Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Just fuck off with this fucking war shit.

256 replies

NaiceHamAndHugs · 19/02/2022 22:19

Why as humans do we never ever learn? It’s always about testosterone and power and oil.

Fuck off with. Why was it possible for so many countries to pull together when COVID kicked off and now it’s back to slapping their balls on the table to see who has the biggest set.

It just all so unbelievably depressing.

OP posts:
NETSRIK · 20/02/2022 09:39

And what makes it worse is that our chief willy waver is a liar of a PM who can't even be honest about parties and now he is getting involved in this. What a joke.

ollehto · 20/02/2022 09:36

Mrs Thatcher then had the Belgrano sunk to ensure there would be no negotiated withdrawal, it was an argentinian WW2 ship that was outside of the exclusion zone and sailing away from the islands.

Not the old outside the exclusion zone chestnut.

Exclusion zones are for the benefit of neutral vessels, not those belonging to countries at war. The captain of the Belgrano agrees his ship was a legitimate target, as did the Argentine government in 1994.

Though the ship was outside the 200-mile exclusion zone, both sides understood that this was no longer the limit of British action — on 23 April a message was passed via the Swiss Embassy in Buenos Aires to the Argentine government, it read:

“In announcing the establishment of a Maritime Exclusion Zone around the Falkland Islands, Her Majesty’s Government made it clear that this measure was without prejudice to the right of the United Kingdom to take whatever additional measures may be needed in the exercise of its right of self-defence under Article 51 of the United Nations Charter.

In this connection Her Majesty’s Government now wishes to make clear that any approach on the part of Argentine warships, including submarines, naval auxiliaries or military aircraft, which could amount to a threat to interfere with the mission of British Forces in the South Atlantic will encounter the appropriate response.

All Argentine aircraft, including civil aircraft engaged in surveillance of these British forces, will be regarded as hostile and are liable to be dealt with accordingly.”

Adastraperaspera · 20/02/2022 09:34

@travellinglighter- agree with everything you say.
Recent antics in Afghanistan showed the Russians how weak US and Europe are currently. Brexit caused another big rift. However, I think the Germans need to do more in terms of security keeping. They are a powerful country.
Another issue is China. Europe and US need to improve relationships there as well. It is another weakness Putin is banking on.

ParsleySageRosemary · 20/02/2022 09:33

Talking about this in terms of Russia and the grievances of a would-be empire on one hand v USA on the other with maybe a bit of U.K. is playing straight into Putin’s hands.

This is about Eastern Europe and the many peoples there who want to maintain their sovereignty in the face of Russian aggression.

I’m surprised there haven’t been some info in the media about the long running history of the region: I’ve seen more background about Yemen.

Tabbacous · 20/02/2022 09:33

@ivykaty44

None of this current situation is the fault of the West.

Really? www.thecable.ng/issues-in-the-russia-nato-face-off-on-ukraine

Guarantees were given so why are NATO backtracking on this?

Ukraine isn't eligible to join NATO at the moment anyway, anything is far from imminent despite being in their constitution and being a lite member of sorts. They also have aspirations to join the EU but are also not eligible currently. So what are NATO backtracking on, seen as though they haven't developed an action plan or promised to let them into the fold?
ivykaty44 · 20/02/2022 09:24

And in backtracking on this they knew full well what the outcome would be…so hardly faultless

ivykaty44 · 20/02/2022 09:23

None of this current situation is the fault of the West.

Really? www.thecable.ng/issues-in-the-russia-nato-face-off-on-ukraine

Guarantees were given so why are NATO backtracking on this?

travellinglighter · 20/02/2022 09:18

@dangerrabbit

Military industrial complex.

Britain is largest exporter of weapons in the world and needs them to be used so they can sell more.

Not even in the top 5 and neither Ukraine or Russia use significant amounts of U.K. weaponry.

On the subject, people seem to think this is a plot somehow aimed at the west but it’s actually done to curry favour with the his own population. Russia seems to love a strong leader. There history shows that when the Czar’s eased up a bit on their brutal tactics it opened the door communism and led to the rise of Stalin who actually killed more people in concentration camps than Hitler.

Russians see the Ukraine as part of Russia and will welcome it back into the fold and see it as some sort of sign that Russia is coming back to its position as a superpower. The reality is they’re a second sate power with a one trick pony economy.

