Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To ask why you’ve missed/delayed/declined cervical screening?

936 replies

chickentikkawhatswrong · 19/02/2022 13:56

I see a lot of the campaigns on Facebook about women not going to smears or putting them off for too long.

However it’s generally stats and doesn’t seem to delve too far into the actual reasons?

If you are reluctant what holds you back from attending?

OP posts:
JenniferWooley · 19/02/2022 18:51

@EmmaH2022

Jennifer why did they do a biopsy?
Because they used to do it routinely at 40, it's currently done routinely at 45 & she said because I'm 43 they'd just do everything at the same time.
Theluggage15 · 19/02/2022 18:46

When I tore on the last occasion, it was the dismissive and unpleasant attitude of the nurse that was the worst thing. I’ve done my research and know I’m very low risk and am not going to go again.

The attitudes of some on this thread remind me of the nurse.

Terfydactyl · 19/02/2022 18:45

@Appin

I used to think smears were uncomfortable until one found cervical cancer. What I then went through in terms of treatment and investigations was beyond uncomfortable.
See I opted out of smears completely, no reminder letters, no stress in the run up to it, no asking for valium to get through it ( I didnt but I sorely wanted to) because I had a truly terrible smear years ago. I mean off the charts insane, not even a psychopath would treat someone like that. And then you tell me if I get cervical cancer then it's worse treatment still. In that case I'd rather not know, I'm gonna die one day of something, rather die than have any more rummaging around by strangers down there.

And OP ^ this is why I will never ever have a smear again. If the healthcare system had been more forward thinking, they might have realised such an invasive test on the population that is raped and assaulted most often was not a great idea. Add to that the HCPs who make it a hundred times worse than it could be and you put off a massive chunk of women.

Everyone else who detests them or no longer wants one, email your surgery, tell them you no longer consent to smears and you will not have any more fear inducing letters.

greyinganddecaying · 19/02/2022 18:44

So am I correct in thinking:

1- if you don't have HPV they won't test for abnormal cells. So if you know you're HPV negative there's no point in having a smear.

2 - most cervical cancer cases are picked up on symptoms rather than screening

3 - if you've not had sex since your last smear (that was HPV negative) then it's unlikely that you'll become HPV positive (and what's the reason for asking about sexual activity at a smear test?)

4 - you can't use lube for the smear test, so if you have vaginal atrophy then there's a decent chance it'll be more difficult/painful - there's no way around this

grapewine · 19/02/2022 18:44

Just reading these and wondering if the people fell prey to c/c. Would it make them think how stupid they were

Comments like this one are so fucking unhelpful. It is not the woman's fault if she gets cervical cancer. And that campaign ad upthread should not have been approved.

But for some reason, it is OK to condescend and guilt-trip women.

RedToothBrush · 19/02/2022 18:44

I've requested that my GP doesn't do this because its one thing (of many) that stops me going to the GP because of the harassment. It was supposed to be added to my notes with a big - don't do this.

Still happened.

It has seriously damaged my trust, because I don't feel listened to and respected.

No is not a word that exists in this context. We can't make an informed choice to opt out. Thats fundamentally wrong in its own right.

Skade · 19/02/2022 18:41

@Svadhyaya

It's incredibly insulting to insinuate that it isn't painful. Nobody has any way of knowing what someone else's perception of pain is like.

For me it IS physically painful and emotionally triggering due to past abuse. I can manage to get it done by taking a diazepam beforehand.

Oh - and as for childbirth - I couldn't give birth naturally either due to the same trauma and had a c-section I'd rather have my stomach sliced open than have medical professionals (probably men) rooting around down there

Agreed. I had two large babies vaginally in a short space of time without pain relief, believe me, I am well versed in pain. Cervical screening is a whole other level for me - I require 3 diazepam and a nurse standing by me with a vomit bowl for me to throw up into. It makes me very angry to hear people say that I am somehow being silly for finding it painful.
wolfmom · 19/02/2022 18:41

BestKnitterInScotland you need to ask your GP to notify them. I had the same and was listed as a defaulter even though I had everything removed 6 years ago

XenoBitch · 19/02/2022 18:40

@RedToothBrush

Just opt out if you dont want to have screening.

You can't. They continue to harass you and harass you.
Even when you tell them not to.

Letter after fucking letter.

