Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Dh is jealous of my parents treating me

581 replies

vbnm89 · 20/02/2022 08:38

My parents are in their late 70's and have had a tough couple of years
My dad isn't well but is doing OK. They enjoy good food and theatre. So a couple of times a year they treat my brother and me to a theatre show and a meal out. My husband doesn't like this - I think it is jealousy- he says it is selfish of my parents to exclude him and my SIL and the grandchildren.

My dh hates eating out and theatre so he wouldn't enjoy it. Obviously this is quite expensive and he says that the money would be better spent on taking us all out for a lunch in harvester and to a theme park/ cinema as they are purposely excluding grandchildren and son and daughter in law.

My parents see us and my brothers family regularly but also enjoy going out and as just the four of us and doing something the four of us enjoy . Dh says he thinks it is very odd that PIL want to spend (in his opinion waste) money on being pretentious and purposely excluding the extended family. I think he is over reacting but he says they are selfish and next time they invite me out I say it is all of us or none of us. My SIL loves these days as she gets my brother out of her way for a day!! Opinions please.

OP posts:
MdNdD · 21/02/2022 21:54

My opinion is that your DH is acting by like a childish twat. He should stop acting like a four year old.

paws17 · 21/02/2022 21:51

*But you expect you to receive the inheritance? Not your PIL bloodline?

You and your DW should have security that if either of you die you're secure. Inheritable is a bonus and you should never need it, because you've arranged your own security to look after your family. Why would you need the inheritance? You should have cover to pay your mortgage and provide whatever else is needed.

So you get your wife's share of the inheritance, meet someone else and decide you're going to leave it to her and not the bloodline DC?

Nope, thats not going to happen with my money.*

With respect, I think you're missing the point here. I'm not expecting any inheritance. However, in the event of my wife's death, I would have become the proxy agent for delivering the love, care and protection to my DW's parents' grandchildren that they would have rightfully expected me to do, given that they had identified my children as next in line heirs to their inheritance. Surely it would be morally right to make direct financial provision for that eventuality to me? To argue that a widowed-spouse is not worthy of support because he's not "bloodline" but, strangely, his children are to be regarded as "bloodline" (and therefore worthy of an inheritance) is short-sighted and horribly divisive, in my view.

MimosaSunrise · 21/02/2022 21:43

Do people who think family means everyone must always be invited think it’s wrong for a parent to spend time separately with different children? Or grandparents spend time with GCs without their children? Do they expect parents to care for partners in exactly the same way as they do their kids? Surely we all recognise that these relationships are conditional as a pp said and is of a very different quality?

BOOTS52 · 21/02/2022 21:37

I think that is really nice that you do things together as the family you used to be and he sees them all the time. He is been controlling and unreasonable especially if he is invited to other things. Just keep seeing your family and do not let him control you. You are only going to a show and dinner not like you are hitting the town and going wild.

Perime · 21/02/2022 21:35

He needs counselling, his childhood seems very sad. It’s not up to you to fix him OP and from what you’ve said the chances of getting him to pay for counselling are slim. You will resent him so much if you listen to him and let this effect your time spent with your parents. Don’t Flowers

hellithurt · 21/02/2022 21:35

@paws17

Stop relying on people to bail you out. They may use all the inheritance in care homes fees or having 15 round the world cruises!

I've no problem with that outcome - It's the deliberate & divisive exclusion of a spouse from the entire picture that I find difficult to stomach.

But you expect you to receive the inheritance? Not your PIL bloodline?

You and your DW should have security that if either of you die you're secure. Inheritable is a bonus and you should never need it, because you've arranged your own security to look after your family. Why would you need the inheritance? You should have cover to pay your mortgage and provide whatever else is needed.

So you get your wife's share of the inheritance, meet someone else and decide you're going to leave it to her and not the bloodline DC?

Nope, thats not going to happen with my money.

Graceambrose · 21/02/2022 21:30

Life too short. I agree to disagree, but respect your opinion.

Whatwouldnanado · 21/02/2022 21:23

Gosh how insecure and weird. If this was my DH I'd be buying chocs for him to share with his folks and wishing them a great night and he'd do the same for me and my dad. Agree with the taking him to something similar, might help knock the chip off his shoulder.

paws17 · 21/02/2022 21:22

Stop relying on people to bail you out. They may use all the inheritance in care homes fees or having 15 round the world cruises!

I've no problem with that outcome - It's the deliberate & divisive exclusion of a spouse from the entire picture that I find difficult to stomach.

LuckySantangelo35 · 21/02/2022 21:21

@Graceambrose lol do you really think in-laws in their 70s one of whom is ill should exchange a trip to theatre and nice meal for harvester and theme park?! Why should they compromise? OPs DF is ill and what he wants should take precedence over DP and the kids. In laws shouldn’t have to be dictated to and forced to compromise for ‘family’

paws17 · 21/02/2022 21:18

@Ibizan

I'm thinking about what would have happened if my wife had died leaving me with two young children to look after by myself.

I bet her parents would have been there through their grief.

BTW, do you plan to give your Children’s spouses a share of your estate so that they won’t feel left out and resentful, and even though you may have no clue that they are in an awful marriage?

I guess I just think it's a shame - and a sign of the times - that parents have to be so defensive & pessimistic about the long-term viability of their children's marriages/relationships. Of course I didn't expect to be included in the will as a direct co-inheritor with my wife, but I would have expected to be entrusted to continue to look after our children properly in the event of my wife's death. I can only be honest about the way I felt about it at the time - and I'm only sharing it to give others who may be interested a deeper insight into the machinations of the male psyche.
Nelliephant1 · 21/02/2022 21:17

I can kind of see where he's coming from. When you marry you're supposed to become part of the family and to be excluded must hurt.

It's definitely thoughtless to say the least.

Graceambrose · 21/02/2022 21:12

It is a case of old family versus new family. Honestly, they should all go out together and compromise on the venue. In the end Family counts and that includes EVERYONE .

NowWhatUsernameShallIHave · 21/02/2022 21:08

Do you think it’s jealousy o or just that he doesn’t want you socialising with anyone apart from him?

What is he like if you go out with friends or other people without him?

Seems quite controlling (like my STBXH)

hellithurt · 21/02/2022 21:08

@paws17 you need to ensure your own family can cope in the event of death or illness!

So let's assume your DW died before her parents, what then? They have to fund you? No! Again have your own cover in place to repay the mortgage and provide a monthly income!

Stop relying on people to bail you out. They may use all the inheritance in care homes fees or having 15 round the world cruises!

Ibizan · 21/02/2022 21:07

This reply has been deleted

Message withdrawn at poster's request.

Cameleongirl · 21/02/2022 21:06

I don't think it usually works like that, paws. My inlaws have three children with spouses and they definitely don't feel the same way about the spouses as they do their children. They like us well enough, because we make their children happy - but it's conditional love, not the unconditional feelings you have for your children.

I know I'd be out in the cold if I made DH unhappy!

MimosaSunrise · 21/02/2022 21:05

It’s not weird or wrong for parents to want to spend time with adult children alone - the idea that a spouse or long term partner is the same as a child in a parent’s eyes is unrealistic. My parents care about my dp of 20 years, but he’s not their son at the end of the day. So sometimes they want to spend time just with me. And frankly, even if they did love him as much as me, it is nice to spend time with people on their own sometimes. Like how I might spend time with my dad on my own without my mum. Or my dad might do something with my brother and not me.

I find it sad that people find op’s parents controlling and whatever else for wanting to spend some time just with their adult dc.

LuckySantangelo35 · 21/02/2022 21:03

@Graceambrose
But just because you get married and have kids doesn’t mean that you stop being a person in your own right! Being a wife and mother doesn’t mean that OP stops being her parents daughter. You don’t get chained to the kitchen sink when you become a wife/mother, incapable of going out without your husband and kids you know.

Do you genuinely believe that OP’s parents are being selfish and unnecessary in treating their children to the kind of outing which her husband doesn’t even like/doesn’t agree with, especially when one of them is terminally ill? Really?

paws17 · 21/02/2022 21:01

[quote hellithurt]@paws17 you should've had term assurance and family income benefit in place! You've got children and no cover? [/quote]
Yes, of course - but surely I was "family" - and both of my own parents had already died early & so it was already known to everyone that I didn't have any inheritance of my own to look forward to.

Cameleongirl · 21/02/2022 21:00

@paws17 That's what life insurance is for. Both DH and I insured ourselves up to the hilt when we started our family! It would give the surviving spouse time to sort themselves out financially.

Graceambrose · 21/02/2022 20:58

No not joking. I guess it is a Mars and Venus thing. Can't help it.

hellithurt · 21/02/2022 20:55

@paws17 you should've had term assurance and family income benefit in place! You've got children and no cover?

paws17 · 21/02/2022 20:54

[quote Cameleongirl]@paws17. You’re winding us up, aren’t you? Why on earth would you expect to be included in their wills?? I 100% know that spouses aren’t included in my in-laws wills-because DH is an executor and has copies. Same on my side. Even though we all have long marriages at this point.[/quote]
I'm thinking about what would have happened if my wife had died leaving me with two young children to look after by myself.

Barmychick · 21/02/2022 20:54

Silly silly jealous little person.