Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To ask why you’ve missed/delayed/declined cervical screening?

936 replies

chickentikkawhatswrong · 19/02/2022 13:56

I see a lot of the campaigns on Facebook about women not going to smears or putting them off for too long.

However it’s generally stats and doesn’t seem to delve too far into the actual reasons?

If you are reluctant what holds you back from attending?

OP posts:
SpaghettiArmsMurderer · 19/02/2022 18:13

@RedToothBrush

What is clear from this thread that one of the top reasons for not attending is not embarassment, but poor previous care and appalling attitudes from NHS staff that patients don't want to repeat.

Not exactly the narrative that the NHS PR people and government want to hear and promote. Easier to lay it on women and tell them they are being petty and pathetic.

We should all be asking them to 'do better'.

Completely agree with this. Inconsistent/poor quality care is a huge problem in the NHS. In loads of areas, including gynaecology, but also for example DP is having some mental health struggles and was having absolutely rubbish care from our GP, changed practices and the new GP is fortunately much better. But that shouldn't happen. I have PCOS and have had excellent care but I know from talking to others that that is hugely variable too - not just in quality but even what you are offered and who you are referred to.

Any nurses on the thread - do you get much training on giving smears? It seems that quite a few people are put off by bad workmanship as it were. I wonder if that is where the NHS could put more of its energy.

@CrocodilesCry thanks, will take a look

RedToothBrush · 19/02/2022 18:13

[quote SpaghettiArmsMurderer]@MarchCrocus What exactly do you think my view is? I expressed surprise that people are weighing up today's certain pain vs tomorrow's less certain but greater pain and coming down in favour of avoiding today's pain (which I suggested may be down to optimism bias, a cognitive bias everyone has which makes us think bad things won't happen to us), and concern that the women who develop cancer despite being low risk may be missing out on smears that could help them. How is that misogynistic?

And men are guilt tripped about prostate cancer risk. There are regularly stalls with people accosting men about it in my local train station. If anything I've previously wondered why there are stalls for that and not cervical/breast cancer![/quote]
The outcomes are actually unnecessary pain, greater pain or no pain. There is also the risk of psychological trauma and damaging the patient/doctor relationship through poor or gaslighting treatment.

Risk profiles for women are fairly well studied - I suspect they are in a similar place to breast cancer - which I said upthread is about to be streamlined to reflect this nuance and to try to reduce unnecessary harms.

We already know that rates of cervical cancer in women who have had the HPV vaccine are significantly lower - to the point that arguably negates the benefit of screening.

As for the guilt tripping over prostate cancer. I am not sure I've ever seen blokes posting on social media or telling their mates, 'oi have you had your prostate? Otherwise you could leave your children without a father' amongst themselves... If the most they get is a few stalls at the station (when most people round here drive) then I think we are talking a completely different level of harassment promotion.

bitemyarsenic · 19/02/2022 18:13

[quote crosstalk]@bitemyarsenic

I hope people read your post.

However: if you've been monogamous throughout your life, presumably HPV isn't a problem? or can you inherit genital warts etc?

What is the NHS using instead of steel?

How widespread and reliable is home testing?

Is the NHS addressing the issue of women's reluctance to submit themselves to testing?[/quote]
The high risk HPV type doesnt give you genital warts.
Its hidden, hence the swab.
It can pop up at anytime even if you only have one partner in your lifetime.
If they have it, they can pass it to you and it usually dealt with by the imnune system.
In some individuals it then reactivates, probably something to do with the immune system

Its a clear plastic speculum now, single use only.
I dont think home testing is available generally on the NHS, although there must be potential for research/ studies.
It is available privately via online services such as Superdrug.

StrawberryTartington · 19/02/2022 18:13

They don't check for abnormal cells if you're HPV negative (as I am), is that correct? My cervix is tilted towards the back, so they can't see anything, meaning they'd miss a cyst. Meaning I could have a 'less common' cervical cancer and not know anything until I develop symptoms?

They're just testing me for HPV, but I think I've had the all clear after a cervical smear?

There is no point in going through it then, is there?

Bumpy23 · 19/02/2022 18:12

@StaplesCorner
That's not been the case for me. My letter comes back saying abnormal cell changes but no HPV so they must be checking for both.

Leonberger · 19/02/2022 18:12

@StaplesCorner I’ve been to the local STI clinic for smears 3 times now. It’s totally anonymous, you don’t have to see the nurse that resides at the doctors knowing she’s looked up your bits a week before.

Also the STI clinic must put in so many speculums they are very fast and very skilled. It’s always been over in seconds.

It was a revelation when someone told me about it!

Dominoeffect101 · 19/02/2022 18:11

I've seen a lot of comments saying how painful they are. I'm 30 and have had a smear test every year since turning 25 as I have HPV that won't shift and borderline abnormal cells for the last two years. Anyway, my first few smear test were excruciating, honestly i was convinced I'd be heavily bleeding after it hurt that bad. And then when I had my 3rd, I explained to the nurse I find them very very painful, and she had a look. She said I have an inverted cervix which causes smear tests to be alot more painful than for those who have the"average" cervix position. She told me to put my hands into a fist and put them under my bum, and she used the device in a slightly different position, and before I knew it she said she was finished! I barely felt a thing let alone pain. Since then I've told every nurse just before the examination about my inverted cervix, and I havnt had a painful smear test since.

This might not be the case for everyone of course, but had that nurse not told me and I then told others, I fully believe I'd be going through this agony still each time.

oakleaffy · 19/02/2022 18:11

The skill of the tester makes a HUGE difference.
No one in their right mind would like smears, but they are a necessary bit of discomfort.