I think its appalling that you are not allowed to say no.

I've tried.

Same. I still get at least two letters each year. And it get mentions when I am seeing a GP for something like mental health. Do men get the same level of pressure for prostate exams?
Silverswirl · 19/02/2022 18:39

@mogsrus

Just reading these and wondering if the people fell prey to c/c. Would it make them think how stupid they were to avoid going for ten minutes to see that everything is ok
And this is the exact attitude that puts many women off going. Minimising the procedure to basically don’t be a big baby. Just because it wasn’t agony for you, doesn’t mean it’s not for someone else. You may well have put someone off who was on the fence with just this comment. Hope that makes you feel strong and powerful.
RedToothBrush · 19/02/2022 18:36

Just opt out if you dont want to have screening.

You can't. They continue to harass you and harass you.
Even when you tell them not to.

Letter after fucking letter.

I think its appalling that you are not allowed to say no.

I've tried.

bitemyarsenic · 19/02/2022 18:32

The comments relating to HPV vaccine are valid.
Pretty sure that the screening will change but remember thats the 26/27 year olds and under.
Women over that age wont have been vaccinated.

You are invited every 3 years from age 25 and then every 5 years from age 50.
Screening ceases at age 64 unless you have symptoms.
3 reminders are sent .
Can you imagine if one reminder was sent and was missed, the NHS would be sued left, right and centre.
Just opt out if you dont want to have screening.

HestersSamplerofCarrots · 19/02/2022 18:32

Because my cycles can vary from as short as 18 days to over 45, it takes literally days to get through to the GP surgery and they want you to go at a certain point in your cycle - I’m sick of ‘debating’ with receptionists about it. I can’t book a short notice appointment because of the difficulties getting through and how hard it is to get an appt with a nurse when I do get through.

I’d go if they made it easy to.

Afraidofninja · 19/02/2022 18:30

@sairiegamp

Vaginal atrophy.
Precisely. Vaginal atrophy is a significant problem for many as we get older. It feels a bit patronising to see younger women saying that smears aren't a big deal if you deal with them the right way. They have no idea.
Afraidofninja · 19/02/2022 18:27

@Dominoeffect101

I've seen a lot of comments saying how painful they are. I'm 30 and have had a smear test every year since turning 25 as I have HPV that won't shift and borderline abnormal cells for the last two years. Anyway, my first few smear test were excruciating, honestly i was convinced I'd be heavily bleeding after it hurt that bad. And then when I had my 3rd, I explained to the nurse I find them very very painful, and she had a look. She said I have an inverted cervix which causes smear tests to be alot more painful than for those who have the"average" cervix position. She told me to put my hands into a fist and put them under my bum, and she used the device in a slightly different position, and before I knew it she said she was finished! I barely felt a thing let alone pain. Since then I've told every nurse just before the examination about my inverted cervix, and I havnt had a painful smear test since.

This might not be the case for everyone of course, but had that nurse not told me and I then told others, I fully believe I'd be going through this agony still each time.

Smears were a breeze for me when I was younger, I have an inverted cervix. See how you feel when you're in your 60's, hopefully all will be fine.
RedToothBrush · 19/02/2022 18:27

[quote SpaghettiArmsMurderer]@RedToothBrush do you know if the is NHS reducing it for vaccinated women? Or all women?
I am the age where we had the HPV jab at school, one of my friends unfortunately still managed to catch it and needed some treatment which was picked up on at her first smear. However that means I am also the age where no one posts on social media any more so I can't comment on that Smile I went to a breast cancer charity do at uni and remember pink ribbons being on everything circa 10-15 years ago, but can't say cervical cancer has had much publicity in my age group apart from receiving the invitation to screening.[/quote]
I don't there are currently any plans for the cervical screening programme to be formally reduced.

I do know there is talk that screening will become a thing of the past, but I don't think anything has been actioned and I'm not aware of guidance reflecting this yet. But I do think that they are starting to say that the research is building up.

MarchCrocus · 19/02/2022 18:26

Oh it hasn't gone in the quote bit, nvm, it did in the preview.

MarchCrocus · 19/02/2022 18:25

[quote SpaghettiArmsMurderer]@MarchCrocus What exactly do you think my view is? I expressed surprise that people are weighing up today's certain pain vs tomorrow's less certain but greater pain and coming down in favour of avoiding today's pain (which I suggested may be down to optimism bias, a cognitive bias everyone has which makes us think bad things won't happen to us), and concern that the women who develop cancer despite being low risk may be missing out on smears that could help them. How is that misogynistic?

