Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To ask why you’ve missed/delayed/declined cervical screening?

936 replies

chickentikkawhatswrong · 19/02/2022 13:56

I see a lot of the campaigns on Facebook about women not going to smears or putting them off for too long.

However it’s generally stats and doesn’t seem to delve too far into the actual reasons?

If you are reluctant what holds you back from attending?

OP posts:
Tillyvonpantsalo · 20/02/2022 07:37

I never missed a smear so went for my routine one on time. The nurse carrying out the smear asked the Dr to see me immediately as she was so concerned by what she could see.

I didn't have cervical cancer but did have a rare cancer caused by an underlying gynae condition.. Treatment is much more invasive than a smear. I do wonder if people on here who don't have a smear would choose to decline treatment if they did develop a gynae cancer. Sadly, whilst in hospital I saw this scenario.

Please try to go. It really did save my life. I know my case was rare, but somone has to be that one.

Stillgoings · 20/02/2022 07:28

I always did go..they struggled to find my cervix but it was ok. Then in 2014 as I was becoming perimenpaisal I had an incredibly painful experience. It was awful, she tried 4 or 5 times and couldn't do it. I left in tears. A couple of years later I had to go to a gynae clinic at the hospital about a fibroid and while I was there they strapped me into stirrups and did the smear test..They were very good at it and very quick but it was still painful. I haven't been since. I've just been put on vagifem for vaginal atrophy and the Dr said they will try to get a smear done for me.when it has kicked in. I'm full of dread but also really worried about not having had one for so long

QueenOfToast · 20/02/2022 07:19

Like @JollyAndBright , I know that I don't have HPV so there's no point having smear tests any more.

WiseUpJanetWeiss · 20/02/2022 07:09

@Willowkins

I did a quick word count on this thread and there are 380 references to pain. I need to have one last one and I'm going to ask for local anaesthetic but I'm worried that I'll be dismissed (we don't do that here) or belittled (it's not that bad).
I don't think they will do that. Women can't often get LAs for hysteroscopy (for several reasons including ones of medical risk) so I can't see a practice nurse doing this.

PPs have mentioned GA, which seems a bit extreme, but if you're higher risk that may be an option. Or maybe going private.

WiseUpJanetWeiss · 20/02/2022 07:05

@thingymaboob

I am absolutely shocked by the majority of these posts. I simply cannot believe that so many people would risk not knowing whether they have a cancer because of a couple of minutes of embarrassment and discomfort. You know cancer is quite painful, too and cause a lot more discomfort than a smear:
I am absolutely shocked by the lack of reading comprehension and empathy shown by some posters on this thread.

Screening carries its own risks. Risk of pain, fear, humiliation, flashbacks, and over-treatment for cell changes that would never have gone on to develop into cancer. Anyone who dismisses these risks is ignorant as well as having no empathy.

All women have agency and can make their own informed risk assessment based on the above factors. The screening programme should educate not coerce.

You have made your own risk assessment and no-one here is trying to persuade you otherwise.

KattyR786 · 20/02/2022 06:33

I’m genuinely curious here, as to WHY WHY WHY there is so much emphasis on. A test for a cancer we have less than 1% chance of getting? And an awful test at that when self testing has been available for years? Stroke and heart disease kill more women than this rare cancer, do we ask each other if we attend appointments about this? Do we ask each other if we have been to the dentist/ opticians and breathe each other if negative reply? Do we chase men to get bowel screening? Why do some of you feel it’s acceptable to berate women who choose not to have this test? To tell abuse survivors to get counselling and then go? For a test for a cancer that kills 690 women a year out of 30 million women. My vagina my decision. Your vagina your decision

sanluca · 20/02/2022 06:18

@thingymaboob

I am absolutely shocked by the majority of these posts. I simply cannot believe that so many people would risk not knowing whether they have a cancer because of a couple of minutes of embarrassment and discomfort. You know cancer is quite painful, too and cause a lot more discomfort than a smear:
Because it is not little discomfort and embarrassment but real pain and humiliation. I for one cannot understand the complete lack of empathy in women towards other women with regard to female issues we all know and should be able to understand.

