for stepkids or they aren't, but CMS just cherry picks what's better for NRP.

He sounds like a right peach @ABCeasyasdohrayme
Finallylostit · 20/02/2022 23:58

Poll4 - I am a high earning RP - no intention of "squeezing" anything out of the NRP but they are his children and he has to contribute commensurate to what he can afford. Clothes still need buying, food still needs buying - the RP subsidise the NRPs lifestyle by doing all the providing - we divorced for a reason not for me to pay for his new lifestyle

Non payment is not an option- he is their bloody father.

Poll4 · 20/02/2022 23:00
  • it shouldn't be reduced if you move in with step children.
  • I'm on the fence about it being reduced if you have more biological children. In most families the available pot goes down when more children are born, I don't think it's that unusual. BUT that wouldn't be so much of an issue if it wasn't a pittance most of the time as it is.
  • non payers should be made to pay in some way.
  • controversial opinion but in the case (and I know it's not super common) where you have a very well earning RP and a low earning NRP I don't always agree that they should be forced to pay out of principal. People often say it's about maintaining lifestyle over both homes when you have a high earning NRP but that's never the tune when it's a high earning RP. Not to say they shouldn't pay anything but I don't see the point in a RP on 100k for example squeezing what they can from a minimum wage NRP just because. Personally in that situation I'd rather my child's other parent spent the money on the kids when they were there.
Piggyk2 · 20/02/2022 22:40

Once you register your child at birth and your not with the father I think CMS forms should be given out and filled in on the same day.
It's about time CMS was deducted off of the paying party's wages.

It's complex though because people have children... don't look after them and then go and start a new family! It's a vicous cycle.

Orangello · 20/02/2022 22:35

Oh and yes of course your new partner's children should not mean that you can pay less for your own. Why would it, you're not financially responsible for their costs.

Pleasebeafleabite · 20/02/2022 22:35

I love some of these ideas.

I think there should be an additional percentage of tax on earnings from both parents to go into one account. Money comes out of that account to pay for childcare thus enabling both parents to work; the rest is split pro rata by night spent with each parent.

I find it inexplicable that student loans can be deducted under PAYE but not CM

AlmostAJillSandwich · 20/02/2022 22:34

What about when a NRP suffers a long term illness or disability after having the child resulting in complete inability to work, assesed to get minimal benefits (just standard UC of £324 a month, no housing element due to who they are staying with owning outright)? Barely scraping by on the essentials to live, with literally nowhere they can cut costs to make any contribution, and no foreseeable changes in circumstance on the horizon?

I appreciate these circumstances will be the minority, but (as is the case with a friend of mine) it does happen. He has to pay for his room, food, towards utilities etc and is counting pennies every month with no luxuries what so ever. He adores his DC and wishes he could contribute, but as the saying goes, you can't get blood from a stone, and he has no viable options to generate any extra income, nothing to sell etc.

Orangello · 20/02/2022 22:16

In my home country, the system is not ideal. But there's a minimum amount you have to pay that in theory should be sufficient to cover the basic needs of the child, there's no 5 quid per week type of joke payments.
If you don't pay, bailiffs will absolutely go after your assets. You can't just claim you have no salary and that's it.
And not only can you lose your driver's license and other permits, non-payment of maintenance when you were financially able to, is a crime.

Finallylostit · 20/02/2022 22:15

I have paid extortionate amounts in child care / holiday clubs etc which would have been at least half if he had done his share of child care as he did before he left.

I paid childcare so I could keep working and make sure the DCs were cared for

Lets not start on clothes - whihc seem to disappear all the time.

Sports lcubs on sports he wanted them to do.

No his paymens did not cover a fraction of that.

on100K plus per annum

MaryPoppinPills · 20/02/2022 21:43

Stop reducing payments if they move in with someone who has kids
My ex moved in with a women who has kids. My payment got reduced. Why should she technically have 3 people supporting her child (her, her kids dad maintenence payment and my ex) and my child get a reduced amount. I don't understand the reasoning behind it.

comfortablyfrumpy · 20/02/2022 21:32

@Dithercats

Reducing CM if you live with another woman with children - or if you have another child should be stopped. Men should pay for their children regardless of who they go on to be with.
This entirely.
Theunamedcat · 20/02/2022 21:30

So they should close the loopholes

No discount for living with someone who has children

Lifestyle looked at when they are "self employed"

Wages before deductions dividend taken into account

Actual real punishment for non payment

I have ideas

Cars clamped for non payment the clamp should read non payment of child support in big letters

Adverts in national newspapers a weekly round up of persistent non payers

Licence loss

Passport loss

RetireReady · 20/02/2022 21:26

And the bullshit of reducing payments if you are shacked up with someone

RetireReady · 20/02/2022 21:24

CM should be calculated before salary sacrifice to stop people using this as a means to reduce their payments

ChiselandBits · 20/02/2022 21:12

but you can't quantify basic costs. There are far too many variables.