Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To not pay £480 to fix dd's friend's phone

580 replies

FarangGirl · 19/02/2022 14:17

Dd (14 yo) was with her friends and accidentally hit a friend in the arm. He had his phone in his hand and dropped it. Apparently it will cost £480 to repair!!! His parents want us to pay this. I think this is ridiculous. First, friend dropped the phoen, it wasn't like dd was using it. Second. If you're going to give your kid a stupidly expensive phoen, you should insure it and have a bullet proof cover.
Aibu?

OP posts:
ThirdElephant · 22/02/2022 03:57

I'm with you, OP. The kid dropped his phone. That's his own fault. She hit his arm, not the phone itself, therefore it was a case of him not holding his phone tightly enough. His fault.

I'd offer £50 (in writing) as a gesture of goodwill (and state that it's a gesture of goodwill in writing, with no admission of fault or liability), take it or leave it. And say they can take it to small claims court otherwise.

Ridiculous behaviour from the parents.

me109f · 22/02/2022 03:41

Apologise, but pay nothing. Any parents rich enough to buy a child an expensive phone but stupid enough not to insure it should grudgingly accept the loss. They should then buy butterfingers a very cheap phone, or reactivate an old phone and use the chip from the damaged one which is probably OK. I have never broken, damaged or lost a phone (I have had 5 in 20 years), although I have on occasion sat on them or had a phone drop off the roof of my car and had to stop and retrieve it from the road. (I always buy a rubbery cover for them. My phones are always quite cheap, on a contract and I never insure them).
The parents are trying to scam you, they are trying to punish your little girl and charge you excessively for a teenage accident of no consequence. The greedy arses would have no chance of getting money from me!

llizzie · 22/02/2022 03:23

has anyone mentioned that it might be a cheap/reconditioned phone and he is trying it on?

Perhaps he should learn the lesson in life that no one likes a flashy showoff.

FarangGirl · 22/02/2022 03:04

Actually we haven't heard anything from the paretns since Saturday evening so we'll see. Potentially (as I suspect from the timeline) the mum hasn't actually seen the repair quote since the friend was asking for the money directly on Saturday morning on the basis that he had got a quote from Apple but didn't want to involve his parents. So possibly she's realised that her son has not been entirely honest (I don't know but I have some suspicions here given the price).

Or alternatively they're just away for half-term!

OP posts:
UnevenBooks · 22/02/2022 00:19

The cause of the event is clear, although clearly wouldn't be taken any further, your DD assaulted their friend, and as a direct consequence of this the phone was damaged

Assault implies intent to harm in some way.

BambinaJAS · 22/02/2022 00:09

@Turkey98

You should have paid already - you are completely liable. If they take you to court, you will lose.

Just think about the arguments you are making and others are on this thread and think about the common case of car 'accidents'. Accidents happen, but there are consequences for those who cause them.

i) The cause of the event is clear, although clearly wouldn't be taken any further, your DD assaulted their friend, and as a direct consequence of this the phone was damaged.

ii) Insurance is the choice of the phone owner and covers their mistakes - whether they have insurance and whether they claim is down to them. Even if they do claim on their insurance, the insurance company can claim again whose fault it is - i.e. your DD (and you).

iii) You don't get any say in how expensive an item you choose to cause damage to. Same way as if you hit a Ferrai, you can't say you shouldn't have such an expensive car - you are responsible for any damage you cause from an event you start if such damage is reasonably foreseeable.

iv) The friend does not have to use a case if they don't want to - they only have to do that if they want to minimise damage they cause - they don't have to do that before the accident - only minimise their loss after the accident.

v) They are entitled to a repair to get it into the same state - using original parts - and these must be carried out according to manufacturers standards - in essence, Apple authorised repairers must perform the repairs using Apple parts (otherwise Apple won't support it).

vi) It doesn't matter if they didn't have a tight grip on the phone as long as they wouldn't have dropped it anyway. If you crash into a car and the car then hits another, you are liable for the entire pile-up, not just the car you originally hit. There is no comeback by saying they should have left more space so if someone hit them they wouldn't have hit the other car.

If you said anything like you were not paying to me, I would rent another phone (of same type) and charge you for that as well - you are 100% liable and should have paid the same day.

Stop blaming the person who suffered the loss, and accept your DD caused the accident and is fully responsible. Pay up before they take your DD to court.

This is all moot because you first need to establish ownership of the phone.

