Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To ask why you’ve missed/delayed/declined cervical screening?

936 replies

chickentikkawhatswrong · 19/02/2022 13:56

I see a lot of the campaigns on Facebook about women not going to smears or putting them off for too long.

However it’s generally stats and doesn’t seem to delve too far into the actual reasons?

If you are reluctant what holds you back from attending?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Notdoingthis · 03/03/2022 18:27

I do have them but since having kids I hate them. The nurses always feel the need to comment on my unusual cervix and scarring, and one quizzed me about my sex life. If they didn't talk it would be ok. Very relieved it is now one every 5 years.

Ereshkigalangcleg · 03/03/2022 18:06

I'm sorry, that's awful Thanks totally inappropriate when you already feel vulnerable

sleaf · 03/03/2022 12:38

I've cancelled mine as firstly it appears these days to be nothing more than an HPV test, which I can do at home with a kit from Superdrug, but secondly because I fear seeing the same nurse as before who insisted on weighing me, staring at my body while I stood on the scales and then being very unkind and rude about my weight, to the point that I left the surgery in tears. I know I'm overweight but don't want to be bullied over it at a smear appointment.

IsabelHerna · 28/02/2022 09:38

@Whattochoosenow thank you for replying to me. I do like the idea of vaginal swabs, and you're right they would be less invasive.

Whattochoosenow · 25/02/2022 13:30

@IsabelHerna the link between papilloma virus and cervical cancer is now established so there is an argument that traditional screening may not be required. Our smears in Scotland aren’t even examined unless the sample tests positive for HPV, and some places in England are offering self test kits to swab, as a pilot trial.
HPV screening can be done privately and my understanding is that a vaginal, not a cervical sample is necessary.
Maybe we should all just be offered a vaginal swab and then recalled if positive? It would certainly be less invasive.
Now that the female population is gradually being protected maybe we won’t need routine smears in years to come.

Winter2020 · 25/02/2022 12:19

I'm a bit cynical about it. In my experience if you present to the GP with symptoms that could indicate bowel cancer you are repeatedly fobbed off and it takes several years to get diagnosed. By which point it becomes unsurviveable. I know of several people that have died/dying of bowel cancer. But you must have cervical screening even with no symptoms? I'm guessing there is cash attached to getting women to have their smear tests and not to diagnosing bowel cancer early? That's how it seems to me - box ticking.

JanisMoplin · 25/02/2022 12:02

Just had mine after putting it off for a while. Wasn't fun and a bit painful, but the nurse was very helpful and kind. That's me done for the next 5 years apparently.

WiseUpJanetWeiss · 23/02/2022 15:48

@IsabelHerna

I didn't even know this was a thing! After thousands of years of evolution and medicine, a doctor figured out the smear test, governments all over Europe agreed to offer it to women for free, and now we just don't do it? I know it can be traumatic for women that have faced multiple miscarriages and have faced other fertility issues, but in general, I think testing saves lives.
Maybe read the thread and find out why it's "a thing". Screening (for pretty much anything) carries risks as well as benefits.
BobbyeinArkansas · 23/02/2022 13:46

[quote pawpaws2022]Like this
www.jostrust.org.uk/about-us/news-and-blog/blog/left-lateral-position-–-better-option-patients[/quote]
This is great to know but I’m sad that this article doesn’t mention the word woman anywhere.

ItchyKondera · 23/02/2022 10:00

I delayed mine - was due one, then pregnant so had to wait, obv not high on your list with a baby. Tried a few times to arrange one but so hard to get an appointment - they only released the appointments in "blocks" and often didn't have any that worked.
then you have to remember to ring up again for the next block
then pregnant again, so had to wait.

eventually, 7 years since the last one - stage 1a1 cervical cancer..... all sorted surgically but now i have annual colposcopies which are not exactly fun. I am still HPV positive...

IsabelHerna · 23/02/2022 09:56

I didn't even know this was a thing! After thousands of years of evolution and medicine, a doctor figured out the smear test, governments all over Europe agreed to offer it to women for free, and now we just don't do it? I know it can be traumatic for women that have faced multiple miscarriages and have faced other fertility issues, but in general, I think testing saves lives.

Crocusee · 21/02/2022 20:51

"*@DimplesToadfoot Jesus…
To all of you that said you had trauma (either birth or sexual abuse) - that’s understandable and I feel for you but you should get some counselling and get the test done.
To everyone else that says it’s painful - no it’s not. It is uncomfortable and embarrassing definitely and I hate it too but god it is so important for your health!
Same with mammogram- I get one every 2 years (I’m 37). It is not painful at all- it’s pretty much having a picture taken of your breasts. They are a little squeezed alright but how is it painful
…"

Aren't you lovely!

I enjoyed giving birth therefore all women should enjoy giving birth unless they have a DAMN GOOD REASON not to!!

I actually did enjoy giving birth and I actually DO find smears exceptionally painful. So there.

Graphista · 21/02/2022 18:42

If we say you are at risk, we will agree this test/screen if you also lose weight/quit smoking/cut drinking/stop having any fun, we know best.
And then if you go to a GP with actual things wrong with you, you are shoved out the door with some tablets if your lucky and spend the next 10 or more years trying to get to see a specialist.

Omg this is absolutely spot on!

commute · 21/02/2022 18:31

@Elphame

It does make you wonder doesn't it.

I found an article deep in the NHS's pages that says it is likely that the new FIT test will miss 51% of early bowel cancers due to the level of blood in the sample that triggers a positive.

It could be set lower but then they don't have the resources needed to cope with the number of colonoscopies that would result...

