Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To not pay £480 to fix dd's friend's phone

580 replies

FarangGirl · 19/02/2022 14:17

Dd (14 yo) was with her friends and accidentally hit a friend in the arm. He had his phone in his hand and dropped it. Apparently it will cost £480 to repair!!! His parents want us to pay this. I think this is ridiculous. First, friend dropped the phoen, it wasn't like dd was using it. Second. If you're going to give your kid a stupidly expensive phoen, you should insure it and have a bullet proof cover.
Aibu?

OP posts:
Silvers11 · 20/02/2022 18:58

I can't believe this. She wasn't doing anything wrong and nor was he from the sounds of it yet his parents want you to fork out the whole cost of the repairs? It was an accident, plain and simple for starters. Surely they will be able to claim at least part of the repair from their House Insurance?

He/his parents were at least partly to blame. More so, in my opinion. You buy a very expensive phone, give it to a 14 year old - and don't get a decent solid cover and screen protector on it? That's an accident waiting to happen and very negligent on the part of the Boys parents not to consider how the phone could be best protected.

Personally I would have got Insurance for it too if they didn't already have it. I think it might be reasonable to pay some of the excess if they have insurance - but you need to call them out on whether they have insurance and get sight od the claim, the reply from the Insurance - and the final invoice. I suspect they are at it....

Strictly1 · 20/02/2022 18:55

@Turkey98

You should have paid already - you are completely liable. If they take you to court, you will lose.

Just think about the arguments you are making and others are on this thread and think about the common case of car 'accidents'. Accidents happen, but there are consequences for those who cause them.

i) The cause of the event is clear, although clearly wouldn't be taken any further, your DD assaulted their friend, and as a direct consequence of this the phone was damaged.

ii) Insurance is the choice of the phone owner and covers their mistakes - whether they have insurance and whether they claim is down to them. Even if they do claim on their insurance, the insurance company can claim again whose fault it is - i.e. your DD (and you).

iii) You don't get any say in how expensive an item you choose to cause damage to. Same way as if you hit a Ferrai, you can't say you shouldn't have such an expensive car - you are responsible for any damage you cause from an event you start if such damage is reasonably foreseeable.

iv) The friend does not have to use a case if they don't want to - they only have to do that if they want to minimise damage they cause - they don't have to do that before the accident - only minimise their loss after the accident.

v) They are entitled to a repair to get it into the same state - using original parts - and these must be carried out according to manufacturers standards - in essence, Apple authorised repairers must perform the repairs using Apple parts (otherwise Apple won't support it).

vi) It doesn't matter if they didn't have a tight grip on the phone as long as they wouldn't have dropped it anyway. If you crash into a car and the car then hits another, you are liable for the entire pile-up, not just the car you originally hit. There is no comeback by saying they should have left more space so if someone hit them they wouldn't have hit the other car.

If you said anything like you were not paying to me, I would rent another phone (of same type) and charge you for that as well - you are 100% liable and should have paid the same day.

Stop blaming the person who suffered the loss, and accept your DD caused the accident and is fully responsible. Pay up before they take your DD to court.

This. Mocking the parents for allowing their child an expensive phone is deflecting from your daughter's daft actions. You don't get to decide for everyone else what's reasonable!
bemusedmoose · 20/02/2022 18:55

my son has an okish phone (not an iphone or anything top of the range) nice enough not to be embarrassed about but not expensive. It's insured and has a bomb proof cover that has saved it from even a scratch after flying out his hand and down a hill!

Dont want big charges - dont get a kids a stupidly expensive phone! I know year 5s with the latest Iphone (why!?!?!) if you insist on still doing it - insure it and cover it or face a huge bill. The kid would have dropped it at some point. Sounds like an Iphone - even the screens on those cost loads to get a real replacement (the high street fixes usually over heat and have issues but are cheap)

NYnewstart · 20/02/2022 18:54

If she was holding it or being silly, then yes half, but under the circumstances ,no!

