Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Child’s photo edited.

162 replies

Mom201 · 19/02/2022 21:22

Hi all.

Just want advice on if I am being over sensitive.

My DD was born nearly 3 years ago. She is the only Great Grandchild my Grandma met before she sadly died (RIP). She was the apple of her eye and a typical loving Grandma.

My sister had her son not long after my Grandma died.

My issue here is a photo. It happens it be my favourite photo - the first time Great Grandma met my DD. It has been taken without my permission, shared to a stranger and edited. Edited that my DD was removed and a photo of my DN inserted. This was then given as a present to my sister and I found out from good old social media (another whole issue with our families). I would like to add it was a family friend that did this - possibly in with another sisters input.

Not at any time was I asked or considered with this, even with the finding out.

Am I being too sensitive to the photo? The scenario? The disrespect? The sharing it with a stranger?
I don’t know if I am angry or sad about it. It’s a lovely photo but it’s the lead up to it. I don’t know where that photo has been sent too and such a precious memory to me has been taken and used.

OP posts:
StarsAndSugarlumps · 20/02/2022 00:34

Genealogists of the future are going to be pissed…

@NoSquirrels you always have a fantastic way of summing things up!

saraclara · 20/02/2022 00:29

Or would you like 99.9% of people have thought 'that is fucking insane'

I suspect you're being naive there @AmyDudley. I bet there are far more people than you and I would be comfortable with, who'd actually love that.

AmyDudley · 20/02/2022 00:16

I don;t understand why people say 'it's a lovely photo of them together' - it isn't. It is tow separate photos of two people who were never together. I surely has no sentimental value because it doesn't exist in reality.
Everyone who thinks this kind of thing is normal, would you have thought it normal if photos of Prince Harry's wedding had had Diana photoshopped into them - up on the balcony waving along with the other royals, sitting in the church, maybe sitting in the group photos of Archie's Christening, holding the baby perhaps ? Or would you like 99.9% of people have thought 'that is fucking insane'?

OpheliaThrupps · 19/02/2022 23:59

It's a very weird thing to do. I would not want a novelty faked photo of something that never happened if I was the parent of the child that was spliced in. I mean why not splice him into Leonardo's Last Supper, or the moon landings?

But to be honest I don't think I would be much bothered as the "owner" of the original photograph. I mean you still have it.

Divebar2021 · 19/02/2022 23:49

It’s a little sad that the Great Grandma didn’t get to meet the baby but having a photo doesn’t mean she got to meet the baby. So the kid will potentially grow up asking “who am I with in this photo?” “Oh that’s your great grandma” “oh I don’t remember her” “no she died before you were born… this is what it might have looked like if you had met her” Pointless.

Swear · 19/02/2022 23:47

I feel that making that kind of photo is disrespectful of the dead person. Their life is being turned into a fake. A commodity in a way.

TokenGinger · 19/02/2022 23:46

I couldn't care less in this position. My Nana died a week before my niece was born. If somebody took my Nana's first photo with my son and photoshopped my niece, I would be so happy that my brother had such a beautiful photo of them.

AmyDudley · 19/02/2022 23:37

the concept reminds me of those weird Victorian dead photos - where dead people (actual dead people before they were buried) were propped up in photos with other family members. Often it was children but also you get some dead older people propped in an armchair while others stood round them trying to look normal.
They are the creepiest photos ever, quite disturbing.

I think the whole idea of the fake photo to include people who have passed is very weird and something I can't get my head around at all. If someone gave me a photo like that I'd be freaked out. I think taking your photo without your permission is disrespectful, it shows a total lack of awareness by the person who did it that it never occurred to them that this was inappropriate.

Nemorth · 19/02/2022 23:37

My DH edited a toddler photo of me and my Mum to be a toddle photographer of my DS and my Mum.

My mum died when I was 8.

I treasure this photo beyond measure. I know it's not real but just imagining her holding him like that is so precious. I'm nearly in tears thinking about it now.