If the parents in question cannot produce a receipt for said phone, then legally speaking none of your "points" are applicable.

Additionally,

It would also explain the odd comments around the phone being out of the warranty period. If the parents got the phone from an external source (not bought directly by them) it is unlikely that they would have a proper warranty or insurance.

In fact, I would have to say that this whole story sets of alarm bells as it looks suspiciously like they are trying to replace an uninsured phone from a dodgy out of UK source, with a UK-bought phone with all the bells and whistles (hence the £480 price tag).

OP:

Ask to see the receipt. If they stall or say they lost it, then you have your answer. Do not pay a dime.

To Turkey:

A judge in the UK would laugh you out of court if you tried to claim damages in small claims court without being able to establish proof of ownership via a receipt.

BreadInCaptivity · 21/02/2022 22:04

Leaving aside for a moment, the responsibility of the OP to fund the repair I'd say the most pressing considerations are:

  1. £480 is a large amount of money to hand over without any evidence of what exactly it's being used for because it's not appropriate to expect someone to transfer that amount of money to a minors bank account just on their say so and that is all it is right now.
  1. There is a responsibility on the part of the friend/his parents to specify exactly what's broken other than the cracked screen her DD witnessed beyond the description "other things" and proof of a quotation, or better still multiple quotations. This has not been forthcoming. No proof, no explanation, no cash.
  1. Its perfectly reasonable to question the red flags here.
  • Its "interesting" that the unsubstantiated repair bill is virtually identical to the cost of buying a refurbished version of the same phone.
  • It's also "odd" that despite a world wide warranty this phone does not have one, but an very expensive repair from Apple is somehow "necessary" despite there being nothing to invalidate. Preferred maybe, but not necessary and it's reasonable point to argue that it's not appropriate to ask someone to substantially fund your preference if a cheaper suitable alternative can be found (such as a repair shop that offers a warranty on the repair).

Upshot it's all very well banging the drum of moral superiority/outrage that the OP should pay up in full but I'd suggest there's quite a few things that need to be clarified before she commits to offering anything.

NYnewstart · 21/02/2022 20:29

What have they said to your offer?

MinnieGirl · 21/02/2022 20:19

@PainterMummy

OP, forgive me if I read this and it didn’t register, but have you called your local apple store to enquire about authorised repair locations near you (often “authorised” is more than just local apple store) and how much a repair would be? Getting this independently may shed some light on whether the quote given to you is inflated or not.
That is a very good idea…. And I would do that before you offer to pay anything. You could also say to the store that you’ve been quoted £480 and are a bit taken back… Once you know how much it actually will cost you can proceed to offer if you feel you need to. Personally, any idiotic parent who gives their kid an iPhone 12 and doesn’t insure or protect it deserves everything they get!
Jacopone · 21/02/2022 18:45

Nowadays, phones are objects of everyday use. Any item of this size and shape being handled as often as they are would risk accidents of being dropped, slipped out, knocked off etc. By teenagers especially as their usage is tenfold and with lesser care. If you decide to buy an expensive phone you must take it into account. Hence the insurance. You don’t insure a beach ball as it is easily affordable to replace. You need to insure an expensive item like a phone as accidental damage is very likely and because it is very difficult to prove liability. This should be stressed - it is very difficult to prove liability. It is therefore reckless not to insure a 1K phone as there is no legal or moral ground to expect to be paid in case of such accidental damage.

Devora13 · 21/02/2022 17:15

'Did they not have it in a sturdy protective case? When you give your kid an expensive phone, you get a good case to go with it with a screen protector.'

We got a case for our son and he refused to use it. Dropped it and screen cracked. Totally on him.

Unless she was deliberately throwing it around, frankly it's on his parents for letting him take something so expensive out of the house uninsured.
I really don't get this at all. Ours was s £108 Moto G, same as mine, perfectly good and a quarter of the price. I would view damage to expensive phones in the say way as designer clothes or trainers; a bit daft if you expect them to be kept in pristine condition by kids/teenagers.

PseudoplasticFluid · 21/02/2022 17:00

You think the world would be a fucked up place if people replaced, or contributed to the cost of, the items they break?

I think the world would be a fucked up place if people didn't bother to take responsibility and protect their items adequately, or insure them, expecting other people to foot the bill. When it could have easily been avoided by purchasing a proper case and getting out phone insurance.

bluebeau · 21/02/2022 16:58

kids play and things break, it happens.
i'd tell them to fuck off

Itsalmostanaccessory · 21/02/2022 16:45

@HaudYerWheeshtYaWeeBellend

If everyone paid for accidents, then the world would be a fucked up place.

