Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Child maintenance

467 replies

Lalala1 · 20/02/2022 14:35

Posting here for traffic!

The amount of threads on mn surrounding child maintenance I’ve noticed there’s completely opposite opinions on it.
Some find the way it’s calculated fair some don’t.
Some say it doesn’t cover everything and “certain things should be split” out with cms.
Some say people get too much because they only get lower and are “greedy ex wives” so they should be grateful.
Some say the rules around calculations are wrong and should be changed.

So I’m curious if you were in charge of cms what would/should it be?
How should it be calculated?
Should it cover everything or not?
How would it or could it be changed to be fair for all children?
Or
Is the way it is set up and conducted fine as it is?

Just putting this for vote

YABU- cms is fine as it is no change
YANBU - cms should be changed and how?

OP posts:
owlinnahat · 21/02/2022 18:59

I don't see that forcing NRP into debt or unemployment, or forcing second families into poverty because first families always have to have the same income would really solve anything, but I do think that maintenance could and should be collected more efficiently. I don't understand why it doesn't work more like student loans, or similar, where repayments are just taken directly from salaries.

I think it would also be reasonable for dividends/investment income to be taken into account.

Theunamedcat · 21/02/2022 18:57

It's less than I thought its only 12%for one child

Child maintenance
QuestionableDanceMoves · 21/02/2022 18:53

@SleepingStandingUp but why should the lifestyle choices of the NRP (having more kids) have a financial implication for the RP?
The RP doesn’t get a say in whether the NRP has more kids or moves in with someone who already has kids but does have what little maintenance they may get reduced.
That’s not a fair system.

nancybotwinbloom · 21/02/2022 18:52

Was there a ama thread with someone who worked in the CMS or did I dream that? I think I might have suggested it ages ago but I don't think there was one. I wish someone would and answer questions like why they can't enforce payments and what other difficulties they have.

IstayedForTheFeminism · 21/02/2022 18:48

Honestly? My ex would rather not work. He's only gone back to work because he had to. If he lost his license and then his job he would just claim he can't work anymore.

Taking away driving licenses might work for some NRPs though. I believe CMS already have the power to do it. They just don't.

Fireflygal · 21/02/2022 18:44

CM should be calculated before salary sacrifice to stop people using this as a means to reduce their payments

Ex chooses salary sacrifice for an expensive bike which enables him to pay less.
There's a max rate which hasn't risen in 15 years so very high earners actually pay a very low percentage of earnings to support a child.

nancybotwinbloom · 21/02/2022 18:37

There should be an ISO standard that employers should adhere to where the csa debt should be flagged to potential employers.

They are either not employed if they have debt or they have to sign terms and conditions to actively reduce the csa debt whilst employed with that company and agree a set amount straight from their wages/salary.

Fluffyhairteddy · 21/02/2022 18:35

Child maintenance should be based on an assumed salary. My ex is just not working so I get nothing. Move more to US system of an imputed salary. Arrears build based on that assumption. They follow the payer around for life - pension payments if need be until settled.

user1487636583 · 21/02/2022 18:35

CMS should take in to account that a child born after the cut off for tax credits costs the parent with care way more than the NRP. I have to work term time only, so that there is someone to look after the 3 children, ex won’t have them during the week even if he is off work and childcare would cost so much so I am a lower earner and now claim tax credits. My ex changed jobs, and reduced his hours, and also works cash in hand over time so that he only has to give me £65 a week for three children who he has overnight 6 nights a month. I don’t get any tax credits for the younger child, which obviously wasn’t an issue when we had him and both worked. I don’t think 21 pound something is enough towards a child per week! He has such a better quality of life and leaves me to deal with everything
the children need and begrudges that!

SleepingStandingUp · 21/02/2022 18:31

I never understand how it varies but the cost of raising different children does vary. My friends two kids go to private school, mine don't. They have a foreign holiday and three UK holidays a year. We have 1 UK holiday. Both parents drive, my kids have to get the bus. They go to tennis and ballet, mine go to gymnastics. They're dressed new from online, fair trade, organic, handmade, MC lines. Mine are dressed from George or Vinted. They both earn good salaries, DH earns an OK salary and I don't work. Beyond the basics there is no standard cost and why should kids with wealthier NRPs only get the minimum it costs to raise mine, or why should my "ex" have to put himself into debt to give the kids a standard of living they'd never have had if we were together

SleepingStandingUp · 21/02/2022 18:26

And no cutting the first family's money so you can start family no. 2. but most people do this when they have a subsequent child. I know the difference is the consent of both parents but the point is that there IS less money for the first child if you have a second unless you're very wealthy. We had a second, had twins. Of course there's less money for DS as I can't cover all their costs on £26 CB

itsjustnotok · 21/02/2022 18:02

I never understand how it varies and how NRP’s sometimes manage to pay so little. Child maintenance has always been terribly managed and doesn’t look like it’s gotten any better. DH signed over everything to his ex for her and their children and took all of their debt bar the mortgage as she wanted the house. Me and him are still paying it off and it’s been years. His bills bounced because he was giving all he had, to the point where I was feeding him as he no money. His ex told anyone who would listen that he didn’t pay her anything when the truth was he paid her £600 a month and left her debt free. The system has never worked, nothing seems to change.

Porcupineintherough · 21/02/2022 18:02

@IstayedForTheFeminism it's not about solving the problem it's about punishing the offence. Right now he doesnt pay and it doesn't affect him one bit. If it meant the end of his job and his wages he might think again.

