Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To ask why you’ve missed/delayed/declined cervical screening?

936 replies

chickentikkawhatswrong · 19/02/2022 13:56

I see a lot of the campaigns on Facebook about women not going to smears or putting them off for too long.

However it’s generally stats and doesn’t seem to delve too far into the actual reasons?

If you are reluctant what holds you back from attending?

OP posts:
RedToothBrush · 20/02/2022 14:15

@Tillyvonpantsalo

I'm sorry, it's not about being able to keep my nose out of other people's reproductive systems.

Having had a gynae cancer ( not cervical, but picked up a nurse at the smear). All I can say is that having met people shit out their vagina where cancer had eaten tissue away or be admitted to hospital unable to breathe due to the tumours spreading. I personally would rather go through a smear than experience the above. I do have vaginal atrophy and despite no cervix I have to have vault smears as this is the most likely place for a recurrence. I can't have HRT and these smears are not comfortable but far better than brach therapy (radiotherapy seeds placed in vagina) chemo, major surgery etc.
I met no risk factors for my particular cancer bit still got it.

Would people seriously rather run the risk of the above than have a smear.

I think the answer to your question is they would rather take the risk that they are unlikely to be in that situation rather than the certainty of the examination.

That tells you rather a lot about the procedure and how its not fit for purpose.

It also says that people make different, valid risk assessments and are perfectly capable of doing so.

Crossing the road and driving a car carries the risk of ending up in a traumatic accident. We still do it.

okthx · 20/02/2022 14:14

@Tillyvonpantsalo

Would people seriously rather run the risk of the above than have a smear.

I don’t want to run a risk of anything, but I have got many more organs than my vagina/cervix and no one interested to have any kind of checks/scans/tests. Why, please tell me why it’s only my cervix or my breasts (once I reach certain age)?

Sausageandeggs · 20/02/2022 14:13

As per previous posters, I’ve done the research and it doesn’t add up for me. The false positives, the unnecessary treatments, the fake narrative where women aren’t told they actual statistics to be able to make informed decisions about their own bodies, the policing and bullying from other women who feel it’s their duty to force others to go so they feel better about going themselves.

It’s yet another misogynistic tool of control. No thank you.

RedToothBrush · 20/02/2022 14:11

@Iheartmysmart

That’s a very good point by *@okthx*. I’ve been going to my GP for 7 YEARS with the same symptoms but nothing ever happens. Blood tests are done and quite honestly the last lot of results were abysmal but because they are barely in range the GP won’t treat.

However I’ve been bombarded with messages to get a smear test, get a mammogram, get a flu jab, get a coil.

A more cynical person could assume it’s to do with the fact they get paid extra for these.

Read the patient paradox by the above mentioned Margaret McCartney.

The Worried Well and taking up far more resources than they should be at the expense of those with an actual problem.

Its easy money. Whereas certain referrals might get taken out of your budget.

Tillyvonpantsalo · 20/02/2022 14:04

I'm sorry, it's not about being able to keep my nose out of other people's reproductive systems.

Having had a gynae cancer ( not cervical, but picked up a nurse at the smear). All I can say is that having met people shit out their vagina where cancer had eaten tissue away or be admitted to hospital unable to breathe due to the tumours spreading. I personally would rather go through a smear than experience the above. I do have vaginal atrophy and despite no cervix I have to have vault smears as this is the most likely place for a recurrence. I can't have HRT and these smears are not comfortable but far better than brach therapy (radiotherapy seeds placed in vagina) chemo, major surgery etc.
I met no risk factors for my particular cancer bit still got it.

Would people seriously rather run the risk of the above than have a smear.

PinkSparklyPussyCat · 20/02/2022 14:02

I mean no-one can be this stupid.

Sadly it appears they can, there’s quite a few of them on this thread!

Scianel · 20/02/2022 13:54

It’s uncomfortable but not painful and that’s it.

You do realise that everyone isn't the same as you, right? I mean no-one can be this stupid.

Katya213 · 20/02/2022 13:53

@LyricalBlowToTheJaw. Obviously you do!😊

RosesAndHellebores · 20/02/2022 13:48

@okthx agree completely. In the last 6 months I've had a smear reminder, DH and I have been asked to provide BP readings and reminders for bowel screening. However my GP has refused to refer me for back investigations (I paid privately and yes the T12 was broken) and for NHS physio.

Perhaps someone would be kind enough to produce a comparative risk analysis of cervical cancer and covid.

MakkaPakkas · 20/02/2022 13:29

I'd add that the 'go for your screening ladies, it's there to save your life' type persuasion is very ineffective for me. There's an underlying assumption that people who don't go or are reluctant are silly and stupid which is NEVER persuasive (even if we are)

MakkaPakkas · 20/02/2022 13:26

Don't like having them done. Irregular periods. Low risk for cervical cancer.

Once a doctor put their finger up my bum without warning during one which I really didn't like & they essentially forced me into having it by withholding contraception until I had it which I also didn't like.

So I do usually tend to put it off often for about 6 months.

Livelifeinthebuslane · 20/02/2022 13:25

Has anyone posted stuff by GP Dr Margaret McCartney who raises some of the issues in universal screening? Particularly that you are more likely to get a false positive than an actual positive and go through invasive treatment that you didn't actually need, this is another factor in my decision-making (along with no family history of cancer, not being sexually active, and living very healthily). https://www.heraldscotland.com/news/13054346.cancer-screening-no-thanks-says-gp/ She does emphasise that it's crucial to get any symptoms checked out.

I also identify okthx with being treated badly by medical professionals in the past (and recently) and wanting a more equal relationship.