The parents should have had insurance, it’s their lack of responsibility to blame not the child who was just talking to her friends!

You think the world would be a fucked up place if people replaced, or contributed to the cost of, the items they break?

I've heard some bullshit before but this might win.

PainterMummy · 21/02/2022 16:33

OP, forgive me if I read this and it didn’t register, but have you called your local apple store to enquire about authorised repair locations near you (often “authorised” is more than just local apple store) and how much a repair would be? Getting this independently may shed some light on whether the quote given to you is inflated or not.

Blackbird2020 · 21/02/2022 15:53

OP I think your DD’s situation would be the perfect topic for a high school ethics class Smile

@Itsalmostanaccessory Granted, we are all entitled to our own opinions, but you are coming across a little, ahem, hectoring Wink

FarangGirl · 21/02/2022 15:50

[quote Giraffesandbottoms]@FarangGirl

Why bother asking then?[/quote]
My decision was formed based on the majority input on this thread. Hadnt decided when I posted. Now I'm confident its right one, the same as or exceeding the majority of posters.

OP posts:
Giraffesandbottoms · 21/02/2022 15:48

@FarangGirl

Why bother asking then?

FarangGirl · 21/02/2022 15:41

I'm happy with my decision and my morals.

OP posts:
HaudYerWheeshtYaWeeBellend · 21/02/2022 15:38

If everyone paid for accidents, then the world would be a fucked up place.

The parents should have had insurance, it’s their lack of responsibility to blame not the child who was just talking to her friends!

BedisBliss · 21/02/2022 15:34

It is no-one's fault; accidents happen; that's what insurance is for and if they don't have insurance, they shouldn't have bought their child an expensive phone!!

BedisBliss · 21/02/2022 15:32

Had to put my tuppence worth in here as my DD was telling me yesterday how her clumsy boyfriend twice knocked her phone out of her hand yesterday. Iphone 13 - both times it hit the ground; no damage. Point is - it happens, and if a phone has a good case and one of those glass protective screens it will survive.

AskingforaBaskin · 21/02/2022 15:18

@Itsalmostanaccessory

Moving around, turning yourself, waving your arms as you talk are all things you do whilst paying attention to your surroundings.

If you hit someone then you weren't thinking about your surroundings. You were showing a lack of thought. That's what she did.

The amount doesnt matter. Morally, if you break something, you pay to replace it. If you contribute to breaking something then you split the bill.

But we have become a lot more selfish as a society and a lot more, "but it's more his fault than mine." As evidenced by his parents asking you to pay it all and you saying you're not paying.

You're as bad as each other. Both your kids contributed to breaking it. Both of you should pay to fix it.

Your daughter needs to understand that sometimes she will be around expensive things. If she talks with her hands then she will need to pay attention to what they are hitting.

You keep saying morally like it's one fixed explanation.

You may feel morally obligated to pay. I wouldn't. Not a penny.

Your morals do not have to almighty with everyone else.

Itsalmostanaccessory · 21/02/2022 15:05

Moving around, turning yourself, waving your arms as you talk are all things you do whilst paying attention to your surroundings.

If you hit someone then you weren't thinking about your surroundings. You were showing a lack of thought. That's what she did.

The amount doesnt matter. Morally, if you break something, you pay to replace it. If you contribute to breaking something then you split the bill.

But we have become a lot more selfish as a society and a lot more, "but it's more his fault than mine." As evidenced by his parents asking you to pay it all and you saying you're not paying.

You're as bad as each other. Both your kids contributed to breaking it. Both of you should pay to fix it.

Your daughter needs to understand that sometimes she will be around expensive things. If she talks with her hands then she will need to pay attention to what they are hitting.

FarangGirl · 21/02/2022 14:50

No one said she was thoughtless or careless though. She was behaving reasonably. The boy was equally careless by holding the phone in his hand so loosely while walking. Plus no case. Plus no insurance. Quite a few more strikes against him in the responsibility stakes.

The main difference between that thread you linked to and this one is the amount. I am 100% sure the responses would be the same if it were a teenage girl. Most posters are not OMG he has testicles, you must not pay. They are OMG 480 pounds, WTF?! You just don't like that they don't agree with you and you clearly believe you have a superior moral view of the world.

OP posts: