Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Child maintenance

467 replies

Lalala1 · 20/02/2022 14:35

Posting here for traffic!

The amount of threads on mn surrounding child maintenance I’ve noticed there’s completely opposite opinions on it.
Some find the way it’s calculated fair some don’t.
Some say it doesn’t cover everything and “certain things should be split” out with cms.
Some say people get too much because they only get lower and are “greedy ex wives” so they should be grateful.
Some say the rules around calculations are wrong and should be changed.

So I’m curious if you were in charge of cms what would/should it be?
How should it be calculated?
Should it cover everything or not?
How would it or could it be changed to be fair for all children?
Or
Is the way it is set up and conducted fine as it is?

Just putting this for vote

YABU- cms is fine as it is no change
YANBU - cms should be changed and how?

OP posts:
ChiselandBits · 21/02/2022 11:37

But the reality is that many. Nrps simply won't contribute to these major expenses and don't have to cope with the fall out of the trip not happening or stopping the hobby or whatever. My ex is refusing o contribute even anything to a trip my DS whole year group is going on, let alone 50%. He sees them less than eow and simply doesn't get what it would mean for him not to go. So I will find it, on credit cards, because I have to.
I disagree that payments should be reduced for subsequent children. In together couples, a further child and its impact on finances for child 1 would be a joint decision. An NRP is perfectly entitled to increase his progeny with a new partner but not at the expense of the first one(S) and the ex who in practice, ends up making up the difference and effectively subsidising the new child. The new child has access to 84% or so of his parent's income, and gets to live with them 100%. The first gets maybe 4 days a month and 16%. I know which one is 'worth less'.

Glitterygreen · 21/02/2022 11:34

The NRP needs to be looming at their finances, including the amount of child support and deciding if they can afford another child based in that

There's no point comparing it to separated parents because if they were together they would make that decision together, if they are apart its the NRP deciding to have another child and the RP taking the financial hit

Even worse when the RP takes the hit for someone else's kids.

This will never work though because it applies both ways.

Lots of RPs go on to have further children and then obviously the NRP's child support will get used on new children too. Even though they are not theirs and the NRP could argue in the same way that their children are losing out due to the RP's decision to have more children and stretch the money further.

People can never be allowed to dictate their ex's life due to money.

Glitterygreen · 21/02/2022 11:29

Tbh although it clearly has issues, I can't really think of a better way to do it than based on a percentage of the NRP's income and based on time spent with the children, as it is now.

It has to take into account that NRPs need to maintain a separate household and also need to spend on the children when they are with them.

I also think it's fair for it to be based on paying for 50% of essentials and not on additional costs like school trips, hobbies etc as these would be optional even if the family were together. Ideally the parents would discuss these and agree on whether to do them, and then split the cost.

ABCeasyasdohrayme · 21/02/2022 11:13

@AndAsIfByMagic

I'm appalled at the number of people saying it shouldn't be reduced if the NRP has another child. In a non-broken family adjustments are made when another child is born and the same should apply in that case.

To say an innocent child is less entitled to support than its sibling is vile.

The NRP needs to be looming at their finances, including the amount of child support and deciding if they can afford another child based in that

There's no point comparing it to separated parents because if they were together they would make that decision together, if they are apart its the NRP deciding to have another child and the RP taking the financial hit

Even worse when the RP takes the hit for someone else's kids.

Finallylostit · 21/02/2022 11:11

Andasifbymagic - the new DC is not less worth - they benefit from between 88 and 84% of the NRPs income. Hardly less worthy. Even if you calculated the days - EOW and one ON per week - then the previous children still benefit considerably less from the NRP than the new child.

sofakingcool · 21/02/2022 11:07

@AndAsIfByMagic

I'm appalled at the number of people saying it shouldn't be reduced if the NRP has another child. In a non-broken family adjustments are made when another child is born and the same should apply in that case.

To say an innocent child is less entitled to support than its sibling is vile.

It's absolutely vile to have one child being given less than another, but I'd like to see something put in place to stop NRP from just moving on and having more babies, that they can't afford, whilst turning a blind eye to their older children.

My ex didn't give a shiny shit that by moving in with a woman with her own child, and having 2 subsequent children with her, that it meant he couldn't afford to support DS. He couldn't have cared less. Simply shrugged his shoulders at me.

