Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To ask why you’ve missed/delayed/declined cervical screening?

936 replies

chickentikkawhatswrong · 19/02/2022 13:56

I see a lot of the campaigns on Facebook about women not going to smears or putting them off for too long.

However it’s generally stats and doesn’t seem to delve too far into the actual reasons?

If you are reluctant what holds you back from attending?

OP posts:
PinkSparklyPussyCat · 20/02/2022 09:54

[quote Katya213]@RedToothBrush nobody on here cares whether you get a smear or not. The doctor doesn't lose sleep over it either. Your body, your choice.[/quote]
So why all the patronising, minimising posts on here and the constant reminders from the doctor?

Katya213 · 20/02/2022 09:48

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk guidelines.

U2HasTheEdge · 20/02/2022 09:43

@thingymaboob

I am absolutely shocked by the majority of these posts. I simply cannot believe that so many people would risk not knowing whether they have a cancer because of a couple of minutes of embarrassment and discomfort. You know cancer is quite painful, too and cause a lot more discomfort than a smear:
My chances of getting CC are extremely small.

I risk not knowing whether I have cancer every day. I could develop cancer anywhere and I won't be aware until I get symptoms. I live with that risk and knowledge. Same for CC. If I get symptoms I will seek medical attention.

I am much more likely to develop heart disease with my family history. No one is screening me for that, except the occasional blood pressure check.

I am absolutely shocked that you have downplayed people's experiences here. If you read the thread you will see that it is not just a 'couple of minutes of embarrassment and discomfort' for everyone.

namechange9862629 · 20/02/2022 09:42

@thingymaboob - I ended up needing valium for four days last time as I couldn’t cope with the flashbacks after, bit the back of my hand and ended up bruised and that was with a GP and nurse I feel very safe with . I jumped so much when the GP touched me that I almost kneed her in the nose . GP phoned me the morning after to make sure I was OK and was on phone 20 minutes .

That’s not a couple of minutes of embarrassment or discomfort .

Believe me, I’ve had dozens of gynae appointments - twice a year from age 16-28, first internal I had was age seven, have had multiple surgeries (disorder of development), and NHS eventually had to apologise to me fourteen times in a five page letter for what they called systemic abuse - I can’t hack smear tests because of past treatment . People are saying on here to get counselling; apparently unaware of the fact that counselling for PTSD is very very limited on the NHS .

I’m well aware of the risks of cervical cancer, but genuinely think my risk is very very low given I’ve never had sex or anything close with another human, have never been touched by another person who wasn’t wearing gloves at the time . Unless you can catch it from the GP couch or a swimming pool .

TimBoothseyes · 20/02/2022 09:37

@thingymaboob

I am absolutely shocked by the majority of these posts. I simply cannot believe that so many people would risk not knowing whether they have a cancer because of a couple of minutes of embarrassment and discomfort. You know cancer is quite painful, too and cause a lot more discomfort than a smear:
Having to take the maximum strength OTC painkillers and bleeding for 3 days after having one makes it a bit more than "a couple of minutes of embarrassment and discomfort". If that's all it is in your experience then all I can say is lucky you.
bitemyarsenic · 20/02/2022 09:30

@KattyR786

But, BiteMy Arsenic, breast cancer kills far more women than cervical cancer, and we don’t have continuous awareness campaigns and hysteria over that, and women who don’t attend mammograms ! And bowel cancer affects both men and women, ditto! Where are the posts and threads aimed at bullying men into screening? Or women for that matter? A woman’s lifetime risk of cervical cancer is less than 1%! Be she a nun or ordinary Joanna Public! Women are adults and can choose for themselves! It’s so sad here, the women who have smears under anaesthesia, who use pessaries for vaginal atrophy, who dread smears but still force themselves to go, when there is a self test option that the NHS could roll out tomorrow if it wished! That Dutch and Finnish women have had access to for years and their CC rates and death are among the lowest in the world! As to Ms Goody, she had adenocarcinoma, a rare and aggressive form of this cancer that affects mainly younger women and that the smear test rarely picks up, and she had her first abnormal cells removed at just 15 or 16 when we know the cervix is still maturing and can produce wildly abnormal results at one screening and reverse to normal by the next. This is why the screening age was raised. I always think Ms Goody was damaged so badly by possibly unnecessary treatments . My personal opinion. To those who liken screening to getting their hair dyed… really? Some. Women might choose no smear and no hair dye. Their valid choices. To those who say, why be embarrassed the nurse sees it every day, it’s not about the nurse it’s about the woman’s feelings! I opted out in 2015 and haven’t had a smear in 22 years. My vagina my decision!
There are continuous campaigns, fund raising and awareness surrounding breast cancer . Im not overly keen on the term " hysteria" used in the context of womens health. Internalised misogyny given that womens health concerns are often dismissed and on average womens diagnosis take 8 times longer than men for shared health concerns.

