Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To not pay £480 to fix dd's friend's phone

580 replies

FarangGirl · 19/02/2022 14:17

Dd (14 yo) was with her friends and accidentally hit a friend in the arm. He had his phone in his hand and dropped it. Apparently it will cost £480 to repair!!! His parents want us to pay this. I think this is ridiculous. First, friend dropped the phoen, it wasn't like dd was using it. Second. If you're going to give your kid a stupidly expensive phoen, you should insure it and have a bullet proof cover.
Aibu?

OP posts:
Cameleongirl · 20/02/2022 20:09

I agree that if you buy your teen an expensive phone, you should be prepared for accidents, i.e., get insurance! It's really not your DD's fault that her friend didn't have it insured nor had a cover on it. My DD (now 16) broke her phone twice when she was in her early teens, once she dropped it herself and the second time she was with friends and said someone jogged her arm....she also hadn't put the cover on, even though we'd bought her one.

Insurance covered the first breakage, but the second time we said she'd need to go on a monthly payment plan if she wanted a new phone. She paid for a few months and then we paid it off for her when she'd shown she was being more responsible with her phone.

So, I agree with PP's who said that perhaps asking for £100 would have been reasonable, but it's not your DD's fault that the phone didn't have a cover and wasn't insured.

RachaelN · 20/02/2022 20:05

Not a chance. They should have it insured.

QuizzlyBear · 20/02/2022 20:03

When I was 14 I was in drama class with a friend and we were learning stage fighting. Unfortunately my ring smashed the face of her watch when I went to 'punch' and she went to block.

Her parents wanted us to buy her a new (very expensive) watch and got really shirty about it. They based this on the fact that all jewellery was supposed to have been removed before the class.

They only stopped harassing me for the money when my dad pointed out that if I should have removed the ring, their daughter should also have removed her watch...

A real shame but our friendship never really recovered.

Mollymoostoo · 20/02/2022 19:55

@itsgettingweird

What would they have done if someone in the street knocked him arm and he dropped it?

These things are a general risk of real life if you carry expensive items (or even cheap ones!)

Exactly. I suspect he has blamed your daughter to get off accepting responsibility.
Personally I would offer to get it repaired and get a quote done. I am guessing g the cost they are suggesting is from apple, there is no way a phone screen costs that much.
Zilla1 · 20/02/2022 19:50

HNRTT but regarding @turkey98 assertion of assault, I suppose it might depend on jurisdiction, if there is a jurisdiction where accidentally hitting someone on the arm constitutes assault, presumably where @Turkey98 lives. In the UK, assault depends on intent.

savethecactus · 20/02/2022 19:46

YANBU. If you give your child an expensive phone you do it at your own risk. You can't expect other parents to subsidise this by paying for repairs. There might be some obligation if OP's dc was using the phone and being very careless, but it sounds like pretty normal behaviour, the kind of things most teenagers do, and the reason most people buy cheaper phones for their children, or get decent insurance, shock absorbing cases and screen protectors.

AnnieSnap · 20/02/2022 19:39

[quote BellaVida101]@anniesnap the warranty you are offered by apple all cover accidental damage, worldwide[/quote]
Really? Is that not Apple Care, which is different to the warranty? If not, I’ve been seriously missing something!

sueelleker · 20/02/2022 19:31

@Abricot1993

Turkey98, the parents of the boy will not be taking anyone to court. It seems they bought the phone abroad so I bet they have no paper trail as they say they have no warranty (you get a warranty when you buy abroad I did when I bought an apple product in Dubai). Bet they did not pay customs duty either.
I wonder if it's a genuine apple, or a cheap knock-off?
Fuckitydoodah · 20/02/2022 19:30

There's absolutely no way I'd be paying any of that. It was a genuine accident. Not your fault if they don't have any insurance for it.

They can jog on.

Suzyinthesummertime · 20/02/2022 19:26

The parents shouldn't be so stupid as to buy a child such an expensive gadget

I wouldn't pay or engage with them whatsoever, its ridiculous

Abricot1993 · 20/02/2022 19:26

Turkey98, the parents of the boy will not be taking anyone to court. It seems they bought the phone abroad so I bet they have no paper trail as they say they have no warranty (you get a warranty when you buy abroad I did when I bought an apple product in Dubai). Bet they did not pay customs duty either.