I love it.

However. It was a picture of me that was edited and I'm ok with that.

I think I'd be upset in your shoes but I also know the power of that gift. I wish your permission had been sought. That might have made it better.

I don't know what to say OP.

Lampzade · 19/02/2022 23:16

Sorry that is just weird

BearOfEasttown · 19/02/2022 23:15

Editing a dead person into a photo is commonplace now? WHYYYYYYYYYY?

NoSquirrels · 19/02/2022 23:14

This sort of thing isn't uncommon anymore, especially when a loved one has passed away before important occasions - like your sister having her baby. It's a fairly well known practice, e.g if a parent dies before a wedding they edit them into photos / portraits, or if a grandparent had died they edit them into a family photo.

Bloody hell. You learn something new (and totally batshit) every day.

Genealogists of the future are going to be pissed…

TricolourCat · 19/02/2022 23:13

It is disrespectful and selfish. The least they could have done was to say can we are planning a copy of this picture of Grandma and return the original. You could have then said if you wished let me arrange it so you ensure it didn’t get damaged or lost. It is a ridiculous idea anyway substituting another child!

BearOfEasttown · 19/02/2022 23:13

@musicmadnessnumber57806

I just find it really odd that people are happy to have photos of events that never happened Confused
Same.
oakleaffy · 19/02/2022 23:13

@Mom201
That would really irritate me, too.
Editing out your DC is akin to saying she doesn’t matter.

Porcupineintherough · 19/02/2022 23:10

@Walkingalot nothing the OP says about her grandmother suggests she would feel "desecrated" about bring photoshopped with the great grandson she never met. I think you'd be hard pressed to find a loving great grandmother that would really mind, although a sizable number would likely find it a pretty weird idea.

UniversalAunt · 19/02/2022 23:06

@Mom201 I am unsure who took the photo, was it you & someone has edited a copy, or someone else has the original & edited that?

Either way, I find it creepy AF that someone would edit in a replacement baby & pass that off as something that actually happened. Two cut out images together in a frame maybe, but not a revision of history.
Seriously weird.

So if you can, have a nice big copy of your favourite photo in a lovely frame on display at home where everyone can see it. Especially your sister.

Walkingalot · 19/02/2022 23:05

Actually I think it's a bit sick and twisted. The two subjects were never alive at the same time. To pretend otherwise is totally weird. Not to mention desecrating your own precious memories of your DC with GGM.

Cherrysoup · 19/02/2022 23:05

Which family member did this? It’s really, really weird!

Saz12 · 19/02/2022 23:05

It’s a weird thing to do. DG isn’t cuddling cousin, never met cousin, so it’s pretend memory. Odd.

GlendaSugarbeanIsJudgingYou · 19/02/2022 23:04

I would have cropped the wanker right out of my life.

givemeallthecheese · 19/02/2022 23:04

Blimey.

First of all, sorry for your loss.

However - I would be laughing LOUDLY and letting everyone know this photo was fake and HOW FUCKING WEIRD is it that some would do that "ha ha ha ha"

It's not okay, and rightly or not, I would ridicule it to get my point across

BearOfEasttown · 19/02/2022 22:58

@GlendaSugarbeanIsJudgingYou It was a shitty thing to do wasn't it? 'thin-ifying' my friend! Hmm

iRun2eatCake · 19/02/2022 22:56

Personally l find it a really bizarre thing to do.

No matter how good a photoshop it is, it's still not real! The Grandma isn't smiling or cuddling DN with love.... she's cuddling your DD.

How did they get hold of the photo?

Daisy4569 · 19/02/2022 22:54

I’d assume your sister had mentioned how sad she was that your great grandma never got to meet him and how lovely it was that you had photos of yours together and a well meaning friend has done it as a nice gesture. I’d be unhappy with my child being edited out but I can see how others might overlook it.

Swipe left for the next trending thread