Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To be wary of trusting this (or any) financial adviser with my inheritence

112 replies

frammlinton · 19/02/2022 17:08

I'm inheriting a substantial sum from the sale of my mum's house. I want to use the money to help our children (currently aged 18 and 15) onto the housing ladder at an appropriate time. Some ideas I had are:

  1. Buy a rental property in my name, mortgage free, and rent it out. (Pro: Hedge against inflation. Con: tax, fees, hassle).
  2. Ditto, but buy the property via a trust in our sons' names, so I am effectively gifting the money to them now. (Pro: Hedge against future inheritance tax and rental income tax).
  3. Ditto, but buy property in location where DS1 can live during uni (Pro: Will reduce uni expenses and capital gains tax)
  4. Invest the money until the DC's need it. (Pro: Liquidity, growth prospects. Con: Risk of losing money).
I consulted with a financial adviser recommended by a friend. He very quickly dismissed options 1-3 and homed in on option 4 on the grounds that over time investments tend to rise above inflation. I get that in principle, but they can obviously go down as well as up. This adviser claims to be independent, but is nevertheless recommending the funds offered by his own company (for which he will receive a commission), which rings an alarm bell. Am I being too cautious? I know that none of you can tell me whether or not to trust this person or the organisation they work for, but my question is ... how does anyone ever trust any financial adviser? If you use a financial adviser, how did you go about vetting them in the first place? I know the website 'Unbiased.com' is widely recommended for finding independent advisors, but independence still doesn't guarantee that the advice is any good.
OP posts:
PigletJohn · 20/02/2022 15:25

"As I stated previously, it is owned by its investors"

is it? How?

MissConductUS · 20/02/2022 15:12

@Tigersonvaseline

Fiance people don't like vanguard because it's set up by a man who wanted to open up in investing to the masses And remove the need for the snake oil sales.

What miss us means by no risk is low Risk.

Eg jack Bogle Said why search for the needle in the Hay stack .. when you can buy the haystacks.

Market's are self cleaning.if I buy index following FTSE 100 and company fails, it's dropping out and replaced.

What you say about Vanguard and using index funds to avoid single stock risk is spot on. However, I never said "no risk". I said that you cannot go wrong with Vanguard, in the sense that they will not overcharge you, conceal fees and costs or lock you into agreements that will cost you money to get out of. As I stated previously, it is owned by its investors and manged for their benefit.
Tigersonvaseline · 20/02/2022 12:06

Fiance people don't like vanguard because it's set up by a man who wanted to open up in investing to the masses And remove the need for the snake oil sales.

What miss us means by no risk is low Risk.

Eg jack Bogle Said why search for the needle in the Hay stack .. when you can buy the haystacks.

Market's are self cleaning.if I buy index following FTSE 100 and company fails, it's dropping out and replaced.

Allergictoironing · 20/02/2022 12:03

@PennyDeFuckwit

Sure *@sanbeiji*, but I'm happy to clarify on the thread! I should specify that my understanding of "the SJP issue" goes back 3 or 4 years and there may have been some big changes since then.

There is no problem (IMO) with SJP and their proposition or performance. They're a professional outfit and have been extremely successful - they certainly have a big foothold in the market, hence they attract more of the fast talking type of adviser who is focused on earnings, but only a small segment. I'd conservatively suggest that the biggest problem "the industry" has with SJP is a) their fees - the initial charges can be high compared to most IFAs, as are their ongoing (servicing) fees, and b) that they have a clause in their agreement which actually ties clients in to a minimum period of servicing and applies an exit penalty if they terminate. Or, I should say, they used to - this may have been removed in recent years.

What (I believe) pains SJPs competitors the most is that the regulator has not once stepped in to "police" this perceived outrageous practice! The industry villifies SJP because the average small practice could never build or retain a client base on the same fee basis, so it feels grossly unfair that they can charge in this way and never be held to account by FCA (which often states that it does not regulate price). In fairness to SJP, they still hold a big chunk of the market so they must be doing something right...

One of the advisors I worked for a few years ago was with SJP. Again it's very much a lottery of who you get - my boss was exceptionally conciencious and I've seen him advise against moves that would have made him a BIG fee. He would also balance every client's portfolio at least annually (with no fee for changes).

Regarding the "lock in", that's tied in to the transfer/investment fees for pensions. Clients are (or weren't) at that time charged a fee up front for standard pensions transfers or set up, but if you left withion X years then a proportion of the fee would be charged depending on how long you held the pension e.g. transfer fee would have been £5k, if you stay for 5 years you pay nothing, if you leave after 2 years you pay £3k out of any increase in value (figures are not real, just as an example).

So in theory they large initial fee for pensions could be non existant if you stayed invested with them long enough.

True that only the massive wealth behind SJP allows for this to take place, as the company does pay the advisors the fee at the start whether the client stays or not.