I agree that hopefully less invasive testing will be forefront and with the vaccine this awful disease will be eradicated.
Im not party to Jade Goodys medical history so will not comment regarding that.

Adenocarcinoma in young women however is highly associated with contraction of HR HPV at a young age.

heather2908 · 20/02/2022 09:29

I got a letter to book mine yesterday. I don’t mind having them and it just takes a few minutes. However, last time I ended up a few months late because my practice only offered them during term time because of the working pattern of the available nurse and I’m a teacher. I asked about the local sexual health clinic but they only saw you if you had unusual/worrying symptoms and couldn’t get in with your GP. I ended up having to take time off work and have someone cover my class so I could go. I’m hoping this situation has improved since then as it’s been 3 years.

Terfydactyl · 20/02/2022 09:23

@thingymaboob

I am absolutely shocked by the majority of these posts. I simply cannot believe that so many people would risk not knowing whether they have a cancer because of a couple of minutes of embarrassment and discomfort. You know cancer is quite painful, too and cause a lot more discomfort than a smear:
Why are you shocked? Be fair, you didnt read any posts, cos if you had you would have read that

Very few to no posters have said it's about embarrassment or discomfort.
A lot have said trauma a fair few have said pain ( not discomfort) some have decided that as the cells aren't even tested and you can buy a home kit for hpv, or you've never had sex or they just dont want to.
Those of us for any reason or none are allowed to say NO.
It's a complete sentence and its valid.
We have explained why and you haven't listened, just like the NHS dont listen. They keep spouting on about embarrassment and a two minutes thing, when it's their own incompetence and their staff who assault patients and patronise.
If I die of cancer it's far more likely to be breast cancer, I dont care about dying, it doesn't scare me. But I will no longer have people pawing at me and gaslighting me.

RedToothBrush · 20/02/2022 09:22

@katya213
To quote another poster
Well, quite. Any opportunity to hector and berate and zero compassion.

Give it a rest with the utterly tone deaf, insensitive, rude and patronising lecture.

The system is stacked against women.

Theres always a good stick to beat us with. Never enough time to actually listen and address problems though.

balloonsintrees · 20/02/2022 09:16

@JustLyra

Trying to time an appointment around irregular periods has delayed mine since they started doing smears again post lockdown.

You can't get an appointment thats any closer than 5/6 weeks away. I have, and have always had, massively irregular periods. Sometimes 3 weeks, sometimes 12.

You can guarantee that if I book a smear I'll start the day before.

Unfortunately my GP don't offer any way round it. I even suggested I could call for cancellations (they always have a notice up telling you how many last minute cancellations there are, as well as missed appointments), but they won't.

I used to get them done at the sexual health clinic, but theyre only seeing people with worrying symptoms atm, everything else is still phone or online.

This... and I work full time as a teacher so nigh on impossible to take time out for medical appointments. Haven't been for a smear test in 15 years, am 45 now and can't see myself ever going again - I also have a tilted cervix which makes it vomit inducingly painful.
Katya213 · 20/02/2022 09:15

@PurpleDaisies The ladies who are vaccinated are right, it's a small risk. The ladies that aren't are at risk, abnormal cells tend to come back when women are in their fifties and they put abnormal bleeding down to menopause. Nobody has a gun to people head, it's your choice, your body. The service is there if you want it. It has saved an awful lot of women's lives.

bitemyarsenic · 20/02/2022 09:03

Regarding Vaginal Atrophy.
This is caused by lack of oestrogen during and after the menopause.
As stated it is extremely painful , debilitating and can cause severe and repetitive UTI.
Please dont suffer, its easily treatable with an oestrogen vaginal pessary( tiny like a tablet)or cream, which is so small in dose that its not absorbed by the body
I appreciate that many women get nowhere discussing this with their GP and it will shortly be available OTC.
Its yet another area where womens health concerns are either not discussed or dismissed.I was told by the Practice Nurse at my last smear that I could swap my vagifem for a "moisturiser" from Holland and Barrett.( Im a HCP!)
I told her firmly that my vagina needs oestrogen to remain healthy not a moisturiser.