No wonder in my experience so many female health practitioners are unkind, belittling and harsh. I used to believe it was only the male ones as they couldn't relate to the female experience, but I think the overall male oriented way of thinking in healthcare is rubbing of on the women.

And yes, I am one of those who bins the smear invites.

JenniferWooley · 20/02/2022 04:52

@paisley256

I feel a bit daft asking this but does anyone know how they gauge what size equipment they use?

Whenever I've had a smear they put it in and try for ages to take a swab, only to take it out and say it's no good they need the bigger/smaller size before starting again.

It hurts and I've never really understood how they work out the size. Thanks

I've never thought about this but she did ask if all my births had been vaginal during my phone consultation which I thought was a bit weird as not really relevant but maybe it was to gauge whether or not I'd be ok with the regular size speculum Hmm

thingymaboob · 20/02/2022 04:50

@coatofsomanycolours I don't think I explained clearly. I have had probably 6 smears in my life and I have also had the LLETZ procedure for CIN2/3 and I've had various invasive procedures down below (hysterosalpingogram / examination during miscarriage / ectopic) so I've had lots of gynae experiences and the smear is such a short procedure, albeit a painful one. It's over in a couple of minutes. I suffer cervical stimulation which causes me to pass out when i have a smear but again, its transient and over quickly. I'm just shocked that so many women find this short procedure intolerable to the point of refusal. Do the same women forgo sex, childbirth, STI screens and insertion of tampons etc? Had I not been screened and had my abnormal cells removed 7 years ago, I dread to think what I would be going through now. That someone could refuse a short test which would identify and treat cervical cancer is baffling to me, even if it is painful

Willowkins · 20/02/2022 04:03

I did a quick word count on this thread and there are 380 references to pain. I need to have one last one and I'm going to ask for local anaesthetic but I'm worried that I'll be dismissed (we don't do that here) or belittled (it's not that bad).

coatofsomanycolours · 20/02/2022 04:02

Just came back to say can I clarify that my laughing face (🤣) was not at people’s personal pain (I apologise for any offence caused) but at comparing the ridiculousness of labour that for me ended in a lot of pain and an emergency c section against the painless quick swab of my cervix that I have experienced multiple times (something similar to cleaning my ears out with a cotton bud yet but more intimate 🤪)

I was one of the people to be very upset by your smiling face so it means such a lot to have your explanation and apology. Thank you!! I am so sorry that you went through a traumatic birth and glad you find cervical smears painless. For me however the situation is totally reversed in that I have coped with serious gynaecology issues well, when others would need medication I have managed to cope without. But again in my case having a smear became the agonising medical emergency that needed emergency surgery and was life changing. I did not have a smear for over 20 years, although many were attempted, but when I talked to a lovely consultant when going through further gynae treatment, he suggested doing a smear under GA. And so that's what happens now. Thank you again for your words, unfortunately there are others who are far more unkind and aggressive than you, that have made me feel really ashamed of myself tonight and I have shed tears at some people's lack of compassion, as they have hit on my achilles heel.

coatofsomanycolours · 20/02/2022 03:46

I last had one 10 years ago 2 months after having a child (emcs not vaginal birth) it was really painful, never was before so it put me off. Now post menopausal and I have both atrophy and vagisimus, it's so bad I can't even have sex with DH.