Polyanthus2 · 20/02/2022 11:50

BTL properties have been a nightmare over Covid and lockdown - workmen not turning up, workmen not getting required equipment through, workmen charging a fortune as a job takes 3 times as long due to delays and tenant /workmen having covid etc etc.
It's still a nightmare as the electrician who promised to see to smoke alarms (in Scotland had to be done by beg Feb) STILL hasn't done it. And isn't replying to txts etc
I think the people that say buy a property and make lots of money don't own btl.

sanbeiji · 20/02/2022 11:14

@SamphiretheStickerist

Buy to let is still being regulated. H+S, taxation, tax break, standards, yearly checks, ever changing legislation that favours the tenants more and more.

If you can't give your BTL quite a bit of your time for research and then management, over and above any you get from appointing a managing agent, then you won't get the best out of it.

Maybe take what your IFA said and compare it to the general advice on MSE, see what sticks and what doesn't. But please, don't assume BTL will be easy.

Yes, it's not like even 5 (or 10) years ago! Also factor in extra cash for things like damage caused by tenants, maintainence. You MIGHT be able to get away with substandard housing in London but probably not the rest of the country
SamphiretheStickerist · 20/02/2022 11:10

Buy to let is still being regulated. H+S, taxation, tax break, standards, yearly checks, ever changing legislation that favours the tenants more and more.

If you can't give your BTL quite a bit of your time for research and then management, over and above any you get from appointing a managing agent, then you won't get the best out of it.

Maybe take what your IFA said and compare it to the general advice on MSE, see what sticks and what doesn't. But please, don't assume BTL will be easy.

sanbeiji · 20/02/2022 11:10

@PennyDeFuckwit

Sure *@sanbeiji*, but I'm happy to clarify on the thread! I should specify that my understanding of "the SJP issue" goes back 3 or 4 years and there may have been some big changes since then.

There is no problem (IMO) with SJP and their proposition or performance. They're a professional outfit and have been extremely successful - they certainly have a big foothold in the market, hence they attract more of the fast talking type of adviser who is focused on earnings, but only a small segment. I'd conservatively suggest that the biggest problem "the industry" has with SJP is a) their fees - the initial charges can be high compared to most IFAs, as are their ongoing (servicing) fees, and b) that they have a clause in their agreement which actually ties clients in to a minimum period of servicing and applies an exit penalty if they terminate. Or, I should say, they used to - this may have been removed in recent years.

What (I believe) pains SJPs competitors the most is that the regulator has not once stepped in to "police" this perceived outrageous practice! The industry villifies SJP because the average small practice could never build or retain a client base on the same fee basis, so it feels grossly unfair that they can charge in this way and never be held to account by FCA (which often states that it does not regulate price). In fairness to SJP, they still hold a big chunk of the market so they must be doing something right...

Fair enough, thanks! this is consistent with forums like MoneySavingExpert.

From the POV of one relative who use them... they're a one-stop shop for everything. She has businesses all over the place, money in trusts... her IFA also had his own independent practice before moving to SJP.

As far as she's concerned she makes good returns based on their comps, more than the fees. I don't know if she has the time or inclination to compare to other options.

Ultimately the only way is to do your own research HOWEVER bear in mind that a lot of DIY advocating sites claim that it's 'easy'. No it's not!

It's 'easy' if you have a bit of spare cash, and want it to grow beyond savings accounts, and maintain its value. It's not if you factor in things like tax, want to get the MAXIMUM return possible etc. Taking into account all the possibilites.

littlebilliie · 20/02/2022 11:08

@SirGawain

This adviser claims to be independent, but is nevertheless recommending the funds offered by his own company (for which he will receive a commission). I'm not sure that this is even legal.
IFA do not now ever receive commission unless they are in a structure such as SJP. IFAs charge fees initial and ongoing, commission products finished in 2012
littlebilliie · 20/02/2022 11:05

Talk to people who own property

Talk to IFA who have a long standing track record with their firm. Many IFAs stay with the same firm due to their long standing client bank.

Look at the tax advice regarding property ownership and trusts, this will impact returns.

Meet your advisers agree terms and fees. Good advisers will summarise your meeting with initial notes so you will know where you stand.

PennyDeFuckwit · 20/02/2022 10:41

Sure @sanbeiji, but I'm happy to clarify on the thread! I should specify that my understanding of "the SJP issue" goes back 3 or 4 years and there may have been some big changes since then.

There is no problem (IMO) with SJP and their proposition or performance. They're a professional outfit and have been extremely successful - they certainly have a big foothold in the market, hence they attract more of the fast talking type of adviser who is focused on earnings, but only a small segment. I'd conservatively suggest that the biggest problem "the industry" has with SJP is a) their fees - the initial charges can be high compared to most IFAs, as are their ongoing (servicing) fees, and b) that they have a clause in their agreement which actually ties clients in to a minimum period of servicing and applies an exit penalty if they terminate. Or, I should say, they used to - this may have been removed in recent years.

What (I believe) pains SJPs competitors the most is that the regulator has not once stepped in to "police" this perceived outrageous practice! The industry villifies SJP because the average small practice could never build or retain a client base on the same fee basis, so it feels grossly unfair that they can charge in this way and never be held to account by FCA (which often states that it does not regulate price). In fairness to SJP, they still hold a big chunk of the market so they must be doing something right...

Siepie · 19/02/2022 22:49

From a social point of view, I'm not sure I'd recommend buying a house for DS to live in during uni. When I was at uni, a classmate's parents were her landlords, renting the spare rooms out to other students. When something in the house didn't get repaired promptly, the other tenants turned on the landlord's daughter and she ended up quite ostracised. I can also see problems arising if you need to keep DS' friend's deposit for damage or similar.

mjf981 · 19/02/2022 22:45

If you need it in the next few years, just stick it in a bank account.
If its 2+ years, I'd invest in index funds which track the stock market; yes it may go up and down buy you'd have dividends paid as well. But I'd avoid the US market atm - if any of the stock markets are in a bubble, it is the US.

sanbeiji · 19/02/2022 22:42

@WhiteJellycat

I have no real advice except that a friends dm skipped his kids and left her estate to the grandkids. I dont think there will anything left for a deposit. I'm thinking if I get any inheritance I want to pass most of it to my kids but I dont think from what I have seen, having a young adult knowing they have a very large sum of cash guaranteed is a good idea.
There are lots of options.. like leaving it in trust until X age, or that the money's used for a specific purpose
WhiteJellycat · 19/02/2022 22:32

I have no real advice except that a friends dm skipped his kids and left her estate to the grandkids. I dont think there will anything left for a deposit. I'm thinking if I get any inheritance I want to pass most of it to my kids but I dont think from what I have seen, having a young adult knowing they have a very large sum of cash guaranteed is a good idea.

Trolleedollee · 19/02/2022 22:14

I was strongly advised against SJP but others have been very happy with them. I have an IFA who has worked with our family professionally and personally for many years and yes worth his weight in gold. Happy to share details if you want to DM me. Also advised against BTL but explained why and I think he advised me well

sanbeiji · 19/02/2022 22:13

@Frankley

I know someone who has had money invested with SJP for over 10 or more years. He seems to think his advisor has done well for him. A lot of people must use SJP, why if everyone on here advises against them?
@PennyDeFuckwit I'd ve interested to know this too, can I DM you? The people who invest with them aren't what I'd called naive as well quite the opposite.
BernadetteRostankowskiWolowitz · 19/02/2022 22:08

I'd buy a two bed in an university city. Dc can stay there if they attend the uni, and they can rent the second bedroom out to cover the cost of all bills.

EmmaH2022 · 19/02/2022 22:07

@Hoppinggreen

Well 1-3 doesn’t earn the FA any commission does it?
This.
MissConductUS · 19/02/2022 22:06

@SirGawain

You cannot go wrong with Vanguard. Avoid any investment which says something like this. There is no such thing as a risk are investment!
I didn't mean to imply that investing with Vanguard was free of risk. Any investment in shares and bonds will go up and down with the markets. My point was that Vanguard will not try to make a fast profit off you or take advantage of you. With their index funds you will never underperform the market.

It is incumbent on the investor to pick funds that match their risk tolerance and investing timeframe.

RainingYetAgain · 19/02/2022 22:03

The weekly Boring Money newsletter is worth a look. It is very readable and quite educational.Which? Did a book on investments while back, I don't know whether it is still published.
MsE has a money course which covers investment I think. DS found the house buying chapter helpful.
I would see another couple of advisors when you have done some reading around.
Be prepared to pay for advice.

SirGawain · 19/02/2022 21:59

You cannot go wrong with Vanguard.
Avoid any investment which says something like this. There is no such thing as a risk are investment!

PrincessNutella · 19/02/2022 21:52

If you are looking for the most common sense way to invest the money, I agree that you could get ripped off by the financial advisor. But I also think property is risky. How do you know where the child will go to university, etc. I would invest the money in index funds, which have very low overhead and spread out the risk. I would use as simple a strategy as possible such as the one below. And then I would not fuck with it. (warning, this strategy was devised in the US and these are US funds, but I don't know why the same economic principles would not apply in the UK) (google the three-fund portfolio or www.thebalance.com/comparing-three-fund-portfolios-over-time-5115820

Frankley · 19/02/2022 21:50

I know someone who has had money invested with SJP for over 10 or more years. He seems to think his advisor has done well for him. A lot of people must use SJP, why if everyone on here advises against them?

Tigersonvaseline · 19/02/2022 21:50

Sorry I meant to say I like choppy markets And would be buying now.