Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To be wary of trusting this (or any) financial adviser with my inheritence

112 replies

frammlinton · 19/02/2022 17:08

I'm inheriting a substantial sum from the sale of my mum's house. I want to use the money to help our children (currently aged 18 and 15) onto the housing ladder at an appropriate time. Some ideas I had are:

  1. Buy a rental property in my name, mortgage free, and rent it out. (Pro: Hedge against inflation. Con: tax, fees, hassle).
  2. Ditto, but buy the property via a trust in our sons' names, so I am effectively gifting the money to them now. (Pro: Hedge against future inheritance tax and rental income tax).
  3. Ditto, but buy property in location where DS1 can live during uni (Pro: Will reduce uni expenses and capital gains tax)
  4. Invest the money until the DC's need it. (Pro: Liquidity, growth prospects. Con: Risk of losing money).
I consulted with a financial adviser recommended by a friend. He very quickly dismissed options 1-3 and homed in on option 4 on the grounds that over time investments tend to rise above inflation. I get that in principle, but they can obviously go down as well as up. This adviser claims to be independent, but is nevertheless recommending the funds offered by his own company (for which he will receive a commission), which rings an alarm bell. Am I being too cautious? I know that none of you can tell me whether or not to trust this person or the organisation they work for, but my question is ... how does anyone ever trust any financial adviser? If you use a financial adviser, how did you go about vetting them in the first place? I know the website 'Unbiased.com' is widely recommended for finding independent advisors, but independence still doesn't guarantee that the advice is any good.
OP posts:
Allergictoironing · 19/02/2022 19:17

Ah @PennyDeFuckwit said it so much better than me, with more up to date knowledge. Crossposted Blush

Allergictoironing · 19/02/2022 19:13

I worked as a financial administrator and paraplanner for a while, with different organisations. The variety of the quality at both places was massive - luckily I worked closely with 2 who were excellent, but did paraplanning for some who I wouldn't trust with a tenner of my own money.

Definitely shop around, and make sure that the ones you talk to all come from different organisations, as IFAs tend to be self employed but "tied" to one organisation who have their favorite investment platforms. There are a few companies who have their own packages of funds and the IFAs tied to them can't really advise different funds.

A decent IFA should not only make a recommendation, but explain why they have made that recommendation in "common person" language e.g. maximise ISAs each year for the tax benefits, invest in pension funds again for the tax benefits and also for the compound growth etc.

Soontobe60 · 19/02/2022 19:13

A friend of mine’s parents bought a house for her to live in whilst she was at Uni in Manchester. It was 4 bedroomed in a student area, and my friend had 3 other students living with her there. She charged them a very small rent and all bills were split 4 ways. By the time she had left (4 years) she had saved enormously as she didn’t need to take out a maintenance loan whilst at Uni and the rent she got covered her own bill. It worked really well. Her mum then put the house in my friends name to do what she wished with it - she rented it out for a couple of years to fund travelling round the world, before settling down, selling it and buying where she wanted to live.

PennyDeFuckwit · 19/02/2022 19:13

I'm the compliance oversight officer for a national IFA. @Elphame yeah I know exactly what company that is too!

Commission was replaced by fees in 2013, the only "commission" to be earned now is from protection policies. All advisers charge a fee for their professional services, as an accountant or solicitor does, although IFA's rarely charge hourly.

It's simple really, if you think you know best and all advisers are out to shaft you, invest it how you see fit. If you're not sure of the long term tax implications, indications for capital growth or loss and how investment risk works, use a professional and pay them for their expertise (there's been some good points made about the illiquidity and fragility of property investment already).

There is a minimum level of qualifications and evidence of ongoing development required of all proper advisers, and all the dinosaurs who used to take the highest amounts of commission for the least amount of work have all but died out.