I am sorry you have been through this. My medical history is different to your own but decades of gynae treatment has meant I have the same result as yourself. It isn't a case of embarassment or having the smear done in different ways by different people, or with pain killers or even sedation, it is physically more than is bearable. It was once suggested I have it under a GA, and that's what I have done. Unlike some people on this thread I have had nothing but compassion and understanding by the gynacology medics in the hospital (not so GPs but that's another story). So if it is the pain of the procedure and you would otherwise wish to have a smear test perhaps you could ask about this, although of course I understand having a GA isn't right for everyone either. But I wish you well.

coatofsomanycolours · 20/02/2022 03:35

I am absolutely shocked by the majority of these posts. I simply cannot believe that so many people would risk not knowing whether they have a cancer because of a couple of minutes of embarrassment and discomfort. You know cancer is quite painful, too and cause a lot more discomfort than a smear

Please try and understand that for some people it is agony, beyond agony to have a smear. I am so glad it is just a little uncomfortable for you, really, that's how it should be. But for me and others it is impossible (and as I have previously said not particularly embarrassing, just agonising). I have a high pain threshold normally and have coped with other medical matters without any pain relief that maybe others could not. We are all different. Thankfully the doctors and nurses I have seen have been so lovely and understanding and I have it done under GA, initially their suggestion not mine. But every medical professional I have seen since have been kind and compassionate and never once said any of the words I have read on here tonight. Words that have made me feel belittled and ashamed. I feel a bit of a freak now actually - and until this thread I never did. But for the sake of others in a similar situation to my own, please try and realise, and this is not just to you thingymaboob but to others that have had similar views to your own, that we are all physically different, we all have different histories, and after decades of gynaecological treatments I am unable to have a smear test in the way others do. If the medics can understand that, why can't you?

paisley256 · 20/02/2022 03:16

I feel a bit daft asking this but does anyone know how they gauge what size equipment they use?

Whenever I've had a smear they put it in and try for ages to take a swab, only to take it out and say it's no good they need the bigger/smaller size before starting again.

It hurts and I've never really understood how they work out the size. Thanks

CaptainWentworth · 20/02/2022 03:15

I can’t remember when my last smear was; I had a reminder when I was pregnant with my 3 year old, and I can’t remember if I ever went after she was born. Covid hit when she was 16 months, and while I don’t positively know that screening was suspended at my surgery, the messaging we were given then as a nation was so strong on not contacting the NHS unless you were basically dying, I assumed such things were off. Then I moved house (and surgery), got another reminder but was pregnant again with DD2 who’s now 5 months.

Just had another reminder this week and was going to book in, but it’s put me off rather that they now only test cells if you have HPV - can’t believe they still put you through all that pain/ discomfort when it’s potentially unnecessary.

I’m 38 so been having smears since I was 21 (at least, possibly 18 actually). I’m fine (ish) with the speculum, but I cannot bear the feeling of scraping/ brushing the cervix - I have to really restrain myself from crawling backwards up the bed away from it. I’m hoping it might be better post childbirth, but worried it could be worse…. I don’t remember it being too awful my first one or two smears (was unpleasant but quick at least), but it seemed very firm and to go on for ages on my last one- there mst have been some memo gone out about brushing harder/longer 🤢

thingymaboob · 20/02/2022 02:52

I am absolutely shocked by the majority of these posts. I simply cannot believe that so many people would risk not knowing whether they have a cancer because of a couple of minutes of embarrassment and discomfort. You know cancer is quite painful, too and cause a lot more discomfort than a smear:

montysma1 · 20/02/2022 02:18

I think people know for themselves what is painful and what isn't.

Gooseysgirl · 20/02/2022 01:51

I do go but I fucking hate it and I'm thankfully almost at the age where I won't need them anymore. I've only had one that wasn't painful. I wish I could be anaesthetised for them. And I don't say that lightly.

musicviking1 · 20/02/2022 00:26

I've had them since I was 21, I'm now 43. I hate the way I am told to relax, I hate the way I am never covered up even though the recent smear test pamphlet I received said women are given something to cover themselves, a man once walked in while I was having one done, I hate the way other staff casually walk in and talk to the nurse carrying out the smear while I'm there with my legs akimbo. I have a tilted cervix so for me having a smear IS painful. I was shocked to discover recently it only tests for HPV. I also can't get through to my GP to book a smear as no one answers the phone so I have to email the reception and frankly I just don't want to have to keep telling reception staff everything.

