Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Asking her to leave the cat with us....

129 replies

LoveMyPiano · 20/02/2022 10:55

My next door but one neighbour is about to finally move out, after about 5 months virtually living with boyfriend, but coming to and fro the apartment (I am in a house next door to the little block).

She has/had two cats. A black one, probably less than a year old, that has been left in the apartment mostly all of the time; and an older one who has always roamed the complex and back road and who has been in my house a lot, comes onto the garden (catches rodents but not birds strangely) and has virtually adopted my friend who also lives in the apartments. It seemed that he was effectively left behind and we have cared for him with all kinds of food (he became very underweight and scruffy at first but now his coat is like silk [maybe we should all eat cat food!], he has a mix of some dried and some wet, and has really improved since we added the pouch food.

He is nicely looked after by us jointly - and now allowed to stay in overnight (previously, not - and mainly his choice - he is very nocturnal). He waits for my friend to come home, and he also seems to know when I will go round but sometimes totally indfferent and stays in one of his many beds/spots. For example, last night, I had my Saturday pizza with the plate resting (lightly) on his head. He will not get off my lap until I tip him off....

Please suggest any way I persuade her to leave him with us. She and I are not especially friendly (due to anothe nasty neighbour - now gone- influence) but I have never said a nasty thing to or about her or her little boy, and she knows what the cat has been doing. But now, her actual move out is imminent, and I have heard (from another neighbour) that she plans to take him...... He was not happy in her home before, as he seems to like quiet, and she has a big boisterous dog and a (I think) 6 year old - and of course the other cat..... I would not criticise any of this - but I really want to plead with her to leave him with us, where he is doing so well, and is such a help to my need to look after something. Sad Sad

He keeps his opinion to himself when I play the piano..... but that eye speaks volumes Smile

Asking her to leave the cat with us....
OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
LoveMyPiano · 24/02/2022 18:16

@WomanStanleyWoman

I have not even said that it is - technically - wrong in moving and taking the cat.

There’s no ‘technically’ about it. A woman moved house and took her pet with her. It’s a perfectly normal situation. What’s not normal is you thinking the whole thing was done by stealth because of you. Frankly it sounds a bit obsessive.

I did not think the move was done by stealth "because of me", although I can see how you might have thought that's what I meant... (I'm not that important Grin)

Without wanting to explain any further - and at risk of sounding obsessed (which I sort of "am" - with the welfare of this cat, who was as far as anyone could tell, abandoned months ago) - there are reasons for things being the way they are.
I have now been told the way in which she took him, and I was right to be concerned; that's all I will say.

OP posts:
WomanStanleyWoman · 24/02/2022 12:40

I have not even said that it is - technically - wrong in moving and taking the cat.

There’s no ‘technically’ about it. A woman moved house and took her pet with her. It’s a perfectly normal situation. What’s not normal is you thinking the whole thing was done by stealth because of you. Frankly it sounds a bit obsessive.

Aprilx · 24/02/2022 10:05

*yes

Aprilx · 24/02/2022 10:05

I think there is no harm in asking, although I am concerned that there are some issues between you and her, as I am not sure why you feel the need to clarify that you haven’t said anything nasty about her or her child (as if this wee a normal thing to do).

Anyway, when I was about 27 a neighbour asked if they could keep my cat. I liked my cat, I looked after her, but it was an apartment and I was working long hours in London. So the cat started spending time with some neighbours who were in more than I was. I had no problem with the cat having other humans in her life. Anyway they were moving, they loved the cat, they were moving to a big house with big garden, they asked if they could take her. After thinking about it for a couple of days, I realised that this probably was the best thing for the cat, so I said

LoveMyPiano · 24/02/2022 09:48

@lunar1

I'm so sorry he's gone.
Thank you Flowers - I am worried about him...... Sad He did have quite a (relative) life of luxury and indulgence with us, so it will be a shock for him Smile Sad

(He was also free to go walkabout and chase the local rats, if he chose..... He was not a softie, once his strength came back.)

OP posts:
lunar1 · 24/02/2022 05:43

I'm so sorry he's gone.

LoveMyPiano · 24/02/2022 00:57

Never wanted to steal him, nor did I/we intend to.
We have taken 100% care of him for over 5 months, and he was a welcome VISITOR before that - but that's all. But he was never in good shape and after being abandoned, declined further. I would not in conscience ignore his plight, but did not consider him mine, or "stealing" him.

I may be wrong about the "stealth" move - but I have seen a fair few of them, unfortunately. The reps of the landlord will come along in afew months, not even knowing the apartment is empty, I gaurantee it. Sadly.

