Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Child maintenance

467 replies

Lalala1 · 20/02/2022 14:35

Posting here for traffic!

The amount of threads on mn surrounding child maintenance I’ve noticed there’s completely opposite opinions on it.
Some find the way it’s calculated fair some don’t.
Some say it doesn’t cover everything and “certain things should be split” out with cms.
Some say people get too much because they only get lower and are “greedy ex wives” so they should be grateful.
Some say the rules around calculations are wrong and should be changed.

So I’m curious if you were in charge of cms what would/should it be?
How should it be calculated?
Should it cover everything or not?
How would it or could it be changed to be fair for all children?
Or
Is the way it is set up and conducted fine as it is?

Just putting this for vote

YABU- cms is fine as it is no change
YANBU - cms should be changed and how?

OP posts:
Toanewstart23 · 21/02/2022 16:16

@OrganisedChaos22

Either trust her or daft?
He MUST trust her Because by registering his business entirely in her name He’s leaving himself very vulnerable if that marriage goes peer shaped
gogohm · 21/02/2022 16:14

So much depends on the circumstances. Where both parents earn similar amounts (say circa £40k +) and the woman didn't take a significant financial hit having children then the current amounts are quite fair. Where the absent parent (lets say dad Grin) earns lots and lots, resident parent earns hardly anything because they were a sahm for years due to child with disabilities and h with long hours it's quite different. I'm in the latter situation but my ex pays spousal without a court order.

The best thing to happen would be for all parents to act like grown ups and be fair but that's as likely as pigs flying. Plus there's often extra factors.

Children are for life, unfortunately not everyone seems to realise that

OrganisedChaos22 · 21/02/2022 16:12

Thing is he tells dc what they do and why. He also pays into a pension to lower it.

It's a piss off but he does care for ds well when there as does the SM.
Never had any major issues. Its just some things are frustrating

OrganisedChaos22 · 21/02/2022 16:11

Either trust her or daft?

Toanewstart23 · 21/02/2022 16:09

@OrganisedChaos22

It is registered with hmrc.

She is the director. Takes a whack of a wage plus dividends.
He does 50 hour weeks for £540pw.
Which is all he has to pay maintenance on.

He must really Trust his new wife. Completely and totally Because to say he is vulnerable - would Bea understatement
OrganisedChaos22 · 21/02/2022 16:07

It is registered with hmrc.

She is the director. Takes a whack of a wage plus dividends.
He does 50 hour weeks for £540pw.
Which is all he has to pay maintenance on.

OrganisedChaos22 · 21/02/2022 16:04

My ex moved away. And re married.
It. Didn't bother me that he payed less as she had dcs. As I'm sure she would have lost her tax credits when he moved in etc and she's a good step mum to dc

I didn't agree he gets a variation because he moved away and costs him more fuel to collect ds! So gets a percentage off for that.
He moved away not me.

Toanewstart23 · 21/02/2022 16:03

@OrganisedChaos22

The NRP opening a business in their OHs name. The OH paying the NRP a ' mediocre wage but above the minimum wage' then the OH having double the wage. So their household income is lovely but the NRP has to pay pittance to the RP.
Not as easy anymore

Has to be registered with HMRC
Set up on payroll
Etc

Toanewstart23 · 21/02/2022 16:02

@ChocolateMassacre

But why would the NRP need to pay someone for 24/7 care for their child? The NRP also looks after the child and the RP is the parent too.

Clearly if NRP and RP were doing 50/50 care, no one should be paying anything.

@ChocolateMassacre

Well there wouldn’t be a NRP then, would there?

OrganisedChaos22 · 21/02/2022 16:01

The NRP opening a business in their OHs name. The OH paying the NRP a ' mediocre wage but above the minimum wage' then the OH having double the wage. So their household income is lovely but the NRP has to pay pittance to the RP.

Chakraleaf · 21/02/2022 16:00

@Dithercats

Reducing CM if you live with another woman with children - or if you have another child should be stopped. Men should pay for their children regardless of who they go on to be with.
Yes, we get next to nothing now.
Toanewstart23 · 21/02/2022 15:58

@Bubblesandsqueak1

I worked out the cost for my ds which is around 110 per week, that includes everything food, clothes, clubs, ect so £55 per week per parent £238.33 PER month i do think its crazy then nrp pay 500 plus per month or more however if child is under 5 they should also split childcare nursery cost on top of that
You’d be horrified then with what my ex pays

And why not? He’s an incredibly high earner and he has the children for alternative weekends

Thankfully he’s happy to at it

nancybotwinbloom · 21/02/2022 15:55

The CMS doesn't seem to benefit anyone. Except the CMS.