Terfydactyl · 20/02/2022 09:03

@thingymaboob

I am absolutely shocked by the majority of these posts. I simply cannot believe that so many people would risk not knowing whether they have a cancer because of a couple of minutes of embarrassment and discomfort. You know cancer is quite painful, too and cause a lot more discomfort than a smear:
Did you read the thread? All those women saying why they wont/can't have it?

RTB wrote
I am sick of the way women are treated and the comparisons with all kinds of bullshit for a very invasive and often very traumatic procedure and who are then told in the most minimising of ways to 'stop being embarassed and go for a smear' because people in authority can not be arsed to actually listen to all the women here telling them the real reasons they haven't gone which are more like - its impossible to get an appointment, I'm treated appallingly, its dreadfully painful or I've had a past trauma so no I'm not going to put myself through that because the NHS can't work out another way to screen that suits them

And I agree, adding too that from previous years when I had a smear I coped, I managed, somehow I got through it. Then I had the worst smear of my life, it was sexual assault and more, not a fucking smear and I decided enough now. Then a bit later I discovered they only test the cells the take IF you are Hpv. So double fuck that shit. Not happening.

ISaySteadyOn · 20/02/2022 08:59

@RedToothBrush

I find it staggering that women are agreeing to this under GA.

GA is a risk in its own right. I think its abhorrent that they make women feel its that crucial they go through that.

The fact that no non invasive test is available in the uk smacks of how women's health is regarded.

It doesn't matter the trauma and pain. Just guilt them (then deny there is an issue with emotional blackmail). Then say i cant believe the responses of women here, what they say is invalid BECAUSE THEY MIGHT DIE.

As someone has just put, 'Stroke and heart disease kill more women than this rare cancer'. Given my family history, im much more worried about that. Is it taken seriously. Is it fuck.

It does feel its more about control and coercion of women rather than giving a shit about them.

Well, quite. Any opportunity to hector and berate and zero compassion.

I am actually appalled at the amount of women on this thread who have suffered poor treatment by HCPs. I am also, after reading the thread, baffled by how anyone could think that women refuse due to embarrassment. Pain, trauma, the experience of being patronised to the hilt, no, that has nothing to do with it. It's the stupid silly women's stupid vanity.

I am grateful for the knowledge of home tests. I will be doing that as I will be more able to obtain that than a GP appointment.

KattyR786 · 20/02/2022 08:58

Just THINK how many men could be saved too if we targeted them about bowel screening! Maybe we need more awareness campaigns over that? Maybe women have heard about smears and are aware of them, after all we have “invitations “ reminders yet more letters, phone calls, harassment about it if we see a GP for our bunions, countless awareness campaigns and countless threads such as this one, countless supposed celebs like Scarlett Moffat (who is she btw why is she famous?) maybe women are deciding they don’t want this test and that should be accepted. End of. Finito

SirSamVimesCityWatch · 20/02/2022 08:57

Do the same women forgo sex, childbirth, STI screens and insertion of tampons etc?

This is the same thinking that decides rape can't be that bad because women happily accept some penises in their vagina, therefore any penis in their vagina mustn't be that bad.

This is in capitals because I really want you to imagine me screaming it at you: FUCK OFF.

Any woman has the absolute right to decide what, when, and in what circumstances, a foreign object is inserted into her vagina by another person.

KattyR786 · 20/02/2022 08:54

But, BiteMy Arsenic, breast cancer kills far more women than cervical cancer, and we don’t have continuous awareness campaigns and hysteria over that, and women who don’t attend mammograms ! And bowel cancer affects both men and women, ditto! Where are the posts and threads aimed at bullying men into screening? Or women for that matter?
A woman’s lifetime risk of cervical cancer is less than 1%! Be she a nun or ordinary Joanna Public!
Women are adults and can choose for themselves!
It’s so sad here, the women who have smears under anaesthesia, who use pessaries for vaginal atrophy, who dread smears but still force themselves to go, when there is a self test option that the NHS could roll out tomorrow if it wished! That Dutch and Finnish women have had access to for years and their CC rates and death are among the lowest in the world!
As to Ms Goody, she had adenocarcinoma, a rare and aggressive form of this cancer that affects mainly younger women and that the smear test rarely picks up, and she had her first abnormal cells removed at just 15 or 16 when we know the cervix is still maturing and can produce wildly abnormal results at one screening and reverse to normal by the next. This is why the screening age was raised. I always think Ms Goody was damaged so badly by possibly unnecessary treatments . My personal opinion.
To those who liken screening to getting their hair dyed… really? Some. Women might choose no smear and no hair dye. Their valid choices.
To those who say, why be embarrassed the nurse sees it every day, it’s not about the nurse it’s about the woman’s feelings!
I opted out in 2015 and haven’t had a smear in 22 years. My vagina my decision!

