Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Child’s photo edited.

162 replies

Mom201 · 19/02/2022 21:22

Hi all.

Just want advice on if I am being over sensitive.

My DD was born nearly 3 years ago. She is the only Great Grandchild my Grandma met before she sadly died (RIP). She was the apple of her eye and a typical loving Grandma.

My sister had her son not long after my Grandma died.

My issue here is a photo. It happens it be my favourite photo - the first time Great Grandma met my DD. It has been taken without my permission, shared to a stranger and edited. Edited that my DD was removed and a photo of my DN inserted. This was then given as a present to my sister and I found out from good old social media (another whole issue with our families). I would like to add it was a family friend that did this - possibly in with another sisters input.

Not at any time was I asked or considered with this, even with the finding out.

Am I being too sensitive to the photo? The scenario? The disrespect? The sharing it with a stranger?
I don’t know if I am angry or sad about it. It’s a lovely photo but it’s the lead up to it. I don’t know where that photo has been sent too and such a precious memory to me has been taken and used.

OP posts:
Gensola · 19/02/2022 22:53

This is so creepy and delusional! Anyone who edits a dead person into a photo needs some serious therapy Confused

DeadButDelicious · 19/02/2022 22:53

That is really weird. I wouldn't like that at all. Especially the underhanded way they've gone about it.

GlendaSugarbeanIsJudgingYou · 19/02/2022 22:52

@BearOfEasttown

On a slightly different tangent, but similar. (Altering/manipulating pics...)

This 'false image' shit puts me in mind of my friend's DH. She was always around 11 stone and a size 12-14 before having a baby, but was around the 13-14 stone mark a few months after having him. (And a size 18.)

The weight stayed with her, and several years after the birth of her son, she had a photo taken standing at the top of a hill she and her DH climbed. She was a size 18, and 13 and a half stone.

When they got home, her DH got the photo up on the computer and 'thin-ified' it. Took her waist and arms and thighs in by about 2-4 inches to make her look about 2 stone lighter. Shock

She said 'what the hell did you do that for?' Hmm He said 'just seeing what you'd look like...' 'look like if what?' she said... 'well just messing about, that's all,' he said. NO explanation at all.

Clearly he wanted her to be thinner. He said 'you can print this off and send it to your extended family 100s of miles away, and your penpals too. She said 'what the fuck? I don't look like this, so why would I?' Hmm

He literally did not GET why she was fucking fuming. Amazingly they're still together! Shock (10 years later!) And SHE is still a size 18 and 13 and a half stone. And gorgeous!

Okay, I'm horrified.

I'm going to continue to be horrified by that story all night.

musicmadnessnumber57806 · 19/02/2022 22:52

I just find it really odd that people are happy to have photos of events that never happened Confused

cuno · 19/02/2022 22:50

@Phobiaphobic

How in god's name do one third of people voting on this thread think this is okay?
They're probably the ones commissioning these kinds of photos.
saraclara · 19/02/2022 22:47

It is just well known in the family this is my favourite. The first meeting. I even have the clothes she was wearing in the photo to make a memory bear with for DD.

Then yes, it was absolutely wrong of the person who organised this to do so without asking you first. Have you spoken to them?

BearOfEasttown · 19/02/2022 22:46

@TonksInPurple

There seems to be a weird craze for this just now editing together pictures with people who have passed away and someone who either never met them or never knew them at the age they are now in the photo.
Really? I haven't seen it myself. Although, as a pp said, I have seen people edit pics of their deceased loved one, so they are walking towards their deceased dog in Heaven...
TonksInPurple · 19/02/2022 22:44

There seems to be a weird craze for this just now editing together pictures with people who have passed away and someone who either never met them or never knew them at the age they are now in the photo.

poTAYtoes · 19/02/2022 22:43

I think YABU. I can see why it might seem weird and annoying that they didn't ask, but it doesn't have to change your memory. You still have that memory and that photo. Your child was the one who actually met your grandmother. The other photo is just wishful thinking. It was perhaps not in the best taste to edit out your child, but I'd imagine it wasn't done spitefully. Maybe that was just the easiest, most realistic way to put the other child into the photo.

I think I'd try to let this go and pretend it doesn't exist. Hold on to your memories. There's no reason this should make your own photo any less precious to you, especially since yours is a photo of something that actually happened.

BearOfEasttown · 19/02/2022 22:43

On a slightly different tangent, but similar. (Altering/manipulating pics...)

This 'false image' shit puts me in mind of my friend's DH. She was always around 11 stone and a size 12-14 before having a baby, but was around the 13-14 stone mark a few months after having him. (And a size 18.)

The weight stayed with her, and several years after the birth of her son, she had a photo taken standing at the top of a hill she and her DH climbed. She was a size 18, and 13 and a half stone.

When they got home, her DH got the photo up on the computer and 'thin-ified' it. Took her waist and arms and thighs in by about 2-4 inches to make her look about 2 stone lighter. Shock

She said 'what the hell did you do that for?' Hmm He said 'just seeing what you'd look like...' 'look like if what?' she said... 'well just messing about, that's all,' he said. NO explanation at all.

Clearly he wanted her to be thinner. He said 'you can print this off and send it to your extended family 100s of miles away, and your penpals too. She said 'what the fuck? I don't look like this, so why would I?' Hmm

He literally did not GET why she was fucking fuming. Amazingly they're still together! Shock (10 years later!) And SHE is still a size 18 and 13 and a half stone. And gorgeous!