I know someone on the 2ww to see a colorectal specialist due to bowel cancer symptoms (later confirmed and needing surgery).

His bowel cancer screening pack came during the 2ww so he completed it (in the hope that it was a false alarm and he didn't have BC) - it came back negative.

So screening seems a bit and miss.

Terfydactyl · 21/02/2022 17:35

To add to this I knew a man who kept being given sleeping tablets by his GP. But he was schizophrenic. What possible good can sleeping tablets be if one is hearing voices, unable to leave the home because of the voices, doing very strange things inside the home ( a lot of tinfoil was harmed in the couple years he was on sleeping tablets) he sellotaped tiny holes in the walls, put tinfoil and black paper over the windows, swore blind he could hear mice talking, he needed very good MH care, he got sleeping tablets.

8 years later I'm still stumped what the GP was thinking.

Terfydactyl · 21/02/2022 17:29

@Elphame

It does make you wonder doesn't it.

I found an article deep in the NHS's pages that says it is likely that the new FIT test will miss 51% of early bowel cancers due to the level of blood in the sample that triggers a positive.

It could be set lower but then they don't have the resources needed to cope with the number of colonoscopies that would result...

Thanks for the link @Whattochoosenow my score was 1.2.

I dont understand why then the NHS is screening anything unless it's to teach a behavioural pattern. If we say you are at risk, we will agree this test/screen if you also lose weight/quit smoking/cut drinking/stop having any fun, we know best.
And then if you go to a GP with actual things wrong with you, you are shoved out the door with some tablets if your lucky and spend the next 10 or more years trying to get to see a specialist.

Paternalistic and I dont like it.

Sherk · 21/02/2022 16:45

Haven’t RTFT. I haven’t because I have been vaccinated against HPV and have only had one partner (my husband), where I am also his only partner. My risk of HPV is essentially 0, and HPV is the most common cause of cervical ca to the point the NHS only looks at cells from screening if HPV is detected, so I see no benefit of going through what is essentially an invasive medical procedure.

Some areas are trialling at-home self-swabbing for HPV detection, which I would gladly do. Sadly my GP isn’t participating.

Graphista · 21/02/2022 16:36

0.8% risk for colorectal cancer in next 15 years

What is the point of these screening programmes if there's so many false positives, they're screening for cancers that are very rare etc?

I'd rather money and resources in the nhs went where it is DEFINITELY needed -

Mh
Gynae REFERRALS When women are ALREADY reporting clear symptoms
Other REFERRALS when patients re already reporting clear symptoms
Providing continuity of care
This would free up appointment times too!

I'd genuinely like to know if these screening programmes are even value for money

Aspiringmatriarch · 21/02/2022 16:01

I went about 18 months ago and the nurse couldn't get to my cervix with the available speculums. I've not been back and I doubt I will tbh. Made me feel like a bit of a freak. Blush

SauvignonGrower · 21/02/2022 15:49

I've been putting mine off. Life is busy. I'm a shambles. Can barely remember to brush my teeth, let alone spend 10 minutes working out how to find a time that accommodates menstrual cycle, childcare needs and nurse appointment spaces.

If the local town had a drop service system I might manage it.

SartresSoul · 21/02/2022 15:48

I had to call up to ask for mine because I knew it was due and hadn’t been sent a letter. My last one was three years ago and I remembered it because 3 year old DS was 12 weeks old at the time. The GP receptionist tried telling me it was two years ago but I asked her to check again because it definitely wasn’t. Turns out she thought 2019 was two years ago… Christ knows whether they’d ever have realised and asked me, maybe a year late if I’d left it to that receptionist.

SirSamVimesCityWatch · 21/02/2022 15:41

I've just done my risk in that, it's 0.5% which is nice.

RedToothBrush · 21/02/2022 14:55

@Whattochoosenow

Interestingly there’s an article in the BMJ which states that bowel screening isn’t helpful if your Qrisk is under 3%. I’ve just put mine into the Qrisk calculator and it’s come out at 1.1% 🤷‍♀️
At what age do you start to think, 'well you've got to die of something?'

I know Margaret McCartney has talked about this too in one of her books (with particular reference to bowel screening).

The really fascinating bit was that there was a study about the level of promotion which encouraged take up, but if they were then given more information to help make a properly informed decision about the effectiveness of it and the potential harms of screening, take up of screening actively dropped. Thus there was a dilemma over how much you should tell the patient to enable informed decision making and whether that was more important than getting the 'correct behaviour' from a patient and higher take up rates of screening.

She bowel cancer in particular she references a Cochrane Review which stated:

Combining the four trials did not show any significant difference in all-cause mortality between the screen and control groups

So basically the point is, if you get bowel cancer it's a sign that your body is giving up on you completely anyway, and it's basically a choice over your cause of death and the manner in which you go.

Of course, if you have a history of bowel cancer in your family or an identified higher risk of it, you might be wiser to play the odds and go for screening as you might well benefit from it more than someone in the general population.

And it was found that once people were informed about this, take up of the screening reduced.

She had a particular beef about how all cause mortality wasn't looked at properly - so you might reduce rates of death from bowel cancer, but you didn't actually reduce deaths.

I think screening probably has its place, but I also think we are locked into a mentality where we think screening = good when it perhaps needs a lot more critical thinking and consideration.

Elphame · 21/02/2022 14:39

It does make you wonder doesn't it.

I found an article deep in the NHS's pages that says it is likely that the new FIT test will miss 51% of early bowel cancers due to the level of blood in the sample that triggers a positive.

It could be set lower but then they don't have the resources needed to cope with the number of colonoscopies that would result...

Swipe left for the next trending thread