Abricot1993 · 20/02/2022 18:53

The boy`s parents claiming they do not have a warranty because the bought it abroad is strange. I live in Switzerland and bought an apple product from an apple store in Dubai last October. Of course as others point out a warranty does not cover accidental damage. However I find this all a bit dodgy. I would not be offering the full amount or even half. I would be interested to see their purchase receipt firstly too. Also how can you be sure the other unknown damage is a result of it dropping? I just checked the cost of a screen repair in Switzerland for the iphone12. It is £234 (294chf) not £480 and as we know Switzerland is a very expensive country to live in. See link. support.apple.com/de-ch/iphone/repair/service/screen-replacement

Watapalava · 20/02/2022 18:53

She’s having you off

I dropped my iPhone 12 and smashed it to the point speakers don’t work nor camera and screen has chunks missing

£80 full repair

I’ve replaced me screen 3x and this was the most expensive

BellaVida101 · 20/02/2022 18:50

I also call bullshit on the repair cost. £480 is to replace the whole phone not just the screen. It must have had something else wrong with it. Here are the screen repair costs: support.apple.com/en-gb/iphone/repair/service/screen-replacement

LoisLane66 · 20/02/2022 18:50

@Turkey98
Presumably, as it was the daughter who flung her arm out, the litigant cannot sue the parents who were not at the scene. How much a court would order a child of 14 to pay, is a moot point.
Good luck with your analysis.
In the UK, a parent or guardian cannot be held responsible for accidents caused by their child unless it can be shown that they were there at the time and failed to take steps to curb any excessive behaviour.
Only children over the age of 10 can be held responsible for criminal actions but in the case in question there us no criminality involved.
The parent of the child who 'caused' the accident has no responsibility in law to make amends but may wish to make a voluntary monetary consideration. There is no onus on the parents of the 14 year old to do anything.

BellaVida101 · 20/02/2022 18:49

i) no evidence of assault, clearly an accident
ii) extremely unlikely the insurance company would make a claim against the person supposed to have caused the damage without proper evidence (which doesn’t exist) especially if a teenager (not worth pursuing)

The other points are irrelevant and the car analogy is nonsense as there are different laws.

The phone is legally the parents’ property and they should have taken reasonable steps to protect the phone from damage which, in the hands of a teenager, is entirely foreseeable.

csigeek · 20/02/2022 18:48

I call bullshit on that cost! Dropping a phone shouldn’t cause much more damage than a smashed screen. I’ve had my fair share of those at even iPhones repaired at Apple don’t cost anywhere near that much!

NotAJammyDodger · 20/02/2022 18:47

He should have held his phone tighter then!

Totally ridiculous to expect you to pay.

If it was deliberately shoved down a loo, or taken and chucked, that would different, but not the case here.

PUGMEISTER21 · 20/02/2022 18:45

Nah! It was an accident. They should except that it wasn't deliberate. Maybe they will put it in a decent case. They can buy a good new phone for under 200 so they should do this. Lesson is, don't buy your kids expensive stuff.

CharlieBoo · 20/02/2022 18:42

@Turkey98 what a load of nonsense!!!!!

Cantstopeatingchocolate · 20/02/2022 18:40

I've skimmed through the thread so not sure this has been mentioned but a brand new iPhone 12 costs just over £550.
I think they're looking for you to cover most of the cost of a new one.
I agree with others, they need to claim on household insurance if they didn't have it separately insured. You can offer the excess.

Ohhelpicantthinkofaname · 20/02/2022 18:37

[quote Turkey98]@AllThingsServeTheBeam

The only reason that typically occurs is because they are not known. If a cyclist scratched a car they would have to pay if the car owner decided that they wanted to do that. Remember comprehensive insurance is at the choice of the owner - only 3rd party is required by law, and the owner can always sue whoever causes any damage - including cyclists and pedestrians.

If you damage someone else's property it is for you to have taken out insurance to protect you, not the owner of the property. This is what mandatory car insurance is for - to pay for damage you cause.

If you were sued what would your defence be for hitting someone and causing them to incur significant loss as a result of your action?[/quote]
Insurance against accidentally knocking someone’s phone out of their hand doesn’t exist though, does it. So you can’t really liken it to car insurance, can you.

Teenagers drop phone, spill things on phones, loose and phones. The moral of the story is, don’t give your teenager a really expensive, uninsured phone or you are asking for trouble.

BellaVida101 · 20/02/2022 18:36

Turkey98 you are clearly not a lawyer, your argument is absolute nonsense, this is a case of accidental damage and it’s not even clear the child is liable. It’s for them to have insured it against damage or put it in a case.

NotMyselfWithoutCoffee · 20/02/2022 18:35

Jfc. The onus is on the parents to have taken out phone insurance, he could have just as easily tripped and broken it that way.
At best I'd offer to pay the excess if it was insured, in this case I would tell them to get stuffed they are being ridiculous.

ScribblingPixie · 20/02/2022 18:31

Ridiculous, Turkey. You sound like pontificating in an episode of The Good Wife.

