Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To tell colleague to butt out over pronounciation issue?

142 replies

frustratedpomegranate · 20/02/2022 12:57

Colleague A started in our team around 3 years ago. She has an uncommon first name and we asked her at the start how to pronounce it and she told us. I've heard her on the phone and interacting with other staff hundreds of times and we say it the same way she does.

Colleague B started about four months ago and when introduced to A, she said 'isn't your name pronounced XYZ'. Colleague A said no, she says pronounces it ABC. B said she knew someone else with A's name and insisted it was XYZ.

B continues to pronounce A's name the way she thinks it should be (its quite different to what the rest of us are saying) and frequently corrects the rest of us when referring to A. We have spoken to A about it but she's very non confrontational and says she doesn't mind B's insistence and doesn't want to speak to her about it. B has quite an aggressive personality and has been prone to outbursts in the office a few times in the short while she's been with us so nobody is really sure what to do.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
stormstormgoaway · 21/02/2022 13:46

B is looking for drama. Don't feed the beast. Just go on saying A's name correctly, and ignore B's "corrections". If she forces the issue, just calmly say "She pronounces it XYZ" as if it's a simple misunderstanding that's never come up before, and then move on. If she tries to argue about it, just ignore.

B will get bored of this before too long. She's only making herself look a fool.

KatharinaRosalie · 21/02/2022 13:39

And when you tell B that "No, you're wrong, A has clearly told us her name is XX and not XY", what happens?

milkyaqua · 21/02/2022 12:01

its also more the issue that we are being corrected when pronouncing it the way A has told us.

This is so bizarre. She knows her own name!

longtompot · 21/02/2022 11:42

It's not so much people saying As name differently, as others have said people do pronounce names differently. Its the being told you are by the person who's name it isn't, person B. It doesn't sound like B will change what they are doing so could you speak to your line manager and say that it's you having the issue of being told you are saying As name wrong by person B, so it's not about A but about Bs treatment of you and the rest of the team?

Sazzlepop22 · 21/02/2022 11:41

As plenty others have said, start calling B the wrong name, she how she likes it. And call her out by asking who she is talking about when she says the incorrect pronunciation for A. Do this in front of people too so they have the confidence to challenge B as well.

Snaketime · 21/02/2022 11:28

Everytime B corrects you say, "no this is how A pronounces it, it is her name and I will pronounce it how she wants it pronouncing." A is being bullied by B, you are all letting it happen. Yes A will say she is fine with it if she is shy and quiet, that is why bully's tend to pick on shy, quiet people, because they wont stand up for themselves.

BunsOfAnarchy · 21/02/2022 11:18

B is disgusting
Whether A cares to make a deal of it or not, its still a form of bullying behaviour in the workplace.
I'd call B out on it and if they still insist on being a dick about it, remind them that this is a form of bullying and reportable to HR.

frazzledasarock · 21/02/2022 11:11

Ignore colleague B entirely and carry on pronouncing colleague A's name the way she has said her name should be pronounced.
Regardless of whether colleague B is aggressive just blank her if she (mis)corrects you.

I have a colleague who's name we were pronouncing incorrectly and she never corrected us, until another colleague joined our team and I heard her pronounce the colleagues name completely differently, I asked the first colleague whether I was mispronouncing her name and she laughed and said I was, but it didn't matter. I think it does matter and made sure I was pronouncing it correctly from then on, the rest of our team picked up the correct pronunciation and call her by her name. It is basic courtesy

It is so disrespectful and lazy making up a name for someone. women mostly don't like to make a fuss, I have spent my life being called variations of my name because it's not an English name, even tho it is phonetically pronounced, you say it how it is spelled.
I did at one point start calling an idiot a variation of English names as he insisted on calling me different names, funnily he didn't like it when it was done to him.