As for embarrassment?.. The nurses do these day in, day out.. nothing to worry about on that score.

Mumoblue · 19/02/2022 18:10

I’m a single mum to a two year old, and his dad only sees him on Saturdays.
I’m going to try and get one done soon, but I’ll have to ask the ex to watch my son, and he gets so shirty about “doing me favours”. 🙄

Skade · 19/02/2022 18:09

I had CIN3 in 2009 and underwent LLETZ treatment under GA with six monthly smears for 3 years afterwards. I have now decided that I will not continue with screening for my own personal reasons.

I find the way that women police each other over this subject nauseating. We are grown adults and intelligent enough to look at the statistics around cervical screening and make a decision - we don't need people telling us that when we develop cancer we'll be sorry. Women have a right to choose whether they wish to opt out of screening and do not need to be made to feel guilty or stupid for making that decision.

EmmaH2022 · 19/02/2022 18:09

Jennifer why did they do a biopsy?

JenniferWooley · 19/02/2022 18:08

Because I'd have to take the day off work (hour each way commute & appointments always after 11am & guaranteed to be running at least 30mins late so pointless going in when lunch is at one so I'd be working 3 hours), because they stopped doing them during covid, because the nurse who carried them out at my surgery obviously trained in butchery, because I've not been sexually actively for the past 4 years.

I did go last week to get my coil removed (2 years overdue because of covid) & they did my smear & a biopsy (cause I'm old) while they were down there anyway so that's me for a while.

RowanAlong · 19/02/2022 18:05

Yes it’s a bit uncomfortable but better than going to the dentist..

CrocodilesCry · 19/02/2022 18:05

www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC153831/ if anyone wants a read.

Bumpy23 · 19/02/2022 18:05

I think maybe the campaigners could do with reading this thread,!! I've often wondered why some women don't go.

I've definitely been enlightened. I'm sorry to all those who have suffered the uncomfortableness of pushy campaigning.

bitemyarsenic · 19/02/2022 18:04

And how many of those 10,000 will have unecessary treatment?

These numbers are important

Difficult to put it in terms of unecessary.
Would you like a watch and wait system for cell changes then?
Treatment usually means that following it and then after a normal smear women can go back onto the usual programne of recall
Vs worrying about it for years, then potentially needing more invasive treatment.

JanisMoplin · 19/02/2022 18:04

Reading back through the thread, it is interesting to see how anxiety manifests. I have a friend who has never been for a smear because she is too scared they will find something wrong. My 50 something anxiety has taken another form: I now go for every medical test offered to me because I am anxious that something which is easy to fix might go unfixed because I forgot to go for a test.

CrocodilesCry · 19/02/2022 18:03

@RedToothBrush - I agree, figures are important. The screening programme is massively flawed.

In the NHS cervical screening programme, 10 000 women need to be screened for 35 years to prevent 10 out of the 25 deaths estimated to occur without screening. Raffle and colleagues (p 901) analysed the screening records of 350 000 women in Bristol across 20 years and modelled cases of cervical cancer and deaths with and without screening. According to their model, for each death prevented, 152 women have abnormal test results, 79 are referred for investigation, and 53 have treatment. The authors draw attention to the fact that because screening is resource intensive and potentially harmful, good evidence on all its outcomes is required.

crosstalk · 19/02/2022 18:03

@bitemyarsenic

I hope people read your post.

However: if you've been monogamous throughout your life, presumably HPV isn't a problem? or can you inherit genital warts etc?

What is the NHS using instead of steel?

How widespread and reliable is home testing?

Is the NHS addressing the issue of women's reluctance to submit themselves to testing?

pawpaws2022 · 19/02/2022 18:00

@JanisMoplin

Ok I have a question. Not a troll promise. Do I need to shave? Or just trim? I am quite old and have lost touch with what is expected these days.
Nope, I just went as I was. Left my socks on because she said "nothing worse than having a smear AND having cold feet" Smile

For people that haven't been for a while or have never been (and I'm not saying go, but it has changed a bit and if someone is reading that has never been and all that...)

Speculums are plastic and you can ask for a small one
The scrape is a brush thing
You don't HAVE to lie on your back, they can do it when you're on your side

venusandmars · 19/02/2022 17:58

I didn't miss any during my 20s, 30s, 40s

But during menopause my cycle were all over the place, booked appointments got cancelled because I had an unexpected period. Rearranged, and re-cancelled. Then I had vaginal dryness and couldn't face it. Then I dropped off their radar....

JanisMoplin · 19/02/2022 17:57

Thanks! I am not really of the generation that takes it all off. I am going to have a glass of wine before I go and treat myself afterwards.
I find mammos also painful and embarassing but not as bad as smears.

bitemyarsenic · 19/02/2022 17:56

Given they don’t actually look at the cervical cells unless they detect HPV it could be argued that not examining the smears they do do could also lead to cancer if you develop a non HPV related one.

No that type of non hpv cancer is usually not found on cell examination either.
It usually presents as looking like a cyst which is why you are examined.
Just to add that no screening system is 100% effective ( HPV is more effective than standard cytology)so anyone experiencing symptoms betweeen smears should always see a gp.

SpaghettiArmsMurderer · 19/02/2022 17:56

@JanisMoplin no need to do anything like that unless you want to Smile

Beachbreak2411 · 19/02/2022 17:56

36 and never had one. I’m too embarrassed and shy / uncomfortable. I was also told by a friend the nurse doing hers weighed her before and lectured her on being overweight during the procedure. I’m over weight and just couldn’t handle that.