MolkosTeenageAngst · 20/02/2022 00:21

I delay booking it for a variety of reasons. I struggle with organisation at the best of times and then it’s difficult to get one around work, plus my periods are irregular so it’s hard to estimate even I will be in the middle of my cycle. I also find them very painful, I have a tilted cervix and so they are never quick or straightforward and the speculum is too large but the nurse never agrees to use the smaller size until she’s tried with the original one and caused pain. I’ve been raped and they also trigger flashbacks, I usually end up in tears or having a panic attack during the smear which is embarrassing. The whole experience is extremely unpleasant both physically and emotionally and I think this means I do put off booking one once the reminder comes through, I do always do it eventually but it’s usually after I’ve had at least a couple of reminders.

HopingForMyRainbowBaby · 20/02/2022 00:14

The only reason I've had to delay is because of a long period and that was only by a few months. I've been raped and sexually assaulted but I've regularly had them and will continue to do so for as long as it is necessary. Might be uncomfortable for a few minutes and it leaves me with pretty bad cramps due to having a retroverted uterus but it would nothing compared to having cervical cancer.

MrsFlump · 20/02/2022 00:06

I last had one 10 years ago 2 months after having a child (emcs not vaginal birth) it was really painful, never was before so it put me off. Now post menopausal and I have both atrophy and vagisimus, it's so bad I can't even have sex with DH. I get letters and the gp surgery rang me last time, explained my issues and she said OK so will see if I get any more letters. I do however go for a mammogram which is very uncomfortable and leaves me with sore breasts but I'm OK with it.

RedToothBrush · 20/02/2022 00:05

@BOOTS52

Aw redtoothbrush you know I actually thought you were the same poster as xenobitch as you sound the same, on the attack. I was not telling other women or forcing them but just writing about how none of us enjoy it and trying to encourage other women to get it. I am not abusive or harsh but you come across just like xenobitch. Very passive aggressive and nit picking on anyone that you do not agree with. You need help with your anger issues as sound very unpleasant. If you cannot comprehend what I said then no point trying to explain again to you. Call me nasty all you want as I know I am not like that and try to offer support but you do you and I will do me..You sound like a bully.
If you think its nickpicking to state that your comparison with dying your hair to a smear is a complete farce and a straw man crack on. Its not. It was a truly dreadful comparison

If you think I sound like a bully for picking up on such a dreadful patronising and actually down right offensive statement, then fair play.

I do not. I think what you said was truly appalling.

I am sick of the way women are treated and the comparisons with all kinds of bullshit for a very invasive and often very traumatic procedure and who are then told in the most minimising of ways to 'stop being embarassed and go for a smear' because people in authority can not be arsed to actually listen to all the women here telling them the real reasons they haven't gone which are more like - its impossible to get an appointment, I'm treated appallingly, its dreadfully painful or I've had a past trauma so no I'm not going to put myself through that because the NHS can't work out another way to screen that suits them.

The personal attack is dire and unnecessary. I am stating that your argument is utterly dreadful and its patronising and offensive. If you don't like it. Tough.

Play the ball, not the man.

Rummikub · 20/02/2022 00:02

@catzrulz

Rummikub

Isn’t it true that incidence of cervical cancer in nuns is low/nil?

Cervical cancer is transmitted by a virus. Virgins don’t get cervical cancer.

Seriously, why are people so stupid....

Who is being stupid?
Porcupineintherough · 20/02/2022 00:02

I dont think GPS surgeries need to work harder, or even longer hours (unless funding for extra staff is made available). I do think they should work differently though, with a lot of the routine screening and reviews offered outside the core 9-5.30pm. Something like the smear program, you need to take away barriers such as women needing to take time off from work, or bring their children along with them because their partner's not home.