I'm not denying that there are charlatans, swindlers and rip-off merchants out there, but it's easy to tell - if it sounds too good to be true it probably is. Any promises of performance are false or exaggerated, and if anyone tries to rush you they're probably shite. Check the FCA register for their firm, an investment adviser must be authorised and certified. Don't invest in anything "sexy" like bamboo or teak, carbon credits, Film Schemes or Dubai car parks. 🙄 Don't take more risk than you can afford to lose, which might mean sticking it in a bank account.

There is nothing wrong with advisers recommending their own proposition at all (certain places, let's call them St Jimmy's shall we, charge a hefty fee and tie you in to a minimum contract with exit penalties but it's only them that do that) - everyone else does much the same thing. They are still classed as independent because they will have conducted complex research to decide what platform and investment approach they'll use for their proposition (and repeat the research every year), and if it isn't suitable for you they'll come up with an alternative. It just means they're not tied to a provider or investment house.

The problem with financial advice these days is that the regulator tied up all the rules so tightly that there is now an advice gap - it's not worth advisers getting involved in the process and taking on a client for less than £100k, and anyone with less than that doesn't really want to pay a fee.

OneSwallow · 19/02/2022 19:12

@Porfre

I'm not an IFA.

But with what little knowledge I have-

  1. Avoid premium bonds like the plague - especially with how high inflation is currently. The only benefit they provide is that you are covered and wont lose your original investment.
They are not a good way of making money, and with inflation high at present you will lose 3-6% of their original value every year you have them.
  1. Investing your money in stocks/ shares will outperform anything else if you are not going to need the cash for at least 10 years. If you invest depending on what you go for, the money may lose value but over time as long as you keep it invested you will generally have done much better than most other investments. Obviously it depends on what you invest in, and there is a possibility you may lose money.
  1. Over the last few years property has been a very good bet, but there is no guarantee this will continue. Also it is not as easy as people think being a landlord. It is very difficult if you get a problem tenant and this can cause you lot of costs.

I would go with investment- into an ISA but via funds on vanguard. I would be vary the FA if trying to earn themselves commission.

Though a good IFA is worth way more and could give much better advice re investments.

What is vanguard?
Porfre · 19/02/2022 19:00

I'm not an IFA.

But with what little knowledge I have-

  1. Avoid premium bonds like the plague - especially with how high inflation is currently. The only benefit they provide is that you are covered and wont lose your original investment.
They are not a good way of making money, and with inflation high at present you will lose 3-6% of their original value every year you have them.
  1. Investing your money in stocks/ shares will outperform anything else if you are not going to need the cash for at least 10 years. If you invest depending on what you go for, the money may lose value but over time as long as you keep it invested you will generally have done much better than most other investments. Obviously it depends on what you invest in, and there is a possibility you may lose money.
  1. Over the last few years property has been a very good bet, but there is no guarantee this will continue. Also it is not as easy as people think being a landlord. It is very difficult if you get a problem tenant and this can cause you lot of costs.

I would go with investment- into an ISA but via funds on vanguard. I would be vary the FA if trying to earn themselves commission.

Though a good IFA is worth way more and could give much better advice re investments.

notapizzaeater · 19/02/2022 18:47

Presume the FA is aligned to SJP ?

A good IFA is worth their weight in gold. I'd look at a few before you decide what you want to do.

PinkPanther50 · 19/02/2022 18:45

My parents had a financial adviser who invested well for my parents. Now my generation have inherited we also inherited the IFA so luckily we know him but I would be wary of using someone I didn’t know

PigletJohn · 19/02/2022 18:44

do you already own a house?

if so, what %age of your wealth is in domestic property?

If you buy another house, the %age will be even higher.

Eggs, baskets.

As for effort, I know people in building trades who say they make a lot out of housing. Doing work themselves mostly.

Can you replace a boiler or mend a roof?

HTH1 · 19/02/2022 18:40

I would go for 1 and 3 (so in your name but uni town). If you put it into DC’s name, what happens when one of them meets someone and wants to sell even if the other DC doesn’t want to?