LyricalBlowToTheJaw · 20/02/2022 13:21

@JuergenSchwarzwald

I simply cannot believe that so many people would risk not knowing whether they have a cancer because of a couple of minutes of embarrassment and discomfort. You know cancer is quite painful, too and cause a lot more discomfort than a smear

Why do you care? Worry about yourself and stop mithering on about what other people do. Doesn't affect you.

And the smear test does not find cancer, it finds cell changes that could lead to cancer.

Yeah, it's amazing how many posters can't keep their noses out of other women's reproductive organs.
Terfydactyl · 20/02/2022 13:18

@Bellalasagne1

Because I've now only got one boob as I lost the other to cancer. Go for your screening ladies, it's there to save your life.
No thank you.
JuergenSchwarzwald · 20/02/2022 13:16

Jesus Christ some women here are worse then kids- yes it’s not comfortable of course and it’s humiliating but come on cope on - it’s just a test

It isn't just a test. It is very painful for some of us so bog off. It also gets more painful as you get older.

jessieminto · 20/02/2022 13:13

I go for my smears but they are getting more and more difficult. I have a progressive condition that affects a lot of things I my body, and it seems as though this is causing smears to become unbearable, the pain is ridiculous. Since a GP at my practice didn't stop when I asked her to, I now have anxiety about it all as well.

I go to the hospital and they do it as part of a special clinic for people who have difficulty with smears. The gynea chair they use makes it so much easier than the standard bed at the GP and the staff there are used to doing difficult smears.

My last one was over so quickly and was the easiest in the last 10 yrs but has come back inconclusive. I will have to go back in 3 months for another. I will keep going for them, but know my condition will reach a point where I will prob need gas and air or sedation in order to do it. I will ask for a hysterectomy when I reach this point.

JuergenSchwarzwald · 20/02/2022 13:13

And to answer another point - yes if you have irregular periods it can be quite difficult getting the timing right. You used to have to be in the first 10 days of your cycle. They are less prescriptive now but it's still not easy.

Last time I waited until the first day of my period and then phoned and got an appointment for 3 weeks later. It worked - but when you are peri-menopausal it might not!

JuergenSchwarzwald · 20/02/2022 13:11

I simply cannot believe that so many people would risk not knowing whether they have a cancer because of a couple of minutes of embarrassment and discomfort. You know cancer is quite painful, too and cause a lot more discomfort than a smear

Why do you care? Worry about yourself and stop mithering on about what other people do. Doesn't affect you.

And the smear test does not find cancer, it finds cell changes that could lead to cancer.

BloomingTrees · 20/02/2022 13:06

I'm massively overdue and actually had one booked for last week but had to cancel as DC was ill and DH away. I now have another one booked way in advance, no idea if it'll clash with my period or not - we'll see.

I don't find them particularly painful or traumatic or anything, but it is something that is easily put off especially as my life is incredibly busy and it's not easy getting an appointment.

Restzol · 20/02/2022 13:06

@okthx I can really identify with what you say. I think I have arthritis in a couple of joints, my chest sometimes feels tight and I have increasingly bad migraines. Getting to see a dr feels an odyssey. No face to face. No availability. Yet I can be consistently harangued over a smear. Lots of resource available for blanket processes. If you don’t fit the cookie cutter, jog on. I exaggerate to prove a point but only slightly.

bitemyarsenic · 20/02/2022 13:03

@Restzol

I think someone on this thread mentioned or implied that the test is also a visual screen of the cervix? I’m not sure this is actually the case? I’m not undermining practice nurses who do the majority of these tests however they are not trained gynaecologists who will have had experience of seeing examples of what is a rare condition presenting at different stages. Yes, they might spot something obvious but that is not the point of the test; getting a cell sample is.
It was me. Im a HCP Yes they do visualise the cervix,they take the cells from a specific area of the cervix, it has to be seen to do this. They are not gynaecologists but know what a normal cervix looks like and if something looks concerning or they see a cyst or polyp then further referral for investigation is made.

A GP was called in to check mine as it looked abnormal and I was sent for colposcopy.
Ive lso had a cervical polyp seen by the practice nurse and it was removed by my GP( womens health specialty)

okthx · 20/02/2022 12:54

@Iheartmysmart
I feel the same. I feel like they don’t care about me as a person, unless it’s my cervix or something to do with their campaigns. They never address my own concerns, even when their colleagues strongly recommend so. I remember having an ultrasound scan with a consultant and my thyroid had abnormal changes. Even after that they refused me a full thyroid profile. I’ve got a history of thyroid cancers in the family. That’s why I see red when they keep bombarding me with reminders about smears. And yes, GPs got rewarded for high intake of smears, at least it was the case in the past.

LyricalBlowToTheJaw · 20/02/2022 12:47

WE HAVE LOL!! Some people don’t agree with you, get over it.

Nobody gives a shit what you think.

Iheartmysmart · 20/02/2022 12:47

That’s a very good point by @okthx. I’ve been going to my GP for 7 YEARS with the same symptoms but nothing ever happens. Blood tests are done and quite honestly the last lot of results were abysmal but because they are barely in range the GP won’t treat.

However I’ve been bombarded with messages to get a smear test, get a mammogram, get a flu jab, get a coil.

A more cynical person could assume it’s to do with the fact they get paid extra for these.

bedheadedzombie · 20/02/2022 12:41

I'm very chill about smears, very relaxed, find them only slightly uncomfortable, don't care about the sex or gender of whoever does it, go to every one.

And I still can empathize why for some women it might be an issue and support their reason/ decision. It's their body after all.

Swipe left for the next trending thread