AcrossthePond55 · 19/02/2022 22:42

I'd find it a bit morbid, tbh. Sort of like those old momento mori photos where a 'ghost' of the deceased was superimposed on a photo of living relatives.

There's nothing you can do about it without raising a big stink though. But I do think that every time I saw it or someone mentioned it I'd say "Oh yes, the photo where 'Mary' was photoshopped out and 'Bobby' was photoshopped in" in as neutral a tone as possible.

BearOfEasttown · 19/02/2022 22:42

@Phobiaphobic

How in god's name do one third of people voting on this thread think this is okay?
Batshit hour is upon us!
EllaB22 · 19/02/2022 22:42

It is a very strange thing to go!

Mom201 · 19/02/2022 22:42

I don’t resent the photo. It is nice. I feel for my DN that one day he will be told that it’s not real, someone chopped your cousin out and put you in.
If that’s there thing, let them carry on.

DH lost his Grandma just before falling pregnant - he would never see photoshopping DD on a picture as normal (to us). He see’s it as they never met, it’s on him to teach her about Grandma rather than make it look like they had met and create a false memory.

My sister receiving it never knew about it and then shared it to social media after receiving it as the best thing ever.

I was never once asked - even if it was just a courtesy conversation. I was once part of a conversation too discussing the ‘present’ whereby it could have easily been said to me but was obviously avoided so I would not know in advance.

I have many many photos with them together. It is just well known in the family this is my favourite. The first meeting. I even have the clothes she was wearing in the photo to make a memory bear with for DD.

Whilst I see it can be normal to other people, it’s not normal to me and obviously our photo/memory. But I think from reading the replies it is more the slyness of it I am angry about, not the actual photo.
I’m 100% happy I have the original, I have the memory imprinted in my head, I have the story to tell around it happening. It’s the scenario around it.

OP posts:
BearOfEasttown · 19/02/2022 22:42

@Seema1234

I wouldn't get upset about this as it's all types of batshit that it's almost funny. I mean, who does this stuff ??

Fast forward 20 years ' Here's a picture of you with your granny. She died in 2019.' '

'what do you mean 2019? I was born in 2020'.

' Yes that's right dear. You never actually met her, we edited a photo to make it look like you did .' Confused It's the kind of stuff you read in Bella magazine. Grin totally batshit OP. I'd just nod and ignore these loons.

Grin
Lindy2 · 19/02/2022 22:40

So they basically photoshopped a photo of your Grandma that they had.

I have to say it's not to my taste but I can't see how it really impacts on you. You still have your copy of the photo. The original that has a special meaning to you.

Another photoshopped version is a bit tacky but if your sister actually likes it then fine - she was her Grandma too.

Phobiaphobic · 19/02/2022 22:40

How in god's name do one third of people voting on this thread think this is okay?

Seema1234 · 19/02/2022 22:39

I wouldn't get upset about this as it's all types of batshit that it's almost funny. I mean, who does this stuff ??

Fast forward 20 years ' Here's a picture of you with your granny. She died in 2019.' '

'what do you mean 2019? I was born in 2020'.

' Yes that's right dear. You never actually met her, we edited a photo to make it look like you did .' Confused It's the kind of stuff you read in Bella magazine. Grin totally batshit OP. I'd just nod and ignore these loons.

shivawn · 19/02/2022 22:39

This is quite common in photoshop groups on Facebook, people asking for persons to be inserted in to photos of dead family members.....I don't get it myself, photos are for memories not fake scenes that never happened. I'd just shrug it off as being as bit weird and sad OP. I doubt they intended to cause offence.

Thewindwhispers · 19/02/2022 22:37

Yanbu. Someone got hold of your fave pic, which is of your child meeting her great grandma, then deleted your child and inserted another. That is very weird and disrespectful to you and your child.

I’d be upset and v offended and having words with whoever did it.

BearOfEasttown · 19/02/2022 22:35

@cuno

What a bizarre take. Lots of stuff has no "impact" on real life... except it does. It shows you, in this instance, someone's complete disregard for your own personal memories and lack of respect for you, your child and your boundaries.

They didn't even ask first, so even if you happened to be okay with it (most people wouldn't, it's abnormal), then they didn't care either way. Which tells you a lot about the person who did this.

This. ^

autienotnaughty · 19/02/2022 22:35

Weird as fuck and yes I'd be annoyed.

BearOfEasttown · 19/02/2022 22:33

[quote AskingforaBaskin]@QuillBill no I don't. The original and digitalis still exist. She didn't destroy anything. It has no impact in real life at all. [/quote]
Are you for real? Confused

The OP is freaked out and upset (understandably) AND most of the posters think it's as weird as fuck.

I think it's weird that you DON'T think it's weird!

Buttons294749 · 19/02/2022 22:33

Fucking weird, creepy and odd but yabu to be upset. You have the actual pic, your child is not in the "new" pic,

cuno · 19/02/2022 22:33

[quote AskingforaBaskin]@QuillBill no I don't. The original and digitalis still exist. She didn't destroy anything. It has no impact in real life at all. [/quote]
What a bizarre take. Lots of stuff has no "impact" on real life... except it does. It shows you, in this instance, someone's complete disregard for your own personal memories and lack of respect for you, your child and your boundaries. They didn't even ask first, so even if you happened to be okay with it (most people wouldn't, it's abnormal), then they didn't care either way. Which tells you a lot about the person who did this.

Swipe left for the next trending thread