PurpleDaisies · 20/02/2022 08:53

[quote Katya213]@Afraidofninja....true. A lot of women in later life get hit with gynae cancers which are incredibly painful and life threatening too.[/quote]
Is is a lot of women or an u lucky few?

JollyAndBright · 20/02/2022 08:53

@Pegasushaswings

Thank you *@JollyAndBright* I’m just too old then.
Me too unfortunately.
Katya213 · 20/02/2022 08:44

@Afraidofninja....true. A lot of women in later life get hit with gynae cancers which are incredibly painful and life threatening too.

Afraidofninja · 20/02/2022 08:27

There are still some very ignorant posters commenting so I will lay this out clearly for them -
It's perfectly possible to go through life inserting tampons, having sex, having children and having smear tests without massive discomfort.
Later in life, for a significant number of women, they get hit by vaginal atrophy. It is a destroyer of sex lives, a cause of infection and can make a procedure like a smear test unbearably painful. Until you experience it yourselves in later life (let's hope you don't eh?) you won't know how it feels, but for some it's on a similar scale to childbirth. Who would be dismissive of that sort of pain being suddenly forced on them?

RedToothBrush · 20/02/2022 08:22

I find it staggering that women are agreeing to this under GA.

GA is a risk in its own right. I think its abhorrent that they make women feel its that crucial they go through that.

The fact that no non invasive test is available in the uk smacks of how women's health is regarded.

It doesn't matter the trauma and pain. Just guilt them (then deny there is an issue with emotional blackmail). Then say i cant believe the responses of women here, what they say is invalid BECAUSE THEY MIGHT DIE.

As someone has just put, 'Stroke and heart disease kill more women than this rare cancer'. Given my family history, im much more worried about that. Is it taken seriously. Is it fuck.

It does feel its more about control and coercion of women rather than giving a shit about them.

bitemyarsenic · 20/02/2022 08:17

@KattyR786

I’m genuinely curious here, as to WHY WHY WHY there is so much emphasis on. A test for a cancer we have less than 1% chance of getting? And an awful test at that when self testing has been available for years? Stroke and heart disease kill more women than this rare cancer, do we ask each other if we attend appointments about this? Do we ask each other if we have been to the dentist/ opticians and breathe each other if negative reply? Do we chase men to get bowel screening? Why do some of you feel it’s acceptable to berate women who choose not to have this test? To tell abuse survivors to get counselling and then go? For a test for a cancer that kills 690 women a year out of 30 million women. My vagina my decision. Your vagina your decision
690 women die of a disease that is largely completely preventable not to mention those who survive but have gruelling treatment and loss of their fertility,side effects and change in body image. The vast majority are in women who have either never had or who miss smear tests. Its gut wrenchingly awful seeing the distress of a women who says if only I had gone, why didnt I ?

Sadly those who suffer CSA are at even higher risk due to sexual abuse at a young age when the body is maturing.
I include young girls who have underage sex in this, they are not able to give consent.
There is a still proportion of young women in their early 20s with cervical cancer and I dont think the issues they have suffered are being addressed.
Its swept under the carpet.
Everyone should have agency and autonomy over their own bodies, whatever their age/ sex.
This is the unspoken horror of this disease, the abuse they have suffered is still affecting them throughout their lives and prevents screening being accessed.
I really hope that the vaccine plus less invasive screening means this disease is eradicated in the future.

tirednewmumm · 20/02/2022 08:01

I've always had mine, never delayed or missed. Unfortunately since I had my baby there's a lot of scar tissue, I went for it and they were physically unable to complete it. Two different speculums couldn't open the scar tissue far enough to reach the cervix Sad
They suggested I come back but I'll be delaying a while after the agony and humiliation for sure even though I know how important it is

Undercity · 20/02/2022 07:47

Why do so many women on here not see that smears are unnecessary for as long as cells are not actually tested?

I have been pre-cancerous without HPV and they don't bother checking my cells even now. A virus doesn't stay in just one area; there will be other ways to test for HPV.

Swipe left for the next trending thread