Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To not pay £480 to fix dd's friend's phone

580 replies

FarangGirl · 19/02/2022 14:17

Dd (14 yo) was with her friends and accidentally hit a friend in the arm. He had his phone in his hand and dropped it. Apparently it will cost £480 to repair!!! His parents want us to pay this. I think this is ridiculous. First, friend dropped the phoen, it wasn't like dd was using it. Second. If you're going to give your kid a stupidly expensive phoen, you should insure it and have a bullet proof cover.
Aibu?

OP posts:
Ohwowhoho · 21/02/2022 14:50

@woody87

I can't believe some of the answers on this thread.

OP I would tell DD's friend and his parents to, excuse my French, FUCK RIGHT OFF.

Same!
Itsalmostanaccessory · 21/02/2022 14:44

@FarangGirl

In the other thread, the originall poster was quite clear that she couldnt afford to pay for it. And what was the response? Oh yeah, "you broke it, you pay for it."

Just not when it's a teenage boy with an expensive phone.

The parents asked for the full amount. The ficking logical thing to do is say, "we'll pay half or we will.pay your insurance excess but we're not paying it all as you could have mitigated this with a phone case."

I dont understand what you find so alien about the concept of "you broke it, you pay for it."

It doesnt matter if it was an accident. Thoughtlessness has the same affect as malice here. Your daughter didnt pay attention to what she was doing and she broke her friend's property. You should, morally, offer half the money.

But you're not going to because that's how people behave now. Nothing is their fault and even it if is, someone else must be more at fault so they're not taking any part in rectifying it.

FarangGirl · 21/02/2022 14:23

@Itsalmostanaccessory

Interesting that my dd's friend's parents haven't heard of your madeup code given that they are insisting we pay it all.

This isn't a man, it's a 14 year old boy. Trying to bring sexism into this is totally ridiculous!

Of course the amount involved matters. That is why most posters said the woman should pay in the earlier thread when it was 40 pounds and not when it's 480 pounds.

If tables were turned (and they have been ), I wouldn't be chasing anyone for money. I would accept responsibility for having given a teen a stupidly expensive phone, not protected it and not insured it. You might not agree about the partition of responsibility but, as you can see, most posters on this thread agree (and, no, it's not because it's a boy and not a girl - now you're clutching at straws as you have no other explanation why people thought 40 pounds would be reasonable to pay but not 480 pounds).

Anyyway, i'm not paying half. In agreement with or in excess of the vast majority of the opinions on this thread, I'm going to offer what I think is reasonable and no more. And I think that's fair and totally fine. If they don't like it, too bad. In fact, if the boy keeps on giving my dd shit about this, I won't pay anything at all.

OP posts:
Itsalmostanaccessory · 21/02/2022 14:06

@FarangGirl

It is not about the amount. It is actually really simple.
If you break something, you pay to fix it.
If you have a hand in breaking something, you pay half the bill.

I work in an area where every day I see people do everything they can do avoid taking responsibility. I see it in here all the time, and it is so much worse when the person on the other end is a man.

You're doing everything you can to blame the parents for something your kid caused.

She broke the phone. All this, "it's there fault for buying it" iis just bullshit. People are becoming more and more selfish and its disgusting.

She broke it. When you break something, you replace it. In this case, its 50/50 because they didnt put it in a case but she still knocked into him because she didnt look at what she was doing and she should have. Have you actually told her that?

FarangGirl · 21/02/2022 13:53

@Itsalmostanaccessory

www.mumsnet.com/Talk/am_i_being_unreasonable/3367017-to-not-pay-for-friend-to-get-her-phone-fixed-after-i-smashed-it

The one I'm thinking of is older but I cant find it. Here's one from the smasher's perspective. Majority of responses telling her to pay or at least pay half.

I'd also have been willing to have paid 40 pounds too and I wouldn't have bothered posting about it. But that's not what they're asking for. They're asking for 12 times as much for essentially the same thing! Hence the reason why the majority of posters have said no way would they pay 480 pounds in the same situation or even 240.

Why is mumsnet OK and reasonable when the posters agree with your point but an echo chamber when they do not? Linking to previous posts to prove your point kind of undermines your whole argument as to why you're in the minority here. Different situation.

OP posts:
Bookworm20 · 21/02/2022 13:49

Parents buying an expensive phone for their kids is 100% not relevant here

Actually its very relevant. The whole reason the repair is so high is because its an expensive phone! Given to a bloody 14yo.

I am really baffled by people saying OP should pay something.

I wouldn't dream of charging my kids friends for knocking their phone out of their hand! But then I wouldn't buy a teenager an expensive phone that I couldn't afford to replace/repair.

Sorry your DD is having hassle from this boy OP. Says alot about him though that he is taking zero responsibility for this himself. Sounds like a typical spoilt entitled rich kid tbh. And one thats on the scam at that.

WhenSpringArrives · 21/02/2022 13:41

This sounds SUPER dodgy and I wouldn't be paying a penny!
They are trying it on!
If they've bought it from Apple it will be under warranty. Even if it was bought in the UK and you live in Thailand.
They are absolutely trying it on and this 'friend' sounds bloody awful!
I wouldn't pay anything. Why on Earth wouldn't they insure such an expensive phone, especially when it's a child taking it out?!