Poll4 · 21/02/2022 10:41

I may be wrong but i certainly meant when another partners children are used to reduce cms. Not natural children to the nrp..

Yes this is totally wrong. A new partners children shouldn't reduce maintenance but I don't think it's so abhorrent that new biological children would potentially reduce it. Depending on circumstances.

Poll4 · 21/02/2022 10:40

@AndAsIfByMagic

I'm appalled at the number of people saying it shouldn't be reduced if the NRP has another child. In a non-broken family adjustments are made when another child is born and the same should apply in that case.

To say an innocent child is less entitled to support than its sibling is vile.

This is why I'm on the fence about it.

In a nuclear family, there would be less money to go around each child when you have more. It's not uncommon in fact it's totally normal. Obviously with CMS it can be a piss poor contribution anyway so when that's further reduced it's a further piss take. But in general, money needs to go further when you have more children which may mean you have slightly less to spend on each of the children but all should be equal. A new child shouldn't go without so an older sibling can keep getting designer clothes and expensive holidays for example, however the basics shouldn't change.

I know people who argue against this will say the RP doesn't have a say over whether their ex goes onto have more children so it's not fair to reduce the contribution. Unfortunately that's the same with lots of things in separation. We don't have any control over our exes and what they do once you start co parenting as a separated couple.

Starlightstarbright1 · 21/02/2022 10:38

@AndAsIfByMagic

I'm appalled at the number of people saying it shouldn't be reduced if the NRP has another child. In a non-broken family adjustments are made when another child is born and the same should apply in that case.

To say an innocent child is less entitled to support than its sibling is vile.

I may be wrong but i certainly meant when another partners children are used to reduce cms. Not natural children to the nrp.. New partners children should be claiming their own cms
AndAsIfByMagic · 21/02/2022 10:34

I'm appalled at the number of people saying it shouldn't be reduced if the NRP has another child. In a non-broken family adjustments are made when another child is born and the same should apply in that case.

To say an innocent child is less entitled to support than its sibling is vile.

hazelnutpraline · 21/02/2022 10:21

@Shostaklovhich that has been my experience too

Shostaklovhich · 21/02/2022 10:15

I would say the cms desperately need to train their staff better. The number of times I’ve phoned up and spoken to different people who say completely different things. Spent an hour once trying to explain to someone that my XH did not need to be repaid any money that he had “overpaid” because the amount of money referred to was simply in a letter but never initially paid by my XH. Suddenly after trying to explain in so many different ways, the member of staff just went quiet…. the penny had dropped! It was a hallelujah moment I can tell you!
And another thing is that every time there is a minor change in amount to be paid, like 30p, they send out a new letter with a thick pamphlet of info. I received 8 of these letters in as many weeks recently, which given that my XH now only pays £20 per month is a little overkill I would say.

cherryonthecakes · 21/02/2022 09:28

There's loads wrong with CM

I think that for cases where the CMS is used, the government paying the CM and chasing the NRP would end up with more revenue collected. They could use the infrastructure that chases people for VAT. There are people owed 5 figure sums which is unacceptable. The government should have paid the resident parent and chased the NRP.

There needs to be more cross referencing. If a NRP claims to earn £150pw, then that's the figure that should be seen when the NRP applies for a credit card or mortgage. Non payment if CM should appear on a credit report

If a NRP moves in with someone with kids he shouldn't get his CM reduced. If they have another child, his CM shouldn't be reduced. If that relationship breaks up then CM should be payable. The current rules around this are as ridiculous as the RP getting more maintenance when they have a child with a new partner.

hazelnutpraline · 21/02/2022 09:19

@ChiselandBits absolutely agree with you

RedCandyApple · 21/02/2022 09:14

@AlmostAJillSandwich

What about when a NRP suffers a long term illness or disability after having the child resulting in complete inability to work, assesed to get minimal benefits (just standard UC of £324 a month, no housing element due to who they are staying with owning outright)? Barely scraping by on the essentials to live, with literally nowhere they can cut costs to make any contribution, and no foreseeable changes in circumstance on the horizon?

I appreciate these circumstances will be the minority, but (as is the case with a friend of mine) it does happen. He has to pay for his room, food, towards utilities etc and is counting pennies every month with no luxuries what so ever. He adores his DC and wishes he could contribute, but as the saying goes, you can't get blood from a stone, and he has no viable options to generate any extra income, nothing to sell etc.

That’s like my ex, he’s been on disability benefits for 5 years, not worked in the 5 years since we split up as he gets pip etc... only he has a 3 bedroom house that he rents out to 3 lodgers so certainly isn’t struggling financially but I don’t see any of it as it’s all cash in hand... so on the outside people would feel sorry for him being on pip and not being able to afford to pay but I know the truth.
ChiselandBits · 21/02/2022 09:12

I've said ti's on other threads and it's been mentioned here too but I absolutely cannot understand why the cms simply isn't rolled into a dept of hmrc. Shared computer systems, shared info, deduced at source or added onto tax bill if not paye. In the latter case, hmrc can pay the RP what is due and reclaim it. And yes the rates should be higher. My ex pays what many would consider be a good amount but it still doesn't touch the sides of their actual cost and if you add in the additional loss of earnings / pension that I take in order to be a present parent (I do work full time but don't go for promotions etc) then that's even more true.

Wannakisstheteacher · 21/02/2022 09:09

Reducing CM because you shacked up with someone else and THEIR children should be illegal.

Internetio · 21/02/2022 09:08

threat of jail would probably be the only way to get my alcoholic ex to pay up... the loss of alcohol would prompt some action!

hazelnutpraline · 21/02/2022 09:06

The CMS staff need to be better trained and actually communicate with each other as every time I speak to someone they tell me something different to the last person and 80% of the time it’s completely wrong. Also non payment should be treated as a crime. Try not paying council tax and see what happens! Whereas I’m owed thousands despite the fact that my dc’s father has been working the whole time and buying cars and holidays, and the CMS have done absolutely nothing. to be completely fair sometimes they have not legally been able to do anything so the law needs to be changed.

Orangello · 21/02/2022 09:06

The amounts are ridiculous. 7 quid, what's the point even? Does that mean the resident parent should contribute equally and you can somehow house, clothe, feed a child for 14 pounds per week? Magic!

Sicario · 21/02/2022 09:00

I never received a penny from my exH and worked myself into the ground raising the kids alone. He now has 6 properties and has been living the life of riley. There was nothing I could do about it.

AllOfUsAreDead · 21/02/2022 08:54

Just had a look at the percentages they have to pay, 12%?! I'd make it 30. Kids cost a lot, just because one side has fucked off doesn't mean they suddenly cost less.

And yeah close all the stupid loopholes and actually send the pricks who don't pay to prison. Don't want to pay? Fine can ruin your life, no problem.

Poll4 · 21/02/2022 08:51

@Piggyk2 that's fine, you don't have to agree.

Orangello · 21/02/2022 08:28

I told the CMS and they said it was my job to prove it.

Sounds like CMS is not fit for purpose. In my home country, the child support payments (if not paid voluntarily) go through bailiffs, who get paid a percentage - their fee is paid by the non-resident parent. So of course it's in the interest of bailiffs to get the money and they will do the legwork to find out if the debtor is working or if their lifestyle does not match the poverty they claim.

Piggyk2 · 21/02/2022 06:39

@Poll4

- it shouldn't be reduced if you move in with step children.
  • I'm on the fence about it being reduced if you have more biological children. In most families the available pot goes down when more children are born, I don't think it's that unusual. BUT that wouldn't be so much of an issue if it wasn't a pittance most of the time as it is.
  • non payers should be made to pay in some way.
  • controversial opinion but in the case (and I know it's not super common) where you have a very well earning RP and a low earning NRP I don't always agree that they should be forced to pay out of principal. People often say it's about maintaining lifestyle over both homes when you have a high earning NRP but that's never the tune when it's a high earning RP. Not to say they shouldn't pay anything but I don't see the point in a RP on 100k for example squeezing what they can from a minimum wage NRP just because. Personally in that situation I'd rather my child's other parent spent the money on the kids when they were there.
Ohh I don't agree with this. Someone could be on min wage.. but come from a supportive family ie grandparents who have a good input. Perhaps the NRP lives in a mortgaged house on a min wage.

I've read through a lot of comments and the issue is. Is your willing to create a new family with someone else..... that's your tough luck! This should be a consideration before you go on to further more kids.

I have one DC. It is my choice and I would be bloody well Pissed off if my ex went on to have other children and told me he would have to reduce his payments.