Also a good hedge against DC losing it in a future divorce.

Winter2020 · 19/02/2022 18:36

I don't know what the right answer is but I would avoid any property in your children's names - as your children won't be entitled to any first time buyer incentives at the time such as help to buy accounts, no stamp duty for first time buyers etc.

I also think you have to be super careful not to change the course of your children's lives and restrict their choices. E.g. your child going to uni should choose the course they want in the city they want to live in and mix with others in the same boat - not choose the city and where abouts in it to live based on house prices (in my opinion). Also if you buy a property for the 18 year old at uni they might stay in it (when they otherwise might have travelled for work/moved cities/come home) changing the course of their lives. Can you afford to in turn by another property when your younger child goes? Will they have to go live with their older sibling or miss out?

What if your child has a partner and they have good jobs and would like to buy together but instead of saving up as a team and starting out together they are squabbling over ring fencing deposits - and your child not wanting to marry their partner as their cash is then exposed to the risk of divorce.

That's all very doom and gloom and I don't mean it to be but I believe you should play your cards close to your chest. Have your own savings or investment property and help your children as you see fit at the time. E.g. If your child was buying with a partner and saving up it might be better for their relationship to gift them a relatively small amount of help with their deposit than a huge amount that makes their home buying very unequal. You can always make further gifts later towards their mortgage when you are comfortable they are for the long haul.

I also think you should be careful to only give away what you have truly given away - so if you give your child the money for a house at 20 and they decide to sell up to spend a year travelling/lose half in a divorce/lose it all in bancrupcy that is the risk you take. If you want control you need to keep ownership.

If you had your own rental property you could help your children with the income from it without the restrictions/ control and limits over their choices - and with minimal risk.

If you get a rental make sure you understand all the responsibilities and obligations on landlords - perhaps use a well reputed agent. Make sure you understand the tax situation. I don't expect you will make lots of money renting out (after paying tax/repairs/maintenance/voids) but you will safeguard your money so it continues to be worth one property.

Renting a property always has risks but in my experience you can minimise this by having a desirable property (e.g. well maintained family home in sought after area) so you can have a choice of tenants.

If you choose to put your money in the stock market I would have thought a FTSE tracker which spreads your money over lots of UK companies would be a reasonable choice. If stocks perform poorly your money will fall but in the long term should just follow the ups and downs of the market.

As this is inheritance from your mum I think you need to consider that what is in your children's best interests long term and what safeguards the money for the medium term might not be the same as the most financially lucrative in the short term and might not be the same choice as what your kids prefer - e.g. given the choice of being gifted a 200k property for example which I expect they would jump at.

HamsterTrumpet · 19/02/2022 18:35

I’d trust any financial adviser more than Mumsnet tbh!

But I agree that if you have doubts about the one you’ve spoken to, find another one.

earsup · 19/02/2022 18:34

mmmm option 1,2,3.....unless you find an advisor you can trust....?....i understand property so would do that....it wont dissapear over night...if price dips it will go up again....i bought a house for 12k and its been rented out for years and years with only one set of awful tenants and house now worth 750k.....

EmbarrassedAllOver · 19/02/2022 18:30

You get 3 quotes for any tradesman (or should) so why is this any different.

Speak to others. Do your research.

But also - go with your gut. If you lose a bit of it, well, it is inherited anyway so you haven't "lost" any really. No investment is 100%, it's all a risk. You have to accept that with any investment.

Personally - and I'm no expert - I would buy a property in a good location, near something that will hold its value (so near a decent school etc). I would rather buy a small flat somewhere nice than a bigger house somewhere riskier.

It's free money, mortgage free so if you're super unlucky and lose 10%, so be it. Thats life, most people receive zero inheritance.

Hunderland · 19/02/2022 18:27

If your kids are going to uni I would definitely buy a property in that location.

A) you'll save a fortune in accommodation fees and B) if it's in a uni town you'll ALWAYS be able to rent it out.

