Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Child maintenance

467 replies

Lalala1 · 20/02/2022 14:35

Posting here for traffic!

The amount of threads on mn surrounding child maintenance I’ve noticed there’s completely opposite opinions on it.
Some find the way it’s calculated fair some don’t.
Some say it doesn’t cover everything and “certain things should be split” out with cms.
Some say people get too much because they only get lower and are “greedy ex wives” so they should be grateful.
Some say the rules around calculations are wrong and should be changed.

So I’m curious if you were in charge of cms what would/should it be?
How should it be calculated?
Should it cover everything or not?
How would it or could it be changed to be fair for all children?
Or
Is the way it is set up and conducted fine as it is?

Just putting this for vote

YABU- cms is fine as it is no change
YANBU - cms should be changed and how?

OP posts:
Lalala1 · 21/02/2022 12:38

@RedCandyApple

Can I just point out that not all NRP see their children, mine chooses not to see our kids at all and doesn’t want to so not all are providing for the children in their time if they don’t actually see the child at all.
Thats the case with a lot of NRPs they “choose” not to see their children but say the RP is stopping contact so shouldn't have to pay. Even parents with 50/50 court ordered contact people say there shouldn’t be any cms due either way but I think that’s only fair if it genuinely is 50/50 financially. There’s a lot of NRPs with 50/50 that don’t contribute to anything yet there’s still expenses out with that 50/50 that more often than not RPs need to provide. I know RPs who still pay childcare and school lunch money on days NRP has contact yet NRP says “but I don’t need to pay anything cms says”
OP posts:
Finallylostit · 21/02/2022 12:26

The cry is always NRP has to have a house to accommodate the children and this costs but so often on mumsnet - we here that the SDCs are on blow up mattresses, sleeping in the lounge etc etc, spare room is now an office for wfh.

The majority do not provide their DCs with the same as at their main home and this is deemed acceptable because half the time - they can not be arsed to have their DCS more - so they just let it slide.

Jayne35 · 21/02/2022 12:18

A lot of these issues would disappear if a sensible minimum amount was set for CM. Say £300-£400 per month. Non-negotiable and if the NRP can't/won't pay, the state pays for them and defers their state pension.

I couldn't have afforded the above, I paid around £160 per month - I'm not a high earner though. I still had a child at home while my DS moved in with my ex (I got £5 per week for DD as ex was unemployed!)

RedCandyApple · 21/02/2022 12:15

Can I just point out that not all NRP see their children, mine chooses not to see our kids at all and doesn’t want to so not all are providing for the children in their time if they don’t actually see the child at all.

ChocolateMassacre · 21/02/2022 12:14

But why would the NRP need to pay someone for 24/7 care for their child? The NRP also looks after the child and the RP is the parent too.

Clearly if NRP and RP were doing 50/50 care, no one should be paying anything.

Qwertyyui · 21/02/2022 12:11

My issue with it is when the RP refuses to allow 50/50 I think the NRP shouldn't have to cover costs when they actively want the child/children more. 50/50 should be the expected standard and if the NRP doesn't want this then they pay. I also think men who actively don't want a baby should prevent it however there are some (not all) women who lie about birth control. If they want the baby the should shoulder the cost. I don't take CM from my dds dad because I don't need it. I want him to have a secure home and money to spend on her when he has her. I think all incomes need to be looked at as a nrp can earn remarkably less than the RP but still can be skinted by the cost. A NRP still needs the standard of living the RP has. They need additional rooms the children. They have bills etc. I think everyone's should be assessed individually. I agree non payment is a disgrace but I do think a contract drawn up before conception would be the most sensible thing. In a time and age of birth control there should be such less 'surprise' births than there are. Maybe I am a cynic but I know friends who wanted a baby without their partners consent. Had they have known they would be on their own financially then these men wouldn't be fathers. If two consenting adults want a baby and plan for a baby that is different and they should be splitting costs.

rumrunner123 · 21/02/2022 12:11

@LovelyLovelyWarmCoffee

- all income should count, so dividends, investments etc should be included
  • payment still goes down if the NRP has more DC but not for partner’s DC even if they move in together.
  • non payment is treated as unpaid tax, HMRC pays the amount due to the RP and collects it from the NRP with added fees. It could be automatically taken from salary for ex.
I wish this happened, my ex still owes me thousands but as our DS is now nearly 23 I can't see it (this was under old system and they still write to me each year to remind me).

DSS mom, pays every couple of weeks but then stops, had reduced because she moved in with a man who has 3 DC's. Tried to use CMS to collect, that worked for 4 weeks then they called DH to say they didn't think that that was in the best interests of the mother and child (they are NC and have been for 2 years), she hadn't paid because she had been in hospital for weeks (he told them not but they said they couldn't prove it oh and they told us she works cash in hand!)

She knows to work the system that as long as she is not a full 2 weeks behind they will not allow the collection service!

I would have been enraged that the system was so designed to help women if I had not had the same shit service off them when it was my ex, so really not sure who the system benefits - no one?

Old system shite, new system shite - go with straight to HMRC based on any taxable income with the same consequences.

Glitterygreen · 21/02/2022 12:10

Or any childcare through the years tbh, after school club etc.

Glitterygreen · 21/02/2022 12:08

@ChocolateMassacre

But what is a sensible amount for one Is laughably inadequate for another Or simply impossible for another

£300 per month is cheap. If the NRP actually had to pay for 24/7 childcare for their child, that would only cover 2-3 days.

£300 per month is a bargain to have a child taken care of full-time.

But why would the NRP need to pay someone for 24/7 care for their child? The NRP also looks after the child and the RP is the parent too.

CM is not meant to cover all of the costs, only half. £600 is not a small amount to cover a child each month.

I do wonder how people manage paying for nursery though, I do think there should be provision within CM for extra payment to be required if the child is needing to be in a full-time care setting before they start school so both parents can work.

Poll4 · 21/02/2022 12:07

[quote ChocolateMassacre]@Poll4. Does your child go to after-school club? Holiday club?[/quote]
No they don't. And I appreciate that's not the same for everyone.

CMS would be much fairer if it was based on individual circumstances imo. But that's probably impossible.

Generic rules for all are always going to be unfair to some and not others.

ChocolateMassacre · 21/02/2022 12:04

@Poll4. Does your child go to after-school club? Holiday club?

Poll4 · 21/02/2022 12:02

Does anyone have a child who costs them less than £10 per day, once food, clothes, books, childcare are taken into account?

Well it depends, is the NRP supposed to pay all of the cost or half? Because then it would be a child costing £20 a day.

Which of course if you're talking about nursery is still not much but if you're talking a school aged child no I can't say I spend £20 a day on my child.

Toanewstart23 · 21/02/2022 12:01

@ChocolateMassacre

But what is a sensible amount for one Is laughably inadequate for another Or simply impossible for another

£300 per month is cheap. If the NRP actually had to pay for 24/7 childcare for their child, that would only cover 2-3 days.

£300 per month is a bargain to have a child taken care of full-time.

To me £300 is paltry My ex, as a very very high earner, pays many multiples of that.

But I do grasp that for some £300/400 may be very difficult

ChocolateMassacre · 21/02/2022 11:59

Surely this depends on how often a NRP is seeing their child?

Obviously. You'd calculate the daily rate and divide by the number of days.

To be clear, £300 is not a fortune. It works out at below £10 per day.

Does anyone have a child who costs them less than £10 per day, once food, clothes, books, childcare are taken into account?

User310 · 21/02/2022 11:58

Why do people think it is ok for the first born children to have priority over subsequent children’s quality of life?

Of course it’s not your choice that your ex has more children, why would it be? You are not together, that choice no longer applies to you and neither should it.

I do not agree that the amount should be reduced for step children however.

ChocolateMassacre · 21/02/2022 11:55

But what is a sensible amount for one
Is laughably inadequate for another
Or simply impossible for another

£300 per month is cheap. If the NRP actually had to pay for 24/7 childcare for their child, that would only cover 2-3 days.

£300 per month is a bargain to have a child taken care of full-time.

Poll4 · 21/02/2022 11:51

@ChocolateMassacre

A lot of these issues would disappear if a sensible minimum amount was set for CM. Say £300-£400 per month. Non-negotiable and if the NRP can't/won't pay, the state pays for them and defers their state pension.
Surely this depends on how often a NRP is seeing their child?

Why should someone seeing their child 3 nights a week for example (so one night less than the RP) pay £400 a month?

Providing they have a room at their house, clothes, and all the other necessities I think that's a ludicrous amount to pay for the RP having 4 nights a month extra.

Toanewstart23 · 21/02/2022 11:50

@ChocolateMassacre

A lot of these issues would disappear if a sensible minimum amount was set for CM. Say £300-£400 per month. Non-negotiable and if the NRP can't/won't pay, the state pays for them and defers their state pension.
But what is a sensible amount for one Is laughably inadequate for another Or simply impossible for another
Glitterygreen · 21/02/2022 11:49

^^ Obviously the above only applies to NRPs paying a decent amount though, not those paying £9 a month or whatever!

Glitterygreen · 21/02/2022 11:47

@ChiselandBits

Sorry no, it's not 'obvious' that maintenance for one child would be used for another. The RP who goes on to have more will be supported by their new partner or get maintenance from them for the new child.
I disagree. I don't think many RPs ringfence their CM to purely be used on their first children, that would be unrealistic unless they are very wealthy themselves.

I think it totally stands to reason that it goes into the household pot and is used as the rest of the RP's income is.

I'm not saying it's wrong, just that NRPs and RPs are in the same position when it comes to being free to have additional children and it impacts them both.

ChocolateMassacre · 21/02/2022 11:45

A lot of these issues would disappear if a sensible minimum amount was set for CM. Say £300-£400 per month. Non-negotiable and if the NRP can't/won't pay, the state pays for them and defers their state pension.

Toanewstart23 · 21/02/2022 11:43

* Lots of RPs go on to have further children and then obviously the NRP's child support will get used on new children too. *

How come?

ABCeasyasdohrayme · 21/02/2022 11:42

This will never work though because it applies both ways.

No it doesn't.

Lots of RPs go on to have further children and then obviously the NRP's child support will get used on new children too. Even though they are not theirs and the NRP could argue in the same way thattheirchildren are losing out due to the RP's decision to have more children and stretch the money further.

Still no, there's another father responsible for paying towards the other child. Very, very few NRPs pay anything even like half for their children as well, so 'their money' wouldn't be getting used for another child considering it isn't even a dent in what their actual child costs.

People can never be allowed to dictate their ex's life due to money.

NRP is dictating a whole other person's finances due to their decision to have another child. The RP still has the same outgoings, but their money has been cut due to a baby that has nothing to do with them, or children who already have 2 parents paying for them.

Toanewstart23 · 21/02/2022 11:41

The different perspectives go like this

Step mums - always thinks the CM paid by their partners to ex’s is always grossly generous and unfair

RPs think it’s inadequate

NRP think it’s too much

ChiselandBits · 21/02/2022 11:39

Sorry no, it's not 'obvious' that maintenance for one child would be used for another. The RP who goes on to have more will be supported by their new partner or get maintenance from them for the new child.