And men are guilt tripped about prostate cancer risk. There are regularly stalls with people accosting men about it in my local train station. If anything I've previously wondered why there are stalls for that and not cervical/breast cancer![/quote]
I think your views are the things you have stated in this thread. They are unhelpful, as was your insistence on repeating them several times. To clarify, I don't think you yourself are necessarily a misogynist, the misogyny I referred to was about the way in which women are treated by parts of the medical profession.

And there is just no way that men are subjected to the same treatment as women when it comes to intimate procedures. It wouldn't be possible anyway, because the female experience in healthcare stems from societal misogyny, from women's bodies being seen as the problem rather than the default, and women as being lesser. But there is no male equivalent of, for example, the weaponisation of children to try and guilt trip women as in this article and the attached poster.

www.thetimes.co.uk/article/mothers-accuse-the-bbc-of-taking-them-on-guilt-trip-bh8lrhvhv

Btw I don't seem to be able to attach the photo without it looking like it's a quote from you, not sure why. Just to be clear I know it isn't, it's one I am citing as evidence for my point.

To ask why you’ve missed/delayed/declined cervical screening?
Svadhyaya · 19/02/2022 18:25

It's incredibly insulting to insinuate that it isn't painful. Nobody has any way of knowing what someone else's perception of pain is like.

For me it IS physically painful and emotionally triggering due to past abuse. I can manage to get it done by taking a diazepam beforehand.

Oh - and as for childbirth - I couldn't give birth naturally either due to the same trauma and had a c-section I'd rather have my stomach sliced open than have medical professionals (probably men) rooting around down there

SpaghettiArmsMurderer · 19/02/2022 18:24

@RedToothBrush do you know if the is NHS reducing it for vaccinated women? Or all women?
I am the age where we had the HPV jab at school, one of my friends unfortunately still managed to catch it and needed some treatment which was picked up on at her first smear. However that means I am also the age where no one posts on social media any more so I can't comment on that Smile I went to a breast cancer charity do at uni and remember pink ribbons being on everything circa 10-15 years ago, but can't say cervical cancer has had much publicity in my age group apart from receiving the invitation to screening.

oakleaffy · 19/02/2022 18:18

@Dominoeffect101

I've seen a lot of comments saying how painful they are. I'm 30 and have had a smear test every year since turning 25 as I have HPV that won't shift and borderline abnormal cells for the last two years. Anyway, my first few smear test were excruciating, honestly i was convinced I'd be heavily bleeding after it hurt that bad. And then when I had my 3rd, I explained to the nurse I find them very very painful, and she had a look. She said I have an inverted cervix which causes smear tests to be alot more painful than for those who have the"average" cervix position. She told me to put my hands into a fist and put them under my bum, and she used the device in a slightly different position, and before I knew it she said she was finished! I barely felt a thing let alone pain. Since then I've told every nurse just before the examination about my inverted cervix, and I havnt had a painful smear test since.

This might not be the case for everyone of course, but had that nurse not told me and I then told others, I fully believe I'd be going through this agony still each time.

Ohj my goodness....same thing happened to me! I actually fainted after one smear test it was so ''urgh'' But the experienced nurse was so good and kindly.. Balled fists under bumcheeks made it so much more comfortable.

Blessed are the good practitioners.

sairiegamp · 19/02/2022 18:17

Vaginal atrophy.

Belledan1 · 19/02/2022 18:16

Mine was cancelled first lock down and I totally forgot and never had a reminder off gp. I remembered last November but cldnt either get through to make it or when I did was no appts and told ring back which I did but date offered conflicted with a big work thing. Actually got one next week now. Do feel silly forgetting.

euniceanddudley · 19/02/2022 18:16

Mine's overdue. They weren't doing them due to COVID when my letter came and I haven't got round to booking it.

I believe I am low risk these days, never had an abnormal one and single for years, now in my 50s. I will book it though.

Fridafever · 19/02/2022 18:15

For those that do want the screening I absolutely endorse finding a sexual health clinic. They’re much more skilled in my experience than a GP or nurse at the GP’s.