Or sell after their three / four year course.

Property investment is such a good option and your kids are old enough (or very nearly) to hugely benefit from your windfall.

OneSwallow · 19/02/2022 18:21

@Elphame

Retired IFA. Without knowing much more about what he advised no one can possibly tell you. I can however take a pretty good guess at which company you are talking about! Commission was replaced by fees years ago.

However property ownership is not as low a risk investment as people think. We have had plenty of crashes in the past and there will be crashes in the future. Houses are illiquid and indivisible as well. That is not to say that they are not suitable investment vehicles in some circumstances but they carry risks of their own.

How do you advise finding a good IFA? Also, are profits in premium bonds tax feee?
JackieCollinshasnoauthority · 19/02/2022 18:18

He's probably correct in that option 4 will get the best returns, for the least hassle, in a relatively short time frame.

Alexandra2001 · 19/02/2022 18:18

I was in a similar situation, i invested the money in a low/medium risk fund as i don't like the principal of BTL's.
Its far out performed my other option of buying two rentals and by using ISA allowances, i don't pay any tax, i don't have the costs of property mtce or dodgy tenants and i can release the money instantly.

Downside is that it does go up and down a lot, even though over 50% is in fixed interest stuff, 0.5% of a lot of money looks a large amount.

I went through a high street bank, the IFA's i looked at just wanted to sell you their products, none seemed interested in me, other than as a cash cow (on going fee's) and i wondered how i would access the funds should these companies go bust - of course a bank sells you their own stuff but they are unlikely to bust and their fees were far lower as i could negotiate with them and were one offs.

frammlinton · 19/02/2022 18:15

@Elphame

Retired IFA. Without knowing much more about what he advised no one can possibly tell you. I can however take a pretty good guess at which company you are talking about! Commission was replaced by fees years ago.

However property ownership is not as low a risk investment as people think. We have had plenty of crashes in the past and there will be crashes in the future. Houses are illiquid and indivisible as well. That is not to say that they are not suitable investment vehicles in some circumstances but they carry risks of their own.

@Elphame, I will dm you the name of the company.
OP posts:
Polyanthus2 · 19/02/2022 18:13

Advice is usually to spread your money over property, shares, prem bonds, isas then they're not all in one basket- seems sensible!

frammlinton · 19/02/2022 18:09

@GeneLovesJezebel

Are you married ?
Yes. I'm a basic rate tax payer, whereas DH is in the 50% band, so not a good idea to put anything in his name.
OP posts:
Longdistance · 19/02/2022 18:09

I suggest spending it on alcohol and loose men! hahaha! Only kidding.

My dh dabbles in stocks and shares himself. They seem to gain quite a bit over time. Separately, we have invested for dd2 a stocks and shares account as she missed out on the CTF. So we invested money in that and it had been gaining 12% at points, even though it went down during the pandemic it went back up. Maybe something like that for your dc.

Dragongirl10 · 19/02/2022 18:07

Personally l would never trust an financial advisor their livelyhood depends upon selling you products not on securing your Inheriatnce.

I think you have to( unfortunately) do a ton of research, in great detail yourself.....
I have had BTL for 30 years, it is not an easy option, (and l am exiting) but can still offer a good return, but again knowing the market inside out and really understanding all the commitments and many costs is very important.
It would help to buy something that he can live in during Uni as that is a big saving, especially if other rooms can be let out to cover costs and repairs etc...I would probably favour this option although with the caveat of, is the location required a good bet?

seekinglondonlife · 19/02/2022 18:05

Why would option 4 surprise you? He needs the commission no doubt. I tend to look at most FAs as a MLM.

Ginger1982 · 19/02/2022 18:03

Could you have a deed of variation done to your mum's will transferring the house, and therefore the sale proceeds, directly to your kids to perhaps have some form of trust? That's what my mum did with my gran's house, although I was an adult and so was able to have the benefit immediately.