They charge £10 (or that's what it was when I opened my claim five years ago) and then as I use the collect option they take a percentage of the £20 a month my exh pays.

There is over £10k debt on the account.

He is self employed.

They do nothing to address the debt. Nothing to investigate what he earns as is self employed.

I took them and my ex to court, it was court ordered that he should pay £440 a month yet I've never had more than £20 a month but because he's paying "something" they won't take any further action except send him a letter demanding he pay which he ignores.

Absolute waste of 3 years pursuing this.

I sat in court and I had to demonstrate a similar role in a similar area to give a rough guide to his earnings as he didn't turn up to any hearings or provide any of the financial records the court asked for. The csa sat there and argued that he probably only earned £20k per annum. I had to point out this wasn't possible seeing as he took £40k of dividends that year alone.

They are a joke of a service.

There are some good suggestions on this thread about penalties for non payers but none will ever happen as they don't follow through on anything now.

SartresSoul · 21/02/2022 15:42

Anecdotal tale but my friend has 3 DC with her ex. He moved in with a woman and her two children a couple of months after they split so he’s always got away with paying less purely because his girlfriend has 2 children. Two children who are not biologically his at all and had he lived alone or with someone who didn’t already have children, he’d pay more towards his biological children. Somehow that rule doesn’t add up to me and makes no sense. I don’t think stepchildren should be involved with the calculation at all.

Also, the bare minimum isn’t enough for anyone. My friend gets £220 a month through CMS for three children who are not small so cost a lot every month. He barely sees his children either, about 12 hours a month and no overnight visitation because the house he shares with the GF and her kids isn’t big enough for them to stay over.

That situation just doesn’t seem fair to me personally. I think it’s far too easy for Dad’s to walk away, pay next to nothing and do fuck all for their children. Women generally always end up picking up the slack.

ChiselandBits · 21/02/2022 15:09

I think the issue is that many nrps use that as a reason why they should only pay the pretty paltry amount that cms usually adds up to, whilst having the option due to not being the RP to earn more. A lot depends on the time split.

Pinkyxx · 21/02/2022 15:07

It's a tragedy that some people think an adults personal wishes and needs trump those of the children they have.

What of taking responsibility for ensuring the children you already have are taken care of before you go on to another life or have more children? Yes children need a bedroom in the NRPs house, but that child also needs a roof over their head and their needs met in the RP's home as well. An NRPs wants should not come at the expense of the needs of a child they brought into the world. Nor should their partners, or their partners children, or any new children they choose to have. It's grossly irresponsible to go on to set up a new life or take on someone else's children, or have more children when it detriments the child you already have. An RP can't magic up double the income (or more) to cover what were household expenses just like that. Its all very well saying the NRP owes the RP nothing as they aren't together, but they do have a responsibility toward the child that had no choice in the matter.

Not taking on additional costs you can't afford seems like a basic... I've never understood why it's considered ok for the NRP to just pass the costs along to the RP on a pro-rata basis when the NRP is just as responsible for those costs just so that the NRP can fund his nice new life, often with no responsibility at all for the children left behind.

HoleyMoley5 · 21/02/2022 14:36

When it comes to child maintenance it’s the NRP needs to house the children also electric/gas/food etc yet there’s some People on here who argue that “ their home isn’t the children’s home as they are hardly here they live with mum and “visit” here therefore they don’t need a room/space,possessions etc” it’s contradictory

Obviously not everyone thinks this way. There will always be some people who contradict themselves on MN about any subject. But poster's here aren't just one individual so unless you've seen the same poster make both of your points, it's not really proof of anything.

I'm a step parent but I absolutely don't think my step children are just visiting or this isn't their home. They have a bedroom here, clothes, books, games consoles, uniform, bikes etc... They are certainly not just thrown on an airbed in the home office. But yes, all of the above is a cost to us as well, we, like their Mum, have to pay for a house big enough for them to have their own rooms etc... They do live more nights with their Mum so of course my husband makes a contribution toward that but it is right, in our case, to say that we also have to provide most of the same things as their Mum does too.