Annazak · 20/02/2022 18:31

What adult on an average wage can afford £480 to fix their phone? Regardless of whose fault it is that it got damaged.
This is not a good life lesson for parents to set their children….. disposable products everyone else pays for. It’s fine it say no when you can’t afford to expensive things and learning that they get broken and cost a lot to repair is a life lesson to stop them getting into debt as adults.

Turkey98 · 20/02/2022 18:30

@AllThingsServeTheBeam

The only reason that typically occurs is because they are not known. If a cyclist scratched a car they would have to pay if the car owner decided that they wanted to do that. Remember comprehensive insurance is at the choice of the owner - only 3rd party is required by law, and the owner can always sue whoever causes any damage - including cyclists and pedestrians.

If you damage someone else's property it is for you to have taken out insurance to protect you, not the owner of the property. This is what mandatory car insurance is for - to pay for damage you cause.

If you were sued what would your defence be for hitting someone and causing them to incur significant loss as a result of your action?

Ohhelpicantthinkofaname · 20/02/2022 18:26

Why would you give a teenager a top spec phone?

I wouldn’t be paying a penny, it was an accident and shot happens. It’s not your fault he has a ridiculously expensive phone.

Similar thing happened to dd2 with her phone (not the latest model). Her friend knocked it put of her hand and the on off button was dented meaning it wouldn’t turn on or off and was completely unusable. I took it to the local phone repair shop, as apple don’t have a shop near me and they cost a fortune anyway. They fixed it for £25. I would never have dreamt of charging her friend for it!

If you give a phone to a teenager, you have to assume that at some point something will happen to it. If you buy them a super expensive phone and don’t have it insured, you’re an idiot and should suffer the consequences.

Wearethechampionsmyfriend · 20/02/2022 18:25

ENoeuf

She was talking animatedly’ does sound a bit like she was being careless

Hmm No it doesn't! 🙄

PearlyShamps · 20/02/2022 18:22

"...the boy was holding it in his hand while walking. If it had been in his pocket nothing would have happened to it even when dd knocked his arm. So he wasn't showing due diligence in protecting his own phone"

Yes, @FarangGirl - that's exactly my thinking. I always tell my kids not to use phone whilst walking, THAT is careless. Talking animatedly is not being careless.

I presume £480 is the entire cost of the repair? By asking you to pay in full, sounds like they are not accepting their DS has ANY responsibility for what happened. Perhaps offer a token gesture towards the repair (out of goodwill) if you are so inclined... but please do not hand over £480. His parents are being CFs!

AllThingsServeTheBeam · 20/02/2022 18:22

@Turkey98 never read such nonsense in my life. It's a phone! If a cyclist or pedestrian accidentally damaged a car they wouldn't be expected to pay. The driver would have to claim on their insurance.

I wouldn't even consider paying for this phone

Turkey98 · 20/02/2022 18:19

You should have paid already - you are completely liable. If they take you to court, you will lose.

Just think about the arguments you are making and others are on this thread and think about the common case of car 'accidents'. Accidents happen, but there are consequences for those who cause them.

i) The cause of the event is clear, although clearly wouldn't be taken any further, your DD assaulted their friend, and as a direct consequence of this the phone was damaged.

ii) Insurance is the choice of the phone owner and covers their mistakes - whether they have insurance and whether they claim is down to them. Even if they do claim on their insurance, the insurance company can claim again whose fault it is - i.e. your DD (and you).

iii) You don't get any say in how expensive an item you choose to cause damage to. Same way as if you hit a Ferrai, you can't say you shouldn't have such an expensive car - you are responsible for any damage you cause from an event you start if such damage is reasonably foreseeable.

iv) The friend does not have to use a case if they don't want to - they only have to do that if they want to minimise damage they cause - they don't have to do that before the accident - only minimise their loss after the accident.

v) They are entitled to a repair to get it into the same state - using original parts - and these must be carried out according to manufacturers standards - in essence, Apple authorised repairers must perform the repairs using Apple parts (otherwise Apple won't support it).

vi) It doesn't matter if they didn't have a tight grip on the phone as long as they wouldn't have dropped it anyway. If you crash into a car and the car then hits another, you are liable for the entire pile-up, not just the car you originally hit. There is no comeback by saying they should have left more space so if someone hit them they wouldn't have hit the other car.

If you said anything like you were not paying to me, I would rent another phone (of same type) and charge you for that as well - you are 100% liable and should have paid the same day.

Stop blaming the person who suffered the loss, and accept your DD caused the accident and is fully responsible. Pay up before they take your DD to court.

Swipe left for the next trending thread