@Whattochoosenow
Interestingly there’s an article in the BMJ which states that bowel screening isn’t helpful if your Qrisk is under 3%.
I’ve just put mine into the Qrisk calculator and it’s come out at 1.1% 🤷♀️
At what age do you start to think, 'well you've got to die of something?'
I know Margaret McCartney has talked about this too in one of her books (with particular reference to bowel screening).
The really fascinating bit was that there was a study about the level of promotion which encouraged take up, but if they were then given more information to help make a properly informed decision about the effectiveness of it and the potential harms of screening, take up of screening actively dropped. Thus there was a dilemma over how much you should tell the patient to enable informed decision making and whether that was more important than getting the 'correct behaviour' from a patient and higher take up rates of screening.
She bowel cancer in particular she references a Cochrane Review which stated:
Combining the four trials did not show any significant difference in all-cause mortality between the screen and control groups
So basically the point is, if you get bowel cancer it's a sign that your body is giving up on you completely anyway, and it's basically a choice over your cause of death and the manner in which you go.
Of course, if you have a history of bowel cancer in your family or an identified higher risk of it, you might be wiser to play the odds and go for screening as you might well benefit from it more than someone in the general population.
And it was found that once people were informed about this, take up of the screening reduced.
She had a particular beef about how all cause mortality wasn't looked at properly - so you might reduce rates of death from bowel cancer, but you didn't actually reduce deaths.
I think screening probably has its place, but I also think we are locked into a mentality where we think screening = good when it perhaps needs a lot more critical thinking and consideration.