The "new info" (aka, drip feed, I know) just came up in the course of the discussion. I would do the same again, as I have done in the past; I don't consider whether or not it is pretty. The miniature horse was, in effect, stolen from my daughter and me - I took her back, for her welfare, not because of the money that we were not paid.

I am not ashamed of my "track record", I have no idea why you think I should be Angry Angry Angry

OP posts:
RobbieWeirdicht · 24/02/2022 00:33

@Bob0117

In the stealthy, sneaky way? The original owner has been spiteful to you? I’m honestly so confused. It’s her cat. Why is she being spiteful to you? She’s moved house, it’s not stealthy or sneaky. Again, I’m not saying it’s the right move for the cat. But she’s actually done nothing wrong. Maybe she loves her cat.
This.

She moved house and did so at times that suited her so unless she dressed up as a ninja (in which case you wouldn't even know that she had moved... ) you abu even posting this bollox.

Hopefully this experience will put you off trying to steal other people's animals in future but somehow I doubt it and lets face it, from what you've previously posted your track record with your own actual non stolen pets isn't too pretty.

Also the drip drip of 'new info' when you didn't always get the answers you wanted, you were fully intending to steal this cat before you even started this thread.

LoveMyPiano · 23/02/2022 23:53

@Bob0117

You have said you were “robbed” & being dealt with spite. You offered up the story of taking the horse back as if it was justification. You clearly sold him to someone that was not appropriate & that’s fine, you took it back & we all make mistakes. But everyone makes mistake. You’ve said this cat prefers your neighbour, why are you even having this argument? Tbh no one knows what’s going on behind closed doors & everyone agrees cats aren’t loyal. But let’s not shit upon the people that bought a kitten as a pet & it didn’t work out when they’re gonna go where makes them happy anyway 🤷🏼‍♀️
You've ost me now, friend. I'm not quite following you.

I have referenced the experience with the miniature as proof of how far I will go for an animal's welfare. I made the mistake of trusting them, if that's what you mean..... It was not a mistake to take her back.
It is only one example. I have more.

I have NOT said the cat prefers the neighbour, just that animals can be instinctively loyal to the person who "owns" them - even when treated badly - kicked puppy syndrome and all that.
I doubt thatwhen - IF - he walked towards her when she appeared, that he expected to be put into a carrier and taken away.

This cat - no matter WHO owns him - has been taken away from where he is happy and safe, and back into probably and unsafe and unwelcoming and certainly unfamilar environment.

If nothing else, she should have been bloody well thanking us.

OP posts:
Bob0117 · 23/02/2022 23:19

You have said you were “robbed” & being dealt with spite. You offered up the story of taking the horse back as if it was justification. You clearly sold him to someone that was not appropriate & that’s fine, you took it back & we all make mistakes. But everyone makes mistake.
You’ve said this cat prefers your neighbour, why are you even having this argument?
Tbh no one knows what’s going on behind closed doors & everyone agrees cats aren’t loyal. But let’s not shit upon the people that bought a kitten as a pet & it didn’t work out when they’re gonna go where makes them happy anyway 🤷🏼‍♀️

LoveMyPiano · 23/02/2022 23:15

@HeckyPeck

Sorry to hear your update OP.

Hopefully he makes his way safely back home as soon as he can if she continues to neglect him.

Ignore the people sticking the boot in OP.

Whatever you do, there will be people telling you you're wrong.

You made the best decision with the information you had and that's the most any of us can do.

(sigh)

He has gone too far away (Ihought it was closer....) for him to come back. I just feel sad for the upheaval for him, and the new lifestyle that will be forced on him Sad Sad Sad

Of course I know people will have their say, I suppose we can't all be the same... But they are not totally right, and I am not 100% wrong.

OP posts:
LoveMyPiano · 23/02/2022 23:11

@Bob0117

In the stealthy, sneaky way? The original owner has been spiteful to you? I’m honestly so confused. It’s her cat. Why is she being spiteful to you? She’s moved house, it’s not stealthy or sneaky. Again, I’m not saying it’s the right move for the cat. But she’s actually done nothing wrong. Maybe she loves her cat.
Loves her cat?? In what universe is what she has (not) done, demonstrating love or care???

I have not even said that it is - technically - wrong in moving and taking the cat. But honestly, you would have have been there (here) to know why I feel how I do, and have taken the actions that I (we) have over the last few months (and before).

OP posts:
LoveMyPiano · 23/02/2022 23:06

@Bob0117

It’s not your cat. Since your OP you have mentioned selling a horse (to someone who was clearly not appropriate because you STOLE it back) & the original cat owners SEN children & lifestyle. You are not the hero of this story. I appreciate cats will go where they’re welcome. Which this cat has. It still doesn’t give you the right to take someone else’s pet because you feel like you are the superior option. The cat making the choice, fair enough (in all honesty, that’s one of the reasons I’ve never liked cats!) but you still have a decency to her actual owner who chose her & bought her up, because that’s how decency works?!
I did not say I was the "hero". I mentioned that her son is SEN for context; no judgement - he is VERY loud and boisterous, and together with a big untrained dog and at times several kittens - not just the black one who has been left locked in the apratment for months as well, the cat has been bottom of the heap and his demeanour and appearence reflected that. We did not intervene, as the is sadly how his life was. I did have thoughts of involving the RSPCA quite some time ago - since at least before the pandemic.

We TOOK CARE of him when seemingly virtually left behind. I have explained this several times. I did NOT take him, and never would have - although I COULD have concealed him in MY house rather than friend's apartment. But anyway we did not know for sure when she was actually leaving, OR - beieve it or not - she might have (ha ha) actually left him in a familiar place and with us, where he had been completely taken care of for MONTHS.

Again, we have always respected the fact that he is not our cat.

And yes, I "stole" my (& daughter's - age 12 at the time) miniature horse back - although the "stole " part is debatable as they did not pay for her as agreed. So, who actually did the stealing in that situation, do you think? Had they been not incompetent, I might have let them keep her and let the money side go...

I would do it again. And I do not care whether I am seen to be a hero, or not.

OP posts:
Bob0117 · 23/02/2022 23:04

In the stealthy, sneaky way? The original owner has been spiteful to you?
I’m honestly so confused. It’s her cat. Why is she being spiteful to you? She’s moved house, it’s not stealthy or sneaky.
Again, I’m not saying it’s the right move for the cat. But she’s actually done nothing wrong. Maybe she loves her cat.

HeckyPeck · 23/02/2022 22:54

Sorry to hear your update OP.

Hopefully he makes his way safely back home as soon as he can if she continues to neglect him.

Ignore the people sticking the boot in OP.

Whatever you do, there will be people telling you you're wrong.

You made the best decision with the information you had and that's the most any of us can do.

Bob0117 · 23/02/2022 22:49

It’s not your cat.
Since your OP you have mentioned selling a horse (to someone who was clearly not appropriate because you STOLE it back) & the original cat owners SEN children & lifestyle.
You are not the hero of this story.
I appreciate cats will go where they’re welcome. Which this cat has.
It still doesn’t give you the right to take someone else’s pet because you feel like you are the superior option. The cat making the choice, fair enough (in all honesty, that’s one of the reasons I’ve never liked cats!) but you still have a decency to her actual owner who chose her & bought her up, because that’s how decency works?!

Mistressofnone · 23/02/2022 22:18

So sorry and can imagine how hard this must be for you. Maybe if you can find out where she vaguely lives you can have a little look out for the cat to see how he is doing.

Ludo19 · 23/02/2022 22:04

Just read your update OP I'm really so very sorry xx

Floralnomad · 23/02/2022 21:50

Hopefully if she is now living where the actual cat is she will look after it better but frankly you should have kept him in .

TheOccupier · 23/02/2022 21:39

Sad ending but as a real cat lover, I find it infuriating and personally upsetting that despite me and other posters warning you this would happen, and advising you to keep the cat safe until your neighbour was off the scene, you've ignored that and let him be taken off to a less happy life in an unfamiliar place, and now you want sympathy. I will save my sympathy for the poor cat.

LoveMyPiano · 23/02/2022 21:08

@TheMadGardener

So sorry OP.
Thank you Sad

I suppose if we were having to ask her, there was not much chnace really.
Probably some spite in there, I hate to say. Sorry that the little man is caught up in it and am very worried for his care now.

OP posts:
TheMadGardener · 23/02/2022 20:32

So sorry OP.

OnaBegonia · 23/02/2022 19:59

That's very sad and she seems selfish regards the cats, you never know he may turn up.
Then definitely hide him!

LoveMyPiano · 23/02/2022 19:21

@HeckyPeck

I will keep my fingers crossed for you that she does leave him 🤞
Thank you @HeckyPeck - Flowers and all others who were kind, and interested Flowers

He's gone.
She took him, in the sneaky and stealthy way she moved out.
My fault - for "letting him" go out yesterday morning, on his patrol and explorations as usual.

Never responded to our note and offer, and never acknowledged anything that we did for him, which was over the last five months (and before....)

She should have been asking US to keep him (for his sake), not the other way round.

And, having thought about it, it was not about A cat, it was THIS cat.
He seemed to love me (when he felt like it).

SadSadSadSadSad

OP posts:
HeckyPeck · 23/02/2022 17:37

I will keep my fingers crossed for you that she does leave him 🤞