And most posters on MN think that is right (understandably) so why shouldn't it be acknowledged?

YouHaveYourFathersBreasts · 21/02/2022 13:25

@Dithercats

Reducing CM if you live with another woman with children - or if you have another child should be stopped. Men should pay for their children regardless of who they go on to be with.
Totally agree. Takes the piss.
ChiselandBits · 21/02/2022 13:20

Its not £X per day, its the cumulative cost over, say, 12 months. Some days my kids will cost me hundreds in new shoes, uniforms, club subs due, a trip to the cinema, nothing ridiculous or untoward, just fairly normal expenditure and others nothing at all. Where the RP is NOT preventing contact, there absolutely ought to be some recognition that they are effectively providing free childcare for the 50% of the time the kids could be with their NRP. Those saying the NRP has so many expenses also - they also have MUCH greater choices of earning, second jobs, longer hours which RPs simply can't take.

And I don't know why posters are still talking about it being unfair NOT to reduce payments for subsequent children - the 1st family have NO input into the exes decision to have another child but WILL end up compensating for the drop in CMS. They just will. The NRP should not be having more kids if they cannot do so without maintaining their existing obligations - you don't ring up the council and ask for a reduction in council tax, or mortgage or ask for % off your shopping at Tesco because you have to buy baby food now too.

Bubblesandsqueak1 · 21/02/2022 13:19

I worked out the cost for my ds which is around 110 per week, that includes everything food, clothes, clubs, ect so £55 per week per parent £238.33 PER month i do think its crazy then nrp pay 500 plus per month or more however if child is under 5 they should also split childcare nursery cost on top of that

HunterHearstHelmsley · 21/02/2022 13:16

More than anything... CMS need to know what they are doing.

Two mutual friends of mine have been having a huge row about CM. RP is adamant NRP is in arrears, NRP is adamant he isn't and has overpaid. Both showed me their CM journal/log (not sure what it's called). Sure enough, hers shows he is in £400 arrears, his shows he has overpaid £400 and no payments are due. Absolutely astounding.

sanityisamyth · 21/02/2022 13:10

My ExH pays what CMS says he should be. Fair enough to him, he always pays it. But what he pays doesn't cover half the rent, let alone food, heating, water, internet, clothes, after school clubs, after school activities etc. It's a disgrace that he pays so little towards his son.

Lalala1 · 21/02/2022 13:09

@Jayne35

A lot of these issues would disappear if a sensible minimum amount was set for CM. Say £300-£400 per month. Non-negotiable and if the NRP can't/won't pay, the state pays for them and defers their state pension.

I couldn't have afforded the above, I paid around £160 per month - I'm not a high earner though. I still had a child at home while my DS moved in with my ex (I got £5 per week for DD as ex was unemployed!)

I also don’t agree or think the flat rate £7 is anywhere near fair it’s actually a joke! There are some NRPs on benefits with more monthly money than a NRP on minimum wage who pays a percentage of that wage yet on benefits it’s a flat rate of £7! And before anybody goes off on one I know that it’s the state that are then paying for it but if it was a percentage of benefits or a higher standard amount then a lot of NRPs wouldn’t stay on benefits especially the ones who specifically go unemployed for cms purposes.
OP posts:
Orangello · 21/02/2022 13:07

I do agree that a reasonable minimum amount needs to be set. I mean, children need to be fed somehow, the resident parent does not have the option to tell them that here's a fiver, see how you manage.

Lalala1 · 21/02/2022 12:58

@Finallylostit

The cry is always NRP has to have a house to accommodate the children and this costs but so often on mumsnet - we here that the SDCs are on blow up mattresses, sleeping in the lounge etc etc, spare room is now an office for wfh.

The majority do not provide their DCs with the same as at their main home and this is deemed acceptable because half the time - they can not be arsed to have their DCS more - so they just let it slide.

Yes I made this thread as I constantly seen different views on cms when it suits! When it comes to child maintenance it’s the NRP needs to house the children also electric/gas/food etc yet there’s some People on here who argue that “ their home isn’t the children’s home as they are hardly here they live with mum and “visit” here therefore they don’t need a room/space,possessions etc” it’s contradictory! Confused
OP posts: