Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Just fuck off with this fucking war shit.

256 replies

NaiceHamAndHugs · 19/02/2022 22:19

Why as humans do we never ever learn? It’s always about testosterone and power and oil.

Fuck off with. Why was it possible for so many countries to pull together when COVID kicked off and now it’s back to slapping their balls on the table to see who has the biggest set.

It just all so unbelievably depressing.

OP posts:
Wulfenite · 20/02/2022 03:02

It is a man thing imo. Women are just less biologically programmed to fight each other. And a lot of the shitty women leaders there've been through history had to go by a patriarchal playbook to get/stay in power at all. That's not to say women can't be bad people obviously. But less inclined to violence on the whole.

I think there's a lot of countries around the world that haven't experienced much unity or co-operation from others over covid.

Pyewhacket · 20/02/2022 02:54

Everything Boris is saying things to hype it up is just an attempt to cling on to his job. The sooner he goes the better. If he was in charge during a real WW the whole country would be bankrupt by the end of it.

You need to read some history books and stop your political prejudice affecting your brain coz at the end of the last WW we were totally broke. In fact the only country to strengthen their financial position was the Americans.

The current situation is totally down to Putin and the comments Boris made came from a joint briefing with Biden. Personally I like to be kept informed as a war on that scale would send shockwaves right through the international community and send energy prices sky high, which is what Putin wants. And the last person I'd have any confidence in if there was conflict would that be Starmer. He'd do exactly what the Europeans told him to do, only as the Germans are totally reliant on Russian Gas would probably entail him apologising to Putin for being part of NATO.

Tealightsandd · 20/02/2022 02:36

Russia illegally annexed the Crimea

The situation is not the same but like NI, it isn't as simple as good/right vs bad/wrong. Crimea has a very large ethnic Russian population.

It's complicated. And goes back a long way.

I'm not saying 'yay Russia'. It's just that it's a very old and messy and complicated history of tensions. And us/Boris (no doubt clumsily) wading in won't likely help.

But also, where's the money coming from, for us to get involved? We're told we haven't got enough for social care, the NHS, pensions, the disabled. We can't afford a war.

Tealightsandd · 20/02/2022 02:30

Lots of conflicts going on round the world that we don't get involved with. As Blair's Iraq adventure shows, wading into the middle of other people's (complex) issues doesn't generally make things better.

People should look up the history of the Russia Ukraine region. This is a conflict and tensions that go back a long way. And I don't mean just since 1945 (or even 1845). You'll see too how the 'good' guy can swap into the "bad' one at different points of time (Ukraine has a messy relationship with WW2 nazi support, but then they suffered from USSR actions. It's not a simple black and white, good vs bad history).

Another war - particularly an international one won't solve this centuries old conflict.

And actually, not always, but leaders of all types - including dictators - can and have done diplomacy. It doesn't matter if somebody is a good guy or the 'baddie'. Self interest and pragmatism is not the preserve of the 'good guys'.

Whether diplomacy will work in this case is another matter.

knitnerd90 · 20/02/2022 02:18

That Mearsheimer video is about the 2014 crisis, not this one.

TBH though I don't think sabre-rattling from Biden and Johnson is helpful, this is not the west's fault. Putin is playing the blame game--"you're making me abuse you".

Russia illegally annexed the Crimea and effectively controls the Donbas region though puppet separatist states. What this is really about is that Putin, and other right-wing Russians, do not believe in the legitimacy of the Ukrainian state and people. This has long roots in Russian history.

FrecklesMalone · 20/02/2022 02:10

Just don't forget Johnson is a cunt and this is the perfect distraction for him. He will go to war and risk the lives of innocent people as soon if it means he isn't fired

TheresSomebodyAtTheDoorNeil · 20/02/2022 02:09

Depends on the woman........ Thatcher did her fair share of boob waving if I remember correctly.

Lets face it most politicians are narcissistic arseholes so whoever's running the show will wave whatever's to hand and won't stop until theyre satisfied the small chunk of land they're in charge of is suitably fucked up.

Justgivemewine · 20/02/2022 02:02

@Sunwillcomeout

100% agree. utterly, painfully, pathetic.
This^^ Just so pathetic
givethatbabyaname · 20/02/2022 01:43

I had been viewing this as sabre-rattling by Putin. He does it periodically. But I’ve been wondering why now, and I think it’s to do with Germany. Merkel would have pulled the EU, NATO and (if she’d been bothered, because I don’t think it would make much difference either way these days) the U.K. together in a single, unified force militarily, diplomatically, economically. That’s a lot for Russia to stand up to. Russia is getting close to China but there’s still a long way to go before that relationship is strong and secure. Russia would still be alone against all of the developed Western world and she needs to build her credentials if she’s looking at a partnership with China.

Schulz isn’t capable of doing a Merkel. Tbf to him he’s only had the job for two minutes, but this is the weakness. Germany gets 80% of its natural gas from Russia (not it’s only energy source though), and Russia wants to extend those pipelines throughout continental Europe to secure energy dependency. (The US is shipping natural gas over but there’s no way it can provide by sea the sheer volume required by Germany.) Russia has to pass through the Ukraine to do that. The Ukraine is merely in Russia’s way, and far from being a benevolent grandparent Russia sees the Ukraine as an annoying truanting teenager it needs to handle and train to do its bidding. Once through the Ukraine, it’s but a Russian hop, skip and jump into the EU heartland. Crimea was a foreshadowing of what Russia has planned (its access to sea trading, rather than energy in that case).

I think this could end up being more than sabre-rattling. Biden, Johnson, Schulz - they’re all weak, at home and internationally. Biden is the only one with any experience of high-level, international statesmanship - the man can’t get through a press conference on home territory without messing up. Macron had a go but c’mon, he’s young enough to have Putin for a dad and so naive I think he’s actually terrified of Putin as an individual. It’s a perfect storm for Putin. If he can’t win this thing now, with these muppets as his opponents….well, he’s going to look a tool going up to China, isn’t he? I have a horrible feeling he’s going to make a go of this.

Those poor people.

Rhannion · 20/02/2022 01:33

It’s like North Korea, lots of noise & men grandstanding but I honestly don’t think they will invade.

Rhannion · 20/02/2022 01:30

The Russia people like to be liked, they don’t want any wars either.

Tiddlesthecat · 20/02/2022 01:15

What I find shocking is how these men end up in power, the worst sort of human beings, then people are powerless to get rid of them. It comes back to the silent majority who become frozen to act. Although arguably not as bad, I would say that Boris is another example of an egotistical leader whom has no sense of shame and choses to ignore public criticism.

RedToothBrush · 20/02/2022 01:12

What are the non willy-wavers proposing? Maybe take a casserole and ‘have a bit of a chat’ with his mum?

What patronising, embarrassing piffle this thread is.

Well im glad someone is saying it.

The trouble here is someone is lining up his tanks and has started a false flag operation.

Do you think he's really interested in talking, other than for the purposes of delaying the west from taking it seriously.

Look at hostorical precedence. Democracies never take the threats of aggressive dictators seriously. Why? Because war is too awful for them to contemplate because lots of their citizens will day.

And therein lies the rub. Dictators don't mind if lots of their citizens die if it gets the job done because humans are disposable.

Failure to understand this dynamic is where you get multiple countries invaded before Democracies get their head out of their arse and think 'hmm' can't ignore this any longer.

Ionlydomassiveones · 20/02/2022 00:58

This reply has been withdrawn

This has been withdrawn at the poster's request.

IrishMama2015 · 20/02/2022 00:57

The irony of the British government wanting to support a small nation that's in danger of being invaded by its larger neighbour who wants to colonise them and wipe out their way of living......rolls eyes in Ireland 🇮🇪

pollyglot · 20/02/2022 00:56

Youcan'ttourniquetthetaint "Putin's is a sad. flaccid little maggot" - you made my day!

RedToothBrush · 20/02/2022 00:56

@AlexaShutUp

I can't stand Putin but I don't think Biden or Boris are helping the situation either. I said to DH earlier that we would have far less of this sort of nonsense if more women were in power. His comment was that Kamala Harris doesn't seem to be doing anything to tone down Joe Biden. He has a point.

Surely a diplomatic solution would be possible if they worked hard enough. I actually think Boris quite relishes the idea of a conflict. It would distract from all his other woes and I think he quite fancies himself as a great wartime leader. Hmm

He is a dictator. They don't do diplomacy.

The whole point is you can't reason with a dictator if theyve decided they want to do something.

Tabbacous · 20/02/2022 00:45

@AlexaShutUp

Fuck off with your patronising comments *@Tabbacous*. You might be buying into all the willy waving, but some of us would prefer a more grown up approach.
The irony of referring to a grown up approach when going on about willy waving. How about you grow up and read up on the situation- if you don't buy into countries coming together to support the Ukraine if things esculate than that's pretty sad. There is no diplomatic approach here as there hasn't been for the past few decades. And it's not just Boris and Biden, its the entirety of NATO and in fact most of the international community.
KloppsTeeth · 20/02/2022 00:45

100% agree. Ordinary people will suffer yet again, families seeing death and disaster, and for what? Absolutely nothing at the end of the day, except power, greed and money. Makes me sick.

sarah13xx · 20/02/2022 00:41

I was just thinking this the other day. I really feel if this all kicks off we’re going to end up pulled into it too 🤦🏼‍♀️ We have Boris who doesn’t even know if he was at his own party representing us here, I’m so embarrassed that we’re stood behind him 😭

AlexaShutUp · 20/02/2022 00:38

Fuck off with your patronising comments @Tabbacous. You might be buying into all the willy waving, but some of us would prefer a more grown up approach.

SomePosters · 20/02/2022 00:36

The bbc stirring up fear and alarm… what are they trying to distract us from now?

ThatsNotMyGolem · 20/02/2022 00:30

Men. It's men.

Tabbacous · 20/02/2022 00:30

@AlexaShutUp

I can't stand Putin but I don't think Biden or Boris are helping the situation either. I said to DH earlier that we would have far less of this sort of nonsense if more women were in power. His comment was that Kamala Harris doesn't seem to be doing anything to tone down Joe Biden. He has a point.

Surely a diplomatic solution would be possible if they worked hard enough. I actually think Boris quite relishes the idea of a conflict. It would distract from all his other woes and I think he quite fancies himself as a great wartime leader. Hmm

Just Boris and Biden eh? Diplomatic resolution with Russia? Say you don't know anything about it without telling us.
Tilltheend99 · 20/02/2022 00:26

And a point about the pro-Kremlin peeps on here.

Putin has literally been poring money and energy into flooding social media with propaganda via the ‘opinions’ of bots in his bot farms. This is sadly why so many working class British people spout tripe about how great he is.

On news websites like The Guardian half the comments come from fake accounts with opinions that don’t even relate to the topic in the article.

Swipe left for the next trending thread