BellaVida101 · 20/02/2022 19:25

@anniesnap the warranty you are offered by apple all cover accidental damage, worldwide

Cryalot2 · 20/02/2022 19:25

A kid with a phone woth that 😲.

All I am saying that recently both myself and adult dd got new phones ( nothing like that ) I could never afford such and what I have works.
Both of us before using them got screen covers and covers for our phones.

Our last phones ( not iphones) but with screen covers and covers. They both were dropped countless times and hers was drove over twice, and all that happened was having to replace screen cover.

Whatever the rights and wrongs in this case I can't say as I wasn't there. But if me before I would hand over money I would get an independent report on the phone. Then take it from there.
It may be that is not an original or what they claim. But you need to know first.

If it was me I would check cab to see if you are legally responsible.

AnnieSnap · 20/02/2022 19:22

@FarangGirl

According to the mum, its not under warranty because it was bought abroad.
Apple offer a world wide warranty. Although that wouldn’t cover accidental damage.
AllThingsServeTheBeam · 20/02/2022 19:21

[quote Turkey98]@AllThingsServeTheBeam

The only reason that typically occurs is because they are not known. If a cyclist scratched a car they would have to pay if the car owner decided that they wanted to do that. Remember comprehensive insurance is at the choice of the owner - only 3rd party is required by law, and the owner can always sue whoever causes any damage - including cyclists and pedestrians.

If you damage someone else's property it is for you to have taken out insurance to protect you, not the owner of the property. This is what mandatory car insurance is for - to pay for damage you cause.

If you were sued what would your defence be for hitting someone and causing them to incur significant loss as a result of your action?[/quote]
I'm actually amazed you think that you're right 🤣

Hitting someone? You're not even correct about that. Knocked him yes.

Panpastels · 20/02/2022 19:13

Don't engage with them further to saying you won't be paying. It's up to them to prove liability and they are very unlikely to achieve this.

StillWeRise · 20/02/2022 19:08

@Itsalmostanaccessory

Well, she shouldn't be waving her arms around. That is silly.

Pay half.

what''s this? people shouldn't wave their arms about? what nonsense or is it girls, perhaps, who should be more demure.
Watapalava · 20/02/2022 19:08

Not really understanding your point lois

It’s my phone I break so no issue to anyone else

I pointed out the costs to repair are no more than £80

OnaBegonia · 20/02/2022 19:07

I think they're taking the piss, my adult DD just had a new screen on her Iphone12 and it was £140.
I'd be asking for the details of what's actually broken.

PeachyPeachTrees · 20/02/2022 19:06

No way I'd pay a penny. Phones are delicate which is why I bought my son a smart phone for only £150 and he always has it in a case. £480 is ridiculous.

Watapalava · 20/02/2022 19:05

But op doesn’t have to pay for it to be repaired by apple! There are repair shops on every street and screen repairs can be done in an hour! They’re so common

£480 is crazy who’d pay that to repair a phone!

LoisLane66 · 20/02/2022 19:04

@Watapalava
You obviously have no regard for expensive items or else more money than sense.
I read about more about 'abuse' of iPhones re broken screens, lost when walking the dog, dropped in the toilet etc than any other make of mobile phone. The owners obviously have little regard for something costing circa £1000. I wonder if they'd be so blasé about a TV at that price. "Mum, I just broke the TV screen when I was messing about with my mates."
Ah well...silly parents pick up the tab and their kids never learn the hard way.

Musmerian · 20/02/2022 19:00

@Turkey98 - absolute hogwash. It’s not the same situation at all. There’s no way I’d be paying a penny.

MrsRhettButler · 20/02/2022 19:00

Mumsnet never fails to entertain, that's for sure.

MrsRhettButler · 20/02/2022 18:59

Turkey what the fuck are you talking about? You'd get fuck all out of me or my daughter 😂

Op definitely do not pay, or.. Put yourself in the other parents shoes. Would YOU expect the other family to pay up? I certainly wouldn't, I'd tell my child they should have held on to their expensive phone much tighter and I hope they've learned their lesson.