As for what we do. Putin chose this time for a very simple reason. We can’t do much. Sanctions is about it. If we had known this was coming even a couple of years ago we could have done something. As it is with Western economies recovering from covid and Germany dependant on Russian gas. We can target and seize Russian assets in the name of sanctions and embargo the Nordstrom 2 pipeline but that’s it.

Once again, I think at a deeper level the west is to blame. When the Cold War ended we could have rushed in to help the Russian economy. We could have banned western companies from doing business with the gangsters who seized large chunks of the Russian state for its own ends. We didn’t and in fact the U.K. embraced the oligarchs and the money they brought. We sold them large chunks of our own assets. Our political parties took donations and the Tory party in particular seems to be bought and paid for. They have interfered in our elections and they appear to have largely bankrolled the Brexit campaign.

It’s a sad state of affairs and Ukraine will pay the price.

TheresaApril · 20/02/2022 09:16

What worst and best case scenarios are we looking at here? And out of these what's the more likely development?

Just fuck off with this fucking war shit
Op, I 100% agree with you. Sad

GabriellaMontez · 20/02/2022 09:15

Countries pulled together? The rich got richer, the poor were shafted and many of the vulnerable fell through the cracks.

ivykaty44 · 20/02/2022 09:13

Sure Russia is toxic but the West, the EU, especially Germany and the US aren't exactly peace keeping, sharing, sweet, selfless players, are they?

Watching interviews with Putin, it’s clear he portrays NATO as the aggressive force in this and his stance is I’m not going to just roll over in the matter of you putting forces in Ukraine

I doubt if France started pointing weapons at U.K. we’d be to happy and also put in place forces on our boarder

www.reuters.com/world/europe/putin-oversee-nuclear-drills-ukraine-crisis-mounts-2022-02-19/ Strangely no mention of biggest war since 1945

What’s more worrying in all this is what NATO decide to do as they could well be them that escalate this and start WW3

notimagain · 20/02/2022 09:12

@JackieWeaverHandforthCouncil

Absolutely agree to both posts.

turbonerd · 20/02/2022 09:11

I think the West has a good, coherent plan of action. So it seems at least.
There have been diplomatic talks (attempts at talks) with Putin by nearly all the heads og state in Europe and US. Putin has rejected any de-escalation, and has escalated to nearly 200 000 troops on the border to Ukraine + in Belarus (which is North of the Ukraine and brodering Poland).
This is in top of the engineered refugee situation on the border of Poland/Belarus in the autumn.

Biden, Johnson et al are doing the necessary job of calling out Russia’s plans in order to avoid a «repeat» of 1938 where Germany claimed Poland attacked and then merrily annexed huge swathes of east Europe before anyone got around to react

JackieWeaverHandforthCouncil · 20/02/2022 09:03

As much as I dislike Boris. None of this current situation is the fault of the West. Allowing Ukraine to fall is madness and the Russians won’t stop there. Europe needs to find alternative energy sources to reduce reliance on Russia.

JackieWeaverHandforthCouncil · 20/02/2022 09:01

I think going on about women in this situation is quite naive.

We are dealing with a dictator who needs/wants war. Instead of focusing his and his cronies billions in stolen cash on helping his people, he uses it to agitate and destabilise more successful countries.

Putin is the aggressor and is almost impossible to reason with. Westerners who support him believing him to be some right wing string man hero are deluded and dangerous fools. Powerful people who’ve possibly been corrupted by Russia need to be looked at closely such as Dominic Cummings who spent 4 unexplained years in Moscow building an airline which didn’t come to fruition.

TheresaApril · 20/02/2022 09:01

@ivykaty44

I had been viewing this as sabre-rattling by Putin.

Really? And you don’t think that there has been any goading of Russia,

The amount of sheer propaganda printed in MSM like the BBC headlines “the biggest war since 1945…

How to encite a population against Russia and click bait makes money also distracting a voting population from things happening much closer to home

I agree with this.

I also feel very sorry for all the children at my dc's school who are from Ukraine, Russia and nearby areas. I hope they won't feel the fallout because of growing hostility and suspicion.

Sure Russia is toxic but the West, the EU, especially Germany and the US aren't exactly peace keeping, sharing, sweet, selfless players, are they?

blanketyblanked · 20/02/2022 09:00

I just can't imagine women going to war, if we were in power. Machiavellian tactics, yes. Sacrificing countless lives of soldiers and civilians..... No

TheresaApril · 20/02/2022 08:58

@FourChimneys

Anyone else wish more women were in charge of the world? There would be far less willy waving for a start.
No, not really, some of the most competitive and psychologically destructive people I have encountered were actually women.
ArseInTheCoOpWindow · 20/02/2022 08:57

I remember reading in here somebody saying ‘old white men make wars which kill women, young men and children’ so true.

And l also remember somebody saying if men had to look after a couple of toddlers single handedly there’d be no wars.

Sick of this posturing and strutting.

ivykaty44 · 20/02/2022 08:52

I had been viewing this as sabre-rattling by Putin.

Really? And you don’t think that there has been any goading of Russia,

The amount of sheer propaganda printed in MSM like the BBC headlines “the biggest war since 1945…

How to encite a population against Russia and click bait makes money also distracting a voting population from things happening much closer to home

RedToothBrush · 20/02/2022 08:52

@gogohm

Has a whiff of 1914 about it to me, almost like nations are gagging for it. I hope it's actually reverse diplomacy, trying to keep putin from acting by calling him out, whether it works is unlikely.

My dd is is in armed forces, she's had briefings and whilst she isn't, many people she knows are on standby or been recalled from U.K. based training and deployed - I should add this is precautionary, it's meant to be a show of strength to say don't you dare Russia!

Its got whiffs of 1914 and 1938 about it.

I feel very very uneasy about it.

Theres been talk that we've been at war with Russia for a while now - the conflict in Syria has put us directly up against Russia at times via proxy. Its been managed diplomatically. We have also had a disinformation war going on, and there has been significant attempts to influence high profile politicians throughout the West in an underhanded way - either through compromising them or buying them.

I don't like what is happening with China either. They are developing weapons and theres talk of them invading taiwan within 2 years. And Russia and China are very much becoming closer.

Putin also has a sizeable amount of disharmony at home. Patronism and a good old fashioned war is a good way to crush concerns about covid and liberal thought. He is technically only supposed to serve so many terms under law. So there needs to be a way to keep him long term.

Stuff like making russias internet completely separate to the rest of the world, is about stopping western influence and keeping control but its also useful in a war scenario. Russia has also worked hard on food self sufficiency over a number of years - in part because sanctions and border controls have forced it, but also because its strategically sensible.

Its been said for a number of years, even prior to the annexing of crimea that P1utin wanted 'to return Russia to the glory of what it was'.

None of this happened over night. Theres been a movement to this point over years - dictators can have 20 year plans in ways that democracies dont.

Im extremely worried. My sense is one of panic and running around like headless chickens by the west who simply don't know what to do.

Thats probably exactly what Putin is sensing.

Abhannmor · 20/02/2022 08:49

I used to believe that too , as in the song by Ivor Cutler? But I've had my eyes opened since Iraq. Plenty of women warheads - and torturers indeed.

littledrummergirl · 20/02/2022 08:46

It's being talked up by Biden and Johnson in a futile attempt to gain popularity. They want to be seen as knights on horseback saving the Ukrainian people from the evil Russians.

It doesn't matter what the expense is, they can borrow money to pay for it no matter what the interest rate. In fact, the higher the better for those lending the money.
I would love to know the facts around the pandemic borrowing as well but I digress.

War (and pandemics) have always been a way for the rich to get richer, the cost being human lives.

Tabbacous · 20/02/2022 08:42

@gogohm

Has a whiff of 1914 about it to me, almost like nations are gagging for it. I hope it's actually reverse diplomacy, trying to keep putin from acting by calling him out, whether it works is unlikely.

My dd is is in armed forces, she's had briefings and whilst she isn't, many people she knows are on standby or been recalled from U.K. based training and deployed - I should add this is precautionary, it's meant to be a show of strength to say don't you dare Russia!

To put into perspective though, Russia has more troops positioned on the border than we have military personnel in total across all branches. Russia also has decent tech and their cyber capabilities are arguably better than ours so it's not just boots on the ground but also they aren't lagging wildly behind in areas we would typically have an advantage with. Along with the rest of NATO it's a show of power, which is exactly why we should be supporting a country like Ukraine who doesn't have that backing.
Benjispruce5 · 20/02/2022 08:40

Can someone who knows more, explain what is going on? I don’t have time to research.What is Putin doing if not planning on invading Ukraine?