Marynotsocontrary · 21/02/2022 11:06

Maybe B is right and A is using a non-standard pronunciation of her name. Even if this is so (a big if) it doesn't matter a bit! It's A's name so she gets to choose how to say it and anyone with manners will take their lead from her. Seems like B doesn't know how to behave.

I think I'd respect A's wishes so wouldn't make a formal complaint, but I think I'd try to put B straight on how manners work if she started correcting me when using A's name (I'd do this in private though).

MajesticallyAwkward · 21/02/2022 11:05

B is behaving appallingly. If A doesn't want to report or confront her over it I don't know if I'd report, maybe mention it to Bs line manager that she's (wrongly) correcting As name and it's becoming an issue.

It's micro aggression and not acceptable. The petty part of me would mispronounce Bs name, increasingly getting further and further away.

zingally · 21/02/2022 10:50

I can be passive-aggressive as heck. Especially against a bully. I'd start deliberately pronouncing B's name wrong - see how she likes it!

frustratedpomegranate · 21/02/2022 10:50

@KatharinaRosalie

I simply do not believe anybody would genuinely not mind that their colleague goes around and tells other people that the person is wrong about their own name, and they should be called as the colleague prefers. That's just massively weird.
A is very timid and doesn't want anyone to get into trouble but for the rest of us its also more the issue that we are being corrected when pronouncing it the way A has told us.
OP posts:
incognitoforthisone · 21/02/2022 10:33

In this case, I actually don't think it matters whether A wants this raised or not. Everyone else in the office is having to work with someone, B, who is being bullying and obnoxious in the presence of colleagues and has terrible manners. That's not OK. It's not even about whether A is bothered (and I'm sure A is, in fact, bothered, even if they say they're not), it's about the kind of office culture you're working in and what is/isn't acceptable. I wouldn't want to work in a place where that kind of rudeness and lack of consideration to other colleagues was tolerated every day.

Perime · 21/02/2022 09:21

Oh come on. This is low level bullying. It's so rude.

SpiceRat · 20/02/2022 23:48

Every time B makes the mistake just say “I don’t know who you’re talking about, no one works here by x name” and repeat. She sounds like an utter cunt.

WeBuiltThisBuffetOnSausageRoll · 20/02/2022 23:29

lljkk

Nobody is saying that OP should actually become the bully herself; but I think it's helpful to consider the great likelihood of how the colleague is feeling - even if she doesn't want to vocalise it. We all know that women, in particular, are socialised to put themselves last and make allowances for terrible behaviour from others - usually men, but not always.

A lot of people, whether from ethnic minorities, female or both (very rarely white British men) will centre others and diminish themselves - going out of their way to accept others calling them an 'English-friendly' or just more 'familiar' name that partially approximates to their actual name. I think it's very sad that this is so often felt to be necessary - and even if it's what the person themselves gets used to, to the point that they will introduce themselves by the 'more familiar' name. I don't accept that this always comes from a place of complete personal happiness to be known as a different name - more a resigned acceptance that, when other people refuse to bend, you yourself must do it - in anticipation or reaction, and never risk hurting their feelings - even when the issue is your own actual name.

Susu49 · 20/02/2022 23:25

@HunterHearstHelmsley 🤣🤣🤣

Beseen22 · 20/02/2022 22:21

My mum does this. I'm pretty sure if she was going through school now she would have and ASD diagnosis. She does not like names that don't read like they are produced so deliberately says it wrongly (Siobhan she would pronounce exactly as it sounds). I ignore her until she says it properly, so if we were discussing someone called Isla she will pronounce the s and I'll stare at her blankly until she has to correct herself. Drives her mad. Called my son Ruaridh, mostly because I like the name but also because it drives her mad.

phishy · 20/02/2022 21:57

Is A of an ethnic heritage?