ABCeasyasdohrayme · 21/02/2022 18:02

@IstayedForTheFeminism

The problem with withholding driving licenses is it could affect NRPs job and then they still won't be able to pay. My ex is a delivery driver. He doesn't pay any maintenance, but taking his driving license away won't solve that. He'll then just be unemployed and not paying maintenance.
If he is so concerned about his job he should pay for his kid then.

They still won't pay if they lose their license, but they will be more inclined to if it hits their pocket. Would they rather 'lose' 20% of their wages, or their whole wage?

IstayedForTheFeminism · 21/02/2022 17:56

The problem with withholding driving licenses is it could affect NRPs job and then they still won't be able to pay.
My ex is a delivery driver. He doesn't pay any maintenance, but taking his driving license away won't solve that. He'll then just be unemployed and not paying maintenance.

Porcupineintherough · 21/02/2022 17:52

I think the amounts should be raised to something more realistic (no more £5/week) and, most importantly, it should be paid without fail. No more dodgy blokes not working, or going self employed in jobs that mysteriously make no money, or constantly pissing around. And no cutting the first family's money so you can start family no. 2.

And YY to withholding passports and driving licenses for those that wont comply.

SleepingStandingUp · 21/02/2022 17:46

@Toanewstart23
A lot of these issues would disappear if a sensible minimum amount was set for CM. Say £300-£400 per month

But what is a sensible amount for one
Is laughably inadequate for another
Or simply impossible for another

If your child costs more than £6-800 pm i think it's reasonable to say you need to consider your lifestyle CHOICES. if £800 pm is inadequate I'd assume its private school etc so they're already high earners so getting more than the base minimum.

Finallylostit · 21/02/2022 17:40

goghm -
I earn a decent wage as does EX roughly the same.

What is a hit? My wage is bloody good in comparision to many but I have done al childcare / either myself or pad for it, sickness, holidays etc etc.

So you would argue I have not taken a hit but when I compare myself to my male colleagues who have not had children but had their wife at home doing all child related stuff - I earn 2/3s what they do because I have not been able to do the late night schmoozing - same contracted hours.
So yes I am worse off.

londonmummy1966 · 21/02/2022 17:01

It should be quite a straightforward thing to bring CMS and the tax system into line. A straight % deduction from payroll on employed income. Where the NRP has unearned income then they should simply pay the same percentage on that income in two installments in the same way as tax is paid on SE income etc. The % should also come off gross income (ie including cash value of benefits but ignoring deductions for pension/charitable giving etc)..

G5000 · 21/02/2022 16:59

I worked out the cost for my ds which is around 110 per week, that includes everything food, clothes, clubs,

I mean of course one should live according to their means and all, but really? Housing, transport, holidays all included?

QuirkyTurtle · 21/02/2022 16:33

As a stepparent I think CMS calculations are laughably low, especially if you need to take nursery or other forms of child care into account. Other countries manage to take child payments out of paychecks to make it non-optional, I don't understand why the UK can't.

That being said I also think it's tragic that 50/50 in the UK is not standard, if the father wants it.

SleepingStandingUp · 21/02/2022 16:33

I think the proboscis is that there isn't a single solution that suits everyone.
PP the other day wakes away with 70% assets and brought property outright. Assuming daughter costs half of all bills etc it came to just over £300 in total. Mom got £350 so didn't financially pay a penny for daughters living costs and she still wanted him to go e her money and had wanted spousal support (they both worked). On the same calculation someone else will get barely anything and it won't come near half the costs.

You can't bare it in actual lifestyle costs because the resident parent could deliberately increase them to cost the ex more and screw them over.
Salary leads to issues above.
If your deduct for new kids, your imposing that in the first family, but the reality is if you have more kids, you are likely to adjust what you spend on the older one anyway.

Perhaps there should be a basic minimum payment and if you can't afford to pay it, the govt g go but it's deducted from your benefits / added on like a loan

Pinkyxx · 21/02/2022 16:29

@OrganisedChaos22

It is registered with hmrc.

She is the director. Takes a whack of a wage plus dividends.
He does 50 hour weeks for £540pw.
Which is all he has to pay maintenance on.

I don't think people realize how easy it is to do stuff like this all in the name of smoke and mirrors.. and to do it perfectly legally.. It's just another loop hole that NRPs can and DO exploit

If my ex-husbands dividends had been considered I'd have been entitled to apply to court for maintenance as his earnings would well exceed 150k. Instead he opts to ''diversify'' the earnings from his employer, live the life of a king AND pay next to no CMS!

It's pretty obvious to anyone that you can't own a house worth just under a million pounds, wear nothing but designer clothing, eat out at least 4 times a week, drive a snazzy expensive car, take at least 4 international holidays a year + various ''mini breaks'' with your wife ( yes he does cancel contact for these!) on the salary that goes through HRMC.. but trouble is no one is looking. He's laughing his arse off...

ChiselandBits · 21/02/2022 16:26

all of this adds up to what I said on page 1 - that there is no solution short of individual case loads and regular reviews, backed up by robust enforcement but all of that would cost far too much and isn't desired. The current "one size fits no-one" approach leaves everyone feeling hard done by one way or another.

ChiselandBits · 21/02/2022 16:24

gogohm why are the current amounts fair? I guarantee you that two parents, both earning similar, one with EOW contact only will NOT be paying the same toward the childrens' day to day expenses. I guarantee you that the RP will be paying more than 18% of their income and doing all the leg work.