GreenFingersWouldBeHandy · 21/02/2022 13:26

£480? Christ, that's more than my car is worth! What a ridiculous thing to give to a child.

ilovemyboys3 · 21/02/2022 13:24

No I wouldn't pay repairs. It is down to the owner of the phone, how do you know he was holding it tightly or not even messing about himself!

chaosmaker · 21/02/2022 11:35

Should be a lesson to them, OP, not to give them an expensive phone and also to the son to hold onto his possessions tightly!

Redwinestillfine · 21/02/2022 11:05

Are you sure it was the mother dh talked to? Sounds like a scam to me!

Yetanotherchange21 · 21/02/2022 11:00

Nope don't pay. What sort of person spends that much money on a phone with no form of protection/warranty/accidentle damage etc. They chose to do that so that's the risk they took. Now its bitten them on the bum.

FarangGirl · 21/02/2022 10:58

@abc83732239877

Be prepared over the possibility of them taking you to small claims
Ha ha, that won't happen. Presumably they didn't declare customs duty when bringing the phone from the UK. Luxury items here are taxed A LOT. And since DD is 14, not sure how much money they think they'll get out of her.
OP posts:
FarangGirl · 21/02/2022 10:56

@Giraffesandbottoms

This is like that episode of sex and the city where Carrie’s Manolo’s get stolen at a friend’s house and the friend doesn’t want to replace them because it’s Carrie’s choice to have bought such expensive shoes. Eventually it’s clear the friend realised she was being a dick and paid for the shoes.

It’s not your business what people spend on things. If you smashed into a Ferrari you would be liable as you would be at fault. You would also need to cover the cost of correct parts, not knock offs . You need to accept responsibility and at least pay half.

The difference being that Carrie did not know she would be asked to remove her shoes and had a reasoable expectation they would be safe. Here it's different. One can reasonably expect the occasional accident and should take steps to ensure safety.
OP posts:
abc83732239877 · 21/02/2022 10:56

Be prepared over the possibility of them taking you to small claims

NoSquirrels · 21/02/2022 10:55

If you smashed into a Ferrari you would be liable as you would be at fault. You would also need to cover the cost of correct parts, not knock offs

Rubbish analogy. This scenario is literally what car insurance is for. And if the kid’s parents had insurance OP could happily pay the excess for them and it would be a non issue.

Itsalmostanaccessory · 21/02/2022 10:55

www.mumsnet.com/Talk/am_i_being_unreasonable/3367017-to-not-pay-for-friend-to-get-her-phone-fixed-after-i-smashed-it

The one I'm thinking of is older but I cant find it. Here's one from the smasher's perspective. Majority of responses telling her to pay or at least pay half.

Giraffesandbottoms · 21/02/2022 10:52

This is like that episode of sex and the city where Carrie’s Manolo’s get stolen at a friend’s house and the friend doesn’t want to replace them because it’s Carrie’s choice to have bought such expensive shoes. Eventually it’s clear the friend realised she was being a dick and paid for the shoes.

It’s not your business what people spend on things. If you smashed into a Ferrari you would be liable as you would be at fault. You would also need to cover the cost of correct parts, not knock offs . You need to accept responsibility and at least pay half.

GabriellaMontez · 21/02/2022 10:49

@Itsalmostanaccessory

You know, there was a thread on here a few years ago from a poster who was in a pub. She was holding her phone, her friend bumped into her arms and she dropped her phone and it smashed.

The responses were overwhelmingly in the OP's favour. People giving her message ides to send to the friend to make them pay, people telling her to end the friendship as the friend was clearly very selfish and no real friend, people suggesting small claims court.

I wonder if the different here is that it was a boy who was bumped. There were quite a few responses insulting the boy, accusing him of trying to hide it from his parents and place the blame elsewhere etc.

Bullshit. I remember that thread. Everyone was asking why she was waving an expensive phone around in a pub of all places!
Itsalmostanaccessory · 21/02/2022 10:48

@FarangGirl

People said that before you posted that information. They bumped straight until insulting this teenage boys because... well, he's a boy.

Just saying. Near identical scenario years ago involving a woman getting her phone knocked and the responses were the complete opposite.

GabriellaMontez · 21/02/2022 10:46

@woody87

I can't believe some of the answers on this thread.

OP I would tell DD's friend and his parents to, excuse my French, FUCK RIGHT OFF.

Same !!!!
FarangGirl · 21/02/2022 10:46

(the entire amount)

OP posts:
FarangGirl · 21/02/2022 10:46

@Itsalmostanaccessory

You know, there was a thread on here a few years ago from a poster who was in a pub. She was holding her phone, her friend bumped into her arms and she dropped her phone and it smashed.

The responses were overwhelmingly in the OP's favour. People giving her message ides to send to the friend to make them pay, people telling her to end the friendship as the friend was clearly very selfish and no real friend, people suggesting small claims court.

I wonder if the different here is that it was a boy who was bumped. There were quite a few responses insulting the boy, accusing him of trying to hide it from his parents and place the blame elsewhere etc.

Because he was trying to hide it from his parents and place the blame elsewhere? Hence the request for us to transfer it directly to HIS bank account so his parents wouldn't know.
OP posts:
woody87 · 21/02/2022 10:45

I can't believe some of the answers on this thread.

OP I would tell DD's friend and his parents to, excuse my French, FUCK RIGHT OFF.

Itsalmostanaccessory · 21/02/2022 10:45

@newname12345

It sounded like there were walking side by side and for some unknown reasons, she felt the need to turn her body to face him and swing her arms round into his path because she "talks with her hands."