I would be annoyed at being treated like I don’t have a mind of my own.

lljkk · 20/02/2022 21:35

Sigh, Ok, sure, OP should have this conversation with A:

OP: "Hey you know how bossy B keeps saying your name wrong?"
A: "yeah..."
OP: "B is a patronising bully doing micro-aggressions! We're going to (take xyz actions)."
A: "I'm not comfortable making an issue out of this."
Colleague 1: "Oh dear, we know you just don't want to put your head above the parapet."
A: "i didn't say that..."
Colleague 2: "You can't actually like others deliberately and repeatedly mispronouncing your name --"
A: "I don't mind."
Colleague 1: "Yes but, we know that your chilled acceptance and non-confrontational behaviour is actually well-masked frustration and gut-twisting, embarrassed anxiety."
A: "You know my feelings better than me?"
Colleague 2: "Besides, Toxic behaviour towards colleagues undermines positive professional relationships."
A: "But I didn't feel like it was toxic --"
OP: "It isn't really up to you. We can't turn a blind eye. "
A: "It isn't up to me what happens, about something so trivial?"
Colleague 1: "We reckon you're just concerned that the bullying will escalate if you complain."
A: "You know my concerns better than me?"

yeah sure, you have that conversation, OP. Report back, let us know how it went.

ps: What others said, OP talking to line manager about OP feeling harassed in how B insists her pronunciation should be used, this is in realms of very reasonable.
AlmostAJillSandwich · 20/02/2022 21:30

Band together, insist B's name is wrong and all start pronouncing it in the cringiest sounding way possible, because colleague C's cousins best mate pronounces it that way soooooo clearly she's the one getting it wrong. Don't stop until she does.

At least, that's what i'd want to do, but best avoid the "bullying" allegations she'd probably make. Just look at her bemused and say you don't know anyone by that name in the office when she pronounces it wrong.

Clarinet1 · 20/02/2022 21:28

Some of these posts remind of the wonderful writer Maya Angelou. She was born Marguerite but when she worked as a servant as a teenager, her employer insisted on calling her Margaret.

WeBuiltThisBuffetOnSausageRoll · 20/02/2022 21:18

I guess I believed OP when she said

"We have spoken to A about it ... she doesn't mind B's insistence and doesn't want to speak to her about it. "

also

"A has said she doesn't mind B correcting everyone."

So do you really think that, every time somebody says "I don't want to talk to you/her/him about it", that's their simple way of saying that everything is fine? Some people genuinely fear confrontation, especially when they know the other person is acting like a bully - doesn't necessarily mean they're smiley and happy about it at all.

The second quote is even more stark: in what world would anybody genuinely be happy for somebody else to 'correct' people from using their name correctly and badger/bully them to change it to something deliberately incorrect? Not even being understanding/resigned to that individual person always getting it wrong themselves, but supposedly being happy for somebody to arbitrarily give them a new name/pronunciation and then insist on everybody else using this new name instead of their actual name? Seriously??

KatharinaRosalie · 20/02/2022 21:13

I simply do not believe anybody would genuinely not mind that their colleague goes around and tells other people that the person is wrong about their own name, and they should be called as the colleague prefers. That's just massively weird.

iolaus · 20/02/2022 20:48

@Afraidofninja

I would act on my own behalf and complain that I was being bullied into pronouncing A's name wrong. Her behaviour is disruptive in the workplace, it's a shame that A doesn't want to do anything about it, but it's affecting you as well. My sister has an unusual name that can be pronounced more than one way. One of her colleagues insisted on using the wrong pronunciation, even though nobody around her did that and she'd been told. That was until she answered the phone to me and - using different names obviously - I asked to speak to Alicia and she said "Oh, you mean Aleesha". I told her in no uncertain terms that I knew how to pronounce my sister's name correctly and I would expect the people she worked with to know how to as well.
One of my daughter's is Alicia and one of her teachers pronounced her name wrong - she didn't correct her (I think she had a few times and gave us) One of the girls who had known her since she was 3 came up to her after class, horrified saying 'Have I been saying your name wrong for years' She pointed out that everyone else said it right, the teacher was wrong - but the point being a